Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Milton Friedman on business as an enemy of enterprise
Milton Friedman on business as an enemy of enterprise
Nov 27, 2024 6:46 AM

Milton Friedman is one half of the duo so often identified with “neoliberalism” (the other being Friedrich Hayek), the hegemonic power that is typically seen as constitutive of our contemporary age.

Friedman was a brilliant thinker, and one whose ideas warrant attention, not least because of their association with today’s political and economic situation. Oftentimes neoliberalism is connected with an ideology of privatization, which is itself seen as policy intended to empower and prioritize the interests of business and industry.

It’s true that there is a sense in which Friedman emphasized a vigorous and even primary place for the free market in the social order, and the role of firms within that setting; but it is also true that Friedman was more of a proponent of the free enterprise system than of business (and certainly big business) as such.

This is why it is important to recall what Friedman actually said about business, and this includes not only his famous argument about the profit motive but also his warnings about business and how it can be one the greatest enemies of free enterprise.

He identifies it as such in various places and contexts, including his 1977 speech, “The Future of Capitalism.” Here he warns that “The two greatest enemies of free enterprise in the United States, in my opinion, have been, on the one hand, my fellow intellectuals and, on the other hand, the business corporations of this country.”

Much could and indeed has been said about the role of “intellectuals” in the free and not-so-free society. But about business Friedman said:

Every businessman and every business enterprise is in favor of freedom for everybody else, but when es to himself, that’s a different question. We have to have that tariff to protect us petition from abroad. We have to have that special provision in the tax code. We have to have that subsidy. Businessmen are in favor of freedom for everybody else but not for themselves.

Perhaps these kinds of protestations sound familiar; and if so, Friedman’s thought might well be relevant today for his insights into the deep connections between business and government, sometimes also called “crony capitalism.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
What hath Vienna to do with Colorado Springs?
Working as we do here at the intersection between economics and theology, the relationship between various kinds of classically liberal, libertarian, Austrian, and other economic modifiers and religion in general and Christianity in particular is in constant view. Sometimes the conversation is friendly, sometimes not so much. Sometimes the differences are less apparent, sometimes more. Once in awhile a piece will appear on the Acton site or from an Acton writer that brings this discussion to the fore. Last mentary...
The Dog Days of European Socialized Medicine
In August, the Wall Street Journal Europe published an article exploring the difference in health care received by domesticated animals and humans. (see “Man Vs. Mutt: Who Gets the Better Treatment?” in WSJ Europe, August 8, 2009) The editorialist, Theodore Dalrymple (pen name for outspoken British physician and NHS critic, Dr. Anthony Daniels) argued that dogs and other human pets in his country receive much better routine and critical healthcare than humans: their treatment is “much more pleasant than British...
Journal of Markets & Morality, Spring 2009
We’re happy to announce that the latest print issue of the Journal of Markets & Morality is available online. The Spring 2009 issue includes a noteworthy study by Alan T. Y. Chan and Shu-kam Lee. In “Christ and Business Culture: Another Classification of Christians in Workplaces According to an Empirical Study in Hong Kong,” Chan and Lee outline four types of Christians at work: Christian soldiers, panic followers, strugglers, and Sunday Christians. Following the classification, Chan and Lee “develop a...
Religion & Liberty Interviews Amity Shlaes
The new issue of Religion & Liberty features an interview titled “Debating the Depression” with noted columnist and author Amity Shlaes. Shlaes does a superb job at reminding us about some of the consequences associated with massive government spending and regulation. First and foremost among these consequences is the burden of debt and taxes we are heaping upon future generations. This kind of expansion, without the means to pay for it, will sadly have a negative impact upon the quality...
The Inevitability of Finance And The Call of the Entrepreneur
“The Deal Professor,” Steven M. Davidoff, has a good piece at The New York Times website about the indispensability of finance to our economy. It briefly rebuts the view popularized in the Oliver Stone movie Wall Street, in which financiers are portrayed as greedy parasites. I left ment at the web page, noting that our documentary The Call of the Entrepreneur makes a similar case. I include ment below, since it may not pass muster with the ment moderator: A...
Impossible Promises on Health Care
I still haven’t quite gotten to a thorough fisking of “Exhibit B,” yet, and will have to be satisfied with arguing the following thesis in the meantime: It is impossible to increase insurance coverage in America without increasing medical spending. We cannot save enough on bureaucratic reform and government-induced petition” to offset the new costs associated with an influx of 40+ million new participants. Certainly the newly mandated premiums, paid by those who have determined for themselves that it is...
Christ, Culture, and the City
From the vision of the New Jerusalem in Revelation 21 to Augustine’s City of God, the civitas is an enormously pervasive and rich biblical and theological theme. On the contemporary scene there area number of indications that evangelicals are looking more deeply and critically at engagement with the “city” as a social, political, ethical, and theological reality. This is part of the explicit vision of The King’s College in New York City, for instance, where Acton research fellow Anthony Bradley...
Potential and the Peace Prize
In his book Elements of Justice (reviewed in the Journal of Markets & Morality here), University of Arizona philosophy and economics professor David Schmidtz introduces the idea of desert not simply as pensatory notion, but also as including a promissory aspect. That is, what we deserve isn’t always about only what we have done. There might be a real sense in which what we do after an opportunity provides a kind of retroactive justification for having been given a chance....
Less Religion Means More Government
My article from this week’s Acton News & Commentary: munism adopted Karl Marx’s teaching that religion was the “opiate of the masses” and launched a campaign of bloody religious persecution. Marx was misguided about the role of religion but years later munists became aware that turning people away from religious life increases dependence on government to address life’s problems. The history of government coercion es from turning from religion to government makes a new study suggesting a national decline in...
Philanthropy Cannot Serve Two Masters
This week’s mentary looks at the trend by many in the charitable sector to e increasingly reliant on government support. Sign up for the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary newsletter in the form here (right hand sidebar). —– The independence of American charities has steadily eroded in recent years as more philanthropic institutions e to see their mission as one of partnership or collaboration with the government. That’s a nice way of saying, “seeking government dough.” Now, in the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved