Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Perhaps Welfare Shouldn’t Go to Dead People. Or to Pay for Marijuana, Tattoos, and Piercings.
Perhaps Welfare Shouldn’t Go to Dead People. Or to Pay for Marijuana, Tattoos, and Piercings.
Mar 23, 2025 4:14 PM

If you’re on welfare in New Hampshire you might want to rush out and get that new tattoo and tongue piercing, and load up on cigars and weed. In 60 days you’ll no longer be able to use your welfare payment cards on marijuana, cigars, piercings, or tattoos:

Gov. Maggie Hassan signed a law that bans welfare “electronic benefit transfer” cards from being used on marijuana, among other vices.

More than 12,000 New Hampshire households receive benefits on EBT cards that essentially work as debit cards. The new law prohibits them from being used at marijuana dispensaries, cigar and smoke shops and tattoo and body piercing shops.

“We must always work to protect taxpayer dollars against public assistance fraud or abuse while also ensuring that those who need and qualify for financial support can purchase basic essential items,” Hassan said in a news release.

The cards have previously been banned by state and federal law from being used at liquor stores, gambling establishments and “adult entertainment venues.”

If you think that sounds harsh, in Illinois they are even prohibiting dead people from collecting welfare. As Mary Katharine Ham notes, “Even food stamps will no longer flow to those who until recently needed daily sustenance.”

Austin Berg of the Illinois Policy Institute explains the new, must-be-living policy:

Gov. Bruce Rauner signed House Bill 3311 on July 21, requiring the Department of Human Services to conduct a monthly crosscheck of its aid recipients with the death records kept by the Department of Public Health.

If the crosscheck yields a death record, the department will immediately cancel all public aid benefits to the recipient. To hedge against the hardship of a head of household passing away and a family being left without a safety net, the benefits will continue to flow if individuals in the “assistance unit” in question rely on the payments. The unit includes spouses and children.

Welfare dollars for the deceased have long been an object of scrutiny in Illinois. Millions have been spent on dead residents in the last few years.

During the 1976 campaign Ronald Reagan would tell a story that exemplified the problem of welfare fraud:

“In Chicago, they found a woman who holds the record,” the former California governor declared at a campaign rally in January 1976. “She used 80 names, 30 addresses, 15 telephone numbers to collect food stamps, Social Security, veterans’ benefits for four nonexistent deceased veteran husbands, as well as welfare. Her tax-free cash e alone has been running $150,000 a year.” As soon as he quoted that dollar amount, the crowd gasped.

For decades, Reagan was denounced for perpetuating the “myth of the welfare queen.” But it wasn’t a myth. Reagan was talking about Linda Taylor, a woman so audacious she drove her Cadillac to the public aid office to pick up her welfare check. (Slate has a great article on Taylor. Welfare fraud was the least of her crimes.)

You could argue that fraud is the exception the rule. Most people on public aid aren’t using their welfare money to buy dope and get butterfly tattoos on their ankles, much less buying diamonds and furs like the eponymous welfare queen Taylor. That is almost certainly true—and it’s the primary reason to crack down on welfare fraud.

Most Americansagree that we need some sort of social safety net for those truly in need (even if they don’t always agree on how much the government should be involved). But the abuse of the system by a small percentage of cheats has an outsized effect on the perception of the welfare system as a whole. When es to demographics, Americans are terrible at estimating percentages. We believe that 1 in 4 girls between the ages of 15-19 give birth each year (the actual percentage is 3 percent) and that 15 percent of Americans are Muslim (the actual percentage is 1 percent). So when we hear about individual cases of welfare fraud we assume the number of people who are exploiting the system is much, much higher than it is in reality.

By proactively limiting the opportunities for abuse, we can help to ensure that the public does not lose confidence in the fairness of the system and ensures the stigma is attached to the right people—criminals. “There is no disgrace being on welfare,” said New Hampshire House Speaker Bill O’Brien in 2012. “There is a disgrace in engaging in welfare fraud.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Should Notre Dame be rebuilt to reflect secularism?
The flames that consumed the spire of Notre Dame and burned the 856-year-old church to its foundations could have been doused by the tears of the faithful. If France heeds calls to rebuild the cathedral as a reflection of what modern “French people want,” the new structure may be flooded by their tears. The fire, whose origins remain under investigation, was initially reported to have left little more than medieval stones, rose windows,and – make of this what you will...
Why ‘national service’ is misguided nationalism
Earlier this week two presidential candidates ments that how nationalism is dominating American politics. The first came when South Bend mayor Pete Buttigieg told Rachel Maddow “national service will e one of the themes of [my] 2020 campaign.” He said he hopes to “make it, if not legally obligatory, then a social norm.” This in itself is not all that surprising since promoting national service is part of the Democrat Party platform: We believe in the power of national service...
When was the original Good Friday?
Today is Good Friday*, the religious holiday memorates the crucifixion of Jesus Christ and his death at Calvary. Christians have celebrated the event for over two millennia. But what was the date of the original Good Friday?Almost all scholars agree that Jesus was crucified in the spring of either A.D. 30 or A.D. 33. In their book,The Final Days of Jesus: The Most Important Week of the Most Important Person Who Ever Lived, Andreas Köstenberger and Justin Taylor contend that...
As Notre Dame burns, the Cross stands firm
Many mented on the fact that Paris’s Notre Dame Cathedral burned during Holy Week (see here or here or here for just a few examples), and rightfully so — the symbolism of death and the hope of resurrection is hard to miss. Particularly striking were the images of the cathedral’s golden cross still standing amid the wreckage. It being Holy Week, my first thoughts were three traditional invocations of the Cross of Christ. First was the motto of the Carthusians,...
Remedial civics for the rest of us
[Note: This is the introduction to an occasional series that provides information on what you should have learned in school—but probably didn’t—about how the U.S. government works (or why it doesn’t).] For most of my adult life I thought I knew how laws were made. Since the age of seven I had been reciting the lyrics to the 1976 Schoolhouse Rock! segment, “I’m Just a Bill,” and I had learned in civics class the es-law spiel so well I was...
How Jesus Christ upended the scapegoat myth: a Girardian interpretation
All societies, writes the French philosopher Rene Girard, are rooted in violence. Such violence has a mimetic dimension, which means that men are fated to mimic the behavior of other men. They like what others like, they desire what others desire. Inevitably, the dynamics of reciprocal imitation lead to disputes and social chaos. However, the human being rejects chaos and cries for the restoration of order; but without being able to get rid of the mimetic desire, one single solution...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: Bringing China and the West together with the help of Meng-Tzu
The ancient Chinese philosopher Meng-Tzu is usually known to Westerners by his Latinized name Mencius, if he is known to them at all. Though not famous outside his native China, Meng-Tzu left us many ideas worthy of consideration, and these often have unexpected parallels with more modern and familiar thinkers. Alejandro Chafuen, Acton’s Managing Director, International, examines some of these parallels in a piece published today for Forbes. Chafuen argues that Meng-Tzu’s ideas are worth remembering not only for their...
Free market environmentalism: Conserving and collaborating with nature
In an age of rapid industrialization and ever-accelerating technological change, many have grown fearful of environmental neglect and impending natural catastrophe. Such concerns tend to be based in a pessimistic view of economic opportunity, through which more individual ownership will surely lead to more reckless exploitation. Yet the bigger story of our newfound economic freedom and prosperity would seem to paint a different picture—one in which the expansion of economic ownership is actually helping us better protect and preserve our...
Rev. Sirico: Easter in the wake of the Notre Dame fire
It was a terrible thing on Monday to watch as flames consumed the beautiful and historic Notre Dame du Paris cathedral; I’m certain that I was not alone in fearing that before the conflagration was over, we would see that sublime e crashing down in a heap of ash and shattered stone. Thank God that was not the case, and that the courageous Paris fire brigade was able to bring the inferno under control before what would have been the...
New video of Rev. Robert Sirico: ‘Defending the Free Market: The Moral Case for a Free Economy’
Earlier this month Fr. Robert Sirico delivered an address to the Liberty Forum of Silicon Valley titled, ‘Defending the Free Market: The Moral Case for a Free Economy’. The talk begins with an account of a formative childhood experience which first kindled in him a passion for justice. Fr. Robert then describes his own journey from left-wing activism to ing an advocate for free markets. He describes how exploring questions at the heart of economic theory caused him to look...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved