Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How a Protestant pastor defended Brazil’s Catholics
How a Protestant pastor defended Brazil’s Catholics
Dec 28, 2024 1:23 AM

It was in Brazil’s 2010 elections that the majority of the voters first learned about Silas Malafaia. It was also the election in which the left-wing president Lula da Silva reached the height of his political power.

Lula was one of the most successful left-wing populist leaders of Latin America in the first two decades of the 21st century. He had all the pragmatism of a Tammany Hall boss. He could be applauded by a crowd of Communists one day and be praised at the international banker’s meeting in Davos in the next. He was the perfect Trojan horse for advancing the leftist agenda.

His successor, Dilma Rousseff, was even more radical and did immense damage to the economy. Under both these presidents, the current candidate of the Brazilian left in the 2018 presidential elections Fernando Haddad served as minister of education. Haddad is the prototype of the leftist college professor. He also tried to make the Brazilian public education system a lab of gender ideology.

And it is here that Malafaia enters into our story.

His opposition to the Brazilian left’s social policies was the most interesting thing about the 2010 election. Rousseff was a supporter of legalized abortion but, suddenly, she had second thoughts when she decided to run for president.

As leader of the Protestant Assembly of God – Madureira, Malafaia used his weekly TV show to unmask the Brazilian left’s intentions in the area of social policy. That was enough to make him the left’s favorite bête noire for the next few years and, needless to say, the subject of a relentless political persecution.

The subsequent events turned Malafaia into a champion of conservatism in Brazil. There was no single social issue upon which Malafaia did not take a stand. In 2015, for instance, the city of Sao Paulo’s gay pride parade decided to target the Catholic Church. A transvestite paraded dressed as Jesus Christ on the cross. A dozen Catholic saints were portrayed in homoerotic poses. Surprisingly, it was not the National Conference of Bishops of Brazil who defended Catholics against this attack; Instead, Malafaia did.

The fact that it was a conservative Protestant pastor who defended Catholics also provides us with an insight into the tsunami that prompted the conservative populist candidate Jair Bolsonaro to be a frontrunner in this year’s presidential elections.

Until the 1980s, the Protestant churches had been marginal within Brazilian society. The subsequent success of the evangelical churches in Brazil owes much to the way in which liberation theology alienated millions of Brazilians from the Catholic Church. The moral and spiritual emptiness of liberation theology and its tendency to reduce everything to politics and economics fueled a major crisis in the Catholic Church in Brazil and also spurred the growth of other churches that focused on the religious and spiritual message of the Gospel.

The Protestant churches in Brazil have never hidden, however, their concerns about the decayed social fabric. They appeal, for example, to the need to preserve an munity life and the traditional family. They have a simple moral message and are very effective in disseminating it. That helps explain the success of churches like the Assembly of God in gaining widespread acceptance among the poor but also amongst the rising middle class. In less than 25 years, they have drawn more than 30 percent of Brazil’s population, and they are still growing.

Over time, social conservatism has slowly e political conservatism. Even Protestant leaders who once refused to engage in political activity have pelled by the left’s sheer radicalism to align themselves with Brazil’s nascent conservative movement. Since then we have seen the rise of a political posed of Protestants, conservative Catholics and conservative Jews in defense of traditional values and, in many cases, the market economy.

Bolsonaro’s rise to preeminence owes much to the support of Protestant leaders and his willingness to embrace themes associated with the social philosophy created and popularized by many Brazilian Protestants.

Support for Bolsonaro has skyrocketed since the thousands of Protestants chose him as the champion of their causes. In the State of Rio de Janeiro, Bolsonaro’s home state and his political stronghold, is the biggest munity in Brazil. That helps to explain why Bolsonaro was able to win in all cities and to get 58 percent of the votes in the state.

Bolsonaro knows how vital the Protestants are for his political coalition. He himself as Catholic makes clear his affinity with Protestant voters. His sons and wife are Protestants. His campaign is based on defense of values that mon to all Christians but especially to Protestants since they tend to be more conservative than the rest of the population. He has not converted to Protestantism himself, but this has been seen a reflection of his integrity.

The Protestant bishop Marcelo Crivella, a nephew of the very powerful leader of the Universal church Edir Macedo (also a Bolsonaro supporter), was the first beneficiary of the nascent coalition of conservative forces during the municipal election of 2016. Crivella is a populist and not a conservative. A former senator, he supported Lula da Silva and Rousseff for almost 13 years but left them before the Workers’ Party was engulfed by Brazil’s economic and political crisis. In 2016, Crivella ran for mayor of the city of Rio de Janeiro and ended up facing the far left candidate, Marcelo Freixo, in the second round. Crivella crushed Freixo and won more than 59 percent of the votes.

Bolsonaros’ popularity with the Protestant population makes for a stark contrast with the open hostility that the left has towards all Christians. While Protestants aligning themselves with Bolsonaro was not a surprise, the velocity of the electoral transformation is impressive. mitment of so many Protestant religious leaders to support Bolsonaro shows that they now understood the need to push back the political war that the left has been waging against Christians for the last 40 years. Malafaia and many others have begun a process that, hopefully, will be carried forward by a generation of young conservatives who understand that no society can be built without God.

homepage image:Brasília – The minister Silas Malafaia during a public hearing at the Commission for Human Rights and Participative Legislation Senate Rights to discuss the bill the House that establishes penalties for those who discriminate against homosexuals. Wikimidia.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The BBC scraps free TV for the elderly: A lesson from Boxer in ‘Animal Farm’
The BBC is renowned for its educational programming, but its most valuable lesson is being presented on a global stage right now. The BBC is facing backlash for doing away with a universal beneft for the elderly and, in the process, teaching an audience of millions how government programs really work. The BBC is severely restricting a benefit that pensioners e to rely on: free TV licenses. The main beneficiary of this decision is BBC executives. Artistic license The BBC...
New French language article: « Bonne nouvelle, même les socialistes aiment le marché libre! »
The Acton Institute’s Religion & Liberty Transatlantic website has published its second article translated into French: « Bonne nouvelle, même les socialistes aiment le marché libre! » It is a translation of the article, “Great news: Even ‘socialists’ love the free market (poll),” which notes that the same Gallup poll showing socialism’s growing popularity also finds that the vast majority of Americans trust the free market, rather than the government, to regulate the economy. Translating this into French not only...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: Reciprocity and free trade
Alejandro Chafuen, Acton’s Managing Director, International, writes today in Forbes about free trade and its relation to the notions of reciprocity and protectionism — popular topics in our current political climate. Chafuen also cites the ideas of famed economists such as Adam Smith and Ludwig von Mises, who of course defended free trade but also allowed for exceptions. Mises even wrote, “Free trade is not the elimination of all tariffs,” maintaining, however, that free trade is always the ideal: “The...
Why Simonetti is wrong to slander David French
We live in a strange age when good Christian men are slandered in defense of men of low character. Still, I would have never suspected to see such calumny on the Acton PowerBlog. Unfortunately, my new colleague Silvio Simonetti has used our site to assassinate the character of my friend—and Acton ally—David French. Simonetti says that French is “One of the most outspoken instigators of conspiratorial theories about the collusion between Vladimir Putin and Trump. . .” Perhaps if Simonetti...
A one-volume user’s manual for operating Western Civilization
Later this month, Gateway Editions will be releasing Reason, Faith, and the Struggle for Western Civilization, the new book by Acton research director Samuel Gregg. John Zmirak, senior editor at The Stream, has an early review of what he calls “a user’s guide to western civilization“: Read. This. Book. Even if you must do so by artificial light, or on Kindle, in a noisy coffee shop that won’t allow hunting dogs. Gregg’s book is the closest thing I’ve encountered in...
Acton Line podcast: Why you should watch ‘Chernobyl’; A federal commission for natural rights
On this episode of Acton Line, we talk about HBO’s new miniseries, ‘Chernobyl’ and the events surrounding the explosion at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant in Pripyat, Ukraine in 1986. Kyle Smith, writer at National Review, joins us for this segment and explains how ‘Chernobyl’ is an indictment of socialism. Afterwards, Aaron Rhodes, human rights activist and co-founder of the Freedom Rights Project weighs in on the Department of State’s new Commission on Unalienable Rights and explains why he’s hopeful...
The Acton Institute’s transatlantic website publishes its first article in French
The Acton Institute’s Religion & Liberty Transatlantic website marked a milestone today: It released its first article in French. While the transatlantic website has diligently followed events in France and published an array of mentators since its launch in January 2017, until today all its articles had been published in English. This denied us access to the 275 million people worldwide who speak French. The Acton Institute takes seriously our mission to take our message of liberty, human dignity, and...
Why not to be a “polite” conservative in the age of French/Ahmari debate
The debate surrounding David French-ism started by New York Post’s Sohrab Ahmari in First Things is, in my view, less about content — or political proposals, to use another term — than about the future and, to a large extent, the recent past of the American Conservative movement. This debate is not about the benefits of the free market or whether a religiously-based moral philosophy should guide government, but about how mainstream “conservatism” lost its way and what the future...
Anti-religious hostility takes aim at foster care and adoption agencies
To most people, helping orphans and children in the foster system find stable homes seems like a top priority—the kind of priority that transcends politics and ideology,” says Kate Anderson in this week’s Acton Commentary. “Unfortunately, however, those vulnerable children are quickly losing their advocates—and their hope for a stable, loving family—because of rampant anti-religious bias in American society today.” In the United States,more than 400,000 childrenin the foster system are waiting for homes.Around 4%of children are adopted within a...
Sympathy as social virtue: Adam Smith’s solution for disruption
In our dynamic and disruptive economy, we see an increasing cultural anxiety about the automation and outmoding of all things, leading us to increase our focus on technical knowledge and “hard skills.” At the same time, we see increases in social isolation and declines in virtue munal life, causing many to wonder what might be missing. There’s hand-wringing and finger-pointing aplenty, with both progressives and (now) conservatives eager to blame “market capitalism.” The solution, we are told, lies in variations...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved