Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Noah, the Mad Environmentalist
Noah, the Mad Environmentalist
Jan 28, 2026 3:04 PM

Admittedly, this writer attended a viewing of Noah last week with trepidation. A March 17 New Yorker profile on director Darren Aronofsky gave good cause for suspicion the film would be yet another Hollywood environmentalist screed wherein humanity is depicted as a cancer on God’s creation. Instead, the film (largely) avoids such proclamations in favor of some pretty intense – make that very intense – family psychodrama and a spun-from-whole-cloth story involving Watchers, clan rivalry and allusions to other Old Testament stories.

Before the first fistful of popcorn, Aronofsky provides a decent CliffsNotes version of Genesis. The filmmaker deftly avoids religious controversy until depicting Cain’s wickedness as not only manifested by the slaying of his brother Abel but — much worse by Hollywood standards — his subsequent career as an “industrialist.” About here I’m thinking, “Oh, boy, we’re in for a slog.”

Described by Aronofsky as “a fantasy film taking place in a mythical quasi-Biblical world” and “the least Biblical Biblical film ever made,” Noah takes great liberties in its re-imagining of the Great Flood and the eventual reboot of humanity. Whereas other artists focused on Noah obsessing over the building of the Ark, Aronofsky depicts Noah (Russell Crowe) as a man clearly munication with the “Creator” but – just as clearly – somehow getting his prophetic lines crossed as to what exactly his mission entails after the deluge.

But it gets better despite several miscues, telegraphed by the director in the New Yorker piece: “There is a huge statement in the film, a strong message about ing flood from global warming. Noah has been a silly-old-guy-with-a-white-beard story, but really it’s the first apocalypse,” he told writer Tad Friend. Friend summarized: “His Noah, believing that God’s message privileges animals over men, es a scourging Earth First! Activist.”

In Aronofsky’s realization of the Noah story, the title character witnesses his father’s death at the hands of Tubal-Cain, descendant of you-know-who and sworn enemy of the lineage of Seth, the good son of Adam and Eve. Tubal-Cain (Ray Winstone) brutishly asserts his God-given dominion over lesser species, flagrantly grabbing and eating animal flesh tartare. Members of Tubal-Cain’s tribe aren’t above trading their daughters for meat, either.

Thankfully, without divulging any spoilers, the film eventually jettisons its rejection of the innate goodness of humankind. However, it’s not Noah but his daughter-in-law Ila (Emma Watson) who explains to Noah the essence of God’s gift of free will in the final reel. Getting to this point, however, requires tenacity as viewers are navigated through themes of genocide, patricide, and infanticide. This ain’t a Sunday school rendering of an-always-benevolent Noah, and Crowe’s portrayal is equal parts obsessive madman, raging psychopath and nurturing naturalist and family man. Noah, according to Crowe and Aronofsky, will cry over a killed animal but turn into an plished warrior – handy with knife- and spear-throwing and bat – when the occasion arises.

If you can manage it, understand Noah as a $125 million Hollywood blockbuster incorporating dark themes prevalent throughout its director’s body of work (Requiem for a Dream, Black Swan, Pi, The Wrestler, The Fountain), featuring some intense action sequences, wonderful Icelandic scenery, puter-generated graphics of the animals boarding the Ark, and marquee acting talent. This last includes Anthony Hopkins as Noah’s grandfather Methuselah (who, like the Watchers – giant rock beings that got on the Creator’s bad side somewhere East of Eden and wind up performing the lions’ share of ark construction – seems to have wandered into Noah from a Peter Jackson adaptation of a J.R.R. Tolkien story). I wouldn’t mind declaring a moratorium on future cinematic pairings of Crowe and Jennifer Connelly as their two collaborations (A Beautiful Mind being the first) featured more than a modicum of mental instability.

Taken as a whole, Noah is a ripping good yarn if not taken as a literal interpretation of the Old Testament story. Yet, it too easily defaults to blaming industrialization and hubris for all the planet’s ills both before and after the Flood. It’s unfortunate that industry’s net benefits for the good of all humankind couldn’t have found a way into the script along with Ila’s revelation that humanity is worth saving despite Noah’s doubts.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Tracing the Logic of Liberalism
In the Western world there are conservative liberals, liberal liberals, and radical liberals, says David T. Koyzis, but all adhere to the basic principles of liberalism: The liberalism of Thomas Hobbes and John Locke. Of Thomas Jefferson and John Stuart Mill. After all, the Declaration of Independence is a liberal document, unquestioningly accepting that popular consent stands at the origin of political authority. As Alasdair MacIntyre has put it, in the Western world there are conservative liberals, liberal liberals, and...
Monks, Beer, and the Labor of their Hands
Fr. Z’s Blog has a great post highlighting the Benedictine Monks at Norcia and their new brew. Here is the motto from the Birra Nursia site. Wonderful stuff, really: plete harmony with the centuries old tradition, the monks of Norcia have sought to share with the world a product which came about in the very heart of the monastic life, one which reminds us of the goodness of creation and the potential that it contains. For the monks of Norcia,...
Equality of Opportunity vs. Sameness of Opportunity
Conservatives should embrace the cause of equality of opportunity, says David Azerrad, not sameness of opportunity. [W]e must not confuseequalityof opportunity withsamenessof opportunity. Equality of opportunity is a moral imperative and a requirement of just government. Spending money on programs that aim to expand opportunity for the poor is a charitable pursuit to which some may aspire but which government is not bound to deliver. Justice demands that we uphold the rule of law, secure the rights of all, and...
Is Religious Freedom a “Natural Right”?
Over at The Claremont Institute, Hadley Arkes considers whether religious freedom is a “natural right.” His exploration of the question is lengthy plex and, as with everything Prof. Arkes writes, worthy of serious consideration. Here is his conclusion: It may be jarring in some quarters to say it, but it is eminently reasonable to be a theist, and quite as reasonable to understand that not everything done in the name of religion and theism is reasonable and defensible. What else...
Bono, Babel, and the Myth of Economist as Savior
Bono, lead singer of U2 and co-founder of charity-group ONE, recently offered some positive words about the role of markets in reducing global poverty and spurring economic development (HT): The Irish singer and co-founder of ONE, a campaigning group that fights poverty and disease in Africa, said it had been “a humbling thing for me” to realize the importance of capitalism and entrepreneurialism in philanthropy, particularly as someone who “got into this as a righteous anger activist with all the...
The Moral Paper Route
AEI recently held a contest challenging people to make a video that could articulate a moral case for free markets in two minutes or less. The $40,000 top prize was won by Jared Fuller with this entry, “The Moral Paper Route.” At AEI’s Values & Capitalism blog, Julia Thompson talks to Fuller about the making of the video. ...
A State That Co-opts and Crushes Civil Society?
John Zmirak, author and Editor-in-Chief of The Intercollegiate Review, wants voters to know exactly what is at stake in the looming Presidential election. In a guest blogger piece at the National Catholic Register, Zmirak pointedly states that the choice between the two candidates isn’t just about whose economic agenda seems more reasonable or who won which debate: …it’s about what America means: At heart of our Constitutional democracy is the freedom of individuals, even those with unpopular opinions, to pursue...
ResearchLinks – 10.26.12
Call for Papers: “Intellectual Property and Religious Thought” University of St. Thomas School of Law, April 5, 2013. The University of St. Thomas will hold a conference titled “Intellectual Property and Religious Thought,” on April 5, 2013, co-sponsored by the Terrence J. Murphy Institute for Catholic Thought, Law, and Public Policy and The University of St. Thomas Law Journal. The conference will be held at the University of St. Thomas School of Law building in downtown Minneapolis. Call for Papers:...
Acton Commentary: Desiccated Christianity
“When Christian institutions attempt to mitigate promise this understanding of their mission–often as the result of the political pressure–they morph into shadowy versions of their former selves,” writes Rev. Robert A. Sirico.In this week’s Acton Commentary (published October 24), Rev. Sirico explains that by losing theChristological dimension,Christiancharitable work es essentially secular.The full text of his essay follows. Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publicationshere. Desiccated Christianity byRev. Robert A. Sirico Mother Teresa was once asked...
Samuel Gregg: Paul Ryan’s Way
Acton’s Director of Research, Samuel Gregg, notes in a recent NRO article that vice-presidential candidate Paul Ryan has avoided “emotivist nonsense” and presented a clear moral vision for our country. Among other things, Ryan, ever so politely but unambiguously, underlined the immense damage inflicted by sometimes well-intentioned government welfare programs upon those in need. Yet he did so in a manner that detailed the economic costs but also went beyond a narrowly materialist reckoning. Ryan pointed to the manifold ways...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved