Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Literature, Empathy and American Prosperity
Literature, Empathy and American Prosperity
Nov 22, 2025 9:21 AM

From devastating racially-motivated murders in Charleston, South Carolina, to a contentious SCOTUS ruling on same-sex marriage, to heightened partisan rhetoric from presidential contenders, the constant discord at all levels of society has never been more apparent. Even the a superficial analysis of the news demonstrates that much of this controversy is born out of people’s unwillingness – or alarming inability – to step into another’s shoes, understand his unique perspective, motivations and challenges, and then work together to formulate a productive response.

This lack of meaningful connections among citizens is plex problem. It contributes to the crippling partisanship that paralyzes government, to the violence that rips apart cities from Chicago to Baltimore, and to staggering disparity between impoverished nations and those that can provide aid.

Robert Brownstein sums it up well in his recent National Journal article, noting that in many ways, America is “inverting the e pluribus formula.” Instead of “out of many, one,” he writes, “a national motto that more accurately describes our modern disaggregation would read: ‘out of one, many.’

“What binds a nation now woven with so many distinct threads? The fault lines in our diversifying society are obvious. Less apparent is our continuing convergence around shared aspirations (that each generation should live better than its predecessor) and values (among them munity, and personal responsibility). Except during the Civil War, what unites America has always been greater than what divides us. The tragedy in Charleston offers one especially ominous measure of the risks we face if we can’t remember that powerful truth. Far more than the Founders anticipated (and perhaps preferred), we are now truly ‘many.’ That plicated, but only made more urgent, the challenge of finding mon cause to unite this kaleidoscope of a society as ‘one.’”

This is plicated, urgent challenge, but es packaged with a glimmer of hope – that Americans will recognize our shared aspirations and, by occupying mon ground, find a way to e division with unity and meaningful progress.

My suggestion for how to act on that challenge is simple to the point of seeming absurd. I think it would make a significant impact if Americans collectively participated in more serious intellectual engagement with arts and literature, within the higher education system and beyond. If the root of our problems really is a breakdown munication and connection, literature has some incredibly powerful tools to help. In the words of Northwestern University professor Gary Saul Morson, it can teach us to “learn from within what it feels like to be someone else.”

All politicians know that they must appeal to voters, yet many seem unable to genuinely connect to and empathize with the electorate, interpreting the narrative of their experiences and then acting in a way that addresses their struggles and hopes. And that’s just one example – business leaders, lawyers, physicians, economists and more would all benefit from enhanced ability to understand municate effectively with the people they are working with (and for).

As Morson points out, while “many disciplines teach that we ought to empathize with others … these disciplines do not involve actual practice in empathy.” We’ve all been told that higher education must be practical to be worth the price tag. I don’t disagree with that. However, I agree with Morson that learning how to engage with literature and, by extension, with others, is a very practical, widely-applicable skill.

I worry petence in finance, programming, or political science isn’t enough to e the division and tension in America today if it lacks an underlying structure of connection and empathy. As Morson said, “Reading a novel, you experience the perceptions, values and quandaries of a person from another epoch, society, religion, social class, culture, gender or personality type. … Great literature allows one to think and feel from within how other cultures think and feel. The greater the premium on understanding other cultures in their own terms, the more the study of literature matters.”

“Other cultures” could mean people of another nation, whether that’s Greece or Egypt or Russia or Mexico. It could mean people of other political parties, of other races or ethnicities, of other religions, of other regions of our own country. It could mean the executives of a rival corporation or the staff at pany of your dreams.

Currently, the premium on understanding such “other cultures” is skyrocketing. To restore the e pluribus unum paradigm of American society, we need to improve our ability to understand each other better, to empathize with each other. Literature is not about sentimentality or vapid emotion. It has practical benefit – if you understand how your political nemesis is thinking, perhaps you can find ways to articulate your views in a way that resonates with him, addresses the gaps in his logic and pushes you toward a solution. If you know what motivates your employees, you can find ways to boost their morale and your bottom line. If you understand better what it is like to live below the poverty line in America or without basic necessities in a refugee camp, then you can tailor your response to help more people more efficiently.

It’s not necessarily about the specific content of what you read; it’s the underlying practice of putting yourself inside another person’s head, inhabiting a narrative that is not your own, and considering perspectives that you do not share. Time spent actually exercising these skills and improving your capacity to connect and empathize with people – actually reading literature – is time well spent. It’s a concrete step to making you a more effective leader, better positioned to address the crises in our country today and cross the fault lines that have distanced us from each other.

Reading a book won’t singlehandedly bring about the end of American conflict – but it may make you better equipped to start.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Editorial: Where’s the morality?
Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg is quoted in yesterday’s Pittsburgh Tribune-Review editorial on Goldman Sachs: The most shocking moment in Tuesday’s Senate hearing on Goldman Sachs wasn’t Sen. Carl Levin’s repeated use of the big investment house’s scatological description of its own dubious offerings. No, it was when one of Goldman’s high cluckety-clucks actually said that it has no ethical responsibility to tell clients that it is betting against the same investments it mends. That really is (expletive deleted). Samuel...
Tocqueville on Earth Day?
I know I am a little late on this post, but… This year marks the 40th Anniversary of Earth Day, but if we want to understand its origins, one of the best sources is Alexis de Tocqueville’s master work, Democracy in America and his chapter on Democracy and Pantheism. It’s short, but to the point. It’s also Tocqueville so read it carefully. I found an online version at the University of Virginia’s website. You can read the chapter and the...
Obamacare Prognosis: Not Looking Good
I’m a little slow getting to this–some readers have doubtless already seen media reports–but if you weren’t yet aware of the Obama Administration’s actuaries’ study of the probable effects of Obamacare (released last Thursday), you should be. Our friend, Grace-Marie Turner of the Galen Institute presents the lowlights at NRO. Among the predictions: Tens of billions of dollars in new fees and excise taxes will be “passed through to health consumers in the form of higher drug and devices prices...
Pure and Undefiled Religion
James 1:27 states: Religion that is pure and undefiled before God and the Father is this: to visit orphans and widows in their affliction, and to keep oneself unstained from the world. Last week I had the chance to meet up again with Tom Davis, CEO of Children’s Hope Chest. Hope Chest works with orphans in various countries around the world including South Africa, Swaziland, and Russia. There mission is to advocate a munity munity” partnership model. While many great...
Colson: Creation and Man
On The Christian Post, Chuck Colson talks about Earth Day and Christian world view in “Creation and Man.” … Christians are rightly concerned that extremists have turned Earth Day into “Worship-Earth Day.” Just listen to a few of these suggestions for Earth Day 2010 that some of the more radical groups are proposing: taking down “global eco-criminals” like Exxon-Mobil; having school kids meditate about the Spirit of Life (that’s “Spirit of Life” with capital letters); seeking international cooperation on reducing...
Acton on Tap — April 27: Are Tea Parties good for America?
Join us on Tuesday, April 27, at Derby Station in Grand Rapids as we continue our Acton on Tap series, a casual and fun night out to discuss important and timely ideas with friends. This time around, Jordan Ballor & Ray Nothstine will host our discussion and friendly debate on the question, “Are Tea Parties good for America?” Our casual start time is 6pm; The discussion starts at 6:30. Derby Station [view map] 2237 Wealthy St. SE, East Grand Rapids...
Re: Die Hard — The Welfare State
News reports today on the Greek debt crisis are packed with scary terms like “implosion” and “financial doomsday” and “ebola” and “contagion.” The anxiety has ratcheted up considerably this week, and not just for EU heads of state but also for President Obama. He should be worried. As I pointed out in a previous post, “Die Hard — The Welfare State,” the United States awaits its own day of reckoning for the sins of mounting government debt, a bloated public...
Acton Lecture Series: Alinsky for Dummies
Background on the next Acton Lecture Series event: Join us on Thursday, May 6 to hear Mr. Joseph Morris’ lecture Alinsky for Dummies: His Persistent Influence and Its Meaning for American Society and Politics. Saul Alinsky might be called the “anti-Acton.” As Lord Acton warned that power corrupts, Saul Alinsky — the father of modern munity organizing” — rejoiced that corruption empowers. Decades after Alinsky’s death his ideas and teaching continue to shape the American political and social landscape. Barack...
Dear Old Golden Rule Days
There have been many published articles lately about school curriculum, school performance, school choice, and the Obama dictates that are aimed at pumping more money and asserting more control of an already mediocre performing public school industry. In The Wall Street Journal, University of Dallas professor David ments on a revised Texas school’s U.S. History curriculum that has been proposed and awaits approval. It’s caused a stir among the educrates but that’s partly due to a longtime feud between academic...
Prophet Jim Wallis Explains the Doctrine of Coercive Repentance
In a new column on Sojourners, Prophet Jim Wallis reveals that Wall Street financiers ing to him for confession, sometimes skulking along darkened streets to hide their shame: e like Nicodemus – a religious leader who came to talk to Jesus in private – at night. Many have felt remorseful about what happened on Wall Street and how it has hurt so many people. They describe the behavior in their profession with words such as “greedy,” “risky,” or “reckless.” These...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved