Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Is there such a thing as ‘good nationalism’?
Is there such a thing as ‘good nationalism’?
Sep 20, 2024 5:34 PM

In the world of Brexit, Trump, Marine Le Pen, Viktor Orbán and all the rest, “nationalism” has e all too frequent a topic. In the 20th century the term became associated with fascism (the word es from “national,” after all), but the story of nationalism goes back much farther than Nazism and isn’t nearly so one-sided a concept as it’s often made out to be. Does nationalism necessarily lead to aggression and prejudice?

If I may start with a platitude, the goodness, or lack thereof, of nationalism depends on how you define it and how broad a concept you want it to be. Merriam-Webster defines nationalism as “loyalty and devotion to a nation; especially: a sense of national consciousness exalting one nation above all others and placing primary emphasis on promotion of its culture and interests as opposed to those of other nations or supranational groups.” If you stop at the “especially,” there’s no problem. If you add what follows it, then of course there’s an issue. In this sense I think the word “nationalism” is often too broadly applied – most voters for “nationalist” parties in the EU, for instance, are not actually nationalist by the narrower standard.

“Good nationalism is a certain specific solidarity based on the things you have created together, as a nation, and the things you aspire to create,” wrote Zoe Williams in an article last year in, of all places, The Guardian (certainly not known for friendliness to conservative views). Among other things, Williams cites the NHS and the Internet as “things they have created together.” Interestingly, though – and to me, conspicuously – she mentions nothing on a less tangible and more “cultural” level: things such as philosophical ideas, literary works, or anything religious. Her “good nationalism” looks to, in her words, “concrete achievements that it can point to, whether of infrastructure or of living standards.” Valid as far as it goes, but too narrow. I suspect that, to her mind, going further than this would be “uninclusive” of other cultures. Heaven help us if we should be so close-minded as to be proud of our own ideas! But if we tread so (over)cautiously, why speak of nationalism at all, even a “good” one? A good nationalism will indeed take pride in concrete achievements but also in the ideas and convictions that undergird those achievements.

“I could admire another country…but I wouldn’t take pride in it, except at the generic level of the species.” plete though Williams’s picture may be, here she hits the nail on the head, and the point can be extended beyond national borders to the West as a culture more generally. Too many nowadays miss the distinction and act as though taking pride in what is our own would necessarily imply an exclusionary attitude. But in the end such an outlook simply turns the exclusion in the opposite direction, seeking to exclude one’s own in order to be more inclusive of everyone else. This flipped prejudice is no better. Saying a culture is automatically worse is as damaging as saying it’s automatically superior, and leads to backlash. This is one reason for the rise of nationalist parties, particularly in Europe – people want to be allowed to take pride in their own culture and history again. Obviously I’m not saying that all such parties are good or that everything they espouse is right, but this aspiration at least is quite legitimate.

C.S. Lewis in The Four Loves gives a very good take on patriotism (which is close enough to “good nationalism” for our purposes, if not the same thing):

“It asks only to be let alone. It es militant only to protect what it loves. In any mind that has a pennyworth of imagination it produces a good attitude towards foreigners. How can I love my home ing to realise that other men, no less rightly, love theirs? Once you have realised that Frenchmen like plet just as we like bacon and eggs – why good luck to them and let them have it. The last thing we want is to make everywhere else just like our own home. It would not be home unless it were different.”

This value of difference is something that postmodernity, for all its obsession with “diversity,” has only taken to heart in a one-sided and superficial fashion.

In any case, whatever the word we use, nationalism not in a jingoistic sense but rather as a pride in one’s culture, history, institutions, and so on, together with a legitimate desire for sovereignty, is a good thing. And we should note that this good sense doesn’t say anything about race. Flemish and French, for instance, can both be “nationalist” in this sense with regard to Belgium. And an assurance in one’s own culture – could we call it “good culturalism”? – helps rather than hinders the inclusion of ers. Someone who’s grounded in a set of principles can look objectively and thoughtfully at other ideas and ways of thinking, while someone who’s grounded in nothing has no standpoint for such an approach. Too many of the West’s cultural elite base themselves on vague generalities of “tolerance,” “open-mindedness,” and – I would add – a pervasive distrust if not outright rejection of the Western cultural heritage. And from this nebulous position they face the challenges of migration, globalization, demographic decline, and all the rest. And we wonder why it’s not going well?

I certainly don’t agree with people who say things like, “Not one penny for foreigners – America first!” (We’ve all seen social ments to that effect.) But I certainly do believe that if we in the West aren’t convinced that there is good in our culture (and the individual cultures within it) and that it’s something worth defending, this whole story e to a very unsatisfactory end. The desire for peace, harmony and prosperity is noble – it’s a desire we all have – but a lack of cultural self-assurance is a recipe for failure. In this sense I would say that “good nationalism” is not only good, but essential.

Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 4.0. This photo has been cropped.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A Catholic revolution in France
Despite a decline in the number of individuals attending Mass, Catholicism in France is ing more self-confident and, surprisingly, more orthodox. Writing for the Catholic World Report, Samuel Gregg discusses the Catholic Church in France. He says that France’s néocatholiques are leading change in the European nation: Perhaps the most evident sign of this sea-change in French Catholicism is what’s called La Manif pour tous. This movement of hundreds of thousands of French citizens emerged in 2012 to contest changes...
How Does Your State Rank For Integrity?
When Americans think of corruption, we tend to think of third world countries where getting anything done often requires bribing local government officials. We tend not to have such problems here; our corruption is more subtle and sophisticated, and often involves state level lawmakers. For instance, over the past few years there have seen corruption-related charges or convictions of the house or assembly speakers ofAlabama (bribery, misuse of campaign funds),Rhode Island (bribery, misuse of campaign funds),South Carolina (misuse of campaign...
Remembering Austin Hill
The Acton Institute lost a great friend last week. Austin HillI first met Austin Hill at 1997 an Acton Institute, Towards a Free and Virtuous Society conference held in Connecticut. Those conferences were designed to identify young future religious leaders with great potential. We invested well with Austin, who came to numerous of our events over the years. He would a radio host, author and public speaker and was most recently producing “Austin Hill’s Big World of Small Business,” a...
Syrian Refugees and the Arab Spring
We’re having an intense, often heated, debate about the reception of Syrian refugees in the United States. How do Eastern Christians see it? The Antiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese of North America, an Archdiocese of the Orthodox Patriarchate of Antioch and All the East, has issued a balanced and unflinchingly critical statement on the crisis. This is a church that traces its history to apostolic times in Syria and other parts of the Middle East. Many North American Antiochians are themselves...
Survey Finds We’d Rather be Governed by ‘Ordinary Americans’ Than by Our Elected Officials
“I am obliged to confess,” wrote William F. Buckley, Jr. in 1963, “that I should sooner live in a society governed by the first two thousand names in the Boston telephone directory than in a society governed by the two thousand people on the faculty of Harvard University.” A similar sentiment seems to now be shared by a majority of the American people. A recent survey by Pew Research finds that 55 percent of the public believes “ordinary Americans” would...
Acton and Burke: For The Conservative Wisdom of History and Tradition
“It was the genius of the English political system to adhere to the facts of English history,” says Gertrude Himmelfarb in this week’s Acton Commentary. What Lord Acton particularly admired in the later Edmund Burke was his empirical philosophy of politics, his refusal to give way to the metaphysical abstractions, the a priori speculations, that had been insinuated into public life by the rationalists of the French Revolution. Facts, Burke had admonished, are a severe taskmaster. They prohibit the idle...
Explainer: What You Should Know About The Syrian Refugee Controversy
Recently more than half the nation’s governors—27 states—have expressed opposition to letting Syrian refugees into their states. Many lawmakers in Congress are also considering legislation that would suspend the Syrian refugee program. Here is what you should know about the current controversy: Why is there a new concern about allowing Syrian refugees into the U.S.? According to the French government, at least one of the terrorists in the recent attack on Paris is believed to have entered the country by...
The ‘Illiberal’ Religious Campaigners Behind Fossil-Fuel Divestment
The recent decline in oil prices is a boon for consumers but a bust for panies. Collectively, profits of the four supermajors – Royal Dutch Shell PLC; Exxon Mobil Corp.; Chevron Corp.; and BP PLC – have plummeted 70 percent in the first nine months of 2015, according to the Wall Street Journal. Despite a “precipitous drop in profits this year,” the supermajors increased stock dividends 10 percent over 2014, disbursing approximately $28 billion to shareholders. For the time being,...
Ruggles in America: Charles Laughton Recites the Gettsyburg Address
Today marks the 152nd anniversary of the Gettsyburg Address, the speech given by Abraham Lincoln after the battle which left 7,000 American soldiers dead and 40,000 wounded. Given its power and permanence, it may seem strange to memorialize it by pointing to an edy film from the 1930s. But it’s one that stirs all the right sentiments. In Ruggles of Red Gap, the great Charles Laughton plays Marmaduke Ruggles, an English manservant who has been gambled away by his master...
5 facts about the Gettysburg Address
Today marks the 152nd year anniversary of Abraham Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address. Here are five facts about one of history’s most famous — and famously brief — speeches: 1. The Gettysburg Address was not written on the back of an envelope. Despite the popular legend that Lincoln wrote the speech on the train while traveling to Pennsylvania, he probably wrote about half of it before leaving the White House on November 18. 2. Much of the language and thematic content of...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved