Home
/
Isiam
/
Islamic World
/
Deir Yassin: No passing over history
Deir Yassin: No passing over history
Jul 6, 2025 6:03 PM

  On April 9, 1948, scores of Palestinian civilians were massacred at the village of Deir Yassin through cooperative efforts of Yishuv forces like the Irgun, Lehi and the Haganah.

  The Zionist narrative on the events of 1948 and the Nakba - the Arabic word for the depopulation of Palestine - talks about the war as a defensive one where there was no intention on behalf of the Israeli forces to shift the demographics by force.

  Rather, that narrative tells us, the refugees were created during the hostilities which began when five Arab armies invaded Israel the day after it declared its independence on May 15, 1948.

  Too often, people who talk about "making peace" advise that we pass over history and look forward without getting lost in the "dueling narratives" of this period. But peace cannot happen without a rectification of past injustices and we cannot approach this without talking about what these injustices are.

  The Zionist narrative will counter, defensively, that any injustices are not the fault of Israel and this is where the issue of "dueling narratives" prevents further discussion.

  But there are simple, undeniable facts that any two sane people, Zionist or otherwise, should be able to agree on. For example, I think we can all agree that April 9, 1948, occurred before May 15, 1948. This is not a matter perspective, this is chronology.

  When you actually look at the history - even versions documented by Israeli historians using official Israeli archival material - what you learn is that a very significant portion of the total refugees were created long before May 15, 1948. Had it not been for the hundreds and thousands of refugees flowing into Arab states and massacres like Deir Yassin, the Arab armies would likely not have been compelled to intervene.

  Clearly, indisputable and historically non-controversial chronological facts blow significant holes in the Zionist narrative about cause and effect. But sequence is not the only problem. The other point of contention Zionists hold is that Israeli actions during the war were defensive and not intended to depopulate.

  The goal of the Zionist movement was to establish a Jewish state in the land of Palestine which had a significant non-Jewish majority of Palestinian Arabs. Through years of immigration, the Zionists managed to grow from 11 per cent of Palestine's inhabitants in 1922 to about 30 per cent in 1946.

  Refugee creation

  The Zionist goal, which was unachievable for decades, came to fruition after 18 months of hostilities when Jews suddenly became 85 per cent of the population of the state of Israel. So, the Zionist narrative will have you believe that the Zionist dream of establishing a state with a Jewish majority, which was unachievable without war then, finally achieved during the fog of one, happened completely by accident.

  One does not have to be a supporter of Israel or Palestine to accept this explanation - just astoundingly naïve.

  Sweeping changes in demographics over territory do not happen by accident. In the modern era, they are invariably state-driven initiatives.

  Prior to May 15, 1948, the Israeli state army, or Haganah, was engaged in conquering and razing scores of civilian villages - not military installations. There is really no "defensive" explanation for the demolition of scores of entire civilian villages. The only possible objective behind such actions is to prevent Palestinian Arabs from having homes to live in and thus force them elsewhere.

  In March 1948, the United States - which had emerged as a superpower after the Second World War - decided to withdraw its support for the 1947 UN Partition Plan because the vacuum of power created by the impending end of the British Mandate would result "in chaos, heavy fighting and much loss of life in Palestine".

  Seeing this, the Zionists knew their shot at achieving a Jewish state through diplomatic means would be delayed at the least, if not abandoned all together. They decided to achieve it by force. That is why the depopulation accelerated at this point.

  Within 45 days, before May 15, 1948, nearly 170 towns and villages had been depopulated, accounting for about 380,000 refugees. This period, prior to the entry of Arab armies, saw the highest rate of refugee creation between 1947 and 1949.

  The effort to change the demography of the landscape by force was in full swing.

  As many marked Easter and Passover this weekend - celebrations of redemption - we should turn our focus today to the anniversary of a massacre and the decisive period of depopulation during which it took place.

  Israelis and Palestinians alike cannot move forward without addressing the original sins the state of Israel was built upon.

  PHOTO CAPTION

  The Massacre of Deir Yassin, Palestine; April 9th, 1948.

  By Yousef Munayyer

  Source: Aljazeera.com

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Islamic World
Displaced Syrians battle for online lifeline
  Yousef sat on the navy couch with his arms wrapped tightly around his legs, and rocked back and forth.   It's a position he has become all too familiar with over the past year. He turned on his laptop and waited fitfully for Skype to load.   "Without Skype I wouldn't be...
UN: Clashes in Iraq's Anbar displaced 300,000
  Violence in Iraq's Sunni-dominated Anbar province, where armed groups fully control one city and parts of another, has displaced up to 300,000 people in six weeks, the United Nations has said.   The province has been hit by a surge in fighting between pro- and anti-government forces that began at the...
Report demands US probe Yemen drone strike
  US policy on drone strikes has been questioned by a rights group who say a strike on a wedding procession killed civilians, not al-Qaeda fighters, as previously claimed by US officials.   Rights group Human Rights Watch (HRW) published a 28-page report on Thursday that said all the victims of a...
Israel locking up more children in isolation
  Jamil was only 16 years old when Israeli soldiers raided his Bir al-Basha home near Jenin late last year. It was a few hours before dawn when he was awakened by a hard nudge, blindfolded and handcuffed, then taken away in his pyjamas and house slippers.   His ordeal took place...
Children's rights ignored in Egypt crackdown
  Sara Atef was wearing her school uniform on the day she was arrested by riot police.   The 16-year-old had become a regular sight at anti-government rallies organized by Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated groups in her hometown of 6 October city, a sprawling satellite development an hour's drive from central Cairo.   Sara, who...
Syrian refugees struggle in urban Jordan
  Three years after fleeing their war-torn country, more than half a million Syrian refugees living in Jordan’s urban centres have become more vulnerable and destitute, a new study has revealed.   A household assessment released by CARE International on Thursday found that urban Syrian refugees are struggling to cope with inadequate...
UN: Syria drought to deepen food crisis
  The United Nations has warned that a looming drought in Syria could push millions more people into hunger and exacerbate a refugee crisis caused by the three-year conflict.   Syria's breadbasket northwestern region has received less than half of the average rainfall since September and, if it stays dry up to...
Civilian carnage surges in Afghanistan
  Wheeling himself out of the children's ward of Kabul's Emergency Surgical Centre for War Victims, Qasem appeared unmoved by the autumn sun and flowers he turned his wheelchair to face.   "I'll never get better," the seven-year-old from Ghazni province said as his left leg protruded from the red-and-black wheelchair he...
Egypt's human rights situation is going from ugly to uglier
  Egypt's deteriorating human rights situation in the past three years has had something of a boiled frog effect to it - things have gotten worse just gradually enough that the country's unfolding problems have been pushed to the margins.   But the severe abuses meted out to Egyptian citizens are crushing...
Palestinians forced to demolish own homes
  For the past two months, Hamzah Abu Terr has slept on the floor of his home. He gave his bed to his three small children whose room he was forced to destroy earlier this year, to avoid large demolition fines issued by the Israeli municipality.   "I had no choice," said...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved