Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
NHS forces mentally challenged Catholic woman to have an abortion
NHS forces mentally challenged Catholic woman to have an abortion
Dec 23, 2024 6:27 PM

If it were possible to localize all the pathologies undermining the West into a single incident, a court ruling handed down on Friday might serve as the one. A British judge has ordered a young Catholic woman with “moderately severe” learning disabilities to have a second-trimester abortion against her will, in a case filed by the publicly funded National Health Service.

The circumstances are horrific. The mother, who cannot be named, is in her twenties with a mental parable to a six-to-nine year old. She is 22 weeks pregnant and has said she wants to keep her child. The young woman’s social worker agrees giving birth would be best for her well-being. The victim’s mother, a former midwife from Nigeria who has religious objections to abortion, has offered to raise her grandchild. The child could also have been placed in foster care, and agrowing number of experts see 22 weeks as a potentiallynew standard for fetal viability.

However, the government has other ideas. An undisclosed NHS Trust sued to force the woman to have an abortion, in violation of her faith, putatively because it is in her “best interests.”

At a time when the Church of England holds church services in Westminster Cathedral thanking God for the NHS, there is little doubt which god’s will would be done.

The woman “would suffer greater trauma from having a baby removed” from her care after birth, wrote Nathalie Lieven, a justice of the ironically named Court of Protection. “[I]t would at that stage be a real baby,” Lieven wrote, “a baby outside her body she can touch.” (For accuracy’s sake, the mother currently touches her baby pletely that she fully envelopes the child.) Without intervention, an abortion will take place just before the UK’s 24-week legal limit on terminations.

What is at stake is not merely the enormity of pelled abortion, which a UK pro-life organization called “reminiscent of how people with mental health issues were treated in the 1930s of Nazi Germany.”

The ruling in this tragic case strings together a modern catena peccatis of statism.

The judge’s order transgresses against the right to life and the inviolable human dignity of all persons. It violates conscience and vitiates the ability of a vulnerable woman – an immigrant’s child and a likely sexual assault victim – to exercise her religious liberty. It substitutes the judgment of the State for that of the preexisting and superseding authority of parents and family members. It denies genuine health care. pels taxpayers to pay for procedures many of them deem a mortal sin. And the es mired in the stench of cronyism, as the judge channels public resources to her former industry.

Christian Concern said, “No such thing should take place under the NHS.” However, NHS is the pelling the unwanted abortion. In a situation analogous to that of Charlie Gard and Alfie Evans, the government-run, single-payer health care system decreed a child’s life must be ended in violation of the parents’ wishes, despite readily available alternatives. An abortion would require the NHS to expend far fewer of its limited resources than a plicated birth.

Roman Catholic Bishop John Sherrington said the abortion upsets the “delicate balance between the rights of the individual and the powers of the State.” Lieven defended her role in the decision, writing, “I am acutely conscious of the fact that for the State to order a woman to have a termination where it appears that she doesn’t want it is an immense intrusion.”

But her ruling raises another concern: Lieven formerly worked as legal counsel for the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, which describes itself as “the leading provider of abortion services in the UK with over 40 abortion clinics and sexual health centres in England, Wales, and Scotland.”

“At the creation of [BPAS in 1967], women would still need to pay for their [abortion] themselves,” BPAS notes. “Today over 95% of the women we take care of have their treatment paid for by the NHS.”

And in some cases, women have their pelled by the NHS, as well.

The ruling should be a wake-up call for Integralists and others who believe a national health care system would be “pro-life.” The same constellation of abuses cluster whenever the State acquires a monopoly over force and economic activity.

Update:​​​​​​​As thisarticle was being published on Monday, a three-judge panel of an appeals court overturned Lieven’s decision.Lord Justice McCombe, Lady Justice King and Lord Justice Peter Jackson said they will provide their reasons at a later date. Curiously, the publicly funded BBC placed the words “forced abortion” in scare quotes in its coverage.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Audio: Elise Hilton on the Border Crisis
Earlier today, Elise Hilton was featured on the Neal Larson Show discussing several facets of the current “Border Crisis” and suggesting how to address this situation. Listen below: Read mentary this paring our current situation with one 50 years ago in Cuba. ...
Was The Current Border Crisis A Foreseeable Event?
In a scathing report in The Washington Post, reporters David Nakamura, Jerry Markon and Manuel Roig-Franzia detail how the current border crisis involving a surge of children from Mexico and Central America was predicted by several human rights organizations and that the Obama administration failed to act, thus creating not only the increase in children illegally crossing the border, but also the desperate conditions the children have had to endure. In 2013, the University of Texas at El Paso issued...
Fewer Babies, Longer Lives
The Transom links today to a piece about how Proctor & Gamble is ramping up product lines aimed at older adults. “The flip side of the low birthrate is we’re all living longer,” said corporate exec Tom Falk. In fact, the global trend over the last two hundred years has been toward longer lives and fewer babies. This trend really gathered momentum in just the last half-century or so. Consider this short video I put together for a talk at...
How to Understand Snowpiercer
Snowpiercer is the most political film of the year. And likely to be one of the most misunderstood. Snowpiercer is also very weird, which you’d probably expect from a South Korean sci-fi post-apocalyptic action film based on a French graphic novel that stars Chris Evans (Captain America) and Tilda Swinton (The Chronicles of Narnia). The basic plot of the movie is that in 2014, an experiment to counteract global warming (which is based on a real plan) causes an ice...
Faith and the Artisan Economy
I recently detailed the relationship between stewardship and the use of one’s God given gifts through vocational jobs as a path toward human flourishing. Much like vocational work’s hands on occupations, are artisanal jobs, which are on the rise in America. These positions are developed by the individual as a creative outlet to provide a good or a service not in the market. They do not require formal training, but education is important as a foundation for inspired enrichment. The...
Skirting The Law: Five U.S. Territories Now Exempt From Obamacare
Last week was a busy one, news-wise, and this may have slipped by you. Suddenly, 4.5 million people in the 5 U.S. territories (American Somoa, Guam, Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands) are now exempt from Obamacare. Just like that. What’s the story? Obamacare costs too darn much, and insurance providers were fleeing the U.S. territories, leaving many without insurance or at least affordable insurance. These territories have spent the last two years begging to get...
Religious Left Takes Vow of Silence on Left-Wing ‘Dark Money’
When es to political and lobbying spending, it’s a mixed-up, muddled-up, shook-up world, to quote the Kinks’ Ray Davies. Leftist organizations such as the Center for Political Accountability, the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility, and As You Sow seemingly check the closets and under the beds each night to ensure corporations aren’t exercising their First Amendment rights to freely engage in the political process. These shareholder activist groups work together and individually to stifle corporate speech by submitting proxy resolutions...
The Economics Of Sex
Economics, at first glance, doesn’t seem very…well…sexy. It’s all about numbers, right? How the stock market is doing, how much people are willing to spend on stuff they need or want, whether or not people have jobs. That’s economics, right? As the Rev. Robert Sirico is fond of saying, economics is fundamentally about human action. If this is true, then economics applies to sexual activity as well. In the following video (from the Austin Institute), today’s sexual landscape is examined...
Get a Free Rental of ‘The Economy of Creative Service’
For the Life of the World: Letters to the Exilesisa 7-part series from the Acton Institute that seeks to examine the bigger picture of Christianity’s role in culture, society, and the world. Each Monday — from July 7 to August 18 — The Gospel Coalition (TGC) ishighlighting one episode and sharing an exclusive codefor for a free 72-hour rental of the full episode. Here’s the trailer for episode 3, The Economy of Creative Service. Visit TGC to get the code...
Partnering With Poor Women For Health, Fertility
Once, in a Bible study I was involved with, we women got chatting, and one lady (as we were discussing poverty in Haiti) said, “If we could just get those women to stop having so many kids…” [drawn-out sigh.] My reply was that we didn’t need to stop women from having babies; we needed to help educate women. For years, organizations like the World Health Organization have tried to distribute artificial birth control in the developing world. The thinking here...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved