Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How progressives are turning the ‘unthinkable’ into ‘policy’
How progressives are turning the ‘unthinkable’ into ‘policy’
Dec 3, 2025 1:16 PM

Last week two Congressional Democrats, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Sen. Ed Markey, unveiled their Green New Deal. The resolution claims that environmental and economic conditions require the federal government to take drastic action, such as updating or replacing every building in the country and guaranteeing jobs to all Americans. The proposal has been described as “the same old socialist hooey,” and even many Democrats consider it unfeasible.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell announced yesterday that he wants the Senate to vote on the resolution. “I’ll give everybody an opportunity to go on record and see how they feel about the Green New Deal,” said McConnell.

McConnell seems to think he’s going to embarrass Congressional Democrats by showing they’re out of sync with voters. But what he may be showing is that he doesn’t fully understand why we’re even talking about the Green New Deal in the first place.

Those who are proposing the Green New Deal recognize that it’s radical. Indeed, that’s the point. As Megan McArdle explains,

Progressives frequently argue that getting to “as much as possible” requires setting goals that are out of reach. They call it “shifting the Overton window,” or widening the spectrum of plausible policy options, an idea broached in the 1990s by policy analyst Joseph P. Overton. The folk version: Ask for the stars, you’ll get the moon.

The Overton Window describes a “window” in the range of public reactions to ideas in public discourse. Overton believed that the spectrum included all possible options in a window of opportunity:

Imagine, if you will, a yardstick standing on end. On either end are the extreme policy actions for any political issue. Between the ends lie all gradations of policy from one extreme to the other. The yardstick represents the full political spectrum for a particular issue. The essence of the Overton window is that only a portion of this policy spectrum is within the realm of the politically possible at any time. Regardless of how vigorously a think tank or other group may campaign, only policy initiatives within this window of the politically possible will meet with success.

All issues fall somewhere along this policy continuum, which can be roughly outlined as: Unthinkable, Radical, Acceptable, Sensible, Popular, Policy. When the window moves or expands, ideas can accordingly e more or less politically acceptable.

Politicians are necessary to move an idea into the last phase—policy. But it’s a misunderstanding of the process to think that politicians are driving the shift.

“The mon misconception is that lawmakers themselves are in the business of shifting the Overton window,” says Joseph Lehman, a colleague of the late Overton. “That is absolutely false. Lawmakers are actually in the business of detecting where the window is, and then moving to be in accordance with it.”

In other words, politicians respond to the public’s definition of the window, not the other way around. McConnell seems to think the Green New Deal is a bizarre proposal that has no constituency. But as NPR notes, there are 67 co-sponsors in the House and 11 in the Senate, including several current or potential presidential contenders: Bernie Sanders, Kirsten Gillibrand, Elizabeth Warren, Cory Booker, and Amy Klobuchar.

The reason so many Democratic presidential candidates support a bizarre plan like the Green New Deal is not that they themselves believe in it (though many do) but that they know many of their voters (especially primary voters) support the proposal. Politicians aren’t know for their bravery or forward-thinking. If they are ready to support a position it is because they think there is a substantial and vocal portion of the electorate that has already shifted the Overton Window to a point where it has the potential to e policy.

That is why conservative Christians can no longer mock and shrug when a politicians endorses an idea—such as infanticide or socialism—that we believe has been relegated to the dustbin of history. Progressive activists are constantly moving the Overton Window in disturbing ways. By the time we see progressive politicians nodding along in agreement, we’ve already reached a tipping point where the “Unthinkable” may soon e “Policy.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Money is a Means
Over at Think Christian today, I lend some broader perspective concerning the link between money and happiness occasioned by a piece on The Atlantic on some research that challenged some of the accepted scholarly wisdom on the subject. The Bible is our best resource for getting the connection between material and spiritual goods right. I conclude in the TC piece, “As Jesus put it, ‘life does not consist in an abundance of possessions.'” Or to put it another way, we...
What’s a Few Dead Eagles Between Friends?
There are currently two sets of laws in America: laws that apply to everyone and laws that apply to everyone except for friends of the Obama administration. In January I wrote about how the executive branch had argued that the Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918 should be broadly interpreted in order to impose criminal liability for actions that indirectly result in a protected bird’s death. The administration used that reasoning to file criminal charges against three panies. The U.S....
Evangelical and Catholic Leaders Claim IRS Harrassment
After the recent admission by the IRS that employees targeted conservative groups, two prominent Christians e forward claiming they too were harassed for their political views. Franklin Graham, son of the famed evangelist, and Dr. Anne Hendershott, a Catholic professor and author, say they were audited by the IRS after making political statements that criticized liberal political groups. Franklin Graham recently sent a letter to President Obama saying that he believes his organization was also unfairly targeted for extra scrutiny...
Advice for College Graduates on Money, Meaning, and Mission
Yesterday, Jordan Ballor explored the relationship betweenmoney and happiness, referring to money as “a good, but not a terminal good,” and pointing to Jesus’ reminder that “life does not consist in an abundance of possessions.” Over at Café Hayek, economist Russ Roberts offers a panion to this, advising college graduates to have a healthy perspective about money and meaning when entering the job market: Don’t take the job that pays the most money. Nothing wrong with money, but it’s the...
‘Economic Growth: Unleashing the Potential of Human Flourishing’: Values & Capitalism Publication
Values & Capitalism, a project of the American Enterprise Institute, has published a primer of sorts entitled, Economic Growth: Unleashing the Potential of Human Flourishing. The text is just over 100 pages, and gives the reader a thoughtful, concise and essential source on free market economics and its correlation to human flourishing and economic growth. Authors Edd S. Noell, Stephen L. S. Smith and Bruce G. Webb say this about their work: [T]he core proposition of this book is that...
Kuyper on Creation and Stewardship
In Abraham Kuyper’s recently translated sermon, “Rooted & Grounded,” he explains that the church is both “organism” and “institution,” drawing from both nature and the work of human hands. Pointing to Ephesians 3:17, he writes that, “the church of the Lord is one loaf, dough that rise according to its nature but nevertheless kneaded with human hands, and baked like bread.” Yet, as he goes on to note, this two-fold requirement is not limited to the church, but also applies...
Affirmative Action Limits Opportunities For Asian Americans
One of the realities of using race to socially engineer the racial make-up of college freshman classes by elite decision-makers, is that it does nothing but perpetuate the injustice of institutional and planned discrimination. This is the greatest irony of affirmative action education policy. The attempt to redress past injustices does nothing but set the stage for new forms of injustice against other groups. Today, Asian-American high-school students are faced with the reality that, if they are high achievers, top...
Acton University Evening Speaker: William B. Allen
We are about a month away from Acton University, and another keynote speaker is William B. Allen. He is an expert in the American founding and U.S. Constitution; the American founders; the influence of various political philosophers on the American founding. He is Emeritus Professor of Political Philosophy in the Department of Political Science and Emeritus Dean, James Madison College, at Michigan State University. Currently he serves as Visiting Senior Professor in the Matthew J. Ryan Center for the Study...
Senator Cornyn Quotes Lord Acton on Abuse of Power
Senator John Cornyn (R-Texas) took to the Senate floor yesterday and quoted Lord Acton’s well known dictum, “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” There’s a partisan bite to his words, but he mostly warns against the grave dangers and tyranny under concentrated and centralized power. Cornyn of course, is addressing the multitude of scandals blowing up in Washington, many of them linked to the White House. He also admits corruption has been a problem under both political...
Free primary education is a fundamental good. Isn’t it?
Private schools are for the privileged and those willing to pay high costs for education; everyone else attends public school or seeks alternate options: this is the accepted wisdom. In the United States, the vast majority of students at the primary and secondary level attend public school, funded by the government. When considering education in the developing world, we may hold fast to this thinking, believing that for those in severely impoverished areas, private education is an unrealistic and scarce...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved