Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Obama Administration to Federal Judge: We Can Force Your Wife to Violate Her Religion
Obama Administration to Federal Judge: We Can Force Your Wife to Violate Her Religion
Apr 9, 2026 3:40 AM

Has there ever, in the history of America, been a presidential administrationas dismissive of religious liberties as the Obama Administration?

The Administration seems to truly believe that when religious e into conflict with one of the President’s pet policies—such as employers being forced to pay for contraceptives and abortifacients—that religious liberties must be set aside. A prime example is the Administration’s idea that by forming a business entity intended to limit liability, a person loses their First Amendment right to the free exercise of religion.

As CNSNews reports, during an oral argument in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia last fall, a lawyer for the U.S. Justice Department told a federal judge that the Obama administration believed it could force the judge’s own wife—a physician—to act against her religious faith in the conduct of her medical practice.

Here is the exchange, from theofficial court transcript, between this Obama administration lawyer and Judge Walton:

Benjamin Berwick:“Well, your honor, I think, I think there are two distinct ideas here: One is: Is the corporation itself religious such that it can exercise religion? And my, our argument is that it is not. Although again, we admit that it is a closer case than for a lot of panies. And then the second question is, can the owners–is it a substantial burden on the owners when the requirement falls on pany that is a separate legal entity? I think for that question precisely what their beliefs are doesn’t really matter. I mean, they allege that they’re religious beliefs are being violated. We don’t question that. And we don’t question that that is the belief.

Judge Reggie Walton:But considering the closeness of the relationship that the individual owners have to the corporation to require them to fund what they believe amounts to the taking of a life, I don’t know what could be more contrary to one’s religious belief than that.

Berwick:Well, I don’t think the fact this is a closely-held corporation is particularly relevant, your honor. I mean, Mars, for example–

Judge Walton:Well, I mean, my wife has a medical practice. She has a corporation, but she’s the sole owner and sole stock owner. If she had strongly-held religious belief and she made that known that she operated her medical practice from that perspective, could she be required to pay for these types of items if she felt that that was causing her to violate her religious beliefs?

Berwick:Well, Your Honor, I think what es down to is whether there is a legal separation between pany and—

Judge Walton:It’s a legal separation. I mean, she obviously has created the corporation to limit her potential individual liability, but she’s the sole owner and everybody associates that medical practice with her as an individual. And if, you know, she was very active in her church and her church had these same type of strong religious-held beliefs, and members of the church and munity became aware of the fact that she is funding something that is totally contrary to what she professes as her belief, why should she have to do that?

Berwick:Well, your honor, again, I think es down to the fact that the corporation and the owner truly are separate. They are separate legal entities.

Judge Walton:So, she’d have to give up the limitation that conceivably would befall on her regarding liability in order to exercise her religion? So, she’d have to go as an individual proprietor with no corporation protection in order to assert her religious right? Isn’t that as significant burden?

In reference to the judges concerns, the government lawyer says, “Iactually don’t think it is that important.” What he does believe is important is contraceptives, since they are “importantto the health and well-being of women and to advancinggender equality.” Yet even if we concede this point, the Administration has given no rational explanation for why is it necessary for an employer to violatetheir conscience in order to pay for someone else’s contraceptives.

Fortunately, on Nov. 16, Judge Walton granted Tyndalea preliminary injunctionpreventing the Obama administration from forcing the corporation to violate the religious beliefs of its owners. Hopefully, when the issue is taken up by the Supreme Court the judiciary will, once and for all, put an end to President Obama’s trampling of religious freedom.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Cuba: Out Of The Shadows Of Communism Comes Commerce
In 1956, Fidel Castro, along with Che Guevara, led a guerrilla war on the island nation of Cuba. By 1959, Castro was sworn in as prime minister, and began leading the country down the destructive path of Communistic ideation. (Due to his poor health, Castro has now turned over the reins of the government to his brother Raul.) Under Castro, religious organizations, churches and schools have been all but decimated. He took control of student organizations and professional groups. Private...
‘The New Exodus’
Iraqi Catholics carry the remains of those killed in the October 2010 massacre at the Baghdad cathedral. Violence from Muslim extremists is causing Christians to flee the Middle East in staggering numbers. In the early nineties, there were 1.3 million Christians living in Iraq and today there are less than 200,000. Senior staff writer at Legatus Magazine, Sabrina Arena Ferrisi, addresses this in the latest Legatus Magazine. The Middle East is experiencing a new kind of exodus. This time it’s...
The Shift from ‘Alleviating Poverty’ to ‘Creating Prosperity’
“We see poverty in the developing world and we ask—what can I do?” says Michael Matheson Miller, Research Fellow at the Acton Institute and the Director of Poverty Cure, “But what if the question that animates our activity is the wrong one?” What if instead of asking how we can alleviate poverty, we asked, “How do people in the developing world create prosperity for their families and munities?” This sounds like a simple shift, but it can transform the way...
Corruption Is Getting Worse: Transparency International
Transparency International has released its 2013 findings regarding global corruption and bribery. The implications of corruption and bribery are manifold: they decrease confidence in governments, make it difficult for the poor and disconnected to get out of poverty, and break down trust throughout society. In fact, Transparency International found that two institutions that should be the most trusted (police and the judiciary) are the ones most riddled with corruption, world-wide. Here is one example: Fifty-year old Carmela [name has been...
More Americans Receive Food Aid Than Work in the Private Sector
Depressing statistic of the week: The U.S. Department of Agriculture estimates that a total of 101,000,000 people currently participate in at least one of the 15 food programs offered by the agency, at a cost of $114 billion in fiscal year 2012. That means the number of Americans receiving food assistance has surpassed the number of private sector workers in the U.S. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), there were 97,180,000 full-time private sector workers in 2012. The...
Is Fair Trade Coffee Curing Poverty?
“Who could be against fairness?” Victor Claar asked this question at Acton University last month. He and Travis Hester gave a talk titled, “Fair Trade Versus Free Trade” with their focus on the coffee industry. They explained what the fair trade movement is, evaluated its effectiveness, and explored ways for caring people to help coffee growers e poverty. Before looking at the fair trade movement, it is important to note that coffee is what economists call an inelastic good. That...
Family, Flourishing, and the Cement of Society
The economic consequences of changing family structure are beginning to emerge, and as they do, it can be tempting to focus only on the more tangible, perceivable dangers. For example: “How many new babies are needed to keep Entitlements X, Y, and Z sweet and juicy for the rest of us?” Such concerns are valid, particularly as we observe the lemming-like march of the spending class. But as harsh as the more immediate shocks of family collapse may be, we’d...
Common Core: Homogenizing Schools and Our Children
Politicians and public educators seem to constantly revert back to status quo arguments of further centralization as a way to reform education failures in the U.S. The most recent push for uniformity in the public school system is the Common Core, a set of national assessment standards and tests that has been adopted by 45 states and will be implemented possibly as soon as the 2014 school year. President Obama enticed the states to adopt Common Core with his $4.35...
Sobornost and Subsidiarity in Orthodox Christian Social Thought
Alexei Khomiakov, the Russian Slavophile thinker often credited with first articulating the Orthodox principle of sobornost. Today at Ethika Politika I offer an assessment of the phenomenon of globalization from the perspective of Orthodox Christian anthropology. In particular, I focus on the concept of sobornost in the thought of the Russian philosopher Vladimir Solovyov, writing, Solovyov’s account of the moral progress of humanity through globalization is rooted in the Russian idea of sobornost’, which Christopher Marsh and Daniel P. Payne...
Calihan Academic Fellowship Deadline: July 15
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to apply for a Fall 2013 Calihan Academic Fellowship. The fellowships provide scholarships and research grants to future scholars and religious leaders whose academic work shows outstanding potential. Graduate students studying theology, philosophy, religion, economics, or related fields are encouraged to apply. The application deadline is July 15. Information about eligibility, conditions, the selection process, and application requirements can be found on the Calihan Academic Fellowship page of the Acton Institute website. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved