Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Donald Miller’s Lopsided Theology of Work
Donald Miller’s Lopsided Theology of Work
Dec 4, 2025 1:57 AM

When es to theology of work, the church has enjoyed a healthy season of self-critique and introspection. Sermons, books, and seminars abound. Dead theologians and forgotten works are routinely remembered and resurrected, challenging a host of our modern assumptions about wealth, exchange, and the nature of work itself.

We have, as monly hears it, begun the process of tearing down the “divides” between Sunday-morning spirituality and grindstone temporality.

In line with such a development, bestselling author Donald Miller recently shared his own work experiences, which include plenty of transcendent purpose and edification. For Miller, however, such a worshipful encounter is offered as support for why he needn’t attend “traditional worship service”:

I learn by doing the very thing I don’t learn by hearing! My guess is because teaching is a kinesthetic discipline rather than an auditory discipline. But that’s a side note. Here’s the real question:How do I find intimacy with God if not through a traditional church model?

The answer came to me recently and it was a freeing revelation. I connect with God by working. I literally feel an intimacy with God when I build pany. I know it sounds crazy, but I believe God gave me my mission and my team and I feel closest to him when I’ve got my hand on the plow. It’s thrilling and I couldn’t be more grateful he’s given me an outlet through which I can both serve and connect with him…

… So, do I attend church? Not often, to be honest.

I’m glad that Miller has found room for worship in his daily work. Alas, many struggle e even this far.Yet in tearing down the artificial divides between the sacredness of church and the sacredness of work, Miller has proceeded to flatten the order of creation altogether.

He is not, I fear, alone, particularly among low-church evangelicals such as myself.For as encouraged as I am by this push to find eternal significance across all of our endeavors, Miller demonstrates the risk of going too far, of over-spiritualizing and, in turn, emoting our way to “balance” and “integration.” Without a healthy theology of the church — one grounded not just in “teaching” or “individual learning styles,” but in muning, partaking, sacrificing, and serving — our theology of work is bound to tilt toward a pseudo-spiritual humanism. Without submission to the Word — which includes, as Denny Burk thoroughly outlines, going to church — we’ll drive our bulldozers into divides and constraints that are essential for Christian discipleship.

As Derek Rishmawy concludes, in what is perhaps the prehensive critique on the matter, Christianity requires the context the church provides:

The idea that a Christian can experience healthy, Christian worship munity outside of the context of church is an American myth that Miller seems to have played right into. A healthy, functioning Church is about putting Christ on display for the world to see, not our individualism.

Such a context is no less important when es to the realm work itself. Let us remember, it is from the church that we are called and sent forth. It is through the routine munal instruction, teaching, wisdom, prayer, and fellowship among ministers, elders, and fellow believers that we are effective, earnest, and empowered in serving munities. As Lester DeKoster and Gerard Berghoef write, “Christian stewardship will be most successfully practicedwhenever and wherever the church most obediently is the church.”

We should expect to see God glorified across creation — whether in business, the arts, family, education, or a prayerful hike in the woods — and we are called to participate and respond accordingly. But let us not misplace and confuse the local church as merely an ponent— one additional topping on the chocolate sundae of Christian living.

The church is, and shall remain, the fountainhead of Christian worship, and that includes stewardship.

[product sku=”1317″]

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Lessig to Fight ‘Corruption’
Lawrence Lessig, a legal scholar and high-profile advocate of copyright reform, has decided to “shift my academic work, and soon, my activism, away from the issues that have consumed me for the last 10 years, towards a new set of issues.” His new task? “‘Corruption’ as I’ve defined it elsewhere will be the focus of my work. For at least the next 10 years, it is the problem I will try to help solve.” Just how does Lessig define “corruption”?...
More Audio from Acton University
This post will be updated and bumped as more audio es available. Newer audio appears at the bottom of the list. Economic Liberty in Catholic Social Teaching: Kishore JayabalanCompeting Visions of Business: Michael MillerSixteenth-Century Protestant Moral Theologians: Stephen GrabillCatholic Social Teaching: Basic Principles: Stephen Haessler NOTE: This is a re-post; the audio link from a previous post has been corrected.Poverty in the Developing World: Michael Miller NOTE: Due to a recording error, the end of this lecture is slightly truncated.Africa:...
Father Sirico Closes Acton University 2007
Acton University 2007 came to a close this evening with another stirring address by Rev. Robert Sirico which capped a great week in Grand Rapids for all involved. It’s getting late and I can’t hope to top what Father Robert had to say this evening, so I’ll refer all of you to the audio link below. It’s always a relief when e to the end of what is without a doubt the busiest week of the year for Acton’s Grand...
National Security and Global Warming
On today’s Diane Rehm Show, a panel of experts discussed the pending energy policy legislation in the US Congress. Karen Wayland, legislative director of the Natural Resources Defense Counsel talked about the need to join the concepts of national security and climate change when discussing energy policy (RealAudio). From her perspective, these two concerns are tied up together and shouldn’t be separated, in part because if you take energy independence and national security alone, you might think that reliance on...
Subsidies at Home, Suffering Abroad
In today’s NYT: “Oxfam Suggests Benefit in Africa if U.S. Cuts Cotton Subsidies.” “Eliminating billions of dollars in federal subsidies to American cotton growers each year would reduce American cotton production and exports, raise world prices by about 10 percent and modestly improve the es of millions of poor cotton farmers in Africa, according to a new study by Oxfam, the aid group.” About how many other industries could a similar thing be said? It’s also good to see that...
No Place Like Home
At last year’s Acton University, a few Austrian attendees made an interesting youtube video celebrating their rediscovery of the huge and obvious contributions Austria has made to free-market economics. But what about the countries that don’t have an entire school of economic thought named after them? My conversations with international participants at this year’s conference underscored two themes over and over again. First, that even the unlikeliest countries have some philosophical heritage undergirding capitalist thought. Second, that AU attracts the...
Armstrong’s Acton U Post Index
Here is an index of posts from last week’s Acton University: “What is Man?” Why the Answer Profoundly Matters (June 13)Integrity, Virtue and Vision in the World of Business (June 14)More Sights and Sounds at Acton University (June 15)Protestantism and Natural Law Theory (June 15)Economic Myths and Emergent Christian Thought (June 16) ...
Goodbye, World Bank?
As developing countries turn increasingly to private capital markets, the World Bank is facing not only a steep decline in demand for its loans but a crisis of relevancy. Sam Gregg looks at the changing market and how the rules of private lending might also provide a better check on corruption in the developing world. Adieu, World Bank? Read mentary here. ...
Green Consulting, Dogbert-style
Today’s Dilbert is a good one: “green” consulting, Dogbert-style. ...
Praying at the Pump
Do you consider gasoline to be a gift from God? You should. Andy Crouch, editorial director of the Christian Vision Project at Christianity Today, writes in a recent Books & Culture piece, “As our family sits together, eyes closed, we say grace. Today it’s Timothy’s turn. ‘God, thank you so much for all we have,’ he begins in what turns into a typically prolix nine-year-old’s prayer. Eventually he is done—’in Jesus’ name, Amen’—and I turn the key. We have just...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved