Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Don’t write off young ‘socialists’
Don’t write off young ‘socialists’
Mar 15, 2025 9:55 PM

In his State of the Union address this year, president Trump warned of the dangers of socialism. But is there any substance to that worry?

Rep. Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), a self-declared socialist, has made headlines with her Green New Deal proposal. And more recently, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), who identifies as a democratic socialist, announced he will again be running for the democratic nomination for president.

So perhaps we shouldn’t write off the president’s rhetoric as just a call back to a Cold War trope. Actual socialists are growing in popularity in the US and even winning elections. Sanders is one of the front runners for the democratic nomination in early polls, second only to former vice president Joseph Biden, who has yet to officially declare his candidacy.

But what is socialism?

I know the technical answer to that question. I could ment on varying historical and present-day expressions of it and different degrees mitment to an mand-economy system, labor unions, the dialectic of a class war, and so on. That may not match well with what most supporters of socialism in the US think it is today, however.

As Geoffrey Skelley wrote recently for FiveThirtyEight,

Unlike in the 1940s, Americans today are more likely to identify socialism with “equality” than with “government ownership or control,” according to polling by Gallup.

Thus, while public opinion has softened toward socialism, the public’s perception of what socialism is has shifted. No longer a specific economic system, it has been reduced to an aspiration for certain economic (and other) es, at least for some.

While Sanders seems to be an old-school socialist himself, we can see this more aspirational socialism in the Green New Deal. It is more an ideological litmus test mitment to certain economic and environmental es than anything one could call a policy — not to mention concrete legislation — that would realistically achieve those es.

Now, one could rightly point out that in order to achieve those es, a socialist system may be necessary, even presumed.On the other hand, we can also see this aspirational socialism in popular admiration of the Nordic states, which, whatever one thinks of them, aren’t very socialist today, not in any technical sense anyway. So the shift in focus is notable, and it leads to potential munications. As Alejandro Chafuen put it in Forbes, “Advocates from both sides speak past each other.”

This terminological shift moves the discussion from the mechanics of economic policy to the moral motives used to justify them. Thus, for many to say that they support socialism may mean less that they want the US to be the next Venezuela and more that they simply want more fairness and equality. They perceive our current market economy, to put it in Sanders’ terms, as “rigged” in favor of mega-corporations, millionaires and billionaires, at the expense of small businesses, the poor and the middle class.

The senator’s talk about our economy being “rigged” resonates with the more aspirational conception of socialism, and it isn’t without some truth, depending on the market. As I wrote in my book Foundations of a Free & Virtuous Society,

Even in some of the freest economies there is inequality generated not through the creation of wealth [which I think is fine] but through restricting markets to favor parties with political connections….

Unfortunately, Sanders’ and other socialists’ proposed solutions — when they are concrete at all — tend to boil down to more market restrictions. Such restrictions will just end up favoring those with the resources to navigate the Kafka-esque legal and bureaucratic web such restrictions typically require. You know, like mega-corporations, millionaires and billionaires. They may be different ones than those who currently benefit from where cronyist over-regulation has rigged certain markets, but they won’t be small businesses, not the middle class or the poor. That you can count on. They often can’t afford the legal teams pliance costs new taxes and regulations require. And new barriers to market entry would likely mean greater economic inequality, not less. It would certainly mean less fairness. It jeopardizes the rule of law.

In effect, I think today’s socialism-as-aspiration won’t be satisfied, in the long run, with yesterday’s socialism-as-system — or various watered-down versions thereof. But unless one can get beyond writing people off for the labels they pin on their aspirations, I don’t see how one can ever hope to gain a hearing among them.

Similarly, calls for “free” healthcare, child care, or higher education may be impractical, but critiquing the mechanics of such proposals is not enough. There is nothing wrong with aspirations for more affordable healthcare, child care, or higher education in themselves, is there? Those aspirations and others need to be met with positive, workable alternatives, rather than simply dismissed.

A free and virtuous economy may best serve the moral aspirations of the young “socialists” of today. But writing off such socialists without substantial engagement with what socialism actually means to them is only an invitation to be ignored.

Image attribution: GreenNewDeal_Presser_020719

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Dutch Resistance Member Diet Eman Meets King and Queen of the Netherlands
King Willem-Alexander and Queen Maxima of the Netherlands visited Frederik Meijer Gardens and the Medical Mile in Grand Rapids on June 2, marking the third time in history that Dutch royalty stepped foot in Michigan. The occasion, which served as an opportunity for Michigan and the Netherlands to express gratitude for their strong economic ties and trade relations, and to continue this cooperation, also proved special in another way. As part of the day’s festivities, the King and Queen were...
Rev. Sirico: Environmental Encyclical May Fall Prey To Politics
Speaking on The Steve Malzberg Show on Newsmax TV on Friday, Rev. Robert Sirico addressed questions regarding the new papal encyclical, Laudato Si’, which reportedly will be released this week. mented on Pope Francis’ tendency to speak “off the cuff,” saying this may be exploited by the press or others who simply want to push their own agenda regarding the environment and climate change. Sirico also expressed trepidation regarding the pontiff’s plan to address a joint session of Congress during...
Michigan Lawmakers Approve Legislation Allowing Adoption Refusals on Religious Grounds
Every year about 400,000 children spend time in our nation’s foster care system, with roughly 100,000 eligible for adoption. Yet despite this urgent need for parents, note Sarah Torre and Ryan T. Anderson, “various states have adopted policies that would require faith-based providers to place children with same-sex couples, in violation of some agencies’ deeply held beliefs that children deserve a mom and a dad—effectively forcing these agencies out of adoption and foster care service.” In a refreshing change from...
Dory Rowing in the Canyon: Where Work and Wonder Meet
One day, while riding down the Colorado River, Amber Shannon suddenly realized her vocation. “I really wanted to row little wooden boats down big rapids with big canyon walls,” she says. “That was the life dream.” Although it may sound impractical to some, tour guide John Shocklee calls being a boatman in the Grand Canyon “the most coveted job in the world.” “It’s definitely easier to get a PhD than it is to get a dory here in the Grand...
Corporate God-Flies Fail Miserably on 2015 Proxy Resolutions
The Manhattan Institute’s latest Proxy Monitor hit laptops this week, revealing the nature and source of the 2015 proxy resolutions. It seems the corporate “God-flies” at religious shareholder organizations such as As You Sow and the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility account for 29 percent of all shareholder resolutions submitted to the nation’s top 250 publically panies. This percentage is second only to the corporate gadflies – identified by the report’s author, James R. Copland, as “individuals and their family...
Are We Setting Up For A Cultural Implosion?
What does it meant to be happy, and is our culture getting that all wrong? Fr. Robert Spitzer, SJ, thinks that may be the case. A prolific author and speaker, Spitzer explores what happiness means in his latest book, Finding True Happiness: Satisfying Our Restless Hearts. First, we seek happiness in external material possessions. This can range from acquiring that sought-after gadget or enjoying a fabulous meal. There’s nothing wrong with this type of happiness, but it’s fleeting. The second...
Crank Up The Air Conditioning: It’s Good For The Economy
If you are of a “certain age,” you grew up without air conditioning. As unthinkable as it is now, we made due with window screens and fans. And we survived. Honestly, it was pretty miserable sometimes. Especially if your dad happened to have a vinyl recliner that you sat on during hot, humid August days watching Brady Bunch re-runs. Peeling yourself off one of those is an experience that will scar you forever. Air conditioning is more than just a...
Court to U.S. Army: You Allow Vampire Mickey Mouse Tattoos, Why Not a Turban?
If the Army can make an exception to its regulations for a vampire Mickey Mouse tattoo, why can it not do the same for a turban? That was part of a federal court’s thinking in a ruling ordering the Army to allow a Sikh college student to join his college’s NROTC unit without having to shave his beard, cut his hair, or remove his turban. Iknoor Singh, a junior at Hofstra University and an observant Sikh, has “long dreamed of...
Why Family Is Central To A Healthy Society
In this short video, Allan Carlson of the Howard Center for Family, Religion & Society describes the importance and centrality of the family to a health society. Families that work together in some endeavor tend to be healthier, are able to care for themselves and thus e the foundation of a sound economy and society. ...
Explainer: What You Should Know About the OPM Hack
What is the “OPM hack”? The “OPM hack” refers to a massive data breach in which hackers, believed to be based in China, acquired personnel records of federal employees from the Office of Personnel Management (OPM). What is the OPM? The OPM (Office of Personnel Management) serves as the human resource department for the federal government. Among other duties the agency conducts background investigations for prospective employees, issues security clearances, piles records of all federal government employees. How many records...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved