Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Health Care Sharing Ministries: ‘Faith, Liberty, and Charity’ in Health Care
Health Care Sharing Ministries: ‘Faith, Liberty, and Charity’ in Health Care
Apr 26, 2026 3:32 PM

While many Americans are struggling to navigate healthcare.gov and some are fighting against the Affordable Care Act’s threat to religious liberty, an estimated 100,000 people are exempt from the legislation as members of a health care sharing ministry (HCSM); these organizations offer the opportunity for individuals with similar beliefs to share their health care costs.

HCSMs are not panies, but nonprofit religious organizations that receive no government funding. Andrea Miller, the medical director for Medi-Share, one HCSM in the U.S., explained in a recent interview with NPR how the ministry works:

[I]t’s a group of people, in this case Christians, who band together and agree that they want to share one another’s burdens. And the way they do that is that they each put a certain amount of money aside every month and then they actually send that money to another Christian who is in need of it that month in order to help them pay their medical bills.

The Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries explains, in more details, what HCSMs are and offers some interesting facts about them, including parison of current ministries. More than 99% of all applicants are accepted into a sharing ministry. Medi-Share, has shared more than $600 million among members. HCSMs have stricter guidelines than traditional panies on which procedures are eligible. For example, members will not receive sharing to pay for abortions, suicides, and other procedures that are prohibited in ministry guidelines. Members must live Christian lifestyles, abstaining from illegal drug consumption, sex outside of marriage, tobacco use, and may not abuse alcohol or prescription drugs. Because HCSMs are not panies they don’t have to guarantee that they will pay any and all medical bills. Members pay a one-time participation fee, pay a monthly share option, and receive a newsletter or publication that lists the needs of other members. Members must be Christians, affirming their faith through a personal testimony or with a letter from their pastor.

HCSMs have been providing this service in the United States for several decades, but the two largest organizations—Medi-Share: Christian Care Ministry and Samaritan Ministries International—have been working since the early nineties. HCSMs take their mission directly from scripture. Galatians 6:2 calls Christians to “bear one another’s burdens, and thus fulfill the law of Christ.” They also cite Acts 2:44-45, which is often mistakenly attributed to munism: “all the believers were together and had everything mon. Selling their possessions and goods, they gave to anyone as he had need.” Participants of HCSM see paying for each other’s medical bills as bearing one another’s burdens.

The two main HCSMs distribute the funds among members differently. America’s Christian Credit Union manages all funds in a “Member Share Exchange” for Medi-Share and money from there can be transferred from one member to another. Members of Samaritan Ministries International give their monthly share amount directly to other members in need based on their monthly newsletter. When members have needs that do not meet the guidelines or are not paid in full, they can be listed in the monthly newsletters and other members may choose to donate extra funds.

Members not only support each other financially, but also spiritually through prayer and sending words of encouragement. Fred Bennet, from Chattanooga, Tenn; had been a member of an HCSM for several years when he and his wife Beth suffered major health problems. Beth had E.Coli in her kidneys and ended up with a $70,000 bill while Fred suffered a heart attack and had to have several surgeries, other members of their sharing ministry picked up the bill and the Bennetts ended up paying only the deductable for each procedure. While the financial aid is important, the spiritual support offered by HCSMs is also vital. Fred says: “The night before my surgery, the lady who’d helped me locate the right providers and everything called me back and said, ‘Would it be OK if I prayed with you for your surgery tomorrow?’” Two members from Idaho, Michael and Mary Suitter, say that they “found [themselves] in tears as we read the meaningful notes of agape love and encouragement” from other participants.

Although individual participants of HCSMs are exempt from Obamacare for now, it could still cause long term problems for individual members as well as the ministries as a whole. A recent article by Jim Epstein at Reason outlines the risks that Obamacare poses to HCSMs. Epstein says:

It would hardly be the first time that a new government entitlement destroyed a voluntary organization built monly held beliefs.Samaritan is one of the last “mutual aid societies,” organizations that up to the early twentieth century played an integral role in American life.In 1910, an estimated one-third of American men belonged to a fraternal organization, which provided temporary help to those unlucky enough to fall ill or lose a job. The mutual aid societies began disappearing with the rise of government programs such as welfare, Medicaid, food stamps, and unemployment insurance.

The demise of Samaritan and other outfits like it would be cause for concern. Subsidized health insurance plans through the exchanges provide richer benefits than a membership in Samaritan, but they do away with incentives that over time are the key to driving down prices and driving up quality. With the “silver plan” on the health care exchanges, when patients get a routine physical they’re responsible for no more than $45 out of pocket and insurance pays the rest. Samaritan members pay the entire cost of a routine visit out of pocket and they can only submit their bills for reimbursement that exceed $300.

President of Samaritan Ministries, James Lansberry, is not concerned that members will leave Samaritan and other HCSMs for Obamacare, he says: “We look at our exemption from the individual mandate as a miracle from God…members will stick with us even if it doesn’t make financial sense, because by belonging they’re expressing their religious beliefs.”

Acton has plenty of resources to help you understand what’s going on with health care in America. Check out Powerblog posts about Obamacare, Nick Pandelidis’ mentary “Obamacare Reset: A Free Market Vision for Health Care Reform,” and Acton’s “Christians and Health Care” Resource page.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
What is a Christian to think about health care?
Brad Green, who teaches theology at Union University in Jackson, Tenn., published mentary on health care in The Jackson Sun. Green, an alum of Acton’s Toward a Free and Virtuous Society program, is also a co-founder of Augustine School in Jackson. So, what would Jesus do? Jesus would (and mand people to repent of their sins, care for the poor, the sick, the lame and the down-trodden. And Christians manded to do the same. But is a Christian then obligated...
Machiavelli, the Prince, and the Tradition of Liberty
Machiavelli’s succinct and semi-diabolical advice to the prince is one of the most enduring works of political philosophy in the world. This man, writing in a time roughly contemporaneous with the Reformation, was less concerned with seeking the will of God than with winning at all costs. I wrote about him in my book The End of Secularism. He is famous for advising the prince that it is important to appear honest, humane, religious, faithful, and charitable, but that it...
The Market, School of Virtue
This week’s Acton Commentary: Does the market inspire people to greater practical virtue, or does it eviscerate what little virtue any of us have? Far from draining moral goodness out of us—as many think—the free market serves as a “school of the practical virtues.” Rather than elevating greed and self-sufficiency, the market fosters interdependence and cooperation. Its rewards do not go to those who are the most isolated, self-absorbed, or cut off from society, but to those who sustain mutually...
Public schools flunk the test on black males
My latest mentary: Do at-risk black males need to be emancipated en masse from America’s public plex? A new study released about high school dropout and incarceration rates among blacks raises the question. Nearly 23 percent of all American black men ages 16 to 24 who have dropped out of high school are in jail, prison, or a juvenile justice institution, according to a new report from the Center for Labor Markets at Northeastern University, “Consequences of Dropping Out of...
Earned Success = Happiness
David Bahnsen reflects on last night’s annual dinner: (Acton’s) co-founder, Father Sirico, is a friend and patriot. He is a scholar in Catholic social thought, and perhaps as good of an orator as I have ever heard. He and I shared the podium at an event I did in Newport Beach earlier in the year. Fortunately for me, I spoke before him that evening! The talk tonight was challenging and inspiring. He reminded us that the greatest victim in this...
‘Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!’
Today marks the twentieth anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall. Acton adjunct scholar and sometime PowerBlog contributor Eric Schansberg links to a bit of background to Ronald Reagan’s remarks at the Brandenburg Gate provided by Anthony Dolan, Reagan’s head speechwriter, in today’s WSJ. Peter Robinson is credited with the famous utterance, “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!” In his remarks at this year’s Acton Institute Annual Dinner, Rev. Robert A. Sirico recalled that President Reagan’s challenge was derided...
Dems Cornered on Health Reform
As we appear to be nearing a climax in the many-months-long health care reform debate (maybe), opinion is remarkably divided on what the end result will be. Outright victory for left-wing reformers? Passage of a watered down, mon-denominator reform bill? Or clear victory for Republican opposition? All possibilities remain on the table. The relative success of conservative candidates in major elections Tuesday led mentators to reason that the environment has gotten more difficult for moderate Democrats and that, therefore, Pelosi...
Critiquing Fair Trade and Dead Aid
Cardus’ Robert Joustra rightly pillories “fair trade” along with the logic of foreign aid in a challenging article, “Fair Trade and Dead Aid: ‘My Voice Can’t Compete with an Electric Guitar.'” Joustra’s point of departure is sound: “The aid model is not working, and no large-scale cash infusion or debt forgiveness scheme is going to make it suddenly start working. The fair trade brand is too small-scale and ultimately regressive.” Unfortunately, though, Joustra’s well-placed critique of the fair trade movement...
Recommended Post-Reformation Day Reading
In connection with the worldwide celebrations of the quincentenary of John Calvin’s birth in 2009, the Acton Institute BookShoppe recently made available a limited stock of the hard-to-find Light for the City: Calvin’s Preaching, Source of Life and Liberty (Eerdmans, 2004). In this brief and accessible work, Lester DeKoster examines the interaction between the Word proclaimed and the development of Western civilization. “Preached from off the pulpits for which the Church is divinely made and sustained, God’s biblical Word takes...
Finding the Right Charity
The Dave Ramsey Show appears on Fox Business Network and is also available for live streaming via Hulu. In last Thursday’s episode (at about the 18:00 mark), a Twitter follower of @ramseyshow asked, “I want to start giving. How do I find the right charity for me and how do I find out if the charity is legit?” Dave’s short answer: “You have to spend time on it.” He expands a bit, but that’s a great starting point. You need...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved