Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
More on Constitutions and Culture
More on Constitutions and Culture
Nov 14, 2024 1:56 AM

As noted already at the PowerBlog today, Sam Gregg has a fine piece on plex relationship between law and morality, or constitutions and culture, over at Public Discourse.

As a follow-up (read the piece first), I’d like to point to an interesting aspect of James Buchanan’s advocacy of a balanced-budget amendment. As Gregg notes, Buchanan is an example of someone who thought that “America’s constitution required amending to bestow genuine independence upon a monetary authority,” or advocated for the “constitutionalization” of money. A related effort would be Buchanan’s efforts in support of a balanced-budget amendment to the American Constitution, as explored by James Alvey in his piece, “James M. Buchanan on the Ethics of Public Debt and Default.”

As Alvey writes, “Buchanan became actively involved in the campaign to secure a balanced-budget amendment to the U.S. Constitution, and indeed this was almost the only area on which he was active as a policy advocate.” Alvey notes that Buchanan’s analysis of the rise of the problem follows the view of Hayek on the relationship between moral rules (culture) and legal institutions. That is, once the Victorian moral disapproval of debt was transformed and institutionalized into approbation of debt via a Keynesian moral revolution, “there is little hope for any restoration” of the moral rules that “evolve slowly and without deliberate construction.” In such a case, appeals to other legal institutions or constitutional limits (e.g. balanced-budget provisions or the “constitutionalization” of money) e measures of last resort.

These measures are not foolproof, as Gregg points out, and neither are they incorruptible. But they are, on this view, indicative of a failure of moral culture in these areas, and are perhaps the best of available options for preservation of social stability in the short-term. But something that neither Hayek’s nor Buchanan’s account of the rise of moral cultures as the evolution of “moral rules” does is provide adequate insight into the role of morally-formative institutions (other than legal institutions) for the possibility of “restoration.”

As Gregg concludes, “If America is not to head down a social democratic path, reliance on the Constitution is not enough. To use a Romney-esque phrase, culture matters — perhaps especially in the economy.” This means that institutions like the church and the family, and perhaps these two primarily, are the loci of cultural renewal and restoration. They are also the vanguards, and indeed the bellwethers, of civilization. This is a sobering thought, indeed.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Abolishing blasphemy laws in Pakistan will lead to more violence
While religious freedom is the ultimate goal in Pakistan and other Muslim-majority countries, singling out blasphemy laws as the problem will only impede the spread of democracy and usher in an unintended violent backlash. Read More… Blasphemy laws pose a real challenge to religious liberty and democracy in several Muslim-majority countries, with 32 nations criminalizing blasphemy; in Iran, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Brunei, Mauritania, and Saudi Arabia, it is punishable by death. In Pakistan alone, according to the National Commission for Justice...
It’s time to reform foreign aid
When money intended to address immediate international crises e decades’-long dependency projects, it is time to reconsider how taxpayers’ money is spent and on whom. Read More… When we speak of good intentions, foreign es immediately to mind. It e as no surprise to Acton readers that sound economics are not always attached to those intentions. In the U.S., billions of dollars are earmarked annually for foreign aid, and the results are less than satisfactory. Can foreign aid as we...
Dave Chappelle is the greatest comedian in America. Just ask him.
The transgressive stand-up is back with another Netflix special, this time lecturing high school kids on the power of family and education. But is it funny? Read More… The edian America has produced in the post–Cold War era is Dave Chappelle, and if you listen to his new Netflix show, What’s in a Name: Speech at Duke Ellington School of the Arts, he’ll tell you that himself. I suppose it’s not bragging if it’s true, but it’s unusual for celebrities...
The end of Roe is the beginning of new life for citizens and their duties
While many were shocked by the recent SCOTUS ruling that overturned a right to abortion, it should e as no surprise that if you live by the court, you can die by the court. Yet the debate over abortion peting rights has only just begun. Read More… Weeks after the Supreme Court’s landmark 6-3 ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022), which held that the Constitution of the United States does not confer a right to abortion, the...
Is Indonesia’s “Civil Islam” a model for the Muslim world?
Islam patible with democracy and religious pluralism, as the recent cultural and political reformations in Indonesia have proved. Will other Muslim-majority nations take notice? And will Civil Islam help young Muslims stay Muslim? Read More… The rise of “Islamic extremism” in France, the reemergence of the Taliban in Afghanistan, and the recent drift toward Islamist politics—political efforts to enforce an orthodox interpretation of Islam on society—in Turkey have revived the debate about Islam’s relationship with democracy and liberty. French president...
Government regulation of the market is more to be feared than Amazon or Google
A new bipartisan bill in the Senate aims to rein in supposedly monopolistic and unfair business practices. But it will only petition in the long run and hurt the very consumers it’s intended to help. Read More… The popular view of the recent NBA Finals is that the Boston Celtics and Golden State peted for the title of best team. The nation’s best basketball players traded points, victories, and fouls on the way to the Warriors pulling off the final...
We know what women are. They don’t. Now what?
The Daily Wire’s new documentary offers disturbing realities but only one answer to a question that raises many more. What would a sequel look like? Read More… “Nature always tells us the truth, even if we don’t want to hear it.” So begins the latest cinematic offering from the Daily Wire,What Is a Woman? The documentary is stirring up controversy with its sarcastic cultural analysis and skillful showcasing of extreme social absurdity. Conservative mentator Matt Walsh’s dry style edic narration...
Do we really need another brand of conservatism?
In his new book, F.H. Buckley offers a vision of a “progressive conservatism” that sure sounds like the traditional Grand Old Party platform. Not that that’s a bad thing. Read More… Sisyphus was the first conservative, Claremont Review of Books editor William Voegeli wryly observes, because the lot of the conservative is one of short-lived, temporary victories. Conservatives certainly have no shortage of examples. The 1996 Defense of Marriage Act didn’t even last 20 years, made obsolete by Obergefell v....
After Boris: More of the same or a different direction?
Of the two Conservative Party candidates poised to replace Boris Johnson as prime minister, neither seems particularly, or at least consistently, conservative. Read More… We’re down to the final two candidates: Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak. The next prime minister of the United Kingdom with be either our third female premier (all Conservative) or the nation’s first ethnic Indian (and Hindu) leader. Unlike the U.S. president, the British prime minister is not directly elected. The PM is whoever mand a...
The Survivor asks something of its audience
Oscar and Emmy Award–winning writer-director Barry Levinson has adapted the true-life story of Holocaust survivor and professional boxer Harry Haft for HBO. Is this a fitting summation of a long, topsy-turvy career? Read More… Barry Levinson is 80. The Oscar-winning writer-director has played a part in several of the best movies and TV shows of the past half century—and a few of the worst. That pattern of mixing abominable stinkers with memorable successes has continued into the past decade. In...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved