Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Dreher: A virtuous resistance against totalitarianism must challenge the status quo – especially in classrooms
Dreher: A virtuous resistance against totalitarianism must challenge the status quo – especially in classrooms
Dec 15, 2025 1:04 AM

Bestselling author Rod Dreher has spent countless hours interviewing and studying what it takes to produce a free and virtuous society. The key ingredients? Creativity and courage among educators and leaders, upheld by Judeo-Christian anthropology – the eternal “basis” for our inalienable rights and liberties.

Read More…

What’s the foundation of a good education system? Creativity and courage, according to Rod Dreher, author of the bestselling book “Live Not By Lies: A Manual for Christian Dissidents.” Dreher argues it is these creative and courageous educators who will best “dare to disrupt” the Marxist domination of students’ and teachers’ freedom of speech and critical thinking.

Writing his book required Dreher to collect personal testimonies; he spent months interviewing former Soviet and Nazi dissidents who told him how they refused to bow to the collectivist totalitarian ideologies of their day. They “never gave up on their [first] principles” of faith and freedom. They flatly refused the live a life of deceit, one of “absolute lies” while heroically working to preserve the truths of the human condition for generations e.

At an August event in Rome, Dreher said many of those he interviewed ultimately found political refuge in the United States, the then-freest nation on earth. However, ironically, they now forewarn that their adoptive homeland, along with many Western republics, is teetering on the brink of “soft totalitarianism.” By this, Dreher means that former dissidents see today’s citizens as weak-willed vassals of collectivist governments. They are attracted to socialist ideals by means of clever “social justice” language with promises of “a secure future” and “equality for all.” It will be brought to them not by “Big Brother” but by a “Big Mother” nanny state. Therefore, Dreher said we are quickly moving toward the realization of a seductive Huxleyan “Brave New World” rather than Orwellian “1984” police state.

Christian resistance to totalitarianism regimes “begins with total integrity,” personally promising to “never advocate for or live any of the lies” of false ideologies. According to Dreher, we need to stop supporting journalism, media, or other platforms of “propaganda” that fail to uphold the full and consistent truths of Judeo-Christian anthropology, the eternal “basis” for our inalienable rights and liberties.

Dreher made the further point that resistance implies “serious suffering” and not always silently. He explained that human life is not demarcated by la dolce vita, but rather gains its deepest and clearest significance when we painstakingly battle to preserve what is most important to us as dignified children of God: freedom, faith, and flourishing. Suffering is Christianity’s secret “weapon”; it is the Christian modus operandi to sustain “values without which we aren’t willing live.” Indeed, Dreher said that one thing her learned from the former dissidents was that we should “fight for the right to suffer” in an age pletely warps and diminishes any gritty defence of liberty.

During his response to questions, Dreher underscored that collectivist ideologies have pletely taken over the academy, particularly in America. What’s worse, he said, is that they have now sewn roots “deep down” into primary and secondary schools. Nowadays, youth arrive at universities with ingrained belief patterns that are entirely beholden to cultural Marxism. For Dreher, the cultural Marxist vision is so entangled in the U.S. educational systems that it has e “absolutely intolerant” of any criticism or discussion to the contrary. It “demands total submission” to what is “no longer a political movement,” but rather, according to Dreher, a “secular religion.”

Dreher gave the example of a journalist whom he had met in Budapest. The young professional had attended a one-year graduate program at Harvard. When Dreher asked him how it went at “America’s top university” the plained how “fragile the American elite were,” that they were “fearful of sharing frank opinions” on serious matters of public policy, economics, and culture. He said all the Harvard professors worked to create “safe spaces” in their lecture halls where “one and only one vision could be tolerated.”

Following on his acclaimed book “The Benedict Option,” Dreher suggested the entrepreneurs try first creating their own small intellectual and munities, “doing home seminars and in other private settings” before launching any largescale institutional projects. He said that Fr. Tomislav Kolakovic (a Croatian-born Jesuit to whose memory “Live not by Lives” is dedicated) is a wonderful example about what we can today. After fleeing Croatia to Slovakia during the Nazi collaboration with Zagreb, Kolakovic created underground circles of faith and academic discussion in order to prepare Slovaks to resist an eventual munist takeover after the war. Dreher said the Jesuit priest set up a several “pockets of resistance” which resulted in a resilient network of religious and non-religious alliances to keep Western values of freedom alive. “Ultimately they triumphed in 1989, thanks in large part to this deep network.”

“We have to try and imitate this start before it’s too late, starting small and thinking long-term,” Dreher said – just like Kolacovic.

As an ideal example of such a pocket of Italian resistance, Dreher pointed to the G.K. Chesterton Scuola Libera (“free school”) in the Adriatic town of San Benedetto del Tronto “where families of concerned parents just decided to pull together” and started their pletely private school with no state subsidies. Dreher’s admiration for the Chesterton school is based on the fact that parents actively rejected a binding secular system that was destroying their children’s free intellectual and spiritual development. “They saw the problem and actually did something about it.”

Though he issues serious warnings, Dreher maintains a position of hope, believing that Western freedom might well collapse before our very own owns but “we can always place our confidence in God so that whatever does happen in the end” falls according to his plan. He said we cannot simply be optimists, thinking “things will work out just because,” but rather practice the theological virtue that allows us to trust in God’s Providence even if it’s apparent that we may not get our desired e, saying: “What I do know is that suffering has a true purpose” in the Christian life and that it is through this [painful experience] that I know I am surely on the right path” of ultimate justice and personal redemption.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Buying Our Way Out of Crime Will Not Work
Americans continue to be fed the false narrative that poverty causes crime rates to rise. While it is true that not having material needs met makes people vulnerable to do things like steal—even the Bible teaches that (Proverbs 30:8-9)—the ongoing reduction of morality and materiality is doing nothing but setting the stage for the failure of well-intended programs because we are missing core moral issues. One such idea is a New Haven, Connecticut plan to reduce crime rates by giving...
Why Christians Should Care About Government Waste
If I grill a Porterhouse steak for dinner, eat half and then throw away the other half, I’m being wasteful but not necessarily immoral. But if I grill a steak and then, instead of eating it, throw it all in the garbage disposal, my wastefulness is morally problematic. God didn’t create cows or ranchers so I could toss steaks in the trash. A similar distinction can be made when es to government waste. Almost all areas of government contain inefficiencies...
Farm Loans and the ‘Floodgates to Fraud’
“Anytime you are going to throw money up in the air,” says Abraham Carpenter Jr., a farmer in Grady, Arkansas, “you are going to have people acting crazy.” Although “throwing money up in the air” is increasingly one of the main functions of the federal government, Mr. Carpenter is referring to a specific case in which the Agriculture Department “opened the floodgates to fraud.” pensation effort sprang from a desire to redress what the government and a federal judge agreed...
London’s Financial Leaders Challenged, Inspired at Acton Seminar
Last April 16, Acton’s Rome office co-sponsored a seminar in Londonon “The Morality of Work, Commerce and Finance: Lessons from Catholic Social Teaching” with St. Mary Moorfields, the only Roman Catholic parish in the Square Mile and located in the very heart of London’s investment banking district. With several astute financiers, bankers, and business executives in attendance, the seminar’s expert speakers helped them articulate and ponder the moral and vocational aspects of the financial world in which they work. The...
‘I’m not a bum, I’m a human being’
Ronald Davis is homeless and living on the streets of Chicago. In this video clip he shares how he feels about the way other people treat him. “No matter what people think about me, I know I’m a human first.” When we see people like Mr. Davis on the streets our first tendency is often to wonder how he got into this situation or what, if anything, can be done to help him out of his plight. But Davis shows...
‘Motherhood Is Not a Job. It is a Joy’
In a recent piece for the Washington Post, Elsa Walsh offers some healthy reflections on motherhood and career, hitting at some of the key themes I pointed to in my recent post on family and vocation. She begins by discussing her own college-aged feminism, saying, “I wanted to be independent and self-supporting. I wanted love, but I wanted to be free.” With marriage and children, however, her views on freedom, family, and success would eventually e to question many of...
Neuhaus’ Law and Religious Liberty
Emperor Theodosius Forbidden by St Ambrose To Enter Milan Cathedral (Anthony van Dyck, 1620) In the latest issue of Renewing Minds, a journal of Christian thought published by Union University, I examine two different visions of religious liberty. They are roughly analogous to the two versions of the “empty shrines” of secularism described by Michael Novak and George Weigel, respectively, as well as to the visions of the American and the French Revolution. One has to do with the freedom...
Why Does Congress Want to Exempt Themselves From Obamacare?
In 2010, FactCheck.org, a project of the Annenberg Public Policy Center, attempted to debunk a rumor that the pending Obamacare legislation exempted members of Congress and their staffs from its provisions. They snarkily replied, “No. This twisted claim is based on misrepresentations of the House and Senate bills, neither of which exempts lawmakers.” Members of Congress are subject to the legislation’s mandate to have insurance, and the plans available to them must meet the same minimum benefit standards that other...
Is Higher Education a Sinking Ship?
A recent CNBC article by Mark Koba notes the bleak outlook for 2013 college grads looking for work: A survey released last week from the National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE) reported that businesses plan to hire only 2.1 percent more college graduates from the class of 2013 than they did from the class of 2012. That’s way down from an earlier NACE projection of a 13 percent hiring rate for 2013 grads. There is good reason for this...
Virtue Matters More Than Money
There is such powerful interest in sports being a way out of poverty for many e males, especially black males, that we tend to forget about other things, like wisdom, that contribute to success. For many young men and women sports has given them and their families amazing new opportunities to quickly go from subsistence to wealth. However, for many athletes the lessons of stewardship, which are first modeled in the home, were never properly cultivated, resulting in them losing...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved