Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Is the UK facing massive child poverty?
Is the UK facing massive child poverty?
Jul 15, 2025 4:47 PM

Charles Dickens wrote in Oliver Twist that “very sage, very deep” British leaders “established the rule that all poor people should have the alternative … of being starved by a gradual process in the [poor]house, or by a quick one out of it.” If one were to believe a recent UN report on poverty, the fate of the poor remains Dickensian.

Orrather, Hobbesian, as UN Special Rapporteur PhilipAlston quoted the philosopher’s ubiquitous description of life as “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short” inhis preliminarystatement on British poverty.

Yet Alstonmisrepresented the extent and depths of poverty and misdiagnosed its causes,while dismissing the most proven antidote to child poverty.

Confusing poverty with inequality and anecdotes withdata

The UK follows muchof Europe in e inequality, which it definesas poverty; specifically, anyone making less than 60 percent of the e is considered “poor.” In fact, Alston derided the notion the very notionof “so called ‘absolute poverty.’”

Butthe emphasis on relative equality leads to strange results. Alston reprimanded theUK while praising Mauritania formaking “significant progress in alleviating poverty,” although 42percent of the latter nation lives on lessthan £1,000 a year.

Alstonbelittled the May government’s contention “that there is no extreme poverty inthe UK, and nothing like the levels of destitution seen in other countries.” Hethen proceeded to quote a number of personal stories shared with him at foodbanks.

But theplural of anecdote is not data and, as Nobel-winning economist Paul Samuelsonwrote in Newsweek in 1967, “Anecdotesdo not constitute social science.”

Whatreally mattersis the average family’s ability to afford necessities, and the verifiable facts paint a much different picture.

A mere six percentof people said they find it “quiteor very difficult to get by financially” – less than half the numberwho reported being hard-pressed in 2012 – according to the Office of NationalStatistics (ONS). As median household es have exceeded their pre-recessionhighs, the percentage of people satisfied with their household e has spikedsince 2002.

Furthermore,Alston “ignores keyevidence from the ONS which shows es actually increased for thelowest e quintile over the period 2008 to 2017,” writes RichardNorrie at the London-based Institute of Economic Affairs.

Given realproblems in places like sub-Saharan Africa – where Alston’s office typicallyfocuses – why was he in the UK at all?

Associating austerity and Brexit with poverty

Alston saidhe made his office’s fourth visit to a developed Western country in partbecause he wanted his study to help Brits “better understand the implicationsof an austerity approach,” which emphasizes cutting social spending.

“Poverty is a political choice” Alston said.“Austerity could easily have spared the poor … but the political choice wasmade to fund tax cuts for the wealthy instead.”

But tax cuts are not an “expenditure.” (They merely allowpeople to keep more of the money they earned.) The bemoaned “austerity”was neverterribly austere, and Chancellor Philip Hammond’s most recent budgetboosted spending by £32 billion over last year.

Furthermore, hefelt Brexit – the UK’s exit from a supranational government – created anopportune time for the UN to intervene. His statement warns that “fears and insecurity” fueledthe Brexit vote. Leaving the EU will contract the economy by as much aseight percent, and “the poor will be substantially less well off than theyalready are.”

In reality, the UK’s economy outperformed expectations. Economicgrowth hit a two-yearhigh this year. The greatest threat to the market is uncertainty which is caused,in large part, by the doubtful future facing the Brexit-light deal offered byTheresa May.

The governmentrightly assessedthe “extraordinary political nature” of the report as “wholly inappropriate.”

Dismissing the poverty cure

Alston chided theUK government for highlighting the fact that unemployment has reached a 40-year low,because “being in employment does not e poverty.”

However, the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) – far from a ConservativeParty institution – noted in a study last year that “the rate of persistent poverty forchildren in households that have had someone in work in each of the last fouryears is just 5% … On the other hand, children in households that have had noone in work for at least three of the last four years account for slightly over40%.”

Put another way, employment is themost effective way to reduce child poverty, Alston’s purported concern.

The onlypersistently depressing metric in the panoply of data offered by the ONS is thestubborn percentage of young Britons classified as NEETs:those in their prime working years who are Notin Education, Employment or Training.

The message theymost need is not another political jeremiad blaming their problems onpoliticians who are too stingy with other people’s money. Young people at riskneed to hear that unlocking their potential could change their lives, munities, and possibly the world for the better.

The Catholicmystic Catherine of Siena once adviseda young man, “If you are what you ought to be, you will set fire to all Italy.” Thetalents latent in every human heart can illumine every nation in the world.

If only Alston haddelivered such a hope-filled message to children of God who find themselvessidelined in their own lives.

illustration of Oliver Twist. Public domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Reviving the spirit of free trade
The current support for tariffs in the United States has left me disappointed, frustrated, and in many unproductive debates. The French political philosopher, Frédéric Bastiat, best articulated my sentiments in an 1847 letter to Richard Cobden, “And I want not so much free trade itself as the spirit of free trade for my country. Free trade means a little more wealth; the spirit of free trade is a reform of the mind itself, that is to say, the source of...
Radio Free Acton: A first step towards criminal justice reform; The human cost of unemployment part II
On this episode of Radio Free Acton, producer Caroline Roberts speaks with Sarah Estelle,associate professor of economics at Hope College. Caroline and Sarah discuss the subject of criminal justice reform in light of the recently passed, bipartisan bill, The First Step Act, covering specific policies in the new bill and effects of the current criminal system. After that, award winning reporter Anne Marie Schieber continues exploring the effects of unemployment. Last week,we showed the importance of being in the right...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: Michelin short business (and personal) guide
Alejandro Chafuen, Acton’s Managing Director, International, describes in Forbes how a good businessman ought to be first a good man. The principles that guided François Michelin apply not only in business but also in personal life. Michelin is a French surname, but it is also a synonym for quality tires and restaurant mendations. This article, however, is not about the current state of this $18 pany but about some of its most important roots: the principles that guided François Michelin...
Explainer: What you should know about the U.S. president’s emergency powers
What just happened? Last Friday President Trump said he was considering using his national emergency powers to secure funding for the construction of a border wall between U.S.-Mexico border. “We can call a national emergency and build it very quickly,” said the president. What are national emergency powers? The President of the United States has certain powers that may be exercised in the event that the nation is threatened by crisis, exigency, or emergency circumstances (other than natural disasters, war,...
The particular genius of conservatism
The U.S. Constitution is a work of both the historical experience of the Founding Fathers and of the eminently Protestant culture to which they belonged. It is probably futile to try to understand the legal meaning of the Constitution without first grasping its historical and cultural significance. In the Federalist Papers, John Jay makes an unequivocal defense of mon understanding among the Framers: that the nascent republic was blessed because its citizens shared the same language, religion, and ancestries. In...
In Spain, collectivism is rising on the Right
Spain closed out 2018 by witnessing the rise of a new and growing populist party named Vox, writes Ángel Manuel García Carmona in a new essay for Acton’s Religion & Liberty Transatlantic website: Since 2016, right-wing populist parties have been on the rise in Europe: National Rally (formerly the National Front) in France, the League in Italy, the Party for Freedom in Netherlands, Vlaams Belang in Flanders, and the Alternative for Germany are but a few examples. Yet the Iberian...
How do we measure inflation?
Note: This is post #105 in a weekly video series on basic economics. Inflation is an average rise in prices. But how exactly is this average rise in prices measured? In this video by Marginal Revolution University,Alex Tabarrok explains how inflation in the United States can be measured using theBureau of Labor Statistics’ Consumer Price Index (CPI)—a weighted average of the price increases. We can calculate the inflation rate by the percentage change in the CPI over a given period...
6 Quotes by Teddy Roosevelt on virtue and character
Yesterday was the centennial anniversary of the death of Theodore Roosevelt. There are many areas of policy and politics where those of us at the Acton Institute would differ with America’s 26th president. But we share mitment to virtue and character, and its importance for both individual flourishing and for public life. In honor of this anniversary, here are six quotes by Roosevelt on those character and virtue: On virtue and success in life: “There are many qualities which we...
6 Quotes: Richard John Neuhaus on politics and religion
Richard John Neuhaus, founder of First Things magazine, died ten years ago today. Fr. Neuhaus was a Lutheran minister before ing a Catholic priest, and a radical liberal activist before ing a leading voice for religious and political conservatives. In honor of this anniversary of his passing, here are six quotes by Fr. Neuhaus on politics and religion: On politics, culture, and religion: “Politics is chiefly a function of culture, at the heart of culture is morality, and at the...
What Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez gets wrong about Europe
During her interview with 60 Minutes on Sunday, newly sworn in Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez justified her vision of democratic socialism by invoking a caricature of Europe. When asked if she wanted to turn the United States into a version of Venezuela or the Soviet Union, Ocasio-Cortez demurred with an incredulous smile. “What we have in mind,” she said, according to the transcript, “and what of my — and my policies most closely re— resemble what we see in the U.K.,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved