Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
On mythical materialism
On mythical materialism
Jul 6, 2025 6:13 PM

Secular materialists and atheists like Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris like to mock religious people for being superstitious and illogical: resorting to fanciful explanations of events by invoking the work of God or miracles.

Yet it is always amusing to me to see the length that materialists will go to hold fast to their mythical materialist beliefs.

It almost charming to watch Sam Harris make a logical case for determinism and against the existence of free will, all the while imploring us to e convinced of the truth of his position and, well, change our minds. Doesn’t he realize I’m determined to believe in free will, and if he were me, atom for atom and gene for gene, golly, he would be too!

One of my favorite examples of materialists and Darwinists grasping for straws was done by the highly regarded neuroscientist V.S. Ramachandran in his book The Tell-Tale Brain.

For the record, the book is fascinating and I am incredibly impressed by his work. If, God forbid, I needed his help I would e it. His work on phantom limbs and the power of the brain is nothing short of remarkable. To list just one impressive story, Ramachandran used a box with a mirror to help a man who had a phantom limb get rid of the feeling of numbness in his amputated arm. He had the patient put his intact hand in front of the mirror while placing his amputated arm behind the box. When he moved his actual hand it appeared in the mirror he was moving both hands, and his brain registered movement in his missing limb, which helped get rid of numbness and pain. His work is awe-inspiring.

Yet outside neuroscience (and I am not qualified to judge his work inside neuroscience), when es to philosophy and social theory, some of his insights leave much to be desired.

Boxed in

He is unfortunately entirely beholden to the materialist, Darwinian, establishment viewpoint. While he argues that humans are special primates, he has to resort to mind-twisting acrobatics not to give up his establishment credentials. Though at one point he at least pokes fun at absurdity when, after suggesting that our enjoyment of Monet or Van Gogh might be traced back to our ancestor apes’ attraction to fruit, he writes, “This is what makes evolutionary psychology so much fun: You e up with an outlandishly satirical theory and get away with it.”

Indeed. Whether ment is propaganda or ironic writing under persecution I don’t know. Hopefully it is the second. But this doesn’t stop him from suggesting we should have gratitude that atoms came from outer space and it all turned into special us.

It’s easier to break a camel’s back than to make one

Take this one egregious example in his discussion of phase changes. In a discussion of the debates between Owen versus Huxley and Darwin about the unique distinctiveness of human beings, Ramachandran walks the tightrope.

He agrees with Owen that the human brain is distinct. But he still holds strong to dominant Darwinism by asserting that this development could still happen piecemeal over time without divine intervention. How? Through phase changes.

Ramachadran writes that “it is mon fallacy to assume that gradual small changes can only engender gradual, incremental results. But this is linear thinking, which seems to be our default mode for thinking about the world.” He argues that major changes and plex processes” can emerge from “deceptively simple parts” and bring about “radical qualitative shifts.”

To illustrate, he gives an example of a small, incremental change that leads to a major shift: ice to water. A small increase in incremental temperature from 22 to 23 degrees, or from 28 to 29 degrees, will not affect the condition of ice. But a small change from 32 to 33 degrees and the ice undergoes a radical change and es water. “At that key point,” he writes, “incremental changes stop having incremental effects, and precipitate a sudden qualitative change called a phase transition.” So far no problem, but wait, it ing.

“Nature is full of phase transitions,” he tells us. This is how the human brain e so qualitatively different from lower animals. I know there are serious debates among biologists about what is actually needed for a radical qualitative change to take place at the molecular and cellular level, and among mathematicians about the probability of these things taking place, that Ramachandran doesn’t seem to address.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
More on Secularism and Universities
Just a brief note addition to Kevin’s post: the free article from May’s Touchstone magazine is Terence O. Moore’s feature, “Not Harvard Bound.” A key quote: The elite schools no mand the reverence and deference of red-state America. The parents and students of “flyover country” are starting to put their money where their morals are or where they believe truth is. There’s a discussion of Moore’s article at Touchstone‘s reader discussion site, Treaders. HT: Mere Comments ...
Environmental News Roundup
Juliet Eilperin, “Bush Pollution Curbs Are Rated Equal to Clinton’s: Science Panel Says Proposed Cap-and-Trade System Will Help Clean Air,” Washington Post, July 24, 2006: The report from the National Academy of Sciences, released yesterday, represents the latest effort to assess how best to reduce air pollution estimated to cause as many as 24,000 premature deaths each year. The panel concluded that an earlier Bush plan would have allowed pollution to increase over a dozen years, but it found that...
Potty-Mouthed President
The amount of media attention over the past week’s devoted to President Bush’s utterance of a “naughty” word has been incredible. Maureen Dowd uses it as just one more bit of proof supporting her depiction of the president as a frat-boy, who “has enshrined his immaturity and insularity, turning every environment he inhabits — no matter how decorous or serious — into fortable frat house.” She writes, “No matter what the trappings or the ceremonies require of the leader of...
Original Sin
Headline: It’s a Sin to Fly, Says Church Actually, "It’s a Sin to Fly, Screams Headline" would be more appropriate. Here’s what the Church (or rather, the Bishop of London) actually says: “Making selfish choices such as flying on holiday or buying a large car are a symptom of sin. Sin is not just a restricted list of moral mistakes. It is living a life turned in on itself where people ignore the consequences of their actions.” I think there’s...
Taking Games Seriously
An article in yesterday’s NYT, “Saving the World, One Video Game at a Time,” by Clive Thompson, gives a good overview of the current trend in the video game industry, especially by nonprofits and activist groups, to create “serious games,” a movement which “has some serious brain power behind it. It is a partnership between advocates and nonprofit groups that are searching for new ways to reach young people, and tech-savvy academics keen to explore video games’ educational potential.” “What...
Connect the Energy Dots…
Today’s NYT editorializes: “a country that consumes one-quarter of the world’s oil supply while holding only 3 percent of the reserves will never be able to drill its way to lower oil prices, much less oil independence.” You’ll often hear plaint that Americans use more than their fair share of the world’s oil. We’re addicted to it, some say. After all, so goes the reasoning, we have less than one-half of one percent of the world’s population, but we “consume...
Federal Funding for the Humanities
Hunter Baker, blogging at his new home on the American Spectator Blog (recently added to our blogroll), responds to a post by James G. Poulos, which emphasizes President Bush’s “proposed emphasis on math and science education, to the patent detriment of the humanities.” Says Baker, “Although I am a faithful disciple of the humanities, I often fort in the fact that the majority of students won’t have much exposure to the offerings on hand. Better they remain busy with their...
Seek Dignity? Then, “You Gotta Shake Your MoneyMaker”
The Super MoneyMaker Pressure Pump No, we’re not talking about Elmore James’ Blues hit covered by the likes of George Thorogood, Fleetwood Mac and The Black Crowes nor its racy subject matter. Rather, it’s how members of the other oldest profession in Kenya and Tanzania power the irrigation pumps that extend both their growing season and range of crops. This foot-powered move beyond subsistence farming to much more profitable harvests, such as vegetables, is facilitated by the aptly named MoneyMaker series...
Beyond Black and White: New Realities of Race In America – BUMPED: Video now available
Anthony Bradley delivers his remarks last Wednesday The 2006 Acton Lecture Series continued today with Anthony Bradley’s presentation of Beyond Black and White: New Realities of Race In America. Mr. Bradley is an Acton research fellow and assistant professor of Apologetics and Systematic Theology at Covenant Theological Seminary in St. Louis, Missouri. His lecture describes the new market trends which reflect the changing demographics in America. With a decline in population amongst whites, a stagnated black population, and the ever-increasing...
Secular Universities in Decline?
In his New York Times column this week, Peter Steinfels has an insightful analysis of an intriguing and provocative new book by C. John Sommerville, The Decline of the Secular University. Those who study the history of American academia are familiar with the story of the secularization of universities as recounted expertly by Christian scholars such as George Marsden (The Soul of the American University) and James Burtchaell (The Dying of the Light), who decry the shunting of religion from...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved