Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
From mendicants to merchants: The monastic embrace of enterprise
From mendicants to merchants: The monastic embrace of enterprise
Jun 30, 2025 7:37 PM

“If a man does not work, neither shall he eat,” wrote the Apostle Paul in the New Testament. But what if your vocation demands that you own nothing and spend much of your time in contemplation of ethereal mysteries?

In time, even religious orders intended to live as mendicants (beggars) allowed some system of ownership. Occasionally, without any profit motive, monasteries acquired not insignificant fortunes. Some also engaged in enterprise – offering products they created on the open market.

“In the context of Christian religious orders we find this striking fact: a person pletely remove himself merce, even for the most devout religious reasons,” writes Lindsey Wilbur in a new essayforReligion & Liberty Transatlantic.

Wilbur, a former intern at the Acton Institute who works with the institute’s Rome office,Istituto Acton, traces this fascinating history from the mendicant orders (e.g., the Dominicans) to the modern day in her essay, titled “Even monks have to eat: Enterprise meets the vow of poverty.”The monks’ need for food, water, and shelter had unexpected results:

This has led to monasteries accumulating wealth and engaging merce to support themselves and (more importantly from their point of view) to fund their outreach to the poor. In his annual Acton University lecture titled“Markets and Monasticism,”Dylan Pahman provides research that demonstrates the wide variety merce – and wealth accumulation – among Eastern Orthodox monks – while tea, beer, and religious articles are just a few examples of products made for purchase by Roman munities. …

Our Sunday Visitordescribespurchasing such products as way “to partake in the fruit of monks’ and nuns’ labors.” This exchange helps all parties involved. merce, Pahman says, monasteries found that they “need the world and the world needs them, too.”

Wilbur also describes a munity, known to her, in which the superior has empowered individual members to manage money for themselves.

The results proved transformative. Upon adapting this system, one member of munity noticed that she was more efficient with her spending since she could forecast ing expenses, and that she had greater awareness of how much money she spent. … [The new system] brought with it empowerment and privacy…

“We grew as munity,” observed one member. … [M]aking decisions together connected the women on yet another personal level. Since each member had a voice, they came to value the unique voices of each other member, an expression of each person’s inalienable value and worth.These developments shed light on how respect for human dignity drives the human tendency toward liberty – and vice-versa.

Her fascinating overview and case study show that even those least motivated by greed thrive and flourish thanks to enterprise. Commerce not only supplied their earthly needs but helped advance their monastic vocation, deepening their bonds of divine charity.

You can read her full essay here.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The labeling conspiracy is expanding
It looks like Julianne Malveaux is going to have to expand plaint against the labeling of milk to a whole new spate of products, including yogurt. It may be that the whole scope of ing from the dairy industry is going to be affected. Here’s the label off a yogurt container that I ate out of last week: Malveaux is concerned that this kind of labeling, which she argues deceives the consumer into thinking that the product approximates “organic” certification,...
re: Environmental indulgences
Follow up thought, Kevin: Church indulgences had their roots in cheerful giving. Lots of cheerful “carbon giving” going on right now too; in fact, I’d call it downright prideful (which is why giving to God always had this condition on it). That cheerful giving morphed into aguilt-giving, and was ultimately mangled by the Guardians of Truth intoਊ pulsory tax on the faithful. Will we see a similar pattern emerge here? Would not be surprised. Nor would I expect such a...
T-U-R-T-L-E power
This might just be the best argument for increasing the minimum wage that I’ve heard yet: It’s just not fair that Michelle needs to go deep in hock to “feed her Ninja Turtle obsession,” is it? Well, maybe such an “obsession” leads to making poor economic decisions, but to each her own I guess. How sad. In related news, the newest TNMT movie is set for release on March 23, 2007. ...
Material goods and “The Pursuit of Happyness”
In this week’s Acton Commentary, I review Will Smith’s latest movie, The Pursuit of Happyness, which stands as an extended argument underscoring the truth of conservative values. This may sound like an improbable anomaly given the traditional political, ethical, and social allegiances of Hollywood, but the power of the story lies in its basis in fact, the real-life story of Christopher Gardner. This in turn prevents it from being appropriated as a tool for liberal political ideology. The movie’s depicts...
Environmental indulgences
Among the immediate causes of the sixteenth-century split in Western Christianity was the sale of indulgences. The theological crudity of this abuse was encapsulated in the venality of Dominican friar Johannes Tetzel, whose activities in Wittenberg riled Martin Luther. Tetzel allegedly preached “Sobald das Geld in Kasten klingt, die Seele aus dem Fegefeuer springt.” (“As soon as the coin in the box clinks, the soul out of purgatory springs.”) That slogan came to mind as I was reading Jay Nordlinger’s...
Faith and international development at Calvin College
Received an announcement today about this event to be held later this week, “Faith and International Development Conference,” at Calvin College in Grand Rapids, Mich., from February 1-3. Check out the list of sponsors at the bottom of the page, including: Bread for the WorldMicah ChallengeOffice of Social Justice and Hunger Action Just a hunch, but I wouldn’t expect a lot of market-friendly perspectives to be included. ...
The Super Bowl and Christian freedom
This is, as millions already know, Super Bowl week. Nothing is hyped all across America quite like the Super Bowl. This game has reached amazing proportions when es to the viewing audience and mercialization. It is a stunning piece of popular culture and one doesn’t know whether to weep about it or celebrate. Some pietistic folk see this as clear evidence that there is little real difference between us and the ancient Romans in the Coliseum. Others think this is...
European Union releases comic book; EU unintentional comedy production skyrockets
“We noticed that they took the umbrellas and the pens, but threw away the policy leaflets before they walked out of the door.” You don’t say? It’s the weekend; I can get away with a post like this on the weekend. Update: “If all the legislation the EU has passed were laid out lengthways it would be over 120 miles long, whilst legislation currently in force would be 31.7 miles long.” ...
Bainbridge on the Boston Scare: ‘Triumph of capitalism’
Prof. Bainbridge on the hijinks of the Boston duo responsible for the now infamous ad campaign for Adult Swim: “These guys validate my life’s work: They confirm that corporations rule the world and are therefore a worthy subject of study.” Here’s the rather incredible press conference, where almost every question is answered with, “Sorry, that’s not a hair question.” The best part is when a reporter actually gets them to address the situation, if even in a somewhat round about...
The right to a religious education
Sen. Dave Schultheis of Colorado has “proposed a ‘Public Schools Religious Bill of Rights’ bat what he calls mounting, nationwide violations of students’ and school staffs’ constitutionally protected religious freedom.” Without endorsing any particular elements of Schultheis’ bill, I have to admit that I have actually considered writing a piece on an idea like this before, a students’ bill of rights which includes the right to learn about God. It strikes me that for people who are religious, the current...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved