Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
No, Socialism Wouldn’t Succeed ‘If Only Men Were Angels’
No, Socialism Wouldn’t Succeed ‘If Only Men Were Angels’
Mar 18, 2025 1:28 PM

When arguing about the merits of a free economy, its defenders often give way to apeculiar line of reasoning that goes something like this:

“Socialism would be wonderful if it actually worked, and it could actually work if only men were angels.”

Such claims are meantto framesocialists as foolish idealists obsessed with their sillyutopias. But for those of us who believe there’sa certain idealism to thefree society, it’s a rather appalling concession. Indeed,the fundamental problem with socialism isn’t so much that its aims are unrealistic — though they most certainly are — but rather that its basic assumptions rely on a view of humanity that is, in so many ways, unreal.

If we letthe loftylevelers have their way, we shallinherit aworld where humanityisrobbed of its dignity and originality, discouraged from creativityand innovation, and restrained from the collaboration and relationship found in free exchange. Even if such a system were to be filled with morally superiorknow-it-alls and somehow achievematerial prosperity, it wouldstill be asociety of serfs, submissive to their overlords’ enlightened plans for social “equity,” and thus, servile in all the areas where God intended ownership.

Isa land wherein humans are guided by mere robotic efficiency really something that’s all that wonderful, even if it actually “works”? In whose mind and throughwhat sort of contortedimaginationis this considered an “ideal” or “utopia”?

As economist Art Carden once put it, when one surveys its bleak history, the socialist dream is not a “beautiful ideal that was corrupted by bad people” but an organized, “blood-soaked” attempt to “snuff out the things that make us human.” “Socialism didn’t fail because it is an ideal of which we aren’t worthy,” Carden continues. “Socialism failed because it is internally incoherent and structurally unsound.” It relies on Marx’s “intellectual rebellion against economics,” which, in reality, is simply a rebellion against man as he was created to be.

Man is fallen; of this we can be sure. But God created us in his image for specific purposes, blessed with incredible gifts and capable of remarkable reflections that transpire throughout organic life — through creativity and innovation, yes, but propelled by the love that’s spent and lentthrough service and sacrifice and relationship. It is these features that ought to be leveraged, channeled, and unleashed, and it is precisely these whichsocialism seeks to control, suppress, or forbid. Authentic social harmony is impossible without them, and thus, as the planners attempt their pet subversions, we oughtnot be surprised whenthe world correspondingly turns into a cold cultural vacuum at best and a death-ridden Soviet gulag at worst.

Again, we are constantly told that socialism couldsucceed“if only men were angels,” but the more important question appears to be whether socialism would succeedif men were angels. In light of its basic aims and fruits, it seems we would do better to replace “angels” with “robots,” for that is what socialism truly reduces us to: mere material beings, destinedto be programmed and positioned according to missar-designated functions, geared and refined and maneuvered as servile cogs in someone’s preferred vision of supreme equilibrium. This isnot what men were made for, andwhatever it is that angels actually do, I should hope that control and puppetry are not high on their lists.

We are fortunate to live in a society where freedom is cherished and unleashed and haslargely prevailed. But the resistance remains — against knowledge, against spirit, against man. We can romanticize such a rebellion by dismissing it as silly “idealism,” but I’d rather we romanticize the truth of human destiny, and get about embracing it.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
When I Grow Up
“What do you want to be when you grow up?” That’s mon question asked of children the world over. ChildFund International has put out their global survey of children for 2012, and that’s one of the questions they asked, with some intriguing results. When asked, “If you could grow up to be anything you wanted, what would you be?” there were some rather remarkable disparities between the answers of children in the developed and the developing world. Kids in the...
Should We Tax Volunteer Work for Charities?
During the debate about how to resolve the fiscal cliff crisis, lawmakers on both sides have considered reducing the charitable tax deduction. That strikes many people as the wrong approach (especially those of us who work for non-profits!) even though we may not be able to explain why it’s such a bad idea. Fortunately, John Carney has provided a superb explanation for why reducing or removing this deduction is counterproductive. For instance, changing the charitable deduction as Carney notes, has...
Conservation and Entrepreneurial Environmentalism
I found this profile of Mark Tercek, the former Goldman Sachs managing director who was tapped to head the Nature Conservancy, raises some profound issues concerning the relationship between economics and the environment: Tercek, 55, e to the Conservancy to fight financial brush fires. With the help of his board and the input of the Conservancy’s 600 scientists, he wants to remake the face of the American and global environmental movements. He has no quarrel with the current model—largely built...
How Should Christians View Property?
Étienne Cabet, a French philosopher and founder of a utopian socialist movement, once said: “Communism is Christianity.” The concept of property has existed longer than Western Civilization; trying to understand what property is and who can claim it has been an important issue for centuries. But, what is the Christian view of private property and ownership? Cabet, and others who believe that Christianity supports the concept munism or socialism, base their opinion on one particular passage of Scripture. In Acts:...
Social Engineering Makes For Poor Economic Policy
Writing over at The Atlantic, American Enterprise Institute scholar Christina Hoff Sommers shares the unsettling story of what a growing number of Swedish activist groups and political factions are attempting to do to “traditional” gender roles. Is it discriminatory and degrading for toy catalogs to show girls playing with tea sets and boys with Nerf guns? A Swedish regulatory group says yes. The Reklamombudsmannen (RO) has reprimanded Top-Toy, a licensee of Toys”R”Us and one of the largest panies in Northern...
Why Christians in Business Should Read Poetry
Writing for the Harvard Business Review, my friend (and coauthor) John Coleman argues that business professionals can benefit from reading poetry. While his article is not directed at people of faith, I think his claims are particularly relevant to Christians in the business world: Poetry can also help users develop a more acute sense of empathy. In the poem “Celestial Music,” for example, Louise Glück explores her feelings on heaven and mortality by seeing the issue through the eyes of...
Court: Justice Dept. Can’t Just Say ‘Trust Us, Changes Are Coming’
“There is no, ‘Trust us, changes ing’ clause in the Constitution,” wrote Judge Brian Cogan in his ruling issued two weeks ago against a Justice Department motion to dismiss the Archdiocese of New York’s lawsuit against the HHS mandate. “To the contrary, the Bill of Rights itself, and the First Amendment in particular, reflect a degree of skepticism towards governmental self-restraint and self-correction.” More federal judges ing to the same conclusion. Earlier this week a federal appeals court in Washington,...
Something Vastly More Powerful Than Evil
In his latest Forbes column, Rev. Robert A. Sirico explains why despite the tragedy in Newton we can speak of joy during this Christmas season: When we ask our bewilderedwhy? –we are not looking for data points.Even less should we offer glib responses in the face of this shattering loss – this modern-day slaughter of the innocents. We are, instead, seeking themeaningin the face of thismysterium iniquitatis.The meaning we seek is not so much the significance of evil as the...
Free Kindle Ebook: ‘A Field Guide to the Hero’s Journey’
Acton is offering a free Christmas gift: a free Kindle download of the new book, A Field Guide to the Hero’s Journey. The book, co-authored by Jeff Sandefer and Rev. Robert Sirico, has been called a “the modern ‘how-to’ for entrepreneurs working on plishing big things” by Andreas Widmer, and is a terrific book not only for adults but for young people. You can also listen to the authors discussing their collaboration on this book on this Radio Free Acton...
Economics is Too Important to be Left to Economists
I rather like Serene Jones’ piece in Huffington Post, “Economists and Innkeepers.” Jones got some things right. She knows that Christian Scripture teaches many economic lessons, like subsidiarity and stewardship (although she doesn’t use those terms.) She says, “Economic theory is replete with theological and moral assumptions about human nature and society” and that is correct. As Istituto Acton’s Kishore Jayabalan reminds us, Things like the rule of law, a tradition of equality for the law, which should cut down...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved