Home
/
Isiam
/
Islamic World
/
Libyan Karzai? Chalabi? Forget it
Libyan Karzai? Chalabi? Forget it
Nov 16, 2025 7:54 AM

  NATO's political mission "should swiftly identify and nurture a national opposition and plot the path for a post-conflict transition to democracy, probably under UN auspices", or so advises the Financial Times in its lead editorial, "Plotting the Way Forward".

  Both the title and the advice are borrowed from a past era: the post-Afghanistan invasion strategy that plotted the nurturing, financing, and supporting of Hamid Karzai's - the former US corporate oil executive - bid for the presidency.

  Or another throwback: pre- and post-invasion of Iraq, when London and Washington plotted their invasion as they prepared the Iraq National Congress to hopefully replace Saddam's regime.

  Except that this FT editorial comes a decade later and proposes the same plan as the way forward in Libya! Where NATO powers are exploiting their military role to define, or at least influence, the post-Gaddafi alternative.

  Too much of a sense of deja vu? Or the recurring nightmare of predictable Western political interference that follows military intervention using whichever pretext is available; be it 'war on terror', 'weapons of mass destruction', or 'humanitarian intervention'?

  The Libyan National Council, transitional

  Fortunately, the Council wasn't made-in-the-USA or manufactured by another foreign power. Rather it came into existence, a month ago, at Libyans' own initiative, soon after the winds of revolutionary change blew Libya's way, and after its people rose to the occasion with pride and courage.

  Most of the 31 council members are unknown to the media. And the few with a mandate to attain Western and international recognition have used all contacts from their previous official roles or grabbed onto Western overtures through whatever channels possible, even unsavoury French connections, to get it.

  Sources close to the council claim Western powers have opened channels of communications not in return for future Libyan concessions but rather out of concern that they would be left out of post-Gaddafi Libya and its economic opportunities.

  And unlike some of the Libyan diplomats who jumped ship all too recently, and who shifted their position from loyalty to Gaddafi to passionate proponents of Western ground military intervention, the Transitional Council has insisted on a limited UN authorized intervention.

  Indeed, the council insists that the Libyan people could stand up to Gaddafi on their own provided the playing field/battlefield has been leveled with the Gaddafi's militias, either by providing them with arms or neutralizing the regime's heavy weaponry.

  Once again, the aspirations of people on the ground, i.e. the Arabs, seem to count for little in Washington, Paris and London as they debate how far to go with their intervention.

  While the Council is indispensable for engaging the outside world, it's bound by and must represent the aspirations and demands of the revolutionaries fighting on the ground throughout Libya that include fighters and communities, and tribal leaders from all walks of life.

  Council members who stray from their mandate in favor of Western dictates are certain to find themselves as outcasts. Even attempts at establishing a transitional or emergency government, without sufficient consultation with the base, were met with indignation and rejection last week. It ended up as no more than a symbolic emergency committee.

  Libya for the Libyans

  Overreaching Europeans are already clamoring to define and mortgage Libya's future. Libya is a European, not an American problem, they claim. And hence, so is the solution and the benefits.

  Unwilling to recognize Libya as an independent country that belongs to its people and part of an Arab, not Western, sphere of influence.

  Incapable of conceiving the revolutionary transformations that swept through the region, especially those of Libya's neighbors, Egypt and Tunisia, the British, French and Italians still hope for influence over the next government.

  But Libya isn't likely to emerge as a client state, or be led by client leadership, no matter how long the NATO bombardment goes on or how long Gaddafi holds onto power.

  The British tested the water already when they asked for the extradition of Omar Ahmed Sudani - the man accused of killing British policewoman Yvonne Fletcher in London in 1984, but were turned down.

  Any aspiring leader who seeks a political future in post-Gaddafi Libya knows all too well that people power - not NATO power - and mandate is indispensable.

  None of the Council's senior leaders want to be identified or even remotely associated with NATO's plans for Libya. For them, NATO's nurturing of the Libyan opposition means only one of two: Afghanistan's Karzai or Iraq's Chalabi.

  PHOTO CAPTION

  A Libyan revolution fighter holds his rifle alongside a fellow fighter as they walk along the city of Ras Lanuf, near Ajdabiyah March 27, 2011.

  Source: Aljazeera.net

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Islamic World
Libya survivor describes 1996 prison massacre
  Anwar Haraga was 26 when men from Libya's Internal Security agency came to his door in Tripoli one night.   It was 1989. Haraga was newly married and had just returned from five years of study in England. He was heading toward a promising career in computer engineering.   But Haraga had...
Deported Palestinians describe prison ordeal
  Hazem Asili, from the West Bank, was 25 years old when he was jailed by Israel in 1986. Abdelhakim Hnaini, also from the West Bank, was 27 years old when he was incarcerated in 1993. On October 11, a deal was brokered exchanging 1,027 Palestinian prisoners held by Israel for...
Palestinians under pressure to drop UN bid
  The Palestinians have came under intense pressure to drop a bid for UN membership as diplomats worked behind the scenes to head off a looming clash.   Riyad al-Maliki, Palestinian foreign minister, said he was "amazed" by the US efforts to persuade other countries to not to support the Palestinian bid....
Free Syrian Army grows in influence
  The attack by the Free Syrian Army (FSA) on an air force intelligence base in the suburbs of the capital Damascus on November 16 has raised the profile of the band of army deserters, who are seeking to end President Bashar al-Assad’s long rule.   Depending on whom you believe, the...
The tides of mosques
  Syrian protesters have been denied access to public spaces, such as the squares that have become famous in Yemen and Egypt. This has led to mosques playing an even greater role than they already would have.   With the number of dead from the uprising reaching possibly five thousand, funerals have...
Palestinian families await prisoner exchange
  One thousand and twenty-seven Palestinians for one Israeli - this is the deal made between Hamas and Israel last week.   The agreement has been dubbed "the Shalit swap deal" - named after Gilad Shalit, the 25-year-old Israeli soldier who has been held in the Gaza Strip for more than five...
Foreign fighters support Israel's settlements
  Two weeks ago, an announcement appeared on a French website, calling for "militants with military experience" to participate in a solidarity trip to Israel between September 19 and 25. "The aim of this expedition is to lend a hand to our brothers facing aggression from the Palestinian occupiers, and to...
Confusion clouds run-up to Egypt elections
  The streets of Egypt are teeming with the telltale signs of an upcoming election.   Campaign posters fill the once-barren spaces on the sides of buildings, and billboards featuring the faces of candidates vying for a role in the new Egypt loom over the crowded streets of Cairo.   However, what many...
Tripoli celebrates first post-Gaddafi Eid
  Libyans in Tripoli's seaside Martyrs Square have marked the first post-Muammar Gaddafi celebration of Eid al-Fitr, coming out in huge numbers to revel in newly gained independence.   At dawn, thousands of men and about 200 women gathered on huge green carpets to make the special dawn prayer, intoning praise for...
Armed defenders of Syria's revolution
  While outsiders debate when or if the Syrian opposition will turn to arms, on the ground it is clear that elements of the opposition have used armed resistance against the security forces from early in the uprising in response to the regime's harsh crackdown.   Over a period of seven weeks,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved