Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
House of Gucci is Ridley Scott’s “Basta!” to the commercialization of art
House of Gucci is Ridley Scott’s “Basta!” to the commercialization of art
Oct 31, 2024 1:25 AM

Starring Lady Gaga, Adam Driver, and Al Pacino, this mockery of elites as little more than decadent mafiosi may grab some Oscar nods, but The Godfather it isn’t.

Read More…

My first Oscars essay presented Wes Anderson, the Hollywood dandy’s Francophilia, The French Dispatch, and gentle criticism of liberal intellectual pretense. The 2022 Oscar contenders also include an examination of American Italophilia—veteran Ridley Scott’s House of Gucci, as full of today’s stars as Anderson’s movies are of yesteryear’s. Lady Gaga stars as the social climber-turned-murderess Patrizia Reggiani; Adam Driver as Maurizio Gucci, the fashion-business heir husband who left her and whom she paid someone to murder; and Jared Leto as his cousin Paolo Gucci. Salma Hayek plays the lady who helped hire the murderer, and the aged Al Pacino and Jeremy Irons play brothers Rodolfo and Aldo, who made Gucci a global luxury.

House of Gucci is designed like a parody of The Godfather and the entire subsequent generation of movies, which introduced America to Italian concerns with family and honor, passion and decadence, splendor and crime. That’s all over, of course; Americans no longer fantasize about Italy, but decadence and splendor are still important in Hollywood and America. It’s all over but the parody, that is, and Scott, a Brit uninterested in Italians, to judge by his career, seems to enjoy mocking the epic ambition of those stories and their insistence on tragedy.

This time it’s Milan, not New York, and the family business is fashion, not crime; the reputation is accordingly much better, but there’s no toughness, no mystery, no authority; an impressive influence attaches to the Gucci name, but it is a very worthless thing, which makes for a good poetic substitute for bragging. Altogether, Scott wants to show that that emptiness is also morally rotten, even repulsive at times. The suits are impressive, yes, but they are empty. In The Godfather, Don Vito is a ruler with a tradition behind him; in House of Gucci, the two generations we see are clowns played for laughs, a family that self-destructs out of pettiness, caprice, and self-importance.

Don bination of majesty and cunning is split in the parody. Jeremy Irons makes a caricature of the splendor of aristocracy, dressing like an Edwardian gentleman and affecting class contempt through every gesture, grimace, and the occasional pause to swallow his revulsion at everything new in the demotic 1980s. But it turns out he’s irrelevant to the plot; the world simply passes him by—Al Pacino is the more enterprising and worldly of the two, as he heads Gucci in America. He, in turn, makes a caricature of the family aspect of aristocracy, from the Tuscan countryside roots to the avuncular speeches and tender generosity for the future of the family—namely, his nephew Driver and his colorful wife Gaga. It turns out he’s also corrupt, cheats on his taxes, treats his son like a silly child, es to a sorry end. The story encourages us to believe these two very successful men, Rodolfo and Aldo, could never have amounted to anything, since it abstracts the family from the business.

House of Gucci treats the old with contempt, but does much worse to the young. Leto plays Paolo Gucci in the most unsympathetic way possible. He’s not only the victim of the contempt of his elders, but his ambitions to design are also treated as a mere nothing, a distraction from the important stuff, which is his ugliness, his thin voice and absurd gestures, his weak character and halfhearted resentments. He is, you guessed it, the Fredo of the show—he imitates the elders who despise him, and does so badly, but reveals in the process their own ugliness. He is nevertheless a victim we are encouraged to believe deserves even worse than he gets as he plays his part in the family intrigue.

The Michael Corleone role goes to Driver, perhaps the most impressive actor of his generation, wasted in this clown show as much as everyone else. He begins a shy law school student trying to escape aristocratic opulence, fearful of its obsession with the past because he knows it makes for cruelty in the present. Like Michael, he finds himself a local girl, which conceals his calculating mind and unpleasant temper. The pushy wife pushes him back to his family and into the business, which he ends up taking over ruthlessly—like Michael, by destroying any family love, to say nothing of anything sacred.

It’s somewhat funny to see Gaga be manlier than real-life Marine Corps veteran Driver for a while—we even get to see him iron the clothes in a domestic scene. She seduces him, gets him to marry, and even intrigues her way to put him in charge of the business. But aside from the elite media obsession with girlboss roles, it makes no sense to have the story told from her point of view; she’s not just the worst actor in the cast, but also plays the least interesting character, who knows nothing of glamour and its global reach, less still of the crisis it portends. Yet she’s the image of democracy—an independent woman, mind of her own, tough, direct, and although she’s an outsider among the elites, a striver. And I’d bet she gets an Oscar nomination,

The movie is very long, two hours and a half, and though every scene is directed with an easy mastery e to expect from Scott, parody should be much shorter than this. The first half deals with the rise of the Gaga-Driver odd couple, their love and their business triumph, but by the time it all begins to sour up and the second half begins to shows their ugly end, there’s no reason anymore to pay attention. The change of generations is a change from a striving for greatness that proves empty, a mere nostalgic embrace of the past, to irremediable mediocrity, which lacks interest.

Worse, parts of the movie are unbearably boring. Cutting a sex scene between Driver and Gaga to the “Libiamo, ne’ lieti calici” aria from Verdi’s La Traviata, and cutting their wedding scene to George Michael’s Faith—it’s not only bad taste; it’s obnoxious. Scott makes the entire movie about ironic reflections on media, ruining any interest in the plot in the process. He wants you to notice that the famous aria has been so overused that any interest in the opera itself has been destroyed. I think he went so far as to use a Pavarotti recording, to insist on the decadence created by popularity in the age of TV, with instantaneous worldwide broadcasting on repeat. As for Faith, it’s not just a juxtaposition of high and low; it’s a remark on our media degeneracy: They’re in church, hence faith, but with a twist—a hip, modern, and fun scene. He’s very clever in his criticism, but it’s a pain to watch.

Scott seems to plaining that when mediocrity was glamorized to the point of celebrity worship, this nonsense became authoritative and corrupted art. He made this unfunny farce, getting his actors to offer a tabloid view of Italy since the ’70s, to prove we have no tragedy, only sordid scandals, more ridiculous than fearful, and ultimately unimportant. And those actors don’t particularly look like the real Guccis, except maybe Pacino. They don’t talk or act like them—they’re crass caricatures, intended to abuse clichés of characterization, as if to say, if we can have nothing great, we might as well have misery. The movie’s message is gloom: Cinema is dead, because the audience was corrupted, as the ideas of romance to which they’ve succumbed make everything into mercial. Scott himself has been mercials for more than a generation, after all, selling luxury and exclusivity to the middle classes while debasing for their enjoyment the old sacred things. Even the two sacrilegious jokes—Gaga signing herself saying “Father, Son, House of Gucci” (an improvisation) and Driver calling Gucci the Vatican of fashion in an interview—have no power, either as sacrilege or humor.

The good press House of Gucci has received suggests Hollywood and media elites more broadly don’t see that they are the object of his mockery. The Guccis are Scott’s vision of our debased elites, ugly while pretending to be beautiful, as the movie’s conclusion suggests by connecting Gucci to transnational corporations, on the one hand, and to Anna “Devil Wears Prada” Wintour, on the other. As with other satires in our times, our elites aren’t even smart enough to know they’re being mocked.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Bourgeois Equality: The Modern World Can’t Be Explained By Material Causes
Economist Deirdre McCloskey is set to release the long-anticipated conclusion of theBourgeois Era trilogysometime next spring. The book, Bourgeois Equality: How Ideas, Not Capital or Institutions, Enriched the World, will build on her thesis that our newfoundprosperity is not primarily due tosystems, tools, or materials, but the ideas and rhetoric behind them. “The Great Enrichment, in short, came out of a novel, pro-bourgeois, and anti-statist rhetoric that enriched the world,” she writes, in a lengthy teaser for National Review. “It...
Jayabalan: Pope Francis should affirm support for Israel, Jews in talks with Iran
Hassan RouhaniIranian President Hassan Rouhani postponed his much-anticipated four-day European visit after the attacks in Paris over the weekend. According to a Voice of America report, the Iranian leader described the Islamist terror attacks, which have pushed the death toll to 132 and wounded more than 300 in Paris, as “crimes against humanity.” Rouhani had planned to visit Italy, the Vatican and France “in a trip aimed at boosting business and diplomatic ties after years of crippling international sanctions because...
Over-Educated and Under-Trained: Mike Rowe on the Need for Philosophizing Welders
Marco Rubio has inspiredplenty of chin-stroking over his recent remarks about welders earning more than philosophers. “We need more welders and less philosophers,” he concludedin a recent debate. The fact-checkers proceeded to fact-check, withmany quickly declaring falsehood (e.g. 1, 2). Yet the series of subsequent quibbles over who actually makes how much continue toside-step the bigger issue. Thoughthe liberal arts are indeed important and ought not be viewed simplyin terms of “vocational training,” mainstream American culture is certainly fond of...
Why Don’t Christian Victims of Islamic State Qualify As Victims of Genocide?
The Obama administration is moving to designate the Islamic State’s persecution of the Yazidi in Iraq an act of “genocide.” For the past few years the Yazidi, a tiny religious minority in the Kurdish region of the country, have been forced to flee the killings, rapes, and enslavement by Islamic State (the terrorist group formerly known as ISIS). There is no doubt that what is happening to the Yazidi should be considered genocide. But what about the Christians who are...
Arthur C. Clarke’s Inhuman Trade-Off in ‘Childhood’s End’
The fears of the past resonate in the present, and it’s no wonder humanity sometimes grasps desperately for answers in response to a frightening and unknowable future. Sometimes these e to us through literature and film which may allow us to dispense with the worst of them, given enough time. The Overlords of Arthur C. Clarke’s Childhood’s End – a classic 1953 science-fiction novel that serves as the basis for a Syfy network miniseries beginning Dec. 14 – turn out...
Explainer: What You Should Know About the Latest Contraceptive Mandate Challenge
The Supreme Court recently agreed to hear a challenge from religious nonprofit groups to federal government’s contraceptive mandate. Here are some answers to questions you may have about that case. What is this case and what’s it about? The case the Supreme Court will hear, Little Sisters of the Poor Home for the Aged v. bines seven challenges to the Health and Human Services’ (HHS) contraceptive mandate. To fulfill the requirements of the Affordable Healthcare Act (aka ObamaCare) the federal...
Registration for Acton University 2016 is now open
Acton University 2015 Attendees We are now 211 days from the opening day of Acton University 2016! University.Acton.org is updated, full of brand new information, and ready to go for next year’s conference, held at The De Vos Place in downtown Grand Rapids, Michigan on June 14-17, 2016. Registration will be open from today until May 20, 2016 at Midnight EST. That sounds like a lot of time, but don’t delay! We are offering two price points this year: $500...
Acton Institute’s ‘Poverty Inc.’ Wins Templeton Freedom Award
Poverty Inc., the new documentary that has grown out of the Acton Institute’s PovertyCure initiative, was awarded Atlas Network’s Templeton Freedom Award at an event last night in New York. Brad Lips, chief executive of the Washington-based Atlas Network, which administers the award, said the documentary is “without question” worth the attention it is receiving. “Shining a light on an fortable side of charity — where a paternalistic mindset puts the aid industry at the center of efforts to rescue...
Will the Earth Ever Have Too Many People?
At the beginning of human history, God gave mankind a mandate to “Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth” (Genesis 1:28). Sometime later—around the 19th-century—people started wondering, “Is the earth close to being filled with humans?” In 1798, Thomas Malthus predicted that if current birth rates persisted, many in Great Britain would starve to death. Instead, the birth rate was matched by increased agricultural yields, allowing more people to be fed with fewer land resources. Despite Malthus’s failed...
Report: Largest North Korean prison camp has expanded
Do Google Earth satellite images point to more grim news from inside North Korea? According to an article from United Press International (UPI), Curtis Melvin of the U.S.-Korea Institute at Johns Hopkins University noticed a substantial difference in satellite images of a North Korean prison camp from 2013 to some taken last month: [A]erial snapshots from Oct. 15 indicated considerable changes have been made to Camp No. 16. Melvin said the new changes included dams, hydroelectric power plants, apartments for...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved