Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Does the Media Need to Be Schooled in Religion?
Does the Media Need to Be Schooled in Religion?
Dec 9, 2025 1:43 PM

Nobody can know everything about everything, but in the age of the internet, fact-checking isn’t too tough. It’s one thing for a high-school student to attempt to slide by on “facts” in a research paper for sophomore social studies, but another when professional journalists make errors about easily investigated pieces of knowledge.

Lately, the media has been getting blasted for getting the facts wrong about religion. Carl M. Cannon:

The upshot during Holy Week this year was a spate of news reports so inaccurate and off-key that prised a kind of impromptu “Gong Show.”

In the not so distant past, the installation of the first-ever pontiff from the Americas would have been hailed in the press — and not only by Catholic reporters — as a momentous breakthrough. There was some of that coverage when Argentina’s Jorge Mario Bergoglio ascended to the papacy last month. There was also this: a Huffington Post headline blasting the new pope’s opposition to gay marriage, abortion, and contraception — longtime Catholic doctrine, in other words — panied by this kicker: “Accused of Conspiring with Murderous Junta in Priest Kidnapping.”

In the new media environment, a sole source who alleges that Pope Francis was too cozy with the murderous generals who controlled Argentina in the 1970s gets equal billing with persecuted priests who were actually aided by that future pope and a Human Rights Watch report dismissing the allegation against him as untrue.

These days, even when the best news organizations attempt to cover religion insightfully and sensitively, Bible illiteracy taints the effort. On Easter, “CBS Sunday Morning” aired a deeply respectful 7½-minute segment on the Virgin Mary. But that report was marred by the erroneous declaration by the reporter that John the Baptist was present at Jesus’ crucifixion.

Easter Sunday was also flummoxing editors at the New York Times. In its coverage of Francis’ first papal address, the Times wrote the following paragraph:

Easter is the celebration of the resurrection into heaven of Jesus, three days after he was crucified, the premise for the Christian belief in an everlasting life. In urging peace, Francis called on Jesus to “change hatred into love, vengeance into forgiveness, war into peace.”

The first sentence, perhaps added by an editor in the home office, is wrong, as numerous readers pointed out. If three major theological errors in a 27-word sentence isn’t a record, it ought to be. And in its ensuing correction, the Times’ corrected only one of them, thus opening itself to ridicule.

One used to be able to say that such things were mon knowledge”, but in our increasingly-secular society, this is not true for anyone, including journalists. Only about half of Americans know that the “Golden Rule” is not one of the Ten Commandments, the name of Islam’s holy book, or what religion the Dalai Lama is identified with. That doesn’t let journalists off the hook for reporting errors; it just means that they are on track with everyone else in society.

Would hiring more people who practice a religion be the answer? Probably not; personal mitment doesn’t necessarily correlate with religious knowledge in general, meaning that even if a reporter is a practicing “anything”, it wouldn’t necessarily mean he’d be a better reporter on religious topics. What does help with religious knowledge? Reading, studying and talking about religion (stunning, isn’t it?)

The answer for journalistic integrity in reporting on religion is the same for every other topic: do your homework, check your facts, remain professional, and study the topic you’ve been assigned. Do it again. Then write your story. That way, journalists won’t be telling us that Easter is about the Ascension or that the pope is “cracking down” on American nuns. They’ll get their stories straight.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
‘Freedom comes before equality’
That’s the refreshing and surprisingly accurate headline attributed by The Guardian to Pope Benedict’s address to the Catholic Bishops of England and Wales in Rome for their ad limina visit, which all bishops are required to make every five years. As my colleague Sam Gregg pointed out several years ago, this is yet another example of Benedict’s affinity with Alexis de Tocqueville. Benedict’s address is such a clear reminder of what Catholic bishops need to do to defend truth and...
Rowan Williams on Wall Street
The Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, delivered a talk on theology and economics at New York’s Trinity Church last week. The historic Wall Street church was the site of the Building an Ethical Economy: Theology and the Marketplace conference which promised to “bring together leading theologians and economists to talk about the relationship between economics and Christian belief and action.” Williams had this to say: “Inevitably at some point, you have to talk about what level of wealth generation patible...
The Professorial Struggle
Ideas have consequences. Says Paul Tillich in 1967: The anti-religious attitude of almost half of present-day mankind is rooted in this seemingly professiorial struggle between Hegel, Feuerbach, and Marx, with both of the ing from Hegel. Feuerbach turned Hegel upside down, and then Marx introduced the sociological element. The projection of the transcendent world is the projection of the disinherited in this world. This was such a powerful argument that it convinced the masses of people. It took more than...
Acton Commentary: Human Dignity, Dark Skin and Negro Dialect
Distributed today on Acton News & Commentary: Human Dignity, Dark Skin and Negro Dialect by Anthony B. Bradley Ph.D. Black History Month is a time not only to honor our past but also to survey the progress yet to be made. Why does the black underclass continue to struggle so many years after the civil-rights movement? Martin Luther King dreamt about an America where women and men are evaluated on the basis of character rather than skin color. The fight...
Will America Help the Persecuted Copts of Egypt?
Protection and justice for the Egyptian munity is an issue that is very close to my heart. That is a major reason that this week’s mentary highlights the grave difficulty of their situation. The inspiring news is that the international munity has united to peacefully magnify their outrage of the violent shooting that took place on January 6; the date Coptic Christians celebrate Christmas Eve. I’d like to point out to our Powerblog readers one especially moving video by John...
Acton Lecture Series: Does Capitalism Destroy Culture?
Topic: Does Capitalism Destroy Culture? A talk by Michael Miller. When: Thursday, February 18, 2010. 11:45 a.m. Registration; 12:00 p.m. — 1:30 p.m. Lunch & Lecture Cost: $15 Admission $5 Students (including lunch) Where: Water’s Building — 161 Ottawa Ave, Grand Rapids, MI 49503 Map it. Register online today! ...
Acton Commentary: Fracasos de la izquierda latinoamericana
My recent mentary, Latin America: After the Left, has been republished in a number of Latin American newspapers. For the benefit of our Spanish speaking friends, Acton is publishing the translation of the article that appeared today in the Paraguayan daily, ABC Color. The translation and distribution to Latin American papers was handled by Carlos Ball at . Commentary in Spanish follows: Fracasos de la izquierda latinoamericana por Samuel Gregg La izquierda confronta grandes problemas en América Latina. La reciente...
NIV Stewardship Study Bible Guided Tour
Discover God’s design for life, the environment, finances, and eternity. This NIV Stewardship Study Bible trailer provides a 30,000 foot view of the rich resources found within this study Bible. Whether you are pastor, deacon, elder, financial planner, development director, ministry leader, fundraising consultant … or simply someone interested in ing a better steward of the resources entrusted to you by God, you might want to check out this video! NIV Stewardship Study Bible Guided Tour from Brett Elder on...
Join us for the launch of Acton on Tap
Those of you within striking distance of West Michigan won’t want to miss the inaugural Acton on Tap, a casual and fun night out on Feb. 25 to discuss important and timely ideas with friends. And then there’s the beer! The topic for the evening will be “The End of Liberty” and will draw on Lord Acton’s claims about the relationship between politics and liberty. Discussion leader Jordan Ballor, associate editor of the Journal of Markets & Morality, will start...
Acton Commentary: Pope Benedict’s Defense of Authentic Equality
Distributed today on Acton News & Commentary: Pope Benedict’s Defense of Authentic Equality By Michael Miller Once again the mild-mannered but intellectually fierce Pope Benedict XVI has provoked criticism over remarks that challenge the secular establishment’s provincial understanding of the world. In his speech to the bishops of England and Wales in Rome last week, during their ad limina visit, the Pope encouraged them to fight against so-called equality legislation. He argued that such legislation limits “the freedom of munities...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved