Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Does the Media Need to Be Schooled in Religion?
Does the Media Need to Be Schooled in Religion?
Jan 27, 2026 8:11 PM

Nobody can know everything about everything, but in the age of the internet, fact-checking isn’t too tough. It’s one thing for a high-school student to attempt to slide by on “facts” in a research paper for sophomore social studies, but another when professional journalists make errors about easily investigated pieces of knowledge.

Lately, the media has been getting blasted for getting the facts wrong about religion. Carl M. Cannon:

The upshot during Holy Week this year was a spate of news reports so inaccurate and off-key that prised a kind of impromptu “Gong Show.”

In the not so distant past, the installation of the first-ever pontiff from the Americas would have been hailed in the press — and not only by Catholic reporters — as a momentous breakthrough. There was some of that coverage when Argentina’s Jorge Mario Bergoglio ascended to the papacy last month. There was also this: a Huffington Post headline blasting the new pope’s opposition to gay marriage, abortion, and contraception — longtime Catholic doctrine, in other words — panied by this kicker: “Accused of Conspiring with Murderous Junta in Priest Kidnapping.”

In the new media environment, a sole source who alleges that Pope Francis was too cozy with the murderous generals who controlled Argentina in the 1970s gets equal billing with persecuted priests who were actually aided by that future pope and a Human Rights Watch report dismissing the allegation against him as untrue.

These days, even when the best news organizations attempt to cover religion insightfully and sensitively, Bible illiteracy taints the effort. On Easter, “CBS Sunday Morning” aired a deeply respectful 7½-minute segment on the Virgin Mary. But that report was marred by the erroneous declaration by the reporter that John the Baptist was present at Jesus’ crucifixion.

Easter Sunday was also flummoxing editors at the New York Times. In its coverage of Francis’ first papal address, the Times wrote the following paragraph:

Easter is the celebration of the resurrection into heaven of Jesus, three days after he was crucified, the premise for the Christian belief in an everlasting life. In urging peace, Francis called on Jesus to “change hatred into love, vengeance into forgiveness, war into peace.”

The first sentence, perhaps added by an editor in the home office, is wrong, as numerous readers pointed out. If three major theological errors in a 27-word sentence isn’t a record, it ought to be. And in its ensuing correction, the Times’ corrected only one of them, thus opening itself to ridicule.

One used to be able to say that such things were mon knowledge”, but in our increasingly-secular society, this is not true for anyone, including journalists. Only about half of Americans know that the “Golden Rule” is not one of the Ten Commandments, the name of Islam’s holy book, or what religion the Dalai Lama is identified with. That doesn’t let journalists off the hook for reporting errors; it just means that they are on track with everyone else in society.

Would hiring more people who practice a religion be the answer? Probably not; personal mitment doesn’t necessarily correlate with religious knowledge in general, meaning that even if a reporter is a practicing “anything”, it wouldn’t necessarily mean he’d be a better reporter on religious topics. What does help with religious knowledge? Reading, studying and talking about religion (stunning, isn’t it?)

The answer for journalistic integrity in reporting on religion is the same for every other topic: do your homework, check your facts, remain professional, and study the topic you’ve been assigned. Do it again. Then write your story. That way, journalists won’t be telling us that Easter is about the Ascension or that the pope is “cracking down” on American nuns. They’ll get their stories straight.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Sentimentalism in the Church: a modern epidemic
Involvement in the Christian Church should never be characterized by self-centeredness. Christianity, by definition, is a religion that emphasizes sacrifice and selflessness. However, a recent shift towards religious sentimentalism raises questions about the desire for truth in the modern-day. In his article “A Church drowning in sentimentalism”, Samuel Gregg, Acton’s Director of Research, writes about the dangerous trend toward sentimentalism in present-day Christianity. Gregg begins by introducing a term for sentimentalism: Affectus per solam, which means: “By Feelings Alone.” Affectus...
Radio Free Acton: The story of Arthur Vandenberg; Russell Kirk’s horror fiction
On this episode of Radio Free Acton, Gleaves Whitney, Director of Grand Valley State University’s Howenstein Center for Presidential Studies, talks with Hank Meijer, Co-Chairman and CEO of US supermarket chain Meijer, about the story of Arthur Vandenberg (1884-1951), a US senator from Michiganwho became one of the founders of modern US foreign policy. Then, Bruce Edward Walker speaks with Ben Lockerd, Professor of English at Grand Valley State University, about the horror fiction of Russell Kirk. Check out these...
Rev. Robert Sirico on the eternal significance of work
At Acton’s 28th Annual Dinner, Rev. Robert A. Sirico, co-founder and president of the Acton Institute, spoke about the eternal significance of work. Sirico states that serving God and participating in the market are not separate efforts. Rather, engagement in the market can lead to generosity, service, and the reduction of poverty. Work, too, should be seen as bringing more than just profit to people’s lives. “This mundane existence,” says Sirico, “whereby people earn sufficient resources to support their families,...
Reasons for optimism among Brazil’s conservative Catholics
John Stuart Mill was a prominent public intellectual of the Victorian era. A popular figure in liberal circles, Mill wrote about economics, politics, and society. One of his contemporaries in London was Karl Marx. Marx lived in London at the same time as Stuart Mill did and, according to the historian Gertrude Himmelfarb, the two intellectuals never met despite many overlaps in their works. Successive generations tried to turn Marx into a kind of prophet. Many Western intellectuals continue to...
Bolsonaro versus Brazil’s elites
In his book Sovereignty (1955), the French philosopher Bertrand de Jouvenel observed that one of the significant phenomena in the construction of the modern state was the concentration of the means munication in the hands of a few. The e was an asymmetrical distribution of power. According to De Jouvenel, the more the political power was concentrated in the bureaucracy’s hands, the more inaccessible became the means munication for ordinary people. In this way, much of the media became part...
Video: Margarita Mooney, how socialism warps the human heart
Of all the speeches at the Acton Institute’s 2018 annual dinner, perhaps the one bined the greatest emotional impact and intellectual heft into the fewest minutes came from Margarita Mooney. The associate professor at Princeton Seminary, Acton University alumna, and decades-long visitor munist Cuba gave the invocation after a five-minute-long discussion about how socialism crushes the human spirit, violates personal dignity, and reduces people to selling themselves in prostitution for survival when all other businesses are prohibited. Mooney recounts the...
5 facts about Reformation Day
While most people know today as Halloween, for millions of Christians October 31, 2018 is also the 501st anniversary of Reformation Day. Here are five facts about the Protestant holiday: 1. Reformation Day celebrates Martin Luther’s nailing his ninety-five theses to the church door Wittenberg, Germany on October 31, 1517. (Some scholars debate whether he posted them to the door then, later in November, or whether he even posted them at all.) By posting them to the church door—which was...
In the wake of socialism, Venezuela’s black-market capitalists meet community needs
The Venezuelan people continue to struggle and sufferunder the weight of severe socialist policies—facing increased poverty and hunger, swelling suicide rates, and widespread social unrest. Yet even as its president admits to anationwide economic emergency, the government continues to celebrate the very drivers behind the collapse,blaminglow oil prices and “global capitalism,” instead. Meanwhile, amid the turmoil and desperation, Venezuela’s localcapitalism is beginning to emerge as a solution to the woes of socialism. According to Patricia Laya at Bloomberg, the country...
This machine trades Halloween candy for Reese’s cups – and teaches us about trade
Have you ever been disappointed by the candy you received from trick-or-treating? Not a sucker for jawbreakers? Think Smarties are dumb? Do Jolly Ranchers leave you sour? You now have two options: Either one will maximize your happiness and benefit others – one of them aiding soldiers overseas. Reese’s has invented a machine that will let you exchange your unwanted Halloween haul for Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. Simply deposit your “disappointment” in the slot and receive an equivalent bulk of...
Luther’s challenge to the conscience of the West
Yesterday was Reformation Day, the 501st anniversary of Martin Luther’s issuing the 95 Theses. Luther’s95 Theses sparked the Protestant Reformation and changed Christianity forever. But the theses has also had an effect on just about every religion in the world. Joseph Loconte explains what the 95 Theses did for religious freedom and how they have contributed to the formation of the ideal of religious liberty in the West: The papal bull of 1520 municating Martin Luther from the Catholic Church...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved