Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Health care mandate threatens religious freedom in California
Health care mandate threatens religious freedom in California
Apr 3, 2025 3:20 PM

The Associated Press reported Wednesday that the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has decided to uphold the California Department of Managed Health Care’s 2014 mandate that health care providers must include elective abortion coverage in all their plans. Previously, several health panies in California had provided plans exempting these services for customers with religious objections, including churches and religiously-affiliated schools.

The statement released by the Office of Civil Rights (OCR) under the HHS plaints that the California ruling violated the Weldon Amendment, which protects health care providers from pelled to provide abortions. The amendment refuses to fund government programs that discriminate “on the basis that the health care entity does not provide, pay for, provide coverage of, or refer for abortions.” The definition of health care entity includes those directly providing the services, such as doctors, hospitals, and insurers. In response to the challenge, the OCR has determined that only the religious objections of those entities must be respected, not religious objections of their customers. The OCR statement points out that none of the health care providers had religious objections, so California can pel them to provide abortion services in their insurance plans.

However, in the text of the amendment, it does not specify proper motivations behind the refusal to provide abortions, only that such a refusal may not be grounds for discrimination. The amendment also specifically includes “health care plan” in the list of entities. California’s order that all plans include abortion services unless the provider specifically has a religious objection seems to directly defy the Weldon Amendment. Unfortunately, the HHS under the Obama Administration has reinterpreted the amendment in a very narrow way. Casey Maddox, a Senior Counsel lawyer for Alliance Defending Freedom, who originally brought the suit against the mandate on behalf of several religious institutions, has even accused the administration of “inventing new interpretations out of whole cloth.”

The practical effect is that religious and religiously-affiliated institutions, including churches, will pelled to provide elective abortion coverage in their health care plans. This is a clear and blatant violation of the rights of conscience of religious peoples and institutions.

Not only does the mandate burden religious freedom, it is also unnecessary. The government has demonstrated that there are feasible ways to provide access to contraception and abortion services without involving the employer at all. This is no better exemplified than in the protracted legal battle between several religious institutions and the HHS in the case Zubik v. Burwell. The case centered on religious objections to a procedure under the HHS mandate that allowed religious institutions to pass providing contraception on to the federal government only if they signed a document. Religious institutions claimed that signing the document involved them in the process of providing coverage for abortion and contraception, which they could not do in good conscience. When the case made it to the Supreme Court, the Court decided to send the case back to circuit courts for reconsideration, unconvinced that the government was achieving their ends of providing universal abortion and contraception coverage in the way that least involved the employer. President Obama himself, while legal injunctions allowed the religious employers to plying with the mandate, claimed in an interview with Buzzfeed News that the government was having no problem providing women with these services, in total absence of employer involvement.

Considering that it is conceivably illegal for California to force all plans to include abortion and contraceptive services under current laws and that it is unnecessary for achieving the end of providing such services to all women, California should consider retracting its mandate. It is imperative to respect the religious convictions of others and to protect their rights of conscience, and both California and the Obama administration have failed to do so.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A Hanukkah meditation on Maimonides … and venture capitalism
If the average person had to describe a capitalist, he might name “Dickens’ unredeemed Scrooge, or Gordon (‘Greed is good!’) Gecko from the movieWallStreet.” However, the real patron saint of venture capitalism may well be the great Jewish theologian and philosopher Moses Maimonides,writes Laurie Morrow, Ph.D., in a Hanukkah meditationfor Acton’sReligion & Liberty Transatlanticwebsite. “Rambam” believed that the highest form of charity is enabling someone to start a business or take other means so that he will no longer have...
How taxing work affects employment
Note: This is post #104 in a weekly video series on basic economics. An important factor influencing an individual’s decision whether to keep working as they get older is their government’s tax and retirement policies. Taxes on earnings plus penalties, like losing retirement benefits, gives us an implicit tax rate, explains economist Alex Tabarrok. Countries with higher implicit tax rates for older workers see a much lower labor force participation rate for people considered retirement age. (If you find the...
FAQ: What happens in a confidence vote?
Prime Minister Theresa May will face a confidence vote today between 6 and 8 p.m. local time (1 to 3 p.m. Eastern time). The result is expected no later than 9 p.m. London time. What is a confidence vote, how does it work, and what happens afterwards? What is a confidence vote? Under the UK’s parliamentary system, the ruling party’s leader es prime minister. If the leader loses his or her support, Conservative members of Parliament vote to express their...
Samuel Gregg: Paris is burning
“Since 1789, we’ve all had good reason to worry whenever riots break out in Paris,” says Acton research director Samuel Gregg. “Whether it’s 1848 or 1968, social upheaval in France rarely ends well.” The sheer fury vented throughout France by thegilets jaunesmovement over the past three weeks has highlighted specific grievances animating many French citizens. The truth, however, is that the burning cars, blocked highways, vandalism, lawlessness, and running battles between rioters and police in the streets are symptomatic of...
‘The Great Awokening’: The threat of America’s new political religions
The decline of religion in America is real—that is, depending on how you define “religion.” Weekly church attendance is in decline, as is self-identification with a formal religion, denomination, or belief system. Meanwhile, the rise of the “nones” seems increasingly steady in speed, replacing religious-cultural standards and norms of old with a modern menu of “personal spiritualties” based on any number of humanistic priorities—from humanitarianism to political activism to self-helpism to the garden-variety exultations of hedonism, materialism, fortability. But not...
5 Facts about Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Yesterday marked the 100th anniversary of the birth of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn. The celebrated novelist and dissident is considered by many to be a key figure in the demise munism and the collapse of the Soviet Union. As Daniel J. Mahoney says, “Solzhenitsyn embodied, in thought as well as deed, the two great moral wellsprings of European civilization: humility and magnanimity, humble deference to an ‘order of things’ and the spirited defense of human liberty and dignity.” In honor of his...
5 Facts about international human rights
Today is the 70th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, a milestone document in the history of human rights. In honor of the observance, here are five facts you should know about international human rights: 1. Prior to the 1940s there were a number of documents, such as the the British Magna Carta and the U.S. Bill of Rights, that advanced the recognition of human rights. But few documents were recognized internationally as applying to all people at...
An Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn centenary
On this day in 1918, Russian writer and historian Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn was born inKislovodsk, Russia, to Taisia and Isaaki Solzhenitsyn, parents of peasant stock who had received a university education. When he died in 2008 near Moscow, Solzhenitsyn had published his monumental Gulag Archipelago and other literary and historical works — which continue to appear in English for the first time. Over the next few weeks, we’ll be posting Acton archival material and new writings and media on the blog...
FAQ: Who is Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer, Angela Merkel’s successor in Germany?
On Friday, December 7, Angela Merkel’s ruling Christian Democrats elected Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer as party leader. “AKK,” as she is known, is liberal on economic issues, conservative on social issues, and once called for the Roman Catholic Church to ordain a “quota” of female clerics. Here are the facts you need to know. What happened at Friday’s CDU party leadership vote? Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer narrowly won the delegates’ vote to e party leader of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) in a narrow,...
From inmates to entrepreneurs: How work transforms the soul and spirit
James, Gene and Dexter at Refoundry With the promising (but now passing) prospect of a new wave of criminal justice reform circulating around Capitol Hill, discussions have reemerged as to how we might improve the justice system to better help and support our prison population (current and former) in rehabilitating their lives and avoiding the status quo of systematic detours. Meanwhile, at a cultural and institutional level, we continue to new ways of helping individuals better recognize their gifts and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved