Home
/
Isiam
/
Islamic World
/
Libyan Karzai? Chalabi? Forget it
Libyan Karzai? Chalabi? Forget it
Aug 14, 2026 6:35 AM

  NATO's political mission "should swiftly identify and nurture a national opposition and plot the path for a post-conflict transition to democracy, probably under UN auspices", or so advises the Financial Times in its lead editorial, "Plotting the Way Forward".

  Both the title and the advice are borrowed from a past era: the post-Afghanistan invasion strategy that plotted the nurturing, financing, and supporting of Hamid Karzai's - the former US corporate oil executive - bid for the presidency.

  Or another throwback: pre- and post-invasion of Iraq, when London and Washington plotted their invasion as they prepared the Iraq National Congress to hopefully replace Saddam's regime.

  Except that this FT editorial comes a decade later and proposes the same plan as the way forward in Libya! Where NATO powers are exploiting their military role to define, or at least influence, the post-Gaddafi alternative.

  Too much of a sense of deja vu? Or the recurring nightmare of predictable Western political interference that follows military intervention using whichever pretext is available; be it 'war on terror', 'weapons of mass destruction', or 'humanitarian intervention'?

  The Libyan National Council, transitional

  Fortunately, the Council wasn't made-in-the-USA or manufactured by another foreign power. Rather it came into existence, a month ago, at Libyans' own initiative, soon after the winds of revolutionary change blew Libya's way, and after its people rose to the occasion with pride and courage.

  Most of the 31 council members are unknown to the media. And the few with a mandate to attain Western and international recognition have used all contacts from their previous official roles or grabbed onto Western overtures through whatever channels possible, even unsavoury French connections, to get it.

  Sources close to the council claim Western powers have opened channels of communications not in return for future Libyan concessions but rather out of concern that they would be left out of post-Gaddafi Libya and its economic opportunities.

  And unlike some of the Libyan diplomats who jumped ship all too recently, and who shifted their position from loyalty to Gaddafi to passionate proponents of Western ground military intervention, the Transitional Council has insisted on a limited UN authorized intervention.

  Indeed, the council insists that the Libyan people could stand up to Gaddafi on their own provided the playing field/battlefield has been leveled with the Gaddafi's militias, either by providing them with arms or neutralizing the regime's heavy weaponry.

  Once again, the aspirations of people on the ground, i.e. the Arabs, seem to count for little in Washington, Paris and London as they debate how far to go with their intervention.

  While the Council is indispensable for engaging the outside world, it's bound by and must represent the aspirations and demands of the revolutionaries fighting on the ground throughout Libya that include fighters and communities, and tribal leaders from all walks of life.

  Council members who stray from their mandate in favor of Western dictates are certain to find themselves as outcasts. Even attempts at establishing a transitional or emergency government, without sufficient consultation with the base, were met with indignation and rejection last week. It ended up as no more than a symbolic emergency committee.

  Libya for the Libyans

  Overreaching Europeans are already clamoring to define and mortgage Libya's future. Libya is a European, not an American problem, they claim. And hence, so is the solution and the benefits.

  Unwilling to recognize Libya as an independent country that belongs to its people and part of an Arab, not Western, sphere of influence.

  Incapable of conceiving the revolutionary transformations that swept through the region, especially those of Libya's neighbors, Egypt and Tunisia, the British, French and Italians still hope for influence over the next government.

  But Libya isn't likely to emerge as a client state, or be led by client leadership, no matter how long the NATO bombardment goes on or how long Gaddafi holds onto power.

  The British tested the water already when they asked for the extradition of Omar Ahmed Sudani - the man accused of killing British policewoman Yvonne Fletcher in London in 1984, but were turned down.

  Any aspiring leader who seeks a political future in post-Gaddafi Libya knows all too well that people power - not NATO power - and mandate is indispensable.

  None of the Council's senior leaders want to be identified or even remotely associated with NATO's plans for Libya. For them, NATO's nurturing of the Libyan opposition means only one of two: Afghanistan's Karzai or Iraq's Chalabi.

  PHOTO CAPTION

  A Libyan revolution fighter holds his rifle alongside a fellow fighter as they walk along the city of Ras Lanuf, near Ajdabiyah March 27, 2011.

  Source: Aljazeera.net

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Islamic World
Who is held to account for civilian deaths by drone in Yemen?
  There is a history of Yemeni officials lying to protect the US, and the Pentagon and CIA greeting queries with obfuscation.   When news flashed of an air strike on a vehicle in the Yemeni city of Radaa on Sunday afternoon, early claims that ‘al-Qaida militants had died’ soon gave way...
The foot soldiers in Syria's war
  The food is piled high. Steaming pots of seasoned tomatoes and potatoes, yogurt and cucumber, cheese and piles of tortilla-like khubz, dipped in oil. A dozen or so young Syrian men crowd around, chattering excitedly about the day's events.   These men are foot soldiers in the public relations wing of...
Children caught up in Afghan war
  In what had become a daily ritual, Anisa Shahghasi said goodbye to her son, Nawab, with prayers on her lips and a quick wave of her hand.   The world outside their cramped Kabul home was fraught with dangers. And like every other mother in the Afghan capital - which still...
Amnesty: Syrian civilians suffer most in Aleppo
  Human rights group Amnesty International says artillery and mortar fire and airstrikes by regime forces in the northern city of Aleppo are killing mostly civilians, including children.   A new Amnesty report released Thursday said air and artillery strikes against residential neighborhoods are indiscriminate attacks that seriously endanger civilians.   Government troops...
Former Israeli Soldiers Confess Abuse of Palestinian Children
  Testimony by ex-Israeli Defense Force soldiers reveals a devastating portrayal of ill-treatment and abuse of Palestinian youth by members of Israel's occupying army in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.   The testimony by more than 30 soldiers, and fashioned into a booklet by Breaking the Silence, an organization of former...
Israel ex-soldiers say troops abused Palestinian kids
  Former Israeli soldiers who served in the occupied territories say that mistreatment of Palestinian children by troops is "routine" and occurs even at times of relative calm.   A collection of over 30 testimonies published on Sunday by Breaking the Silence, a group of ex-servicemen critical of army practices, says physical...
Education suffers in East Jerusalem
  As thousands of Palestinian youth began the new school year last week, serious concerns have been raised over how a systemic lack of facilities, resources and investment into East Jerusalem schools is impacting the level of education.   According to a recent report released by human rights groups the Association for...
The battle for Area C
  Palestinians face severe restrictions in the more than 60 per cent of the West Bank under full Israeli control.   Dozens of tents, made of wooden planks, small boulders and plastic tarps, cling to the rocky hilltop. Tires, garbage, shoes, children's clothes and broken electronic equipment are strewn between the tents,...
Syria files reveal regime espionage
  In the ransacked and burnt-out remains of various security headquarters in al-Bab lie many clues to the means used by Bashar al-Assad's government to stay in power, revealing why life under the regime had become increasingly intolerable for its citizens.   In the widely-hated building of military security, the formerly locked...
Western report - Iran ships arms, personnel to Syria via Iraq
  Iran has been using civilian aircraft to fly military personnel and large quantities of weapons across Iraqi airspace to Syria to aid President Bashar al-Assad in his attempt to crush an 18-month uprising against his government, according to a Western intelligence report seen by Reuters.   Earlier this month, U.S. officials...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved