Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
P.J. Hill on the social power of markets
P.J. Hill on the social power of markets
Jan 21, 2026 4:00 AM

Economic exchange is often seen as a cold and calculating endeavor—entirely self-focused and impersonal, with sole attention on price and profit and, thus, little regard for actual human needs or well-being.

Such a view fails to recognize that trade is more simply the manifestation of humanpartnership, and, seen rightly, such partnership is filled with positive social and moral implications.

In a recent lecture for the Oikonomia Network, economist P.J. Hill highlights the profound social connections that markets can help to facilitate, while acknowledging the gaps that are likely to remain without proper attention from the rest of civil society.

Hill argues that the market economy is a unique and indispensable mechanism for human connection, acquainting close neighbors and distant strangers alike. Far from leaving us isolated in our own individualized bubbles—detached from the munity—markets provide a context through which “profits and property rights are the primary means of social coordination among people who don’t know each other well.” It’s up to us how much we actually want to harness that potential.

“We need far more than markets for human flourishing,” Hill explains. “But I also see markets as important for extending the ways in which we can serve others. They enable us to exercise our stewardship responsibility over creation and they provide opportunities for productive and purposeful work.

In explaining the overarching social dynamics, Hill offers three distinct lessons that can help shape our thinking in how markets help channel our social natures as human persons. (I’veparaphrased each in my own words with Hill’s actual quotes underneath.)

1. Markets help us connect our good intentions to human needs.

Some see good intentions as sufficient to e the information and incentive problems of coordination across time and space. Intentions are important, but once we move beyond the most personal of interactions, we desperately need information about the needs and abilities of others. A price system is a marvelous mechanism of information generation that allows us to know about and respond to other people—all image bearers—who deserve our best efforts to serve them.

2. Markets petition into social collaboration.

I’m continually perplexed by how many scholars see markets as primarily petition. It is true that in a market economy there are forms petition. But there is also massive cooperation. In fact, firms and individuals are peting to see who can cooperate the best.

3. Markets aren’t the only mechanism for service, sociability and cooperation.

Price signals do not give us plete measure of what should count as the only measure for human flourishing…We don’t want all aspects of our humanity to be coordinated by market signals. Prices do a good job of allowing people who do not know each other well to interact. But if we only focus on that means of social coordination, we will miss much that is important for human well-being, and we will actually destroy the social relationships and beliefs that are crucial for a healthy society.

Taken together, we begin to see the bigger of our role in the broader economic order and the civil societies we each inhabit. Far from acting as a mindless cogs in a grand economic machine, we have the opportunity to embrace our roles and activities as servants, creators, and collaborators in everyday economic life.

Further, we get to reimagine our activities that might appear to be outsideof that sphere—tending to our families, neighborhoods, and social or religious institutions, knowing full well of the foundations we’re laying for whole-scale social and economic abundance.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Lessons on Christian vocation from ‘A Christmas Carol’
“Is Christmas too materialistic? Well, it’s not as materialistic as God ing flesh, redeeming our sinful flesh, and sending us back into the material world to live out our faith in love and service to our physical neighbors.” –Gene Veith We are routinely told that Charles Dickens’ beloved story, A Christmas Carol, was instrumental in giving us Christmas as we know it — marking the holiday not just as a moment of reflection on Christ’s birth, but as a secular...
Is it immoral to waste food?
“Eat your broccoli,” our mothers would say. “Think of the starving children in Africa!” It’s a moral claim we’re all familiar with. If some of our food goes to waste, someone, somewhere, will face imminent harm and the environment will go to the dogs. Indeed, it’s the central message of the popular new documentary, Wasted!, which claims, for example, that one-third of all food produced is never eaten, that 40% of that same food goes to waste, and that 90%...
5 Facts about Christmas
Christmas is the most widely observed cultural holiday in the world. Here are five factsyou should know about the memoration of the birth of Jesus: 1. No one knows what day or month Jesus was born (though some scholars speculate that it was in September). The earliest evidence for the observance of December 25 as the birthday of Christappears in the Philocalian posed in Rome in 336. 2. Despite the impression given by many nativity plays and Christmas carols, the...
The economics of Bedford Falls (Part 2 of 3)
[Note: This is the second post in a series highlighting some of the financial aspects and broad economic lessons of Frank Capra’s holiday classic, It’s a Wonderful Life. You can find part one here.] George’s Life Savings in a Life Insurance Policy George attempts to secure a loan from Potter based on his life insurance policy. He says it has a $15,000 face value and a $500 cash value. Why is his life insurance policy worth cash? George has atype...
Public goods and the problems of free-riders and forced-riders
Note: This is post #61 in a weekly video series on basic microeconomics. Public goods provide an argument for taxation and government provision. But how do we know which public goods should be provided? In this video by Marginal Revolution University, economist Alex Tabarrok discusses the free-rider problem and the forced-rider problem in regards to public goods. Previous in series: Public goods and asteroid defense ...
Totalitarian wolves against the Carpathian shepherd
“Though relatively unknown to the broader public in the West, King Michael’s life was nothing short of extraordinary,” says Mihail Neamtu in this week’s Acton Commentary. In 1927, his father left the throne to pursue a Romantic adventure with a larger than life mistress, Elena Lupescu (1895-1977). The royal families in Europe sanctioned this betrayal of the marriage vows, which the astute and yet amoral Prince Carol II had spoken before the youthful Princess Helen of Greece and Denmark (1896-1982)....
Did Christianity destroy Western culture?
It is always worth remembering how Christianity reformed Western culture – especially during the Christmas season, when we meditate on how Christ refashioned human nature to be a fitting abode of the divine nature. From teaching – and in some cases, inventing written languages – to preserving ancient manuscripts, to founding the university system, it would be impossible to imagine Western civilization without Christianity’s contributions. With this in mind, textbooks once referred to the West merely as “Christendom.” But a...
Skepticism of free markets grows within the Catholic Church
At the top of the Catholic hierarchy, Capitalism has been abandoned. This criticism of free markets, and even profit in general, have caused others within the Catholic Church to e concerned. As the debate grows, it’s helpful to clear up the main arguments of those who oppose and those who support Capitalism.In an article written for CatholicVote, Senior editor for the Acton Institute, Fr. Ben Johnson, does just that. Addressing the positions of First Things editor R. R. Reno and...
The economics of Bedford Falls (Part 3 of 3)
[Note: This is the finalpost in a series highlighting some of the financial aspects and broad economic lessons of Frank Capra’s holiday classic, It’s a Wonderful Life. You can find part one hereand part two here.] Economist Don Boudreaux outlined ten foundational lessons that should be learned in every well-taught principles of economics course. Examples of nearly all of the ten lessons can be found in Capra’s Christmas classic, but for the sake of brevity I’ll merely highlight two of...
A Hungarian reflects on George Washington and the U.S. statue controversy
On this day 241 years ago – December 26, 1776 – George Washington led his forces to a much-needed victory in the Battle of Trenton. Crossing the icy waters of the Delaware River on Christmas night to achieve maximum surprise, his decisive defeat of the Hessians encamped in New Jersey bolstered the colonies’ faltering faith in his military leadership. That led to the foundation of our constitutional republic, enlivened by virtue flowing from religious faith. To this day in much...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved