Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Economics and the social nature of the person
Economics and the social nature of the person
Apr 5, 2025 12:46 AM

Acton TGS

At the center of the economy are human persons.

Economics must first be a human discipline before it can be a technical one.One of the essential characteristics of the human person is that we are social beings.

While each of us is a subject and a unique and unrepeatable person, we achieve human flourishing and moral perfection in relationship with others. We cannot do this alone. We are neither radical individuals, nor are we indistinct parts of a collective. We are social beings.

We are individual substances, yet we are also in relationship with and dependent upon others right from the beginning or our existence. We are born into a family and into a society, and a culture. But we don’t exist solely for the family or the society. We are as the late Jesuit philosopher, Norris Clarke describes in his book Person and Being,substance-in-relationship”

This plex and requires thoughtful reflection. Because we like things simple, we tend to stress one side or the other. At the social extreme we see the person as merely part of a collective who exists for the good of society or the state. We can see this in ancient civilizations and modern totalitarianism. The individualist extreme is to see ourselves as radically autonomous individuals with no nature who can invent and create ourselves according to our desires. This is mon mistake today.

Neither of these does justice to the subjective and social dimensions of the person. And while the idea of radical autonomy appears to affirm individuality, the rejection of any nature or purpose creates the conditions for social engineering and ultimately totalitarianism. If the person has no nature, then whose to say that the social engineers can’t try to manipulate it as C.S. Lewis explains well in the Abolition of Man.

But the Jewish and Christian tradition gives us a more nuanced understanding of the person, and one that reflects our lived experience. We are neither radical individuals nor simple part of a collective. We are both unique subjects and we have a social nature.

We see this social nature in Genesis when after Adam names all the animals and yet is unsatisfied. God says “it is not good for man to be alone.” He then puts Adam in to a deep sleep and from his rib creates Eve. When Adam sees Eve he says “at last” and “bone of my bone, flesh of my flesh.” Man is meant to be in deep relationship with God and others. Each person is subject and flourishes in intersubjective relationships.

The individual and social nature of the person has profound consequences for how we understand the deepest human relationships and experiences from love, joy, mercy, and forgiveness to marriage, family, and all the way up to the largest political and economic questions.

Economics and the Social Nature of the Person

So how does the social nature of the person relate to the study of economics? Nineteenth-century developed the idea of the person as an autonomous individual, homo-economicus. While this can help in helping to understanding the role of incentives, utility-maximization and human action, it has its limits, as many economists will readily affirm.

Behavioral economics has shown some of the weaknesses of this method. Yet behavioral economics has its weaknesses as well. It does not have a robust enough concept of reason. While behavioral economics can correct some of the excesses of the focus on homo-economicus, they too have relied on a constricted vision of the person. .

A better starting point is the person as substance-in-relationship—an embodied person, an individual subject with a social nature. This helps us understand the relationship of man to the nature and to other people. It also highlights the social nature of markets and economic exchange. We can often think of markets as an inanimate force. This is understandable in a global economy. And even more so since we are plagued by cronyism and managerial capitalism where the economy is often rigged in favor of the rich and well connected.

Yet, markets are not simply inanimate forces. They are networks of human relationships where people get together to trade and buy and sell to meet human needs and wants.

In this short video from Acton’s The Good Society series we discuss the issues of work, creativity, and exchange and how markets are a reflection of our social nature. Man is an embodied person endowed with reason and free will and called to work. Man cooperates with nature and transforms it. An example in the series is how fruit trees require cultivation to last for years. Without cultivation fruit trees will overproduce and die within several years. Men and women also cooperate and interact with other men and women to help satisfy their needs and the needs of others. We cannot survive on our own and division of labor, trade, and markets are the primary way that we cooperate with one another to build civilization

Economics is plex and there are no simple answers to the problems that face us. There is no perfect technical solution to the problems of scarcity, human desire, poverty, and wealth. But a beginning is to think about economics within the context of our social nature

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
COVID-19 and crony capitalism
Who wins in the COVID-19 economy? In some cases, outright fraud allows businesses to prosper. In other cases, political connections enable businesses to collect revenue from the federal government. Crony capitalism is defined by the Mercatus Center as “an economic system in which the profitability of firms in a market economy depends on political connections.” Large-scale bailouts and interventions have increased cronyism during the pandemic. The more government funds that are available for individuals and businesses to capture, the larger...
What Nicholas Kristof got right
Recently, Nicholas Kristof’s published an op-ed about the Social Progress Index, a multi-year study of the quality of life in 163 countries. Kristof writes, “New data suggest that the United States is one of just a few countries worldwide that is slipping backward.” While at first reading this sounds like bad news, I think the data (and underlying science) is a bit plicated than they might appear. The SPI seeks to offer “a new way to define the success of...
When cronyism meets ‘creative destruction’
Amid rapid globalization, Americans have faced new pressures when es to economic change, leading to abundant prosperity, as well as significant pain and disruption munities. In search of a villain, populists and progressives routinely blame the expansion of free trade and rise of global conglomerates, arguing that entrenched and moneyed interests are now allowed to run rampant from country to country with petition or accountability. In search of a solution, those same critics tend to relish in nostalgia, either reminiscing...
Fratelli Tutti is a familiar mixture of dubious claims, strawmen, genuine insights
One of the first things that will strike readers of Pope Francis’s new social encyclical Fratelli Tutti is its sheer length. At about 43,000 words in English (including footnotes), that’s more than the Book of Genesis (32,046) and three times the size of the Gospel of John (15,635). Despite its length, there’s little in this text that we have not heard Francis say before in one form or another. But whether the subject is capital punishment or his theme of...
The forgotten child: Pandemic policies are leaving kids behind
The COVID-19 pandemic has claimed many victims, from the millions who have contracted the virus directly to many others who continue to endure its social and economic disruptions. The suffering has been particularly acute for the children who continue to be confined at home, whether struggling to adapt to remote-learning regimens or remaining mysteriously absent altogether. For e and minority families, in particular, the road is even more difficult. As Jonathan Chait recently put it, “The social damage will not...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: freedom and equality
“Equality” is a term that people uss a lot of nowadays – too much, some would argue. This week in Forbes, the Acton Institute’s managing director, international Alejandro Chafuen writes about equality and its relationship to freedom. Not all agree on which factors of equality are most important – equality of opportunity, e equality, equality before the law, and so on – but however we define it, freedom and equality cannot be separated. Dr. Chafuen’s analysis incorporates much from a...
Beyond civility: Ginsburg, Scalia, and friendship
The first presidential debate provided an accurate and disheartening summary of our current political climate – three men shouting over each other for 90 minutes. Opposite sides of the political spectrum cannot seem to agree on basic truths or mon ground. The majority of Trump and Biden voters say that they have few or no close friends who voted for the opposite party. A thriving society requires that we are able to debate important questions and find solutions together. What...
Everything that’s wrong with Dick Costolo’s tweet in 1,531 characters
Woke capitalism went into overdrive on Wednesday, when a former Twitter CEO seemingly endorsed the full-scale liquidation of entrepreneurs who refuse to bring politics into the workplace. Dick Costolo served as COO of Twitter before ing its CEO from 2010 to 2015. On September 30, he replied to a tweet about woke capitalism from venture capitalist Paul Graham. Graham shared a statement from the cryptocurrency exchange platform Coinbase, which vowed to “create a sense of cohesion and unity” by emphasizing...
Gavin Newsom’s gas-powered vehicle ban: the wrong approach to fight climate change
One would expect that the decades-long exodus of low- and e residents fleeing California would be cause for reflection and self-critical introspection on behalf of its effective one-party government. Skyrocketing costs of living and a cratering middle class – caused by years of anti-business regulation, powerful public sector labor union monopolies, and one of the highest tax burdens in the nation – should be ample reason for the Golden State’s progressive leadership to reassess its approach to governance. But don’t...
FAQ: What is Sukkot, the ‘Feast of Tabernacles’?
The Jewish feast of Sukkot lasts seven (or eight) days – in 2020, from sundown on Friday, October 2, to sundown on Friday, October 9. Here are the facts you need to know. When is Sukkot? Sukkot – also known as the Feast of Tabernacles, Feast of Booths, Feast of Ingathering, or simply “The Feast” – always begins on the fifteenth day of the seventh month of the Jewish calendar (Tishrei). Thus, it begins five days after Yom Kippur, the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved