Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Is it possible for the church to be apolitical?
Is it possible for the church to be apolitical?
Dec 14, 2025 3:23 PM

Weary and wary from the Religious Right’s checkered history of unhealthy political alliances, many pastors and churches have opted for disengagement altogether.

Or the illusion of disengagement, that is.

As Andrew Walker reminds us, “It is impossible for churches to be apolitical because Jesus is a King. He isn’t a pious emblem to tuck away into our hearts with no earthly effect.”

The Gospel we preach is inherently political. Indeed, as Walker continues,“Jesus is Lord” is “the most political statement ever uttered in the cosmos.” The question, therefore, is whether ourchurches arehonest enoughto connect the dots for God’s people:

The church that insists on calling itself “apolitical” or relegates “the gospel” to a message of pious sanctimony unbothered by earthly affairs has a tragic misunderstanding of what “politics” really is, and how the church’s very essence is fervently political in nature…

The early church knew this. Its statement that Jesus is Lord was a direct political assault on the claims of Caesar. Caesar was threatened by the church’s message because the church pledged allegiance to a higher authority, and in doing so, subjected Caesar’s temporal authority to Jesus’ kingly authority…The early church was political, and so must we—but political as the Bible defines political, not as how FOX or MSNBC define political.

It’s one thing to avoid the overt co-opting of the pulpit that e to behold— to cease with overly simplistic voter guides andcheapendorsements of particular candidates. It’s quite another to ignore or avoid the widespread cultural implications of the Gospel.

Such a withdrawal opts for a witness that is pletely silent on earthly affairs and institutionsor selectively avoids the moral and spiritual issues of the day based on political heat. In effect, this puts Cultural Consensus before King Jesus, making for a pretend place wherein issues of sexuality, racial injustice, abortion, and religious liberty are “too political,” but human trafficking and global poverty aresomehow not.

As Walker concludes:

The declaration “Jesus is Lord” is the political constitution of the church. That declaration orders our life together, as that is what politics is chiefly about. It sets the parameters of our obedience and dictates how the goals of the Kingdom e our concern. So Christians who labor in the public square out of obedience to Christ aren’t laboring away under abstract metaphysical concepts about human nature; we labor out of the belief that every life is precious in the eyes of God, so anything that attacks the image of God is an attack on God’s fullest image, the Christ. We labor to protect the dignity of the trafficked, the unborn, racial minorities, the immigrant, and the poor because these people bear God’s image in full. We labor in the political square not out of the hope that Christians will be ultimately understood or appreciated, but to bear witness to ing Kingdom and to announce, as Carl Henry said, “the criteria by which God will judge men and nations.”

It is impossible for churches to be apolitical because Jesus is a King. He isn’t a pious emblem to tuck away into our hearts with no earthly effect. Rather, understanding the political implications of confessing that “Jesus is Lord” places great demands upon us as his disciples as we bear witness to this truth in the public square.

Read the whole thing here.

For more on this question, see Jordan Ballor and Robert Joustra’s new collection of essays, The Church’s Social Responsibility:Reflections on Evangelicalism and Social Justice.

Also, Russell Moore’s practical advise to pastors offers a good example of how to faithfully ridethetensions at play:

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Lottery Talk
I pleted an interview that will air this Sunday on the Michigan Talk Network about state-run lotteries and Christian views on gambling for the “Michigan Gaming and Casino Show,” hosted by Ron Pritchard. The occasion was this piece I wrote awhile back, “Perpetuating Poverty: Lotteries Prey on the Poor.” For more, see also “Betting on Gambling is a Risky Wager” and “Gambling Hypocrisy.” You can check out the show live on the MLive talk radio feed here (click on “News...
Wi-Fi in the Developing World
The Green Wifi Prototype One of the concerns with the “little green machine” (discussed previously here and here) has been the issue of Internet connectivity. Little enclaves of mini-networks just won’t cut puters need access to the global web. Word out of the tech world is now that a couple of innovators, Bruce Baikie andMarc Pomerleau, who are “veterans” of Sun Microsystems, working on a solar-powered wi-fi access nodes, “which consist of a small solar panel, a heavy-duty battery, and...
Interview: Lotteries Prey on the Poor
The Acton Institute’s Jordan Ballor was a guest on the Michigan Gaming and Casino Show on the Michigan Talk Radio Network on Sunday afternoon to discuss his March 3rd, 2004 article, “Perpetuating Poverty: Lotteries Prey on the Poor”. Ballor and host Ron Pritchard discussed the negative financial impacts of gambling on the poor and the larger question of the morality of games of chance in general. To listen to the interview, click here (4.3 mb mp3 file, 25 minutes). ...
Another Book Trend
I’ve noted the recent rash of books roughly on the theme of the danger of theocracy. As though in (indirect) response, several books celebrating Christianity’s impact on Western civilization (and democracy) have appeared. There was Thomas Woods’ How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization. Then there was Rodney Stark’s The Victory of Reason, about which others mented in this venue. Now there is Robert Royal’s The God that Did Not Fail: How Religion Built and Sustains the West. ...
Corporate America and the Campus
More news on the campus that may disturb those who are already hyperventilating about corporate involvement in higher education: university newspapers are receiving increasing corporate attention. In an article in today’s WSJ, Emily Steel writes, “Hip, local, relevant and generated by students themselves, college newspapers have held steady readership in recent years while newspapers in general have seen theirs shrink. Big advertisers are going on campus to reach these young readers. Ford Motor Co., Microsoft Corp., Samsung Electronics Co., and...
‘The Almighty has His own purposes.’
This Sunday’s sermon at the church I visited was on Joshua 5:13-15: Now when Joshua was near Jericho, he looked up and saw a man standing in front of him with a drawn sword in his hand. Joshua went up to him and asked, “Are you for us or for our enemies?” “Neither,” he replied, “but mander of the army of the LORD I have e.” Then Joshua fell facedown to the ground in reverence, and asked him, “What message...
Rwandan Coffee Competes and Wins
Unlike the flooded market for conventional coffee products, the specialty coffee market enjoys increasing demand along with limited supply. This means that the potential exists for developing countries to increase the quality and quantity of their coffee production to meet the demand. Rwanda is a case in point, and shows how market pressures help to effectively and efficiently signal which and in what quantity modities should be produced. As Laura Fraser writes in The New York Times, “From the late...
Vitalism Leads to Nihilism
I saw a post on the Web somewhere in the last few days (I can’t recall where), about the trend toward worshiping human life itself as the highest principle…detached from recognition of any higher theological realities. Then I ran across this quote from Dietrich Bonhoeffer that struck me as especially relevant, and so I wanted to pass it along: Vitalism ends inevitably in nihilism, in the destruction of all that is natural. In the strict sense, life as such is...
Second Phase of Welfare Reform
“I’ve got a bunch of government checks at my door / Each morning I try to send them back / But they only send me more.” –Nelly Furtado, “Hey Man,” Whoa, Nelly! (Dreamworks, 2000). Here’s a question maybe our own Karen Woods can address: Does the second phase of welfare reform make it harder for people to get off welfare for good? That seems to be the implication of this article in today’s WaPo, “Welfare Changes A Burden To States,”...
Which of These is More Offensive?
As a brief follow up to my last post and the point about nationalism, see the Liberty Bible offered by the American Bible Society. The Kruse Kronicle passes along some more partisan options for those of us who put being a Republican or a Democrat above being an American (which are both above being a Christian). For my use of the quote appearing on the GOP Bible, go here. I’m willing to bet that the Liberty Bible will sell pretty...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved