Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
National healthcare can’t fail if there are no goals
National healthcare can’t fail if there are no goals
Nov 14, 2024 6:27 PM

As the Brexit debacle monopolizes UK news, the government quietly released a consequential announcement: The National Health Service (NHS) is considering repealing requirements that emergency rooms in England treat or release patients within four hours. The new guidelines vindicate critics of single-payer health care, who say the government inevitably rations care, downgrades its own standards, and then declares victory.

The UK’s goal of a four-hour wait in accident and emergency rooms (A&Es) is roughly twice as long as patients wait in American ERs. However, the government has moved the goalposts in its own favor for nearly two decades, as the Guardian reports:

When Labour introduced the measure in 2004, hospitals had to treat 98% of patients in England within that time [four hours]. The coalition government then reduced the target to 95% in 2010.

However, hospitals in England have not met the 95% target since July 2015 and the relentlessrise in demandfor care means the performance of some has sunk as low as 50% as the NHS has faltered.

Furthermore, hospitals inflating those numbers by rushing 20 percent of all admissions within the last 10 minutes before the deadline.

The problem restricted to A&Es. Some 24 percent of British cancer patients – or 127,000 people – suffered when the NHS missed its 62-day target over the last five years.

Canceled surgeries and delayed treatment became the norm during the annual “winter crisis,” which often lasted longer than winter. Care standards so eroded that the British Red Cross likened NHS service to a“humanitarian crisis” in 2017.

So, politicians handed out the one thing never in short supply: promises. Last June, Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt said Theresa May’s increased funding would mean “the NHS can regain core performance [on key waiting time targets] and lay the foundations for service improvement.”

The new guidelines unveiled by NHS England’s medical director, Stephen Powis, hope that A&Es will see patients with the worst conditions within one hour and expedite the treatment of mental health patients. The new rules will be tested in the 2019-2020 year and, if deemed successful, will take effect in 2020.

The cynical notion behind the decades-long slide is that the government cannot miss its targets if there are no targets.

Instead of improving service, the government reduced its standard to one it could meet. And with the wave of its wand, and the lowering of expectations, its programs go from a failure to a success.

Next year’s report will undoubtedly show “improvement.” But results will not improve in tandem.

A socialist health care system increases demand by providing care “free at the point of service” (although not, nota bene, free). But it does so without increasing the supply. In fact, its payment structure reduces supply by failing to reward innovations, like the invention of new drugs. By removing price signals and separating service from payment, single-payer health care overburdens the medical system. Coupled with an aging population, hospitals find themselves strained to the breaking point.

Preserving people’s lives is the greatest gift next to eternal salvation. As St. Luke of Simferopol, an archbishop in the Orthodox Church and a surgeon, said, “I help people as a physician, and I help them as a servant of the Church.” Christians should speak out against socialism, a system that inhibits all forms of personal charity, secular and ecclesiastical.

of Foreign Affairs and Trade. This photo has been cropped. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Islam, Democracy and Turkey
Bilal Sambur, Ph.D., is assistant professor on the faculty of divinity at Suleyman Demirel University in Isparta, Turkey. He is a guest scholar this summer at the Acton Institute. Islam, Democracy and Turkey By Bilal Sambur The inauguration of Abdullah Gul as Turkey’s new president has provoked a great deal of discussion — and anxiety — about the rise to power of a man who is an observant Muslim with a background in Islamic politics. Instead of anxiety, the world...
Acton Launches New Website
The Acton Institute has just refreshed its online look. Go to www.acton.org to see pletely redesigned Website. All of your favorite content is still available but it should now be easier to find and keep track of. Here is a short list of improvements that you may note: Updated navigation: We now use a horizontal drop-menu system along the top of the website to make finding the content you want a little bit easier.Now@Acton: Find the most current content right...
Maranatha Christian Writers’ Conference
For the next few days, Ray Nothstine and I will be attending the Maranatha Christian Writers’ Conference in Muskegon, MI. As there’s something of interest to pass along and occasion permits, we’ll keep PowerBlog readers updated throughout the week. There’s some excellent background on the thirty year history of the conference in this last weekend’s Grand Rapids Press, “Area woman’s passion became ministry.” ...
Faith and Freedom Vs. The Super – State
Darkness and light have been used to symbolize powerful metaphors in literature, art, film, and all sorts of creative venues. In Scripture, darkness and light are often used to evoke good and evil. In the 9th chapter of John’s Gospel, Jesus heals a man born blind, who furthermore is brought into the fullness of light through faith in Christ. Jesus, however, implicates the Pharisees, by saying, “If you were blind, you would not be guilty of sin; but now that...
UK Approves Creation of Chimeras
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) in the UK has given generic approval allowing “human-animal embryos to be created and used for research.” According to a Christian Science Monitor report, Evan Harris, “a lawmaker on a mittee that has oversight in this field,” says that “No scientist I have found has provided scientific reasons as opposed to religiously based ethical reasons for not proceeding,” he adds, even though mittee “looked high and low for such scientists.” Typically the case...
Helping the “Bottom Billion”
Richard John Neuhaus is calling it “one of the most important books on world poverty in a very long time.” It’s Paul Collier’s The Bottom Billion: Why the Poorest Countries Are Failing and What Can Be Done About It. Neuhaus’s discussion is thorough so I won’t reiterate. Suffice it to say that I’m intrigued by the book’s arguments. I’ve always thought the question of when to intervene militarily—self-evidently one of the key foreign policy questions—is also one of the thorniest...
Samaritan Award Winner
The Acton Institute’s 2007 Samaritan Award winner for outstanding private, voluntary charitable service has been awarded to the Arkansas Sheriffs’ Youth Ranches, Inc. Their mission statement reads, “To address, remedy, and prevent child abuse and neglect by creating safe, healthy, and permanent homes for children.” One of the outstanding aspects of the program is their belief in not abandoning those who participate in their program just because they reach a certain age. Participants are allowed to stay involved and seek...
D. James Kennedy Dies (1930-2007)
From WPBF: FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — A pioneering megachurch pastor and prominent Christian broadcaster has died in Fort Lauderdale. The Rev. D. James Kennedy died early Wednesday morning at his home due plications from cardiac arrest in December. The 76-year-old Kennedy had not been seen publicly since then; his retirement was announced on Aug. 26. Kennedy took the Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church in Fort Lauderdale from a congregation of 45 in 1959 to a megachurch of nearly 10,000 members today....
English, Speak You Do It?
They say that those who can’t do, teach. But what if you can’t teach? From the AZ Republic: “Hundreds of students in Arizona are trying to learn English from teachers who don’t know the language, state officials say.” I’ve never been too attracted to the whole “English-only movement,” but I would think the language should at least be the sine qua non of our educational system. That is, we should be teaching English and other languages. Some of the examples...
Faith and Football
This mentary by Anthony Bradley, “Obviously, Sports Do Not Build Character,” (along with our poll question) made me think of the series of articles appearing in the current issue of Christianity Today, which included a cover story on the NFL and an editorial addressing faith and the NBA. And that made me think of this parody (HT: the evangelical outpost): Update: See also the new “Centre for the Study of Sport and Spirituality.” ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved