Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How to Destroy Your Local Bookstore
How to Destroy Your Local Bookstore
Apr 4, 2025 3:29 AM

What would you do if you hated independent bookstores? Maybe you work for or a bookseller shot your dad or you just want people to read less. For whatever reason, you want to see small businesses that sell books go out of business. What should you do to help destroy your local bookstore?

As San Francisco is finding out, the best strategy for destroying small booksellers is to simply raise the minimum wage.

In November, 77 percent of voters approved San Francisco’s Proposition J, which will raise the minimum wage in the city to $15 by 2018. But the ramifications of that vote are already being felt. A few months ago San Francisco’s best-known science-fiction bookstore, Borderlands Books, published the following on its website:

Although all of us at Borderlands support the concept of a living wage in princip[le] and we believe that it’s possible that the new law will be good for San Francisco — Borderlands Books as it exists is not a financially viable business if subject to that minimum wage. Consequently we will be closing our doors no later than March 31st.

[…]

The change in minimum wage will mean our payroll will increase roughly 39%. That increase will in turn bring up our total operating expenses by 18%. To make up for that expense, we would need to increase our sales by a minimum of 20%. We do not believe that is a realistic possibility for a bookstore in San Francisco at this time.

Borderlands, though, bought themselves some extra time by adopting a patronage model.As National Review‘s Ian Tuttle explains, “a crowdfunding campaign thought up by concerned customers found some 300 sponsors, all of whom agreed to pay $100 to help keep the store afloat until at least March 31, 2016.”

Crowdfunding works if you have a first-mover advantage. The first store asking customers to pay more may survive. But what about the third, thirteenth, or thirtieth?

Brian Hibbs, owner and operator of Comix Experience, says he considered that option but, as he tells Tuttle, there are two problems:

“By saying, ‘Give me money,’ you’re sort of saying you’re not viable.” Furthermore, “There’s a limitation on how much crowdfunding can be done. When you’re the tenth one, I don’t know if it’s going to be easy for you.”

Hibbs has been in business for 26 years and has made a profit in all but two of those years. Now his stores are in trouble. The first minimum wage increase kicked in last week, so Hibbs is required by law to pay his employees $12.25 per hour. By 2018, he’ll have to pay $15 an hour. The increased labor cost will add $80,000 a year in expenses.

Hibb’s stores are currently open 10 hours a day, seven days a week. On an average ic, a store can make about a dollar in profit. That means just to pay for the increased costs that are added because of the minimum wage, Hibb’s would need to sell an additional ics a day—20 per hour for every hour he is open—every single day of the year.

As Hibbs tells The American Conservative‘s Gracy Olmstead,

… A number of my customers have said to me “Ugh, sorry, I voted for this, but I had NO idea it would impact a business like yours”—I think that they thought that they were standing up against multinational corporations who were exploiting their workers, rather than munity-centered local businesses who value art curation over raw profit.

Ironically, the people who thought they were hurting multinational corporations by voting for a minimum wage increase are actually helping them. Every time a small bookseller shuts panies like and Barnes and Noble soak up their business.

This is the problem with assuming good intentions will translate into good effects. By circumventing the market, the voters of San Francisco have made many of their citizens much, much worse off.

Hibb’s employees, for example, will soon be out of work. Hibbs wonders why their preferences aren’t taken into account when the government decides how much they can earn:

Most small businesses I know work incredibly long hours for relatively little pay, because they do it for love and passion first and foremost.

Finally, I do think that the wishes of the employees should be taken into consideration as well—I have staff who work this job as an adjunct to their education, or as a way of helping support themselves as they build their art careers; I have other employees who quit higher paying jobs e work here because we actually give them agency and respect, and because it is their passion as well. As long as no one is being exploited, shouldn’t people be able to choose any wage they are happy with?

People should indeed be able to choose what wages they’ll work for. Workers often have more information about their needs and preferences than the general public, information that helps them determine what wage they can accept. But all too often their knowledge and preferences are trumped by people who are really bad at math and are shocked to find they’ve voted to put people out of work.

While it’s probably too late for the people of San Francisco, other cities can still learn a valuable lesson: If you love your local bookstore (and other small businesses), then you should reject government-mandated wage increases.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Gregg’s Take on Labor Day Debate
Yesterday, five leading Republican candidates participated in the Palmetto Freedom Forum, a serious debate on constitutional principles. Mitt Romney, Michelle Bachmann, Newt Gingrich, Ron Paul, and Herman Cain answered questions from Tea Party congressmen Jim DeMint and Steve King, and Princeton professor Robert P. George. National Review Online has gathered reactions to the debate from notable conservatives; Acton director of research Samuel Gregg and senior fellow Marvin Olasky are among them. Gregg’s take-away is that American politics is shifting in...
Acton Commentary: School Choice Gains Traction
Political discourse and news media have been consumed of late by talk of debt, spending, and recession, but meanwhile the educational freedom movement has been making real progress. State legislatures across the country are giving a green light to vouchers and tax incentives that will in the future pay impressive dividends in the form of better educated students and more efficient schools. Read the rest of mentary here. ...
How to Deliver a Recession: Cut Brake Lines, Accelerate Toward Cliff
Economic historian Brian Domitrovic has an interesting post up at his Forbes blog, Past & Present, on the proximate causes of the 2008 meltdown. According to Domitrovic, uncoordinated, even “weird” fiscal and budgetary policy in the early 2000s kept investors on the sidelines, and then flooded the system with easy money. The chickens came home to roost in 2008 (and they’re still perched in the coop). In 2000, as the stock market was treading water in the context of the...
CFP: Orthodox Christian Economic Thought
Since its inception, the Journal of Markets & Morality has encouraged critical engagement between the disciplines of moral theology and economics. In the past, the vast majority of our contributors have focused on Protestant and Roman Catholic social thought applied to economics, with a few significant exceptions. Among the traditions often underrepresented, Orthodox Christianity has received meager attention despite its ever-growing presence and ever-increasing interest in the West. This call for publication is an effort to address this lacuna by...
Doug Bandow: Troubling News for Religious Liberty
The state of religious liberty around the world is poor, according a new study by the Pew Forum on Religion. Doug Bandow breaks down the report over at The American Spectator—his piece is titled “A World Spinning Backward.” Two years ago, Pew reported that 70 percent of humanity suffered from either government persecution of or social hostility to religion. That trend is growing. According to Pew’s new study, “more than 2.2 billion people—about a third of the world’s population—live in...
Prerequisite for Life: The Man Class
Writing in the Detroit News about the latest rash of shootings in the city (nine dead and 20 injured), Luther Keith asks, “Haven’t we been around this track before?” Yes, actually. He lays out a list of measures to address the crime problem including some predictable (police, gun buybacks, recreational programs) and, refreshingly, something more promising, more powerful: “Emphasize personal responsibility. It es down to choices — right ones and wrong ones, good ones and bad ones and the willingness...
Billboards, Hope, and God’s Highway
Yesterday I was interviewed by WoodTV8 on a story about a controversial billboard near downtown Grand Rapids that reads, “You don’t need God – to hope, to care, to love, to live.” The billboard is sponsored by the Center for Inquiry. My reaction is that the billboard can be a positive because it serves as a conversation starter about a relationship with the Lord and what the meaning of true love and true hope is all about. When I was...
A Thought for Labor Day Weekend
“Work gives meaning to life: It is the form in which we make ourselves useful to others, and thus to God.” –Lester DeKoster, Work: The Meaning of Your Life—A Christian Perspective, 2d ed. (Christian’s Library Press, 2010). ...
Jumping the Shark: Hoffa’s Rant and Rerum Novarum
James Hoffa put on quite a performance this weekend—first on CNN’s “State of the Union,” and then in Detroit at a Labor rally with President Obama. Also this weekend, President Biden revealed that the White House seems to have given up and decided America is already a “house divided,” with “barbarians at the gate” in the form of the Tea Party. Coverage of these incidents is available from whichever news outlet you trust, but there is one thing that CNN...
Rep. Justin Amash on Government Dysfunction
Last week I wrote mentary titled the “The Folly of More Centralized Power,” making the case against ceding anymore power to Washington and returning back to the fundamental principles of federalism. Rep. Amash (R-Mich.), a member of the freshmen class in Congress, made that case as well. Amash was asked about his Washington experience so far in an interview and declared, When I was in the state government, I thought things were dysfunctional there in my opinion. Now I’ve discovered...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved