Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Not From Benevolence...
Not From Benevolence...
Jul 18, 2025 8:09 PM

Whether one agrees or disagrees with the moral philosophy or economic theories of Adam Smith, it is difficult to deny that he is eminently quotable. Being eminently quotable, he is frequently quoted. Hence the familiarity of the following words:

“It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner but from their regard to their own interest.”

As a student of philosophy I tend to find “simple” questions more perplexing than plex” problems. The allegedly “obvious” and “everyday” realities of our existence lead me to wonder. More often than not, I find the so-called problems obsessing the erudite to be little more than hair-splitting exercises in self-indulgence.

Hence a simple, perhaps simplistic, question. Why does Adam Smith see fit to insist that the labors of the butcher, the brewer, and the baker are not born of benevolence? Why not assert that they are not motivated by sadism or by boredom or by a rollicking sense of humor?

Answers to simple questions tend to be no less simple. “Why assert what is obvious? No one would suggest that the butcher, the brewer, or the baker are so motivated.” That simple answer interests me. It suggests that an observer of the behavior of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker might conclude that they were motivated by benevolence.

E.T., rejuvenated after “going home,” returns to earth. He watches the behavior of the owner of my local newsstand and how that behavior impacts upon me. From 4:00 a.m. until 7:00 p.m. that newsstand is open, and during those hours I can procure a copy of the newspaper of my choice. I browse for a few minutes at the stand, seeking for a somewhat obscure magazine. It is not in stock. The owner undertakes to procure a copy for me. When I leave, the owner smiles and says, “Have a nice day.”

E.T. starts preparing his report. “The owners of newsstands are nice people. Specifically, the owner of the newsstand patronized by John Williams is most anxious to promote the contentment of said John Williams. That seems to be the raison d’etre of the newsstand’s owner. Benevolence is the well-spring of his behavior and, it would seem, gives his life meaning and purpose.“

Adam Smith, learning of E.T.’s report, gets into the act. “Dear whoever you might be, I am not so sure. Maybe the newsstand owner is an utterly self-centered, anything-but-benevolent monster. I know little about his motives. I know even less as to how I might change his motives for the better. I think I can so arrange matters that economic forces pel the newsstand owner to behave as though he cared for – what was his name? – oh yes, John Williams.”

So it is along the line. The owners of capital – resources, machinery, and tools – are, in an authentic free-market economy, “forced” to use their capital most efficiently (equals least wastefully) to satisfy the desires of consumers. They must act as though the happiness of consumers mattered to them. The only alternative is to forge an alliance with government, secure special privileges, and “close” the market.

A student of Immanuel Kant penned a volume in which he doubted the philosophical conclusions of his mentor. He was not sure that space and time were human categories brought to and imposed upon reality rather than being derived from reality. Yet he argued that it was illuminating for fallible mortals to think of space and time “as if” they characterized not the limits of reality but the limits of the human mind to perceive reality.

“As if.” The newsstand owner wishes only, let us pretend, to increase his e. He lives for nothing more. If truth be told, he loathes John Williams. Yet the economic structures within which he operates have so been arranged that he is in a sense forced, if he is to increase his e, to behave as though the happiness of John Williams mattered to him. “Old MacDonald” who owns the farm likewise has been “forced” to act in ways at variance with his inner motives. He lives for nothing else than “big bucks.” Yet should he increase his annual e by jeopardizing the long-term profitability of his farm, he loses. The market values his farm in terms of its future earning capacity. Salinate the soil, and that future earning capacity falls as does the market price for his farm. Self-interest dictates that he acts “as if” future generations matter to him.

As a preacher, I have given up attempts to manipulate the innermost motives of my fellow human beings and thereby change their outward behavior. Indeed, that entire enterprise was an exercise in arrogance and pride. The depths of the human soul where motives dwell are beyond my capacity to reach. I today simply focus upon behavior. That I can, given listeners free to accept or reject my advice, affect. Act kindly. Then see if kindness burns into life within you. passionate. Then see passion es for you an inner reality and your fellow pilgrims upon earth take on a new value. Set aside some time to be still and think of the wonder of being alive. Then see if wonder and thankfulness lead you to “do” what people call “praying” and that prayer leads you into the presence of the One of whom we cannot speak but can only adore.

I move from the perhaps sublime to monplace. Sergie Berinski is a candidature student of Economics at Moscow State University. He, unlike most of his peers, has visited the West. I asked him what he valued most in the West. “Shops.” “Because the shelves were laden?” “No. Shop-people were nice to me. Not like here where they are so sulky and bored.”

From benevolence? Maybe or maybe not. Maybe pure self-interest led to the “shop-people” being “nice” to my friend Sergie.

Yet so what? B. F. Skinner and his fellow behaviorists were wrong on the big questions but “spot on” on one issue. When inner motive and outer behavior are in conflict, outer behavior tends to win. The caring behavior erodes even the most self-centered of originating motives. The person forced to act “as if” he or she cares for the well-being of fellow human beings awakens one morning to discover that well-being actually is important.

Which goes to show something, but I know not quite what. Maybe that God holds the final trump card and intends to win, transforming even human selfishness into a hymn of fellow-feeling and praise.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Sister Mary Kenneth Keller
For the first time, we can now mechanically simulate the cognitive process. –Sister Mary Kenneth Keller Sister Mary Kenneth Keller established herself as a strong influence in the world puter science at a time when women in the field were unheard of. At the same time, her work paved the way for what we now understand as the information economy – a key driver of wealth creation. She was the first woman in the United States to earn a...
Editor's Note: Summer 2018
In early July, an Indian court issued a ruling that accorded the status of “legal person or entity” to animals in the state, saying “they have a distinct persona with corresponding rights, duties and liabilities of a living person.” With this measure, designed to prevent cruelty to animals, justices of the Uttarakhand High Court in northern India declared that “the entire animal kingdom, including avian and aquatic ones, are declared as legal entities having a distinct persona with corresponding...
Arvo Pärt and the universal soul of music
Sacred music is not only a devotional posed and performed to honor our Creator but also a bulwark against human sinfulness and frailties. Composer Arvo Pärt has been creating music of faith that inspires while at the same time subverts several of the most oppressive systems of government of the past century. poser’s lifelong development as a poser also led him to a deeper faith. He converted to Orthodox Christianity in 1972. Theologian Peter Bouteneff observed that Pärt is...
The politics of apocalypse
Disarmageddon” is what The Economist earlier this year called placent, reckless leaders” who “have forgotten how valuable it is to restrain nuclear weapons.” The politics of nuclear weapons – deterrence doctrines, mutually assured destruction and so on – have been the obsessive stuff of international politics since the Manhattan Project. There is, as Alissa Wilkinson and I argue in our 2015 book How to Survive the Apocalypse, something unique about the nuclear age, in which it es terrifyingly clear...
Nature, technology, and Pompeii
The primary mission of the Acton Institute since its inception has been identifying and revealing both traditional and innovative tonics to ward off Lord Acton’s dictum: “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” In fact, the manner in which we wield our power over one another, our environment and God’s other creatures defines our humanity, or, in other words, who we are as individuals and social creatures. bined tradition teaches us that humanity was not created by...
Editor's Note: Fall 2018
When I accepted the new position as managing editor of Religion & Liberty, only one thing had been set in stone: Caroline Roberts’ article on Walker Percy would be the cover story. Everything else remained to be determined. Her essay is one of the first e from Acton’s new longform journalism platform, bines extensive reporting with beautiful photography to give readers an immersive understanding of the subject. This project continues to grow and improve. Curt Biren analyzes economic and...
Labor unions, yesterday and today
Along-cherished predisposition on the part of the Roman Catholic Church is that labor unions act as a protection against the exploitation of workers. From Pope Leo XIII’s 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum forward, the Church has been an outspoken proponent of organized labor, worker safety and human dignity. Thus, es as little surprise that the U.S. Catholic Conference of Bishops weighed-in when the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in February regarding the Janus v. American Federation of State, County, and...
Power, people and things in 'Westworld'
Since I was a child I’ve always loved a good story. I believed that stories helped us to ennoble ourselves, to fix what was broken in us, and to help us e the people we dreamed of being.” So begins Anthony Hopkin’s character, Robert Ford, in his speech marking the finale of the first season of HBO’s mind-bending, techno-philosophical series “Westworld.” Ford is the brilliant co-creator of Westworld, a theme park set several decades in the future in which...
The return of nature worship
We live in decadent times. Universal human rights have not been fully attained, yet radical environmentalists insist that flora, fauna and even geological features and structures should be deemed legal persons, a meme known as “nature rights.” The drive to grant rights to the entirety of the natural world has already achieved stunning victories. In 2008, Ecuador granted human-type rights to “nature” in its constitution back, while Bolivia recently passed a law to the same effect. More than 30...
Acton Briefs: Summer 2018
A collection of short essays by Acton writers, click a link to jump to that article: AU and building the free society by Jenna Suchyta Westminster Abbey praises God for the NHS by Noah Gould President Trump nominates Judge Brett Kavanaugh by Joe Carter AU and building the free society Jenna Suchyta, Acton Institute Intern Over 1,000 people flocked to Grand Rapids June 18-21 to listen to more than 80 inspiring faculty members lecture on a wide variety of...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved