Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Ikaria and the Inseparability of Individual and Communal Flourishing
Ikaria and the Inseparability of Individual and Communal Flourishing
Dec 14, 2025 8:09 PM

The New York Times has a fascinating profile on Ikaria, a Greek island located about 30 miles off the western coast of Turkey. With roughly 8,000 inhabitants, the island is known for its slow and relaxed lifestyle, munities, and healthy citizenry.

As Ikarian physician Dr. Ilias Leriadis says in the article: “Have you noticed that no one wears a watch here? …We simply don’t care about the clock here.”

Brendan Case offers a good summary of the article at Call and Response (HT), pointing to some significant themes:

“For people to adopt a healthful lifestyle,” reports Dan Buettner in a recent issue of the “New York Times Magazine,” “they need to live in an ecosystem, so to speak, that makes it possible.” Buettner’s exploration of the Aegean island of Ikaria, where people are 2.5 times as likely as Americans to live past the age of 90, showcases the inseparability of individual munal flourishing.

On Ikaria, a constellation of factors yields long lives: a great diet, and few chances to deviate from it; lots of physical activity (little of which could be classed as “exercise”); even regular napping.

But the likely keys to Ikarian longevity are harder to map. Buettner suggests that social structures — the marriages, families and friendships that knit Ikarians into a densely woven fabric of village life — are what sustain munities in healthy practices.

At a superficial level, it canbe easy for us to overly romanticize such places, especially for thoseof us whoare routinely exhausted by fast-paced Western culture (though I still prefer a widespread concern for clocks). Buettner, for example, often seems over-sold on the notion of Ikaria as Utopia–likely, no doubt, because of his research interests in longevity(understandable).

As Christians, however, we need to be careful that our ultimate aim stays fixed on the glory of God, incorporating a full scope of social and economic goods along the way. Whole-life discipleship requires more than a narrow focus on either busyness or relaxation, short life or old age, andin this vein, Case is helpful in pointing usto a deeper takeaway: “Ikaria dramatizes the fact that the virtues and flourishing of individuals depend munal traditions and practices.”

This vigorous munity interaction and interdependence of Ikaria, Case argues, is something we can learn from, and further, it is something mirrored in and enhanced by the Church:

Effecting change within the Church is no different: because the gospel brooks no division of the Christian life into public and private spheres, the work of forming disciples requires change at all levels, from purging the heart of vice to recasting social structures taken captive to idolatrous greed or hatred.

The Church transforms individuals, not simply by offering moral maxims or inspirational examples, but by constituting an entire counterculture of change. For, as Ikaria’s centenarians can attest, individual virtues flourish only in the greenhouses of munities.

As I’ve already indicated, such flourishing can play out in a variety of ways, resulting in a wide and diverse assortment of healthy and productive “ecosystems,” whatever the wristwatch-to-hammock ratio may be. As Case duly indicates, there is no clearpublic/private division that prohibits this dynamic from impacting the Church’s work at all levels across the culture.

What Ikaria demonstrates is that, whatever the result, we should continuously work to integrate personal virtue and inspiration with munal traditions and practices.” In doing so, we can expect to see things overlap in beautiful and mysterious ways.

To join the On Call in munity, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Anarchists Is a Case Study in the Decadence of Autonomy
A new HBO Max series takes a look at the tragic implosion of munity of self-described anarchists who “escaped” statist America for freedom in Mexico. Tragedy ensues. Read More… I have a reasonably high tolerance for fortable television and movies, maybe a higher tolerance than I should, but the first thing I would say about the HBO Max seriesThe Anarchistsis that it is not for the faint of heart. In this case, though, the tough stomach required is not due...
How Cars Can Keep Us Human
Does technology have its own moral code? And if so, does it influence ours? Why agency and action are essential to remaining fully human. Read More… Truck drivers are cowboys. I work at a food warehouse. Truckers show up with 40,000 pounds of primal-cut beef, equivalent to maybe 50 head of cattle, driven from Nebraska, by a team of horses, bit, bridled, and reined by bustion. I don’t actually spend a lot of time around these guys, but it’s pretty...
Aaron Judge, the Asterisk, and the Record Books
As the Yankee outfielder enters the record books, it’s time to reflect on how we judge the best in baseball. Read More… So Aaron Judge sits atop the American League record books for most home runs hit in a single season—62, breaking fellow Yankee Roger Maris’ 60-plus-year record. And by all accounts, it couldn’t happen to a nicer guy. Michael Conforto, a former outfielder for the New York Mets, had this to say about Judge: “He’s huge but he’s one...
Blonde at Its Best Highlights What’s Worst
This overlong film’s best moments are the simple and the universally understandable. Too bad they were few and far between. Read More… Director Andrew Dominik’s Blonde, now available on Netflix and starring Ana de Armas as “blonde bombshell” Marilyn Monroe, is a long film. Not merely because of its almost three-hour run time but also because it feels long when you’re watching it. The latest attempt to explore plex life of stardom, abuse, and mental illness attempts to do a...
The New Pinocchio Swaps Conscience for ‘Authenticity’
Disney continues its decline by offering a revisionist version of its 1940 classic, with Tom Hanks as a Geppetto swallowed up by postmodernity and a puppet who’s just fine never ing a real boy. Read More… American parents used to trust Disney to charm their kids with beautiful fairy tales. Most such tales were European in origin, but Disney Americanized them, made them more democratic, less bloody minded, and ultimately hopeful. It started with animations, then added amusement parks, then...
Not Jonesing for the Jones Act
An obscure maritime law hit the news recently because of catastrophic weather and its consequences. Let’s hope we never have to hear about it again. Read More… Just a few years ago, very few people knew or discussed the Jones Act. Now everyone is talking about it. In a colossal but somewhat predictable fiasco, while Puerto Rico was being pummeled by Hurricane Fiona, the Jones Act prevented a cargo ship from docking off its coast to deliver some 300,000 barrels...
Does College Get in the Way of Education?
A new book paints a dismal picture of the modern Academy and its failure to truly educate and not just indoctrinate. But are the authors’ solutions any better? Read More… Is college worth it? This has been the question for the past few years, especially in the wake of dropping enrollment. This drop has largely been a response to many college campuses going fully online and imposing a wide slew of mandates and prohibitions in response to the COVID pandemic....
Unlocking the Mystery of Your Wildest Problems
Trying to anticipate all the ways life-transforming decisions can go wrong is stress we’ve all experienced. A new book by economist and podcaster Russ Roberts helps us look at those forks in the road with better eyes. Read More… The most thought-provoking scene in John Boorman’s 1981 lavish epic fantasy film, Excalibur, is one of its most understated. It’s a conversation about love. King Arthur stares enchanted by the Lady Guinevere as she dances across the great hall. After confessing...
Lord Shaftesbury: Evangelical Social Reformer
Social justice warriors of the 21st century have nothing on this aristocratic evangelical. Read More… “I want nothing but usefulness to God and my country” (Diaries, February 22, 1827) When the funeral procession of Lord Shaftesbury progressed through the streets of London toward Westminster Abbey on October 8, 1885, thousands of people lined the streets, bands gathered to play Christian hymns, and hundreds of banners were held high with Bible verses. The representatives of more than 200 voluntary societies linked...
Godard Is Dead. Is Cinema?
One of the founding filmmakers of the French New Wave enraptured, confounded, and infuriated audiences, critics, and filmmakers. But no one was better at capturing the nihilistic moment of the late ’60s. Read More… Jean-Luc Godard died on September 13, 2022, and the news in the world of cinema and culture was received as confirmation that cinema itself was dead. Godard had a remarkable influence on cinema in the ’60s, but his fame went beyond that. He replaced the aged...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved