Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Gaining the world, keeping your soul
Gaining the world, keeping your soul
Jan 29, 2026 12:06 PM

Recently, RossDouthat gave a talk at St. Michael’s College at the University of Toronto on the question, “Can You Be a Harvard Catholic?”

The Harvard grad and New York Times columnist said he has always found religion to be a personal and professional asset to his career, not a hindrance. He mused that this may be particularly the case because of his distinctive path as a journalist. “Weirdness is good,” he said. “It connects you to the mass of human history and contemporary humanity. Especially in college, why would you want to have the patterns of thought and the same assumptions that everyone else has?”

Douthat proposed that the ‘Harvard Catholic’ has more to draw on, more exposure, and more to contemplate than secular Westerners. “Having a better ground than what’s on TV isn’t easy but it’s sort of a gift,” he said.

When es to the challenges of keeping the faith on campus, Douthat considers these to be more personal than intellectual. “Is frantic, strenuous ambition the Christian goal?” he asked. “The Ivy League lifestyle doesn’t challenge the faith intellectually so much but it challenges it in the sense that it says immediate, material succeeding and winning is what counts.”

“Harvard taught me petition and success matter most. It didn’t teach me that God doesn’t exist or that miracles don’t happen,” Douthat began. “This was the deeper challenge, the challenge to a soul’s values and priorities.” He discussed a person’s 20s and 30s as the period of life during which it is convenient to postpone the eternal questions of the soul. While marriage and children bring a person to necessary consideration of mortality and making a gift of self, meritocratic culture can imply postponing those things.

He shared ing face to face with one’s mortality can “bring home the truth that most college students don’t grasp – you won’t live forever, or maybe you will but it won’t be in this context but with God. Most secular life is built on the denial or suppression of those realities and questions. But when those things disappear, then what?”

During Q&A I mentioned that my friends and I tend to be constantly asked by others, “What’s next?” Most of us would prefer to be asked about the present. Answering the “What’s next?” question often results in postponing the questions of the soul due to meritocratic conventions. How can students who are trying not to settle for less than the spiritual grandeur of a life of faith give witness to their concern with the questions of the soul?

Douthat’s immediate reply: “Well, you could say, ‘I’m gonna found a munity!'” he said with a laugh.

He then discussed three counter-cultural ways for young Catholics to offer this witness and give life to cultural renewal. These munity, family, and celibacy. His encouragement was to focus on these as counter-cultural goals and, at the same time, avoid romanticizing them.

Another Harvard grad, Aurora Griffin, has just released a bookcalledHow I Stayed Catholic at Harvard: 40 Tips for Faithful College Students. Griffin agrees with Douthat that her Catholic faith has been an asset, not a detriment to the university experience: “I have found that faith doesn’t take away from the rest of life: it gives it meaning.”

Also a Rhodes Scholar, Griffin recounts in the book an icebreaker activity during which the American scholars were asked to sit in a circle and say something “vulnerable” about themselves. She chose to say, “I am a Roman Catholic who believes all the teachings of the Church. My faith helps me to love people with whom I disagree more than I otherwise would.”

To whatever obstacles – be they intellectual or moral – a person faces in living the faith on campus, Griffin mends a banquet of Christian practices from which students can choose. To the classical spiritual practices, she offers contemporary anecdotes and some fresh, faith-filled interpretation. From spiritual reading and writing, to seeking out good literature, to living the liturgical year and Sundays well, this book offers inviting and encouraging tips.

These are some of the countless ways to, as St. Josemaria put it, ”‘materialise’ [our] spiritual life”. He stressed: “God is calling you to serve Him in and from the ordinary, material and secular activities of human life. He waits for us every day, in the laboratory, in the operating theatre, in the army barracks, in the university chair, in the factory, in the workshop, in the fields, in the home and in all the immense panorama of work. Understand this well: there is something holy, something divine, hidden in the most ordinary situations, and it is up to each one of you to discover it. […]There is no other way. Either we learn to find our Lord in ordinary, everyday life, or else we shall never find Him.”

Ambitious souls are called to use their gifts: “[…If] service, in our serving; he who teaches, in his teaching; he who exhorts, in his exhortation; he who contributes, in liberality; he who gives aid, with zeal; he who does acts of mercy, with cheerfulness.” (Romans 12:7-8)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Hannah And Her Sisters… and Brothers
The other day on this PowerBlog I posted “Learning To Tell The Truth” and ended the article with an observation: It may be instructive to note that the young female reporter who took part in the videos is named Hannah. For Jews the Biblical namesake is one of the prophetesses whose prayer is remembered at Rosh Hashanah [coming soon] and the mother of Samuel. You may recall that Samuel had problems with his succession choices. They weren’t sufficiently obedient to...
Acton Commentary: Marxism’s Last (and First) Stronghold
mentary on Western Europe’s fascination with Marxist symbolism was published today on the Web site of the Acton Institute. Excerpt: Marxism, we’re often told, is dead. While Communism as a system of authoritarian power still exists in countries like China, Marxism’s contemporary hold over people’s minds, many claim, is pared to its glory days between the Bolshevik seizure of power in Russia in October 1917 and the Berlin Wall’s fall twenty years ago. In many respects, such observations are true....
Learning To Tell The Truth
Last week when the videos were aired showing ACORN employees in their Baltimore and Washington DC offices consulting “a couple” pretending to be a pimp and prostitute I watched with amazement. On Saturday my wife sat at puter to see for herself. Busy in another room I could hear the rumbling of the adult’s conversation but what stood out was the unmistakable sound of little kids and the high pitched chatter and muffled squealing that characterizes children at play. That’s...
Give Temperance a Chance
Just about every state has dealt with the issue over the last few years, it seems. But here in Ohio, the legal status of gambling is the issue that won’t go away. It’s on the ballot again in November, this time as a constitutional amendment to permit casinos in four cities. The issue is something of a dilemma for Christians with limited-government inclinations. In general we don’t want prohibitions on legitimate business activity or entertainment, and most Christians don’t consider...
Stewardship, Soulcraft, Work, and Eternity
In what deserves to be considered a modern classic, Lester DeKoster writes on the relationship between work and stewardship. These reflections from God’s Yardstick ought to be remembered this Labor Day: The basic form of stewardship is daily work. No matter what that work may be. No matter if you have never before looked upon your job as other than a drudge, a bore, a fearful trial. Know that the harder it is for you to face each working day,...
Speaking Truth to School Children
On the weekend I read the text of the talk Barack Obama gave on Tuesday to a public school in Virginia and through the medium of technology to students throughout the nation who wished to see and hear him on their school televisions. I think of Ray Bradbury’s story “Fahrenheit 451” and plasma walls at times like these. I’ve written over the years as have others on the errors of having a Federal Department of Education and the Obama speech...
The Political Double Standard for Religion
The point has been made by outstanding thinkers like Stephen Carter and Richard John Neuhaus that the New York-Washington, D.C. establishment eats up left wing religion and declares it delicious. Give a radical a cross and we have activists bravely “speaking truth to power” and “speaking prophetically.” Put the cross in the hands of a conservative and suddenly secularism is the better course and church and state must be rigorously separated lest theocracy loom every closer. I tried to draw...
Review: Faith Under Fire
“But here in the crowd of teenagers and twenty-somethings, the thought of death was about to e a panion.” These words end the first chapter of Roger Benimoff’s new book Faith Under Fire: An Army Chaplain’s Memoir. Benimoff with the help of Eve Conant crafts a harrowing narrative of his second and final tour as an Army Chaplain in Tal Afar, Iraq in 2005. It is a tour that results in him almost abandoning his faith, threatens his marriage, and...
President Obama Praises/Opposes Health Insurance Competition
Our latest health care video short is up: “Why Consumer-Driven Healthcare Beats Socialized Healthcare.” And John Hinderaker of Powerline has an incisive analysis of the president’s speech last night to a joint session of Congress. The passage that stood out to me was this one petition: This seems to me to be the most critical moment in Obama’s speech: My guiding principle is, and always has been, that consumers do better when there is choice petition. Unfortunately, in 34 states,...
Hope Award for Effective Compassion
While the Samaritan Award is on hiatus for 2009, be sure to check out WORLD Magazine’s Hope Award for Effective Compassion. WORLD is profiling nine finalists for the award, continuing the “Profiles in Effective Compassion” series began by highlighting Samaritan Award finalists in 2006. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved