Home
/
Isiam
/
Islamic World
/
Egypt's revolution: Dead or alive?
Egypt's revolution: Dead or alive?
Jan 11, 2025 9:53 PM

  As crowds dominate political discourse in Egypt - on one end, those who support the military, and on the other, backers of deposed president Mohamed Morsi - a middle ground is mourning the loss of a dream.

  "My hope was that we don't live in injustice anymore, because we were basically suffering with that for 30 years," said 33-year-old Hamdi Adel, describing his aspirations for Egypt during the January 25, 2011, uprising which toppled long-time dictator Hosni Mubarak.

  Part of the pro-Morsi vigil in Giza, Adel said that the military was "brutalising and bullying the public", adding that, if any of his hopes had been realised, he wouldn't be participating in the sit-in to reinstate Morsi, ousted on July 3.

  For some, a gloomy pragmatism has kicked in since the heady days of the revolution and even since Morsi’s election, which was widely seen as the first free and fair presidential election in the region's most populous nation.

  The slogan "it took 18 days" rang out across the country in the first halcyon days following Mubarak's downfall. A power grab by the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) followed, before the Muslim Brotherhood rose in influence.

  There have been several massacres since the start of the revolution, several surges of protests - against SCAF, against a supraconstitutional document it tried to pass, against Morsi’s decree (granting himself pharaoh-like powers) and against Morsi's presidency itself.

  It was not the jubilant entrée into democracy that many Egyptians had hoped for.

  "There's a difference between dreams and the reality today," said Mahmud Ali of the Egyptian Association for the Support of Democracy.

  "We dreamed and hoped for freedom of expression and justice.

  "As a [human] rights man, I see no major difference between before January 25 and after - there's the same state interference in the democratic process, in addition to the use of money and power and negligence of the poor.

  "Our dreams haven't been met and we’re still in the dilemma of choice between the Muslim Brotherhood and military rule."

  Coup a 'near-fatal blow' to revolution

  While there is a sense that, if the military manages to take over completely, all will be lost, there's also some hope that - through sheer force of will - something will give.

  Morsi's reinstatement - a long shot by all accounts - would send a powerful message to the military; while a return to military rule would, said Mohamed Rezk, a media rights activist, "take the country back even worse than 30 years of Mubarak".

  "If that happens, all of what we achieved in the revolution will be spilled on the streets."

  No-one mentions the interim government as a long-term player in this game - perhaps an indication of a frustrating lack of progress for a country still stuck in a fight between the military and the Islamists.

  Still, the goals of the January 2011 uprising, with its chants for "freedom, bread and social justice" might still be revivied, said Omaima Abou Bakr, a professor at Cairo University and a founding member of the Women and Memory Forum, a Giza-based NGO.

  "I wouldn't go to the extreme to say that it has died, but it has been dealt a near-fatal blow, particularly in the recent military coup. We need a serious concerted effort to revive it," said Abou Bakr.

  "We need to recall what January 2011 was all about - we've lost sight of that."

  She said she had little faith in the current political elite, in whom she's "disappointed".

  "I don’t know who these people are anymore - they haven't been able to transcend this polarisation on the streets."

  PHOTO CAPTION

  The blood of Morsi supporters stains the street following deadly clashes

  Source: Aljazeera.com

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Islamic World
Besieged Gazans seek escape through painkillers
  Abu Abdullah got hooked on painkillers after his house was destroyed and his 12-year-old daughter was killed by Israel's bombardment of the Gaza Strip at the turn of the year.   "I'm not an addict," said the 39-year-old father of five, who now lives in a cramped rented apartment in Gaza...
Israel strips 4577 Palestinians of right to live in Jerusalem
  Israel stripped 4,577 Palestinians of right to live in Jerusalem in 2008, blocking residency status, at a faster rate than at any time in the history of the Jewish state, an Israeli rights group said on Wednesday, citing official Israeli statistics.   "Revocation of residence has reached frightening proportions," said Dalia...
Displaced and desperate in Gaza
  One year has passed since the beginning of Operation Cast lead, Israel's 22-day military assault on the besieged Gaza Strip and suspended is a word that best describes daily life in the Strip; the internal reconciliation process, 'peace talks' with Israel, and most importantly, reconstruction being halted until further notice....
'They kept pumping bullets into us'
  The Iraqi government is under increasing pressure to aggressively pursue the prosecution of American military personnel accused of killing Iraqis.   The recent decision by Ricardo Urbina, a district judge, to dismiss charges against five security contractors accused of gunning down 17 Iraqis, including women and children, in September 2007 has...
Besieged Gazans raise money for Haiti
  Palestinians, living in the Gaza Strip under years of Israel siege, are in efforts to donate what little they have to help those struck by the earthquake in Haiti.   The reason for the destruction might be different, but Palestinians say they understand Haiti's pain.   Gaza is still considered under Israeli...
'Israel stripped body organs off Palestinians'
  An Israeli Knesset member says there is evidence showing that deceased Palestinians were stripped bare of their vital organs while in police custody in Tel Aviv.   Israeli politician and leader of the Arab nationalist party, Ahmad Tibi, said on Saturday that a medical institution in Israel harvested appendages from the...
14 Palestinian homes demolished in Jerusalem in November
  The Land Research Center (LRC) of the Arab Studies Society in Jerusalem reported that the Israeli authorities conducted 187 violations against Jerusalem in November, and demolished 14 Palestinians homes in addition to issuing orders to demolish 170 homes.   The center prepares and publishes its reports in cooperation with the Civil...
Settlers 'stone' school children
  Twaneh School in Hebron has seen some improvements since former UK Prime Minister Tony Blair paid it a visit as UN Middle East envoy last year.   The track leading from the school to the new main road joining Jerusalem to Israeli settlements on the south eastern slopes of Palestine is...
'The building of a steel wall is a new war on Gaza'
  Khaled Mishaal, the head of Hamas’s political bureau, stated Monday that the building of the steel wall on the Palestinian-Egyptian borders is a new war against Gaza people and their resistance.   In a televised statement, Mishaal recalled remarks made by UNRWA commissioner-general Karen Abu Zaid in which she described this...
'My Husband jailed for protesting Israel's wall'
  By Majida Abu Rahmah   On International Human Rights Day in 2008, my husband Abdallah Abu Rahmah was in Berlin receiving a medal from the World Association for Human Rights. Last year on the same day, 10 December, Abdallah was taken away at 2am by Israeli soldiers who broke into our...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved