Home
/
Isiam
/
Islamic World
/
Iraq reconstruction 'has failed'
Iraq reconstruction 'has failed'
Dec 6, 2025 3:55 PM

  The US-led force's $100bn effort to rebuild Iraq has failed amid bureaucratic quarrels, ignorance of Iraqi society and violence in the country, the New York Times says, quoting a US federal report.

  The newspaper said on its website on Saturday that it had obtained a draft copy of Hard Lessons: The Iraq Reconstruction Experience, which is circulating among senior officials.

  The report was compiled by the Office of the Special Inspector-General for Iraq Reconstruction, which is led by Stuart Bowen Jr, a Republican lawyer.

  In the report, Colin Powell, the former US secretary of state, alleges that after the 2003 invasion the US defense department kept inflating figures on the number of Iraqi security forces on the ground.

  The defense department "kept inventing numbers of Iraqi security forces - the number would jump 20,000 a week! We now have 80,000, we now have 100,000, we now have 120,000", he is quoted as saying in the draft report.

  The report says that Powell's view was supported by Lieutenant-General Ricardo Sanchez, the most senior ground troops officer in Iraq, and Paul Bremer, who was the civilian administrator before the Iraqi government takeover in June 2004.

  It concludes that the US government does not have the policies or the organizational structure required to put the largest reconstruction program since the Marshall Plan into place, the newspaper reported.

  Cronyism alleged

  The rebuilding effort did not go beyond restoring what was destroyed during the invasion and its immediate aftermath, the newspaper cited the draft report as saying.

  By mid-2008, the report says, $117bn had been spent on the reconstruction of Iraq, including about $50bn in US taxpayer money.

  But Ahmed Rushdi, an Iraqi journalist, said that the money had been squandered or taken by corrupt officials.

  "When you are talking about 117 billion dollars, you are talking about stolen money, misused money, and poor planning. But the Americans and the Iraqis said that these monies were being spent on security," he told Al Jazeera.

  "I think Americans and some Iraqis have got very rich [off the funds] and they decided to get rid of all their documents which would show that something was wrong, particularly in Paul Bremer's administration."

  "We must make a rule on how to charge these people with crimes."

  In one example, an official at the US Agency for International Development (USAID) was given four hours to work out how many miles of Iraqi roads needed to be repaired, the Times said.

  The official's estimate came from documents in USAID's library and was then submitted into a master plan.

  Furthermore, funding for a large amount of Iraqi reconstruction projects was divided up among local politicians and tribal leaders, according to the New York Times.

  "Our district council chairman has become the Tony Soprano of Rasheed, in terms of controlling resources," it quotes one US embassy official in Baghdad as saying.

  "You will use my contractor or the work will not get done.'"

  Political lobbying

  The report also pointed to political maneuvering in the US, highlighting an example where a Republican lobbyist working for the US occupation authority called on the Office of Management and Budget to fund $20bn in new reconstruction money in August 2003.

  "To delay getting our funds would be a political disaster for the president [George Bush]," Tom Korologos, the lobbyist, said, according the report.

  "[Bush's] election will hang for a large part on show of progress in Iraq and without the funding this year, progress will grind to a halt," the draft quoted Korologos as saying.

  The Bush administration supported Korologos' request and the US congress allocated the money later that year.

  The draft report is based on about 500 interviews and more than 600 audits, inspections and investigations undertaken in Iraq over several years.

  PHOTO CAPTION

  Iraqis work at a new construction site in Baghdad in August 2008 [AFP].

  Source: Aljazeera.net

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Islamic World
Syria's greater revolution
  Veteran activists of the current Syrian uprising share their tales of struggle and revolution.   The Syrian revolution began gradually; a protest in Damascus, the detention of teenage anti-regime graffitists in Dar’aa, and the subsequent mass rally for their release that led to a strong military reaction happened over just a...
Mass murder in Kandahar
  As the 16 civilian victims of a US sergeant's shooting spree in southern Afghanistan are buried, new details of the horrific episode are emerging. Nine of those killed were children. Three were women.   The residents of Panjwai district in the volatile Kandahar province said they showed no resistance during the...
Syrian surgeon: Why I'm risking my life to treat protesters
  More than 8,000 people have been killed in Syria since the uprising began a year ago, and many more injured. Fearing ill-treatment at official hospitals, demonstrators have sought help at underground clinics. One Damascus surgeon tells his story.   I was at home, looking out of the window, watching a demonstration,...
Revenge of the settlers
  Palestinians are under increasing attacks from Israeli settlers, especially in the last few years, reports have found.   Fadi Quran is little different from any other Palestinian living in the West Bank, where violence from Israeli settlers is part of daily life. Hailing from the town of Al-Bireh, less than one...
Syrians routinely tortured in detention
  People detained by the Syrian authorities are being systematically and routinely tortured, an Amnesty International report alleges.   The rights group says officials are using techniques including suspending and then beating detainees with fists and rifle butts.   Many of those from whom Amnesty gathered testimony said children were among the torture...
Palestinians forge new strategies of resistance
  A one-state solution in Palestine/Israel is a subject being increasingly discussed and debated. One way in which the conversation has emerged is through an analysis of the current situation as a de facto one state, a regime which privileges Jews above Palestinians (the latter being granted or denied different rights...
US troop massacre "occurred in two stages"
  The U.S. Army sergeant accused of killing 17 Afghan civilians is believed to have carried out the rampage in two stages, returning to base after the first shootings and then going out to kill again, a U.S. official said on Saturday.   The official, speaking on condition of anonymity, did not...
Sharp increase in Palestinian deaths in 2011
  The past year saw a sharp rise in the number of civilians killed in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, a human rights group said.   An annual report from the Jerusalem-based B'Tselem showed that in 2011 Israeli forces killed a total of 105 Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, of whom 37 were confirmed...
The causes of the protests in Afghanistan
  Most American media accounts and commentary about the ongoing violent anti-American protests in Afghanistan depict their principal cause as anger over the burning of copies of the Noble Quran, except that Afghans themselves keep saying things like this:   Protesters in Kabul interviewed on the road and in front of Parliament...
Inside Idlib: Assad crackdown grows in ferocity
  Winter still clings to the ancient cultivated hillsides of the northern Syrian province of Idlib. Nights are chillingly cold; mornings alternate between mist and feeble sun. Under the gnarled olive trees, the soil is naked and neatly raked.   Tens of thousands of trees in rows follow the contours of the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved