Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Noah, the Mad Environmentalist
Noah, the Mad Environmentalist
Jan 25, 2026 2:25 PM

Admittedly, this writer attended a viewing of Noah last week with trepidation. A March 17 New Yorker profile on director Darren Aronofsky gave good cause for suspicion the film would be yet another Hollywood environmentalist screed wherein humanity is depicted as a cancer on God’s creation. Instead, the film (largely) avoids such proclamations in favor of some pretty intense – make that very intense – family psychodrama and a spun-from-whole-cloth story involving Watchers, clan rivalry and allusions to other Old Testament stories.

Before the first fistful of popcorn, Aronofsky provides a decent CliffsNotes version of Genesis. The filmmaker deftly avoids religious controversy until depicting Cain’s wickedness as not only manifested by the slaying of his brother Abel but — much worse by Hollywood standards — his subsequent career as an “industrialist.” About here I’m thinking, “Oh, boy, we’re in for a slog.”

Described by Aronofsky as “a fantasy film taking place in a mythical quasi-Biblical world” and “the least Biblical Biblical film ever made,” Noah takes great liberties in its re-imagining of the Great Flood and the eventual reboot of humanity. Whereas other artists focused on Noah obsessing over the building of the Ark, Aronofsky depicts Noah (Russell Crowe) as a man clearly munication with the “Creator” but – just as clearly – somehow getting his prophetic lines crossed as to what exactly his mission entails after the deluge.

But it gets better despite several miscues, telegraphed by the director in the New Yorker piece: “There is a huge statement in the film, a strong message about ing flood from global warming. Noah has been a silly-old-guy-with-a-white-beard story, but really it’s the first apocalypse,” he told writer Tad Friend. Friend summarized: “His Noah, believing that God’s message privileges animals over men, es a scourging Earth First! Activist.”

In Aronofsky’s realization of the Noah story, the title character witnesses his father’s death at the hands of Tubal-Cain, descendant of you-know-who and sworn enemy of the lineage of Seth, the good son of Adam and Eve. Tubal-Cain (Ray Winstone) brutishly asserts his God-given dominion over lesser species, flagrantly grabbing and eating animal flesh tartare. Members of Tubal-Cain’s tribe aren’t above trading their daughters for meat, either.

Thankfully, without divulging any spoilers, the film eventually jettisons its rejection of the innate goodness of humankind. However, it’s not Noah but his daughter-in-law Ila (Emma Watson) who explains to Noah the essence of God’s gift of free will in the final reel. Getting to this point, however, requires tenacity as viewers are navigated through themes of genocide, patricide, and infanticide. This ain’t a Sunday school rendering of an-always-benevolent Noah, and Crowe’s portrayal is equal parts obsessive madman, raging psychopath and nurturing naturalist and family man. Noah, according to Crowe and Aronofsky, will cry over a killed animal but turn into an plished warrior – handy with knife- and spear-throwing and bat – when the occasion arises.

If you can manage it, understand Noah as a $125 million Hollywood blockbuster incorporating dark themes prevalent throughout its director’s body of work (Requiem for a Dream, Black Swan, Pi, The Wrestler, The Fountain), featuring some intense action sequences, wonderful Icelandic scenery, puter-generated graphics of the animals boarding the Ark, and marquee acting talent. This last includes Anthony Hopkins as Noah’s grandfather Methuselah (who, like the Watchers – giant rock beings that got on the Creator’s bad side somewhere East of Eden and wind up performing the lions’ share of ark construction – seems to have wandered into Noah from a Peter Jackson adaptation of a J.R.R. Tolkien story). I wouldn’t mind declaring a moratorium on future cinematic pairings of Crowe and Jennifer Connelly as their two collaborations (A Beautiful Mind being the first) featured more than a modicum of mental instability.

Taken as a whole, Noah is a ripping good yarn if not taken as a literal interpretation of the Old Testament story. Yet, it too easily defaults to blaming industrialization and hubris for all the planet’s ills both before and after the Flood. It’s unfortunate that industry’s net benefits for the good of all humankind couldn’t have found a way into the script along with Ila’s revelation that humanity is worth saving despite Noah’s doubts.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Church and state: do you serve two masters?
Last week, Acton’s Rome office, Istituto Acton, held a conference entitled “The Religious Dimension of Human Freedom” at the Pontifical University of the Holy Cross. (See this Zenit piece for a brief, if unexciting, summary of the event.) In addition to the news angle concerning China, I’d like to say that all three speakers agreed on one point – the rivalry between Church and State on the claims of primary human attachments. This e as no surprise to students of...
Enough religious “Beyondism”
John Armstrong’s thoughtful post below reminds me of the critiques of Jim Wallis offered in this space, here, here, and here (by Armstrong himself). And over at FirstThings today, Joseph Bottum, courtesy of David Brooks, gives me a term that I hadn’t encountered and that serves well as a moniker for the phenomenon Wallis embodies: “beyondism.” As in the effort (or rather the claim) to “get beyond” partisan polemics. As Bottum astutely observes, the program of the beyondist usually can...
Coming soon to your neighborhood bookseller: Al Gore’s Assault on Reason
Oh, I’m sorry. I messed up that title. Gore’s newest book will be called The Assault on Reason. Here’s the book description from : A visionary analysis of how the politics of fear, secrecy, cronyism, and blind faith bined with the degration of the public sphere to create an environment dangerously hostile to reason… …We live in an age when the thirty-second television spot is the most powerful force shaping the electorate’s thinking, and America is in the hands of...
Censuring Sobrino
When the Vatican last week issued a stinging rebuke of Fr. Jon Sobrino, a noted proponent of Liberation Theology, plaints ensued about the Church squelching “dissent.” However, as Samuel Gregg points out, Fr. Sobrino’s books were not only based on faulty economic thinking, his works placed him outside the bounds of orthodox Catholic teaching about the faith. “For Fr. Sobrino, the ‘true’ Church is to be found in the materially poor at a given time, rather than in those who...
Christianity and communism in China
Kishore Jayabalan reported yesterday on the latest happenings with the Acton Institute’s office in Rome and the most recent installment of the Centesimus Annus Conference Series, “The Religious Dimension of Human Freedom.” As Kishore notes, the conference took place within the context of the spate of media attention to the religious situation in China, especially with reference to the relations between Beijing and the Vatican. Last month Acton’s director of research Samuel Gregg wrote in The Australian about the increasing...
Google minds the gaps in statistical analysis
Google recently announced that it has purchased the Trendalyzer software from Gapminder, a Swedish non-profit (HT: Slashdot). Trendalyzer is the brain-child of professor Hans Rosling, who was lecturing on international development “when it struck him that statistics were an underexploited resource, often presented in an prehensible fashion. To solve the problem he developed – along with his son – a new kind of software.” One interesting aspect of this purchase is that the software’s inventor won’t profit from its sale,...
Thanks, but no thanks?
Non-evangelicals and progressive Christians continue to throw their support Rev. Richard Cizik’s way. Now the Institute for Progressive Christianity has released a mending “the courage and Christian concern displayed by Rev. Rick Cizik and the National Association of Evangelicals (NAE) for mending preventive action on the issue of global warming.” Given the care that Cizik has ostensibly taken to distance himself from radical environmentalists, both of the secular and religious variety, and the care with which he has attempted to...
Partisan political engagement in the Church
I grew up in the South. I also grew up during the Jim Crow era. I asked a lot of questions and made a lot of white folks very angry when I did. I hated the “separate but equal” hypocrisy and I was never, in my heart of hearts, sympathetic with the illogic of racism as I knew it. As a teen I was called into the senior pastor’s office and told to stop spreading racial unrest among the youth...
An inconvenient debate
I have tried to read everything that I can find the time to digest on the subject of global warming. I saw Al Gore’s award-winning documentary “An Inconvenient Truth” and even had some nice things to say about it. I have always been put off by the use of terms like “environmental whackos” and “earthist nut balls” from the political right. There is, in my humble opinion, little doubt that the earth is getting warmer. What is in great doubt...
Saving Mother Earth, one dead adorable baby bear at a time
Hey, what can I say – sometimes in the great war to save Gaia, you have to do some… unsavory things, like killing baby polar bears so they don’t have to suffer the humiliation of being raised by humans after being rejected by their mothers. With an assist from our resident Photoshop genius, Jonathan Spalink, I humbly present this artistic token of support to our friends in the environmental movement, in the hopes that it will help them to educate...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved