Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How Four States Voted to Hurt Low-Skilled Workers
How Four States Voted to Hurt Low-Skilled Workers
Dec 17, 2025 2:19 AM

Last night the election results revealed wins for Republicans in almost every state. But in four states where the GOP gained ground — Alaska, Arkansas, Nebraska, and South Dakota — the poor and unskilled suffered a loss.

In each of those states, voters passed ballot measures that will increase the government-mandated minimum wage. Beginning in 2015, the wage in South Dakota will increase to $8.50 an hour. In 2016, Alaska’s wage will be $9.75 an hour and $9 an hour in Nebraska. Arkansas will also raise the wage-floor to $8.50 an hour by 2017.

While the measures passionate — who doesn’t want hard-working people to receive more money? — the effect will be that each of those state will likely see unintended consequences of the action.

Here are four ways the increased minimum wages will hurt low-skilled workers:

1. Minimum wage laws will reduce the number of low-skilled jobs —even in states that didn’t raise the wage — In 1950, there were over 81,000 gas stations and only about200 self-service stations(almost all in California). Self-service stations weren’t popular until the two gas shortages in the 1970s (1973 and 1979) caused higher fuel prices that ledconsumers to look for pricing relief. Almost overnight, full-service stations became all but extinct—taking an entire sector of low-skilled jobs with it.

Rapidly increasing the minimum wage will have the same effect. A small group of employees will see their pay increase while many more would find their jobs pletely, never e back. Because most of the increases won’t occur for 2-3 years, employers have time to find alternatives to the increased cost. One of the most likely changes will be automation in the fast-food industry.

In Europe, McDonalds has ordered7,000 TIOSs (Touch Interface Ordering Systems)to take food orders and payment. In America, Panera Bread willreplace all of their cashierswith wage-free robots in all of their 1,800 nationwide locations by 2016. There is even a burger-making robot that can churn out360 gourmet hamburgers per hour. Increasing wages will encourage corporations to speed up the implementation of automated services. By the time the wages go into effect in Arkansas, there will likely be fewer fast-food jobs available.

But the corporations won’t just use the automation in states with high minimum wages; it’ll be more cost-effective to roll them out nationwide. So the unintended consequences in these four states will affect the labor market for the whole country.

2. Minimum wage laws don’t substantially affect poverty — Most people who support or oppose minimum wage laws and/or increases share mon objective — helping the working poor. Because both sides have noble intentions, the merits of the debate over minimum wage laws and minimum wage increases should be based on empirical evidence that it will actually help, rather than harm, the poor.

Ina piece for the National Center for Policy Analysis, David R. Henderson explains there are two myths about minimum wages and the poor:

Most workers earning at or close to the minimum wage are not the sole earners in a household and most of them are not in poor households. For those two reasons, raising the minimum wage is not a targeted way to help poor people.

Henderson notes that from 2003 to 2007, 28 states raised the minimum wage to a level higher than the federal minimum wage. Using this as a basis for study, San Diego State University economics professor Joseph J. Sabia and Cornell University economics professor Richard V. Burkhauser examined the effects this had on poverty levels in those states. The result shows that there was no difference in poverty levels in those states pared to states with lower minimum wages.

Further, they calculated the effects of a proposed increase in the federal minimum wage to $9.50 on workers then earning $5.70 (or 15 cents less than the minimum in March 2008) to $9.49. They concluded that increasing the minimum wage from $7.25 to $9.50 per hour “will be even more poorly targeted to the working poor than was the last federal increase from $5.15 to $7.25 per hour.”

3.The minimum wage redistributes wealth from the low-skilled poor to the more skilled working poor and middle class— Many supporters of minimum wage increases mistakenly believe that increases in wage rates are transfers of wealth from employers and investors to the workers. But as Anthony Davis explains, the money to pay for the increased wage e from at least one of four places: higher prices for consumers, lower returns to investors, lower prices to suppliers, or a reduced work-force. Empirical research has shown that the primary effect of minimum wage increases is reduced employment, which essentially transfers the wealth (in unearned wages) from the less skilled to the more skilled working poor and middle-class teenagers.

4. Minimum wage increases disproportionality affect African Americans —Employment among African American males between the ages of 16 and 24 isdisproportionately responsive to the minimum wage. A ten percent increase in the minimum wage would reduce employment by 2.5 percent for white males between the ages of 16 and 24, 1.2 percent for Hispanic males between the ages of 16 and 24, and 6.5 percent for African American males between the ages of 16 and 24. Professors Even and Macpherson estimate that in “the 21 states fully affected by the federal minimum wage increases in 2007, 2008, and 2009,” young African Americans lost more jobs as a result of minimum wage hikes than as a result of the macroeconomic consequences of the recession.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
David Platt, Wealth, and the Work of the Gospel
Over at Thought Life, Owen Strachan uses David Platt’s book, Radical Together, as a launching pad for asking, “Are you and I making and using money as if there is no such thing as the work of the gospel?” I’ve already written about my disagreements with Platt’s approach in his first book, Radical: Taking Back Your Faith from the American Dream, and Strachan expresses similar reservations. While appreciating Platt’s emphasis on “exaltation of and dependence on a sovereign, awesome God,”...
Heroic Morality is Mundane
In the current Acton Commentary, I take a look at mon temptation to consider ourselves as somehow uniquely beyond the mundane obligations of the moral order. I do so through the lens of the hero of Les Misérables, Jean Valjean, and a particular moral dilemma he faces. I read through A Field Guide for the Hero’s Journey last week, and was struck by the significance given to this insight in chapter 3, “The Importance of Setting Guardrails.” In a short...
Audio: More ‘Becoming Europe’ interviews with Samuel Gregg; Washington book event
Samuel Gregg on Money Radio 1510, Scottsdale, Ariz.: [audio: Samuel Gregg on the Janet Mefferd Show:: [audio: Gregg’s new book ing Europe: Economic Decline, Culture, and How America Can Avoid a European Future is now available. You can purchase the hardcover or Kindle version here. Daniel Hannan, British Conservative Member of the European Parliament, said ing Europe’ might not sound so bad: old buildings, long lunches, generous welfare. But, believe me my friends, it’s not where you want to be....
Review: Rev. Gregory Jensen on ‘Hero’s Journey’
Update: Rev. Jensen has posted part 2 of his review. You can read it here. Rev. Gregory Jensen, who writes at the Koinonia blog, recently reviewed Rev. Robert Sirico and Jeff Sandefer’s new book A Field Guide for the Hero’s Journey. This is what he had to say about it: Prudence along with justice, temperance and courage, is a cardinal virtue. Unfortunately as contemporary Western culture has e more secularized it has formed generations of men and women who are...
Building ‘With Haitians, for Haitians’
It has been three years since the nation of Haiti was overwhelmed by earthquake devastation. In those three years, to the naked eye, it often appears as if little has been done. After all, at least 360,000 people still live in tent cities and infrastructure remains dubious. However, three years is a short time in a nation’s history, especially a nation like Haiti, with its background of political turmoil, slavery and natural disaster. According to Catholic New Service, progress –...
Why Would Anyone Choose Twitter Over Indoor Toilets?
Do most people value electricity and indoor plumbing more than cell phones and the Internet? In his article, Is U.S. Economic Growth Over?, economist Robert Gordon argues that they obviously do, and offers this thought experiment to prove his point: A thought experiment helps to illustrate the fundamental importance of the inventions of [the second industrial pared to the subset of [computer age] inventions that have occurred since 2002. You are required to make a choice between option A and...
Preventing inauguration blues
For those who voted for Mitt Romney, the Presidential Inauguration on January 21st could be a difficult day. Presidential elections have always been simultaneously exciting and frustrating. Today, alarmists on the left and the right place television advertisements, preach sermons, design billboards, and the like, proclaiming the apocalyptic consequences of the wrong person assuming the office of President of the United States. In the last election, Republicans and Democrats spent over $1 billion each courting support and votes from us,...
Creating a New Class of Young African-American Entreprenuers
Young African American men, especially ex-offenders, face high obstacles to employment. City Startup Labs hopes to help change that by teaching them the skills necessary to e entrepreneurs: This new non-profit was created to take at-risk young African American men, including ex-offenders, and teach them entrepreneurship, while creating a new set of role models and small business ambassadors along the way. City Startup Labs contends that an alternative education that prepares these young men to launch their own businesses can...
C.S. Lewis on transcendent economics
I recently discussed our pesky human tendency to limit and debase our thinking about economics to the temporary and material. Much like Judas, who reacted bitterly to Mary’s outpouring of expensive ointment, we neglect to contemplate what eternal purposes God might have for this or that material good and the ways through which it might be used or distributed. C.S. Lewis captures the tendency powerfully in his book, The Great Divorce, providing a clear contrast of heaven and hell through...
Freedom for Kiwis, But Not for Thee
There are more people living in the city of Los Angeles than live in New Zealand. Yet the small country in Oceania beats out the the U.S. in several key areas, such as on the production of movies about hobbits, ratio of sheep to humans (9 to 1), and . . . economic freedom. And the Kiwis aren’t the only ones. Australia, Canada, Switzerland, and six other countries have more freedom to control their own labor and property than we...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved