Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Journalists Bearing False Witness in Boston
Journalists Bearing False Witness in Boston
Mar 18, 2025 9:09 AM

There are arguably two forces that may be destroying the ethics of journalism today. The first is petition for rankings and advertising that drives the obsession to report something “first” in a 24-hour news cycle. The second is that social media exacerbates the first. These two forces make journalists vulnerable to poor, unethical reporting. We are seeing this play out in what could easily be considered unethical coverage of the tragedy in Boston by CNN and other news platforms.

On Wednesday CNN’s John King reported from law enforcement “sources” that the suspect was a dark-skinned male.

“I want to be very careful about this, because people get very sensitive when you say these things…I was told by one of these sources who is a law enforcement official that this is a dark-skinned male.”

In fact, many other news media outlets have been misled by “sources” that were simply wrong. When CNN and others reported that there was a suspect there actually was no suspect. There was no “dark skin male” or any other male. Eric Deggans, reporting for the Tampa Bay Times explained the debacle:

CNN anchor John King reported around 1:30 p.m. [on Wednesday] that police had identified a suspect in the bombing. About 15 minutes later, he added that an arrest had been made, citing sources in Boston police department, backed by a former presidential homeland security advisor-turned-CNN contributor, Fran Townsend.

Fox News also sent a message on Twitter at 2:05 p.m. saying suspect had been arrested; seven minutes later, the Boston Globe tweeted an arrest was “imminent” and three minutes after that, the Associated Press reported on Twitter that a suspect had been taken into custody.

They were all wrong. Very wrong.

Understandably, the gravity of the event may explain why there was such a frenzy to report based on shoddy information, but journalism has ethical standards because the consequences for misrepresenting the truth can be dire. The standard used to be “verify, then report,” but today the standard is “report, and apologize later if you feel like it.” For example, journalists listening to the Boston Police scanner named Sunil Tripathi, a 22-year-old student at Brown University who has been missing since March 16th, as a suspect in the Boston bombing even though no official report of Tripathi’s role had been announced by the FBI. It was then reported on social media, again, without official verification from federal law enforcement. A few hours later, after the initial report from shoddy sources, Tripathi’s family became victims of brutally vitriolic messages all over the internet. The family and supporters of Tripathi actually took down the Facebook page established to help find their missing son, brother, and friend. The Facebook page is back online today with this message:

A tremendous and painful amount of attention has been cast on our beloved Sunil Tripathi in the past twelve hours. We have known unequivocally all along that neither individual suspected as responsible for the Boston Marathon bombings was Sunil. We are grateful to all of you who have followed us on Facebook, Twitter, and Reddit—supporting us over the recent hours. Now more than ever our greatest es from your enduring support. We thank all of you who have reached out to our family and ask that you continue to raise awareness and to help us find our gentle, loving, and thoughtful Sunil.

The bottom line is that, because of perverse incentives, the news media did wrong by the Tripathi family by alleging, without verification, that this young mitted an act of violence and murder that he did not, in mit. The resultant reporting is simply an instance of “bearing false witness.” In the future, because of advertising and social media branding pressures, news media outlets are going to make better trade-offs for the sake of doing what is right because there is more to reporting than ratings and advertising revenue. mitted to the truth, and reporting the truth, is the best way to maintain credibility as a reliable source for news and information. CNN, and others, failed us all in this regard this week.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Love, Community, and The Walking Dead
The sixth season finale ofThe Walking Dead aired last night and sets up an anxious off-season of waiting and deliberation about what will happen next. I may have some more to say about the larger dynamics of the show as the survivors in this most recent season have really transitioned from concerns about mere survival to actually munity with longer-term plans. But for now I want to focus briefly on the path Carol has walked over the last few episodes...
Payday lending is a debt trap. But regulatory ‘solutions’ may be even worse.
What’s the biggest problem with payday loans? The obvious answer would seem to be “high interest rates.” But interest rates are often tied to credit risk, and so charging high interest rates is not always wrong. Another answer may be that the loans appear to be targeted toward minorities. But research shows that the industry appeals to those with financial problems regardless of race or ethnicity. No, the problem with payday loans —what makes them a debt trap — is...
Samuel Gregg: Catholicism and the Enlightenment
Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg reviews a new book at the Library of Law and Liberty that demolishes the canard that religious figure were “somehow opposed holus bolus to Enlightenment ideas is one that has been steadily discredited over the last 50 years.” In his review of The Catholic Enlightenment: The Forgotten History of a Global Movement by by Ulrich L. Lehner, Gregg points out that the new book shows how “the Enlightenment argument for freedom was embraced by many...
Why Edmund Burke Supported Free Trade
The Republican Party is fracturing on the topic of trade. Alas, in the same corners where free and open exchange was once embraced as a propeller for economic growth and dynamism, protectionism is starting to stick. In response, free traders are pushing the typical arguments about growth, innovation, and prosperity. Others, such as myself, are noting that the trend has less to do with economic illiteracy than it does with a protectionism of the heart — a self-seeking ethos that...
The Disabled Deserve the Dignity of Work
Last week, Hillary Clinton became the first major presidential candidate to ever mend paying all disabled workers the minimum wage. While its seems like a reasonable proposal, I explained why the effect would be to put workers with severe disabilities, such as those with Down syndrome, out of work. Clinton isn’t the only one pushing such measures, though. As Anne Schieber of the Mackinac Center notes, government regulators at the Department of Labor are also considering mandating “integrated work settings,”...
SEC Allows Activist Nuns’ Climate-Change Resolution
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission determined March 22 that ExxonMobil Corporation must for the first time ever allow a vote to proceed on a proxy shareholder resolution submitted by members of the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility. ExxonMobil had attempted to block the resolution with the SEC on the grounds it was vaguely written, pany’s current business practices already aligned with the ICCR resolution and current U.S. regulations. Because any plans for climate-change mitigation in the near future inherently...
5 Facts About Genocide Against Christians in the Middle East
“ISIS mitting genocide — the “crime of crimes” — against Christians and other religious groups in Syria, Iraq and Libya,” says a joint report by the Knights of Columbus and In Defense of Christians. “It is time for the United States to join the rest of the world by naming it and by taking action against it as required by law.” The Knights of Columbus became involved in supporting Christians and other religious minorities in this Middle East because of...
Explainer: What You Should Know About the Panama Papers Scandal
What are the Panama Papers? The Panama Papers refers to the 11 million leaked files from the Panamanian law firm Mossack Fonsecathat shows how some of the richest, most powerful people on the globe use tax havens to hide their wealth. According to the BBC, this is the biggest document leak in history — dwarfing the size of those released by the Wikileaks organization —and includes details on 214,000 entities, panies, trusts and foundations. The documents covered day-to-day business at...
A ‘moral imperative’ or just another exercize in green politicking?
This past Friday, I blogged about the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s recent decision to allow a vaguely worded proxy resolution proceed to a vote. The resolution was submitted by, among others, members of the religious shareholder activist group the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility. The ICCR resolution calls upon ExxonMobil Corporation to take action intended to mitigate climate change. ExxonMobil requested the SEC deny the ICCR resolution on the grounds it was based mainly on nonspecific greenhouse-gas reduction targets...
Losing faith in reason
A lack of reason may lead to violence and an inability to respond to crises, but that didn’t stop the West from abandoning it. In a new article for the Catholic World Report, Acton’s Samuel Gregg reflects on Pope Benedict XVI and his 2006 address near Regensburg, Germany. “Ten years later,” Gregg laments, the West is “still in denial.” On September 12, 2006 Benedict made global news with his lecture–his words enraged, gained support, and were analyzed countless times. The...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved