Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Jeb Bush Says Work Harder; Americans Respond By Complaining
Jeb Bush Says Work Harder; Americans Respond By Complaining
Jan 9, 2025 1:17 PM

During a recent interview, presidential candidate Jeb Bush outlined his economic plan, which included a goal of achieving 4 percent economic growth.

As for how we might achieve thatgrowth, Bush went mita grave and sinful error, daring implythat Americans might need to work a bit harder:

My aspiration for the country —and I believe we can achieve it —is 4 percent growth as far as the eye can see,” he told the newspaper. “Which means we have to be a lot more productive, workforce participation has to rise from its all-time modern lows. It means that people need to work longer hours and, through their productivity, gain more e for their families. That’s the only way we’re going to get out of this rut that we’re in.

The pundits descended, the trolls ignited, and peting politicians proceeded to pounce, including his chief rival, Hillary Clinton, who tweeted: “Anyone who believes Americans aren’t working hard enough hasn’t met enough American workers.” The mediafollowed in turn, runningnumerous stories on the “real” barriers to economic growth: economicinequality, low wages, and — my personal least-favorite — a lack of “good jobs.”

Bush eventually retorted, later explaining how his remarks were taken out of contextand so on and so on.

There’s plenty of fun we can have in debating all that. But regardless of what he didor didn’t mean and what the present or future reality might actually be, the whole spectacle serves as a rather discouraging case study on our country’s shifting cultural attitudes. Recall the basicsequence of events:

Politiciansays we should work more hours if we want to petitive.Americans respond by working plaining about hours and whining about jobs and wages.

Note that every previousgeneration in America worked far longer hours in far worse jobs and were far poorer than we are today. Theytoiled in dire conditions, breathing dirty air, working exhausting hours, and bringing in little pay.And yet, would their first (or second or third) response to #1 be anything close to #2?

Would our ancestorsrespond to this type of rallying cry with pessimism and entitled shruggery? Would those who persevered throughthe Great Depression — who had every reason to be frustrated and broken by their toil — respond to calls for increased hard work and perseverance by saying, “I’m already working hard and long enough, and by the way, get me a better job”?

Our attitudes about work and wages matter. They have the profound power totransform hearts, orient the work of our hands, amplify our economic vision, and elevate the trajectory of civilization. But when corrupted, they distort and pervert the economic order toour peril, distracting us toward narrow materialism and contract-obsessed minimum-mindedness.

When one considers this,the reactionary angst on display mayseem small, but it is nevertheless a signal of an increasingly warped American imagination.

The arguments will vary as to what the “real” economic solution might be. But if I’ve learned anything about the hearts and minds of those who built this country before us, I have a hunch they wouldn’t respond to“work harder” with moping cynicism.

I’m not sure what they’d say, but the voice in my head sounds more like,“Oh yeah? Watch this.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
‘Tea Party Catholic’ Now Available as an eBook
Samuel Gregg’s latest, Tea Party Catholic, is now available for the Kindle. You can buy this version through Amazon, or if you prefer the paper version, visit Robert P George, professor of jurisprudence at Princeton University says, “The book is as carefully and, indeed, rigorously argued as it is provocatively titled. It is a great resource for anyone—Catholic or not—who wants to know what the Church really teaches about the moral requirements of the socio-economic and political orders.” If you...
‘They’re Always Coming To You Offering You More Programs’
An exceedingly honest woman called into an Austin, Texas, radio talk show, KLBJ, to discuss why she chooses not to work. She, her husband and three children rely on tax dollars for shelter, utilities and food. She admits that her parents did not work either, and that free money and programs were offered all the time. And what’s wrong with that? [product sku=1177] ...
Israel Really Wants A King (Part I)
I recently posted some thoughts at The Power Blog on “God’s Problem With Centralized Power”, which took a macro view of what I believe to be God’s clear disdain for mankind pursuing their own ends instead of His articulated purposes when es to how we organize munally. This time I want to highlight a specific, micro-level example of that same general idea. The story of Israel’s demand for a king inI Samuel 8contains so many relevant, interesting nuggets of insight...
‘Good Morning, I’m A Rapist; Can You Help Me Out Here?’
How easy is it for a 33 year old man to buy Plan B for his 15 year old “girlfriend?” Not too hard at all. In fact, the folks in this video from Students for Life don’t bat an eye – even when he makes it clear how old he is and how young his “girlfriend” is. Keep in mind that there is no state in the U.S. where it is legal for a 33 year old to have sexual...
Key Injunction Won In HHS Case
The Catholic Dioceses of Pittsburgh and Erie, along with several nonprofit groups, have won a preliminary injunction against implementing the HHS mandate. U.S. District Judge Arthur J. Schwab granted an injunction in favor of these organizations. The injunction allows them to continue to offer insurance that doesn’t include contraception, sterilization and abortion-inducing drugs while litigation continues. Without the injunction, the insurance administrators for the organizations — though not the dioceses themselves — would have had to start providing the coverage...
‘Get Your Hands Dirty’: The Importance of a Rightly Ordered Life
At the Values & Capitalism blog, Jacqueline Otto Isaacs reviews Jordan Ballor’s Get Your Hands Dirty. Isaacs explains how Ballor articulates a vision for the proper orientation for our lives: In his recent release, “Get Your Hands Dirty,” Jordan Ballor of the Acton Institute lays out a clear case for why Christians ought to have rightly ordered lives and what that might look like. While the book took shape around a collection of essays, this message was as hard to...
Imagination And Virtue
Anne got her best friend, Diana, drunk. Sick-drunk. Neither was old enough to drink, and Anne didn’t really mean to, but…there it was. Diana’s mother was horrified, and forbade the friendship to go on. Anne was crushed. She really had made a mistake: what she thought was a cordial was wine. It was a hard lesson. If you ever read Anne of Green Gables, you know this story. Things get set aright – partly by the adults, and partly by...
Evangelicalism, Large Cities, and the ‘Other’ Christians
One of the profound realities of theology and ecclesiastical enclaves in which American Christians live is each tribal subculture views the world as if Christianity begins and ends with their tribe. Evangelicals are a great example of this trend. Some evangelicals write as if they are the only Christians doing God’s work in the world. For example, Joy Allmond recently wrote a perplexing article about New York City asking “Is New York City on the Brink of a Great Awakening?”...
Don’t Fret About the Premium Increases, You Can Just Pay More in Taxes to Subsidize Yourself
Yesterday I was reading an article about Obamacare in the Washington Post. . . Whether they know about that financial help is a different question, as many have had trouble using HealthCare.gov to figure out how much insurance would cost under the Affordable Care Act. And the study does not include information on whether those subsides would lead to lower premiums for shoppers buying in the health law’s new exchanges. “There’s no question that when people get better coverage it...
So, Why Exactly Doesn’t Healthcare.gov Work?
The Obama Administration has stated that 106,000 people have managed to sign up for health care on the Healthcare.gov site, a site 3-1/2 years in the making. Both HHS Director Kathleen Sebelius and Deputy Chief Information Officer for the Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Henry Cho, have been grilled by mittees as to the incredibly poor performance of the website. What exactly went wrong? NPR’s All Tech Considered breaks it down. There are two popular methods of software development....
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved