Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How Far Does Faith-Based ‘Shareholder Right to Know’ Go?
How Far Does Faith-Based ‘Shareholder Right to Know’ Go?
Jan 28, 2026 10:25 AM

On January 31, the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility issued a press release, announcing the organization’s “2013 Proxy Resolutions and Voting Guide.” A quick read of the release and ancillary materials, however, reveals that these resolutions have very little to do with issues of religious faith and everything to do with the progressive political agenda.

The ICCR guide “features 180 resolutions filed at panies” that call on shareholders to “promote corporate responsibility by voting their proxies in support of investor proposals that advance social, economic and environmental justice.”

The ICCR boasts that “nearly one third” of this year’s resolutions (52) focus on lobbying and political spending, with the remainder aimed at “health care, financial and environmental reform.” The release ominously asserts: “Shareholders have a right to know pany resources are being used to impact elections and public policy, including regulatory legislation.”

Whatsoever the ICCR resolutions have to do with the respective tenets of their member denominations is left to the readers’ imagination.

Under the guise of faith-based “economic and social justice,” however, the ICCR is attempting to prevent corporations from engaging in entirely legal and ethical efforts to work on their shareholders’ and customers’ behalf. As noted previously, initiatives such as the ICCR’s are an effort to force corporations to disclose efforts on their part to ensure corporate sustainability and shareholder profitability – endeavors protected by the U.S. Supreme Court’s Citizens United ruling.

Forcing corporations to disclose donations to the American Legislative Exchange Council, lobbying firms, think tanks and trade groups, for example, flies in the face of U.S. law, and hinders these groups from exercising constitutionally guaranteed rights to work for the benefit of the corporations who create jobs and provide goods and services for the world’s citizenry.

All this presupposes corporations and the wealth, jobs, goods and services they generate are an inherent evil if found lacking the ICCR’s views on social, economic and environmental justice. Nothing could be further from the truth. Aside from a few admittedly bad actors, corporations strive to benefit society as a whole – failure to do so would assuredly result in panies winding up atop the dustbin of entrepreneurial history.

In any event, steering corporate policies to reflect ICCR’s progressive agenda would result in more of a secular rather than a spiritual victory. Such efforts, in Competitive Enterprise Institute President and Co-Founder Fred L. Smith’s words, have a tendency to transform private corporations into public utilities by forcing them “to perform whatever duties are politically attractive at any one time … To ‘socialize’ this process is to reduce the ability of individuals to advance their goals, placing the values of politicians as paramount.”

Hamstringing pany’s efforts to pursue less egregious regulatory enforcement through lobbying or draft legislation, for example, establishes more government authority not necessarily in the best interests of the corporation in question. Nor is it likely that politicians and bureaucrats understand fully the unanticipated negative consequences of realizing their goals. As Smith noted: “The corporation is an extremely valuable way of organizing large numbers of people to produce goods and services efficiently—that is, to create wealth. That wealth then flows into the hands of shareholders, workers, customers, and suppliers, who are then empowered to advance their own individual goals and values.”

The ICCR would do far better by following real religious authority rather than submitting to trendy secular tracts on what constitutes economic, environmental and social justice. Two papal encyclicals e to mind: Quadragesimo anno (Pius XI, 1931) and Centesimus annus (John Paul II, 1991).

While both works identify the proper societal role panies as working for mon good, they also acknowledge the necessity of the profit motive for all involved. Nowhere in either document, however, do the authors make a case for transparency of how corporations advocate in best interests of their shareholders and customers.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Guatemala’s Liberty Movement and the Gospel as Social Cure
Guatemala is not known for freedom and stability, with a history colored by authoritarianism, political corruption, civil war, segregation, colonialism, post-colonial interventionism, and so on. Dire poverty and street violence remain endemic, and yethope remains: for political and economic liberty,yes, butalsofor freedom of spirit. In a beautiful long-form essay for the new PovertyCure Magazine, J. Caleb Stewart explores the promise of Guatemala, highlighting the story of Antonio Cali, “a one-time socialist who began his drift from the left when he...
How My Inner Protectionist Supported a Policy that Harms Africans
I don’t like to be wrong. But I also like to think that I’m open-minded enough to change my opinion when I am wrong (although I could be wrong about how open-minded I am). I try to carefully consider the arguments other people make (at least most of the time), but on occasion, I’m convinced I’m wrong by the person I listen to most: myself. Here, for example, is the gist of a conversation I hadwith myself last week: Me:...
Audio: Samuel Gregg explains need for Brexit
Samuel Gregg appeared on the recent episode of the podcast The Catholic Cave, “Britain, the EU and You,” to discuss Britain’s recent referendum vote to leave the EU. The show considers factors that potentially led to the Brexit other than trade and immigration issues, including dissatisfaction with international bureaucracy, cultural and philosophical differences between Britain and other European countries, and problems of subsidiarity. Gregg sees Brexit as a “reassertion of national sovereignty,” “reaffirmation of the importance of the nation state,”...
Christians should support markets and churches, NOT social democracy
David Schelhaas, Professor Emeritus of English at Dordt College, recently published an article titled “What Does Social Democrat Mean?” Schelhaas suggests that “Christians should seriously consider the merits of social democracy.” Schelhaas is quick to point out that he does not advocate socialism, with state control and management of the means of production, coupled with the redistribution of wealth. Instead, he advocates for the lighter “social democracy.” Schelhaas goes on to outline his vision of social democracy, including the state’s...
5 Facts About the Political Party Conventions
From Monday July 18 through Thursday July 21, the Republican Party will be holding their national convention in Cleveland, Ohio. Then, from July 25 to 28, the Democratic Party will hold their convention in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Here are five things you should know about these events: 1. The political party conventions are held every four years as the culminating event of the presidential primary season. For America’s two main political parties, the Democratic Party and the Republican Party, the convention...
Low Employment of Adults Affects Children Too
Not having a job — whether by choice or by circumstance – can adversely affect spiritual and psychological well-being of adults. But living in a home where the parents don’t work can also have a detrimental impacton children. In a new report, “America’s Work Problem”, Angela Rachidi examines the data related to children in poverty. She finds that while most children in America live with a working adult, those who are in a home without someone working full-time, year-round employment...
6 thought-provoking quotes from AEI’s ‘Economic Freedom and Human Flourishing’
In considering issues of political economy today, it is always prudent to refer to wisdom from the past. The American Enterprise Institute’s recent publication “Economic Freedom and Human Flourishing: Perspectives from Political Philosophy” is a collection of essays that analyzes the thought of several prominent philosophers on the connection between the title’s two subjects. Many of the quotes below, pulled from six of the nine essays, challenge foundational aspects of classical liberalism and the value of the free market. As...
Examining Suspension Policies in the South
In Dothan, Alabama, school officials are meeting to make changes to the Dothan City Schools suspension policies because of disparities between the rates of suspensions between black and white students. Across the American South, these suspension disparities are among the greatest. The terms for how students are punished are largely subjective, and this punishment increasingly falls harder on minority pared to their white counterparts. An August 2015 report published by the University of Pennsylvania highlighted some of the disparities in...
Without Natural Law, We Have No Rights
Our rights as Americans are considered unalienable, says Heritage Foundation president JimDeMint, only because they were inherent in the natural order of life established by the laws of nature and nature’s God. While musing on thewritingsof author and philosopher G.K. Chesterton in his personal notebook, a young John F. Kennedy wrote, “Don’t ever take a fence down until you know the reason why it was put up.” Fences hold things in we want to keep close, and protect us from...
Socialism Makes People Selfish
Does socialism make people kinder and more caring, while capitalismmakes people greedy and more selfish? No, in fact, justthe opposite is true. In this video, Dennis Prager explains the moral differences between socialism and capitalism, and why anyone who wants a kind and generous society must support one and oppose the other. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved