Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
ICCR’s Rules for Radical Nuns
ICCR’s Rules for Radical Nuns
Dec 31, 2025 12:50 AM

What is it with nuns crusading against corporate lobbying? This fad of recent years has grabbed headlines as orders such as the Sisters of Mercy and the Benedictine Sisters of Virginia gravitated toward political actions as members of shareholder activist group the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility. Seems there’s nothing alternately cuter pelling than a nun “speaking truth” to corporate power as the ICCR nuns do each year in their campaign against lobbying and donations to nonprofit organizations such as the American Legislative Exchange Council.

How any of this has anything to do with Christian praxis or, more specifically, Roman Catholicism is beyond this prehension. But the press covers these pointless resolutions which I presume is part of the nuns’ name and shame plan. Somehow, we’re supposed to connect the nonexistent dots between the nuns’ religious authority and proxy resolutions that would require corporations increase transparency of their lobbying efforts. This is merely a smokescreen for panies to abandon ALEC and quit advocating in their own – and their shareholders’ and clients’ – best interests.

For example, The Charlotte Observer reported last week:

The sisters of two Catholic religious orders that own Duke Energy stock want the nation’s biggest electric utility to open up about its lobbying of federal and state officials.

Investors will vote Thursday, at Duke’s annual meeting, on a shareholder proposal to disclose more about its lobbying and membership in industry-friendly advocacy groups.

Duke may have billions of dollars at stake when energy and environmental rules are crafted. pany has spent more than $33 million in federal lobbying in the past six years, records show.

Duke says it already files required lobbying reports. At the urging of institutional investors, pany beefed up its oversight of political contributions and lobbying last year.

The nuns say that’s not enough.

Before proceeding, your writer ecstatically reports the nuns’ resolution garnered only 29 percent support at Duke Energy’s annual shareholder meeting last week. But readers may rest assured the nuns will return next year with more of the same nonsense.

Nonsense? Indeed, the ICCR-endorsed resolutions are nonsense on both religious and secular grounds. There exists no genuine religious reason to defund ALEC or publicly divulge lobbying efforts, despite public records and The Charlotte Observer already disclosing Duke spent $2.5 million on federal lobbying and $800,000 on state lobbying in 2015.

Additionally, Duke lists its Political Action Committee, trade association dues and 527 (tax-exempt political organization) contributions on its website albeit without breaking down the amounts given to the unnamed recipients, which is what really sticks in the ICCR and nuns’ craw.

Nope, it’s not remotely religious in nature but only political. ICCR and its kindly sisterhood affiliates demand more transparency because it makes it easier to name donation recipients in attempts to shame Duke from funding them, and the leftist agenda of ICCR squarely is opposed to ALEC or any group that dares express skepticism regarding climate change and efforts to mitigate it. Your writer recalls no Biblical or doctrinal edict to shut down opposing voices on politicized science, but only a portion of the game plan laid out in Saul Alinsky’s Rules for Radicals, particularly those that proclaim “the threat is more terrifying than the thing itself” and “pick the target, freeze it, personalize it and polarize it.”

In their actions and resolutions, ICCR and the Sisters of Mercy and Benedictine Sisters act contrary to the best interests of fellow shareholders, Duke Energy and its clientele, by siding exclusively with the Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan – a radical plan currently stayed by the U.S. Supreme Court due to the pliance costs inflicted upon panies – and extremist environmentalists Bill McKibben and Naomi Klein.

Thank goodness for the shared wisdom of the 71 percent of Duke Energy shareholders who voted against the nuns’ resolution.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Why Cheap Food Makes Us Richer
While it may not seem like it when you’re standing at the checkout line at the grocery store, food is cheaper now that it was half a century ago. “We are purchasing more food for less money, and we are purchasing our food for less of our e,” says Annette Clauson, an agricultural economist. “This is a good thing, because we have e to purchase other things.” A recent report published by the U.S. Department of Agriculture shows how the...
Free-Market Federalism
“States and municipalities craft laws that reflect local cultures, and this proximity to the people has market consequences,” says James Bruce in this week’s Acton Commentary. “Let’s call it free-market federalism, the encouragement of local markets by permitting states and municipalities to frame, as much as possible, the laws by which munities engage merce.” In a spirited defense of decentralization, Abraham Kuyper argues that a central government can only supplement local governments and families. Put another way, the central government...
When a Church Embraces the Power of Entrepreneurship
When we hear about church “outreach ministries,” we often think of food pantries, homeless shelters, munity events. But while these can be powerful channels for service, many churches are beginning to look for new ways to empower individuals more holistically. For some, this means abandoning traditional charity altogether, focusing their ministry more directly around recognizing the gifts and strengths of others. For others, like Evangel Ministries in Detroit, it involves a mix of many things, but with a particular emphasis...
Are Our Rights Gifts From the Government?
In his recent announcement that he was running for president, Sen. Ted Cruz’s said “our rights e from man, e from God Almighty.” That raised some eyebrows in our secular culture. For example, Meredith Shiner, a Yahoo reporter, tweeted:”Bizarre to talk about how rights are God-made and not man-made in your speech announcing a POTUS bid? When Constitution was man-made?” The idea that the “unalienable Rights” mentioned in the Declaration of Independence e from God is considered obvious to many...
Review: Hope for the Workplace, Christ in You
Bill Dalgetty’s Hope for the Workplace, Christ in You is rich with stories of people in business who are struggling to integrate their faith and work lives. Weaving biblical parables with dozens of real life stories gleaned from his experience as president of Christians in Commerce International, Dalgetty points—usually explicitly and sometimes in a more nuanced way—to universal truths of human conscience. Dalgetty, a career attorney and executive for Mobil Corporation, is sensitive to corporate America’s overly PC culture. He...
5 Principles for Spiritual Discernment in the Economic Order
If there’s one area of the faith-work conversation that’s lacking in exploration and introspection, it’s the role of spiritual discernment in the day-to-day decisions of economiclife. It’s one thing to orientone’s heart and mind around thebig picture of vocation and stewardship — no small feat, to be sure — but if economics is about the intersection of knowledge and human action, what does it mean to serve a God whose thoughts are higher than our thoughts?Before and beyondourquestions about ethics...
Our American Children And Poverty
Robert Putnam says our children are in a state of crisis. Those who live in poverty or near-poverty seemed to be doomed to stay there. Those born into families with money will likely go on to enjoy the lives that money affords. His book, Our Kids: The American Dream in Crisis, follows a number of individuals, tracking a list of factors, including the ability to move up or down the economic spectrum. One pivotal factor is marriage: Highly correlated is...
What Does Human Dignity Look Like?
It monplace in Christian circles, whether Orthodox, Roman Catholic, or Protestant, to appeal in public discourse to the inviolable good of human dignity. Today at Ethika Politika, I seek to answer the question, “What does human dignity look like in real life?” It is fine to talk about it in the abstract, but what does it look like on the job or as a parent? I write, Real, flesh-and-blood human persons do not evoke our respect as naturally as an...
Entrepreneurial Stewardship: Employees Share Millions After Company Sold
J.C. Huizenga Photo from Mlive Employees of the Huizenga Automation Group got a great surprise earlier this week. According to Mlive, after selling pany, owner J.C. Huizenga gave away $5.75 million in bonuses to his employees at two panies that were part of the Automation Group. Huizenga acknowledged that his success was due to the work of his employees so he wanted to share his profits with them: “We all worked together at J.R. Automation and Dane Systems” and panies...
Radio Free Acton: Burt & Anita Folsom on Uncle Sam’s Subsidy Problem
On this week’s edition of Radio Free Acton,Burt and Anita Folsom discuss their latest book, Uncle Sam Can’t Count.Weexamine whether the government has a good track record in subsidizing industry and innovation, and look at some of the unforeseen consequences of subsidies in society. You can listen via the audio player below, and then be sure to check out the video of Burt’s Acton Lecture Series address as well. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved