Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
ICCR Working Inside Progressive Bubble
ICCR Working Inside Progressive Bubble
Mar 23, 2025 4:09 AM

“A little older, a little more confused,” the late Dennis Hopper once intoned. One month into 2014, the same could be said for this writer. After all, what could be more confusing than members of the munity employed as willing conspirators in the great organized labor gambit to stifle corporate political speech? Year after year, however, that’s increasingly the case.

For example, the Interfaith Council on Corporate Responsibility’s recently redesigned website heralds its distaste for corporate participation in the political process:

Unchecked corporate cash in the form of political donations and lobbying expenditures has the power to exert undue influence over public policy and regulatory systems and threaten our democracy. Yet in spite of this power, most S&P panies lack a formal system of lobbying oversight and don’t fully disclose how monies are being spent, particularly through third-party organizations like trade associations. Investors are concerned that lobbying expenditures may inadvertently be diverted to groups advancing agendas contrary to the stated missions panies, setting up potential conflicts of interest and panies to reputational risk.

And this:

Led by the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) and Walden Asset Management, ICCR members and other responsible investors are attempting to shine a light on corporate lobbying and political spending policies. Faith-based investors have filed shareholder resolutions with panies. These proposals panies to disclose oversight policies and details around political donations and lobbying initiatives, including through trade associations such as the American Legislative Exchange Council and the Heartland Institute which spend heavily on ad campaigns designed to undercut regulations.

Got that? One of the country’s largest unions has joined with religious proxy shareholders to panies from representing their interests in Washington and state capitals.

According to the Center for Responsive Politics, AFSCME represents 1.6 million members of 3,400 unions as well as 240,000 retirees. CRP reports AFSCME spent monies in the following manner in 2012:

Contributions to candidates: $2,340,117

Contributions to Leadership PACs: $322,000

Contributions to parties: $305,310

Contributions to mittees: $53,509,506

Contributions to outside spending groups: $8,384,879

This amounts to a cool $65 million – overwhelmingly to progressive candidates, groups and causes. Of the $2.3 million donated to federal candidates, for example, only $2,000 was given to a Republican. That’s one, singular, individual Republican – in this instance, New Jersey Rep. Chris Smith.

“Wait,” you might ask, “if these amounts are available publically for AFSMCE why shouldn’t corporations adhere to the same transparency?” Because AFSCME represents public employees who work for public entities, which means there’s no negative blowback for supporting progressive policies and candidates. In other words, no one’s ever boycotted a government office or caused it to lose money.

Companies, however, are vulnerable to boycotts and “name-and-shame” public campaigns. One pany is Minnesota-based Target Corp. Target donated $150,000 to MN Forward, a pro-business political action group. MN Forward supported Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer strictly on his pro-business positions. Emmer, however, also had strong opinions on social issues, particularly against gay marriage. Target stores throughout the United States were subsequently protested or boycotted by gay marriage advocates. Given this real-world scenario, it’s no wonder corporations are wary of publicly disclosing their political contributions.

Same goes for The Heartland Institute and the American Legislative Exchange Council panies supporting the former’s Business and Tax initiative may incur unwarranted reactions because of the think tank’s stance on climate change (in the interest of full disclosure your writer serves as a policy advisor for Heartland).

Similarly, ALEC’s model “Stand Your Ground” legislation prompted more than 50 panies to cease funding the group under pressure from liberal groups – regardless the dozens of model legislation drafted by ALEC members that would have been immensely beneficial to those very panies. But panies figured the very real negative publicity for supporting ALEC far outweighed the potential benefits it provided.

On this readers shouldn’t be confused as was Dennis Hopper: The name-and-shame tactic serves as punishment for pany brazen enough to support anything outside the progressive bubble. ICCR and its AFSCME cohorts aren’t seeking transparency in political speech, but are instead seeking to shut down all opposing voices.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Loving God Should Liberate Generosity
For Christians giving is not about equations and intensives, says Peter Heslam, it’s about a spontaneous response to the grace of a lavishly generous God: In Cape Town in 2010, this response inspired the launch of a campaign to encourage a global culture of Christian generosity. The Global Generosity Network is now establishing resources and local networks, helped by leading entrepreneurs. Such entrepreneurs understand that wealth distribution relies on wealth creation – their business thinking and practical skills generates wealth...
U.S. Federal Budget Debate Highlights Catholic Social Teaching
Current debates surrounding the U.S. federal budget have turned the spotlight on subsidiarity, solidarity and mon good, all aspects of Catholic social teaching. In an article by the Catholic News Service’s Dennis Sadowski, Acton research fellow and director of media Michael Matheson Miller said, “The principles are there. They are to guide us and we are to pay attention to them. You have to affirm those principles. Where Catholics are going to disagree is in the prudential implementation of them.”...
The Inhumane Wendell Berry
“Can one have an off day in giving the Jefferson Lecture (an off week or month in writing it)?” asks Matthew J. Franck in reference to the recent NEH honor afforded to agrarian Wendell Berry. “I’d like to think so. For judging by the text of the lecture Berry gave in Washington at the beginning of this week, his thinking can be fairly repellent.” Titled “It All Turns on Affection,” his lecture is chiefly a catalogue of Berry’s hatreds. He...
The Tragedy of Dutch Compassion
Albert Hahn: Dr. Kuyper's care for the little people (1905)In yesterday’s post I highlighted a pair of articles that cover the transition over the last 120 years or so in the Netherlands from an emphasis on private charitable giving to reliance upon the welfare state. In some ways this story mirrors a similar transformation in American society as described by Marvin Olasky in his landmark book, The Tragedy of American Compassion. Olasky’s work does double-duty, however, not only chronicling this...
Our National Debt is a Loan from Future Generations
Why do democracies struggle with debt? One reason, as John Coleman notes, is that one of the problems is that debt is essentially an intergenerational wealth transfer: Debt can often be seen, essentially, a loan from future generations to the current generation. In a democracy, some of the least represented individuals are the young or those from future generations. Young people vote less. They donate and volunteer less. And their concerns — 20, 30, or 40 years in the future...
The Free Enterprise Values of Burning Man
Each year tens of thousands of mostly underdressed people spend weeks hanging out in the Nevada desert in an “annual experiment in munity dedicated to radical self-expression and radical self-reliance.” If you’re like me, the first thing es to mind when you hear about the Burning Man festival is . . . hippies. Lots and lots of hippies. But Burning Man isn’t a hippie festival. (Really, it’s not.) In fact, underneath it all, says the festival’s co-founder, Larry Harvey, is...
Audio: Sirico Speaks in Kansas
Rev. Robert A. Sirico, President of the Acton Institute, was in Overland Park, Kansas on April 27th to address an audience of local Acton friends and supporters. His topic was “The Moral Adventure of the Free Society.” For those who attended and would like to listen again, or for those who weren’t able to be there personally, the audio of his address is available via the audio player below. [audio: ...
Charles Colson’s ‘Ecumenism of the Trenches’
“Walter Hooper once said of C.S. Lewis that he was the most truly converted person he had ever met,” says Baptist theologian Timothy George. “The same thing can be justly said of Charles W. Colson, who came to faith in Christ through reading Lewis’ Mere Christianity.” In an article for the National Catholic Register,George examines the legacy of his friend, a man who helped forge Evangelicals and Catholics Together and the ‘Manhattan Declaration.’: Sentenced to prison for his Watergate crimes,...
Coolidge and His Foundational Views on Government
Below is an excerpt from an early speech given by Calvin Coolidge to the Algonquin Club in Boston, Mass. in 1915. These remarks are included in a series of speeches Coolidge published in the book, Have Faith in Massachusetts. The speeches primarily deal with his philosophy of government, which because of his emphasis on foundational beliefs, remained consistent. In the excerpt, Coolidge quotes a “Dr. Garman,” who was a professor at Amherst College, in Amherst Mass. Coolidge graduated from the...
The Nobility and Greatness of Work
May 1st was the Feast of St. Joseph the Worker on the Catholic calendar, and in 2005, Pope Benedict XVI offered a short reflection on human labor when speaking to construction workers (via Whispers in the Loggia): I’m taken in mind to how, in the New Testament, in the profession of Jesus before his public ministry, the word “tecton” appears, which we translate as “carpenter,” because then homes were mostly homes of wood. But, more than a “carpenter,” it’s an...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved