Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How the $15 minimum wage accelerates community decline
How the $15 minimum wage accelerates community decline
Apr 16, 2025 2:35 PM

As Congress debates the specifics of yet another stimulus bill, President Joe Biden and Sen. Bernie Sanders continue to push for the inclusion a $15 federal minimum wage – a policy that is only likely to prolong pandemic pain for America’s most vulnerable businesses and workers.

As if to confirm such fears, large corporations like Amazon and Walmart have been quick to voice their support for the increase. “It’s time to raise the federal minimum wage,” writes Amazon’s Jay Carney, boasting of their decision to increase wages in 2018. “We believe $15 an hour is the minimum anyone in the U.S. should be paid for an hour of labor. We also believe it’s good for business.”

But while it may be “good for business” for Amazon, such an increase will pose significant challenges for others, particularly smaller businesses and those operating in low-cost states. According to one study, “Roughly half the minimum-wage workforce is employed at businesses with fewer than 100 employees, and 40% are at very small businesses with fewer than 50 employees.”

According to the latest analysis from the Congressional Budget Office, the proposed Raise the Wage Act would eliminate an estimated 1.4 million jobs while increasing the federal deficit by $54 billion over the next 10 years. This doesn’t even account for the indirect ways such a policy is likely to drive automation, squeeze consumers with higher prices, and reduce gross domestic product.

As Timothy Carney explains in The Washington Examiner, it’s yet another example of “regulatory robbery,” wherein government and large corporations collaborate together to diminish opportunity and economic diversity. For those truly concerned about the roots of economic inequality and the pressing problems of poverty, this is a leading problem.

“Amazon and other giant corporations often lobby for costly labor regulations and mandates in order to kill petitors,” Carney writes. “Uber has recently argued that states should require all panies to provide medical and disability coverage for injuries incurred on the job, and Walmart was an early supporter of Obamacare’s employer mandate in health insurance.”

There are many reasons to oppose such an increase. By taking a one-size-fits-all approach to prices, we ignore their functional role as signals for service. In doing so, we diminish our ability to specialize and imagine new possibilities and partnerships across the economic order.

But given the decline of munities and the particular economic problems of the pandemic, the collusion among large corporations makes the destruction all the more painful and perverse. At a time when online shopping and fast-food behemoths are booming – and independent retailers and restaurants are struggling to survive – such an approach gets things backwards with remarkable precision, working to erode economic diversity and accelerate decline where help is needed most.

As Carney explains, the fruits will not be purely “economic” in nature. By using the government to kick “Main Street” businesses when they’re already down, our government is poking at things far more profound than mere “jobs,” “wages,” or static little storefronts:

So the corner store that somehow has survived the pandemic and decades petition from Amazon may pay a local college student $7.25 an hour to stock shelves. If you outlaw that job, you may help Amazon, but you also hurt that college student and that mom and pop. What’s more, you hurt munity.

Brick-and-mortar stores on Main Street draw people to Main Street. When people walk up and down Main Street, they bump into neighbors, they stop in at the coffee shop. Their children run into other children. These unplanned and serendipitous encounters are the building blocks of munities.

The car-centric, inhuman sprawl caused by Robert Moses, Walmart, zoning laws, and yes, Amazon, makes it easier for most people (those with cars and who don’t have car-seat-aged children) to shop and harder for others (those without cars and who have to buckle the baby, unbuckle, and rebuckle, re-unbuckle, et cetera). It has also munities by reducing how much people know their neighbors.

For those who claim that these policies are designed to help the “little guy,” the irony abounds.

To be clear, such policies have also proved disastrous for employees of large corporations, as well as businesses in high-cost metropolitan areas like Seattle. What more damage might they achieve in areas that face greater vulnerabilities? The possibilities for unseen negative effects are virtually endless.

Some would argue that these risks are mostly due to other “outside forces” — globalization, automation, and innovation — and in many ways they are. But it’s one thing if a business closes due to natural forces, based on authentic prices and petition among freely operating enterprises and institutions. It’s quite another when such disruption is unnecessarily forced or accelerated by the hands of the federal government.

As the cheers of Amazon and Walmart make clear, this is not “creative destruction,” properly understood. This is cronyism of a certain sort, and our most munities are in the crosshairs.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Don’t fear the ‘job-killing’ robots: Remembering the power of creative service
As Americans face increasing pressures of economic change and uncertainty, many have relished in a range of renewed nostalgias, whether recallingthe blissful security of post-war industrialism or therise of the Great Society and the prowess of the administrative state. Meanwhile, economic progress continues at a break-neck pace. Indeed, as politicians attempt to prevent or subvert economic change by squabbling over wage minimums, salary caps, trade barriers, and a host of regulatory fixings, entrepreneurs and innovators are accelerating with a subversion...
The human rights threat and the North Korean Regime
“North Korea –Pyongyang” by Stephan (CC BY-SA 2.0) Update: The full interview is now available online. — What’s going on in North Korea? The First Issue of Religion & Liberty in 2017 will explore this question in depth. The main feature will be an interview with Suzanne Scholte, president of the Defense Forum Foundation. She has spent the last two decades fighting for the freedom, human rights, and dignity of the North Korean People and is considered one of the...
Understanding the President’s Cabinet: Education Secretary
Note: This is the fourthin a weekly series of explanatory posts on the officials and agencies included in the President’s Cabinet. See the series introduction here. Cabinet position: Secretary of Education Department: U.S. Department of Education Current Secretary: Betsy DeVos Succession: The Secretary of Education is fifteenth in the presidential line of succession. Department Mission: “[Education Department’s] mission is to promote student achievement and preparation for petitiveness by fostering educational excellence and ensuring equal access. Congress established the U.S. Department...
Business for the common good
“If you are a young person saying ‘I want to go into ministry because I want to change culture,’ how would delete the word ministry and replace it with business?” asks Greg Thornbury, president of The King’s College in New York City. Thornbury isn’t trying to discourage people from ing pastors and missionaries. Instead, he’s trying to reframe the misperception many young people have that full-time vocational ministry is the only or primary way for Christians to have an influence...
Ted Cruz highlights the dangers of EU healthcare systems in debate with Bernie Sanders
In an age of sound bite orations and 140-character manifestos, the nation received a rare treat from CNN this week. On Tuesday night, Senators Ted Cruz and Bernie Sanders debated the merits of national healthcare reform for two hours. The format gave both sides the opportunity to make substantive arguments, and Ted Cruz did not disappoint. The Texan pointed out that Senator Sanders, an advocate of Scandinavian socialism, has suggested the United States adopt policies more akin to European welfare...
Mini-grants for course development and faculty on free market economics available
An invitation to American and Canadian college faculty: Acton is currently offering mini-grants for course development and academic projects in free market economics at colleges and universities. The purpose of these mini-grants is to promote free market economic scholarship on college campuses (in the U.S. and Canada). If you are a current U.S. or Canadian college or university faculty member or know any college faculty interested in promoting the free market on campus, you are encouraged to apply or pass...
R.I.P. Hans Rosling: 4 memorable talks by the Swedish statistician
This week, we received the sad news that Professor Hans Rosling has passed away due to pancreatic cancer. A brilliant statistician and mesmerizing public speaker, Rosling was widely known for his dazzling data visualizations pelling lectures on health, poverty, population, religion, inequality, and economic growth. His lectures were heavily driven by data, and although his conclusions sometimes suffered from an underlying utilitarianism, Rosling’s ultimate contribution was to point us beyond the numbers and data points. Rosling had an exceptional gift...
Radio Free Acton: Judge Joe Scoville’s verdict on Judge Neil Gorsuch
On this edition of Radio Free Acton, we’re joined by Judge Joseph Scoville, former United States magistrate judge for the western district of Michigan, to review the nomination of Judge Neil Gorsuch to replace the late Justice Antonin Scalia on the United States Supreme Court. We examine the qualifications and judicial philosophy of Judge Gorsuch, and address the question of whether or not the left is correct to accuse Republicans of “stealing” the seat from President Obama. Additionally, we start...
Samuel Gregg asks, ‘what good is money?’
While money’s purpose is to serve as a medium of exchange, this is not its only function. Samuel Gregg, in an article for Witherspoon Institute’s Public Discourse, defines the purpose of money and finance, in general, as well as its ability to serve the economy of the people. This is where it finds its good. In this article, Gregg is concerned with the ethics of money in our modern capitalist climate and finding policy solutions to utilize money ethically, as...
Paul Ehrlich brings his bad economics to Vatican
“People Near Train Station” by Redd Angelo (CC0 1.0) In a recent article, Kishore Jayablan of Istituto Acton addresses the controversy surrounding the Vatican’s invitation to Paul Ehrlich, a known population control activist and the author of the 1968 book The Population Bomb.He was invited for a conference on “biological extinction.” Jayabalan finds this situation troubling: … the Pontifical Academies for Science and Social Sciences are giving a platform not just to bad economics but blatantly anti-Catholic, immoral social policies....
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved