Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How Kuyper can bring evangelicals and Catholics together
How Kuyper can bring evangelicals and Catholics together
Apr 26, 2025 12:47 AM

Have Catholics sacrificed the integrity of their faith tradition by allying with conservative evangelicals (like me)?

Matthew Walther, a national correspondent at The Week, thinks so. Walther claims the alliance between Catholics and evangelical Protestants was born of supposedly shared values. “In fact, few shared values exist,” says Walther.

Seemingly in exchange for the cooperation of evangelicals, conservative American Catholics have abandoned one of the great jewels in the crown of the Church, her modern social magisterium, the tradition that runs from Pope Pius IX’s denunciation of Victorian-era classical liberalism to Pope Francis’ Heideggerian assault on the merciless logic of globalized technocratic capitalism. For evangelicals, the idea that there is mon good toward which the political order must be oriented — and that this mutual flourishing cannot be conceived of as the mere aggregate of millions of individuals pursuing their own material interests with limited interference from the state — has no basis in theology. In return for evangelicals’ acknowledgement of one evil, Catholics have learned to ignore what the Church has to tell them about how we are to live in the world with one another.

Walther’s disparagement of evangelical theology, whether borne out of animus or ignorance (or possibly both), is not particularly surprising. Walther is among the young firebrand “traditionalists” whose primary pose is to be “more Catholic than thou.” For example, Catholics who deny that government is responsible for providing everyone with healthcare are, as Walther implies, essentially Protestants. When someone has such uninformed disdain for Catholics who don’t read the social encyclicals the way he does, you can’t expect him to have much respect for us lowly evangelicals.

If Walther had a better understanding of both evangelicalism and Catholicism, he’d be able to see mon ground is based mon grace and mon creed.

Abraham Kuyper (1837–1920) was about a big a fan of “Romanism” as Walther is of Protestantism. But Kuyper agreed there are two specific realms—creedal confession and morals—that are “not subject to controversy between Rome and ourselves.”

“[W]hat we have mon with Rome concerns precisely those fundamentals of our Christian creed now most fiercely assaulted by the modern spirit,” said Kuyper.

As J. Daryl Charles explains, Kuyper contend that differences of theology and ecclesiogy were “not now the points on which the struggle of the age is concentrated.” Rather, “the lines of battle” are drawn as follows:

Theism versus atheism and pantheismHuman fallenness versus human perfectibilityThe divine Christ versus Jesus the mere manThe cross as a sacrifice of reconciliation versus a mere symbol of martyrdomThe Bible as inspired by God versus a purely human productThe Ten Commandments as ordained by God versus a mere archaeological documentThe eternally established ordinances of God versus an ever-changing law and morality spun out of human subjectivity

“The character mon grace in Kuyperian thought is mirrored in its accent on our shared mon moral ground, and public responsibility based on the created order,” says Charles. “As a theological reality, it has its roots in the absolute sovereignty of God, a sturdy doctrine of creation, and a full-orbed, passing understanding of redemption.” He adds,

In addition to Kuyper’s insistence that two realms—creedal confession and morality—are the basis for Protestant–Roman Catholic unity, a further bit of evidence indicates that natural law mon ground between Kuyper and Roman Catholicism. In 1897, on the occasion of the 25th anniversary of his editorship of De Standaard, Kuyper stated what was his one great passion in life: “to affirm God’s holy statutes” in all of life and “to engrave God’s holy order,” known through creation and Scripture, “upon the nation’s public conscience.”

Walther is probably right in claiming that “few shared values exist” if that requires Catholics and evangelicals to submit their consciences to a particularly left-leaning interpretation of Catholic social teaching. But I believe that Kuyper is correct in claiming that shared mon grace, and natural law are the more natural basis for ecumenical cultural engagement. And I agree with Charles that, “If we update Kuyper’s program where needed and push it in a fuller ecumenical direction, the fruit might be rich beyond measure.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Integral Human Development
The Journal of Markets & Morality is planning a theme issue for the Spring of 2013: “Integral Human Development,” i.e. the synthesis of human freedom and responsibility necessary for the material and spiritual enrichment of human life. According to Pope Benedict XVI, Integral human development presupposes the responsible freedom of the individual and of peoples: no structure can guarantee this development over and above human responsibility. (Caritas in Veritate 17) There is a delicate balance between the material and the...
How to Steal a Bike in New York City
Edmund Burke didn’t really say it, but it still rings true: All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing. In a test of this maxim, filmmaker Casey Neistat tries to steal his own bike in several locations around New York City and finds that most people do nothing about it—even when it’s done right in front of a police station. I recently spent a couple of days conducting a bike theft experiment, which...
Reagan, Whittaker Chambers, and the Threat to Freedom
Over at the Liberty Law Blog, there is an excellent post titled “Ronald Reagan, Whittaker Chambers, and the Dialogue of Liberty” by Alan Snyder. Snyder delves into the influence Chambers had on Reagan and how their worldviews differed as well. Many conservatives and scholars felt Chambers’ prediction that the West was on the losing side of history in the battle against Marxism collapsed after the fall of the Iron Curtain and the Soviet Union. For many, the ideas of Chambers...
Lord Acton and the Power of the Historian
Looking through my back stacks of periodicals the other day I ran across a review in Books & Culture by David Bebbington, “Macaulay in the Dock,” of a recent biography of Thomas Babington Macaulay. The essay takes its point of departure in Lord Acton’s characterization of Macaulay as “one of the greatest of all writers and masters, although I think him utterly base, contemptible and odious.” As Bebbington writes, “Acton, a towering intellectual of the later 19th century, was at...
Let’s Change Hearts and Minds (and Laws, Too)
Few clichés are so widespread within the evangelical subculture, says Matthew Lee Anderson, as the notion that our witness must be one of “changing hearts and minds.” In careful hands, the idea is at best ambiguous. At worst it reinforces the sort of interior-oriented individualism that allows for and perpetuates a blissful naivete about how institutions and structures shape our dispositions and thoughts. In less than careful hands, the phrase drives a wedge between law and culture by attempting to...
Italy’s Tax Man Takes Aim at the Vatican
Kishore Jayabalan, the Acton Institute’s Rome office director, was interviewed by the Zenit news agency in an article titled, “Is Taxing the Church a Real Solution for Italy?” In the article, Jayabalan discusses the history of the Italian state and its imposition of property taxes on the Roman Catholic Church’s land holdings, residences and non-profit businesses. Sometimes in the past, particularly under Napoleonic rule and before the Lateran Pacts, the institution of property tax was often a subject of state...
Is Work a Curse?
Is work a curse, a result of mankind’s fall from grace? Not according to the Book of Genesis. As Hugh Whelchel, Executive Director of the Institute for Faith, Work & Economics, explains, what Adam was called to do in the garden is what we are still called to do in our work today: Humanity was created by God to cultivate and keep God’s creation, which included developing it and protecting it. You see, we were created to be stewards of...
How to Love Liberty More Than a Libertarian Economist
I have a deep and abiding love for liberty—which is why I find myself so often in disagreement with libertarians. Libertarians love liberty too, of course, but they tend to love liberty a bit differently. I love liberty in an earthy, elemental way. I love liberty because I need it—like I need air and food—for human flourishing. In contrast, the libertarians I’ve encountered tend to love liberty primarily as an abstraction. Indeed, the most ideologically consistent libertarians I know seem...
Constitutional Cases and the Four Cardinal Virtues
Should virtue be a consideration in judicial decisionmaking? Indiana Law Professor R. George Wright makes an intriguing argument for why the four cardinal virtues could be useful in interpreting constitutional cases: Judges typically decide constitutional cases by referring to one or more legal precedents, rules, tests, principles, doctrines, or policies. This Article mends supplementing this standard approach with fully legitimate and appropriate attention to what many cultures have long recognized as the four basic cardinal virtues of practical wisdom or...
Obamacare’s Religious Rubes
The White House has a plan to mobilize prayer vigils in front of the Supreme Court in defense of Obamacare. It was reported that the administration met with leaders at non-profit organizations and religious officials who support the new health care law. The court takes up the constitutional test of the health care mandate in a couple of weeks. The mandate has now been challenged in 26 states. Cue the same stale big government religious prophets who confuse statism and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved