Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How a universal income could discourage meaningful work
How a universal income could discourage meaningful work
Apr 4, 2025 7:20 AM

In his popular book, Coming Apart, Charles Murray examined the key drivers of America’s growing cultural divide, concluding that America is experiencing an “inequality of human dignity.” Such a divide, Murray argues, is due to a gradual cultural drift from our nation’s “founding virtues,” one of which is “industriousness.”

“Working hard, seeking to get ahead, and striving to excel at one’s craft are not only quintessential features of traditional American culture but also some of its best features,” Murray writes in his chapter on the subject. “Industriousness is a resource for living a fulfilling human life instead of a life that is merely entertaining.”

Murray fully acknowledges the deep significance that work can bring beyond economic provision. Yet despite that recognition, Murray and a range of other conservative and libertarian thinkers continue to advocate a solution that would surely accelerate its demise: a universal basic e (UBI).

A UBI is variation of welfare through which regular transfers of cash are guaranteed to citizens by the government, regardless of status or situation. For Murray, who proposes an annual $10,000 transfer to anyone after turning 21, such a plan would only succeed if it was leveraged as a substitute for the welfare state. Indeed, simplifying the bureaucracy and minimizing the state is at the core of his reasoning.

“Under my UBI plan, the entire bureaucratic apparatus of government social workers would disappear,” Murray explains, “but Americans would still possess their historic sympathy and social concern. And the wealth in private hands would be greater than ever before.”

As far as UBI plans go, Murray’s solution is surely preferable to those of Mark Zuckerberg and Richard Branson, each of whom appear to view a UBI as simply another perk in the existing welfare state. But for Murray and the chorus of other conservative and libertarian voices who continue to join him, the question remains: given our belief that meaningful work and the “virtue of industriousness” are closely tied to America’s moral and social fabric, won’t such a policy simply exacerbate our underlying cultural problems?

If work offers something distinct in value — socially, economically, spiritually — what do we lose if we promote material transfers from the government that are independent from the actual creation of value? How are we to restore or cultivate those “founding virtues” if we promote policies that cast them even farther to the side?

Murray has responded to these concerns by shrugging off idleness as inevitable. “Yes, some people will idle away their lives under my UBI plan,” he says. “But that is already a problem… The question isn’t whether a UBI will discourage work, but whether it will make the existing problem significantly worse.”

His other major claim is that, while he agrees in the value of all that, the threat of automation is simply too great for human workers to withstand. “People have been worried about technology destroying jobs since the Luddites, and they have always been wrong,” he explains. “But the case for ‘this time is different’ has a lot going for it.”

In all of this, we see a fear of automation that undermines that original faith in human ingenuity and industriousness. Likewise, we see a focus on economic or policy efficiency that overlooks the side effects to the human heart. Both of which highlight an fortable reality for many on the right: It is not enough to simply be “small government” if our preferred pathways look only to the material factors on the surface. We also need to heed the cultural, social, and spiritual connections that lie beneath.

If we fail to recognize the value of work to the destiny of the human person, for example, our tinkering on the surface might only make matters worse. Yes, we may achieve certain surface-level gains in simplifying the government’s methods for moving cash, but at what cost to a culture that values and flourishes from meaningful work?

As Peter Cove argues in his own critique of conservative support for the UBI, “Our future depends on a robust future for work, because work does so much more than provide for our basic needs. Work draws us into the public square and instills in us a sense of personal responsibility. It allows people to feel the pride and self-respect e with supporting their spouses and children.”

We should seek efficiency wherever we can, even in our safety nets and policy mechanisms. But in doing so, we needn’t lose sight of those “founding virtues,” just as we needn’t lose faith that a widespread restoration of those virtues is possible.

As we look to the challenges of the future, let’s pursue efficiency and effectiveness in our government. But let’s do so with a continued faith in human capacity and creativity, and all that it brings brings to the world we’re trying to build.

Image: Attack of the Piggy Banks, Low Jianwei,(CC BY 2.0)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Giuliani and the Godbloggers
After the jump is the (hyperlinked) text of a column I filed last week from GodblogCon. Here are some related items worth exploring: “Evangelicals and Evil Empires: Religious voters have long had an interest in foreign policy,” OpinionJournal (HT: CT Liveblog).“Rudy’s Gamble: Giuliani’s audacious strategy for the nomination,” OpinionJournal.“Evangelical flocks on their own at the polls,” LA Times (HT: J-Walking).“On second thought, conservatives give Huckabee an amen,” LA Times.“Clarifying Media Distortions,” Focus on the Family.“Robertson for Rudy,” God’s Politics.“The Robertson...
Wichita Business Journal: The Call of the Entrepreneur
Pat Sangimino wrote an article for the Wichita Business Journal titled, “Documentary seeks to dispel negative images of entrepreneurs ” (subscription required). A premiere of The Call of the Entrepreneur took place in Wichita, Kan., on November 14th. Sangimino noted in his piece: Some consider Wichita to be the Midwest’s cradle of entrepreneurship. Evidence of that is the original Pizza Hut building, which was moved to the Wichita State University campus in 1984 to serve as a reminder of what...
Black America Is Just As Class Divided As The Rest Of America
The Pew Research Center released a new report stating: “African Americans see a widening gulf between the values of middle class and poor blacks, and nearly four-in-ten say that because of the diversity within munity, blacks can no longer be thought of as a single race.” Here are the key findings: • Asked whether blacks can still be thought of as a single race, given the increasing diversity within the munity, 53% of blacks say they can, but 37% of...
Prosperity, Sexual Sin, and Forgiveness
A recent survey by the Pew Global Attitudes Project finds that “religion is less likely to be central to the lives of individuals in richer nations than poorer ones” (HT). Given the Bible’s many warnings about the danger presented by wealth, specifically the temptation to no longer rely on God and his providential care, that probably isn’t surprising. But what might be more surprising is that “the United States, the wealthiest nation, was ‘most notably’ an exception, scoring higher in...
Alarmism and Corruption
Regis Nicoll over at The Point notes a WaPo story that is getting a lot of play on the blogosphere about the UN’s downgrade of the estimate of the extent of the AIDS epidemic, “U.N. to Cut Estimate Of AIDS Epidemic: Population With Virus Overstated by Millions.” Nicoll writes that while of course it is good news that fewer people are infected than were previously thought, “The bad news is that previous estimates were inflated because of politics, bad science,...
George Hearst of Deadwood: ‘The-boy-the-earth-talks-to’
In a bit of an addendum to my review of the HBO series Deadwood in the current issue of Religion & Liberty, “A Law Beyond Law: Life Together in Deadwood,” I couldn’t help thinking of this bit from Clement of Alexandria when describing George Hearst, the über-robber baron of the Old West. In that piece I write, “Hearst fancies that he is doing his fellow man a service in his devotion to mining gold, to acquiring ‘the color.'” There’s a...
A Child’s Faith
“People were bringing little children to Jesus to have him touch them, but the disciples rebuked them. When Jesus saw this, he was indignant. He said to them, ‘Let the little e to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of God belongs to such as these. I tell you the truth, anyone who will not receive the kingdom of God like a little child will never enter it.’ And he took the children in his arms, put...
Rock N Roll ‘Jesus’
Last night the American Music Awards were televised on ABC. Among the big winners were alumni of the hit TV show, “American Idol,” whose stars won 3 AMAs. Kid Rock, the Rock N Roll “Jesus.” But there was another kind of “idol” on display at the AMAs, as Detroit’s own Kid Rock was a presenter and did a spoof of his fight with rocker Tommy Lee in edy bit with host Jimmy Kimmel. Kid Rock released a new album last...
God Hears the Compassionate
“If a man shuts his ears to the cry of the poor, he also shall cry himself, but shall not be heard.” Proverbs 21:13 I remember being very young and hearing a minister dramatically describe the flames and fires of hell in a sermon. I know I was somewhere between the age of six and seven. At this time, I also had little knowledge of salvation in Christ, so I worried about my eternal destination. Couple this thought with a...
Reports on Globalization and National Capital
Last month the World Bank published a report titled, “Where is the Wealth of Nations?” (HT: From the Heartland). The report describes estimates of wealth and ponents for nearly 120 countries. The book has four sections. The first part introduces the wealth estimates and highlights the level position of wealth across countries. The second part analyzes changes in wealth and their implications for economic policy. The third part deepens the analysis by considering the importance of human and institutional capital,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved