Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Does the Generosity of Black Americans Explain the Racial Wealth Gap?
Does the Generosity of Black Americans Explain the Racial Wealth Gap?
Dec 11, 2025 2:27 AM

One of the most astounding economic statistics is the wealth gap between black and white Americans. According to a Pew Research Center analysis of government data from 2009, the total wealth (assets minus debts) of the typical black household was $5,677 while the typical white household had $113,149. Why is the median wealth of white households 20 times that of black households?

Plummeting house values were the principal cause, says Pew Research. Among white homeowners, the decline was from $115,364 in 2005 to $95,000 in 2009 and among black homeowners, it was from $76,910 in 2005 to $59,000 in 2009. The fact that only 46% of black Americans own a pared to a homeownership rate of 76% for whites likely affect the gap too.

But in a paper published last month, Princeton graduate student Rourke O’Brien suggests another reason: the generosity of black families.

O’Brien argues that middle and e black families don’t accumulate wealth as quickly because rather than investing their money, they give more of it to poor friends and relatives. Another study, cited in O’Brien’s paper, suggests that as much as 27 percent of the black-white wealth gap can be explained by the greater financial claims made on e blacks.

According to the Boston Globe, e blacks are more than twice as likely as e whites to have a poor sibling and more than four times as likely to have parents below the poverty line. O’Brien’s research finds that black families earning more than $100,000 a year are about twice as likely to have given money to friends and pared to white families.

While I certainly have no idea how to close the racial wealth gap, I think it does highlight how most economic debates miss the financial reality in America. Since the Occupy Wall Street crowd started focusing on the fact that investment bankers earn more e than bongo-playing hippies who spend their days protesting investment bankers, the economic buzz has been about e inequality.” But that misses the true e inequality gap in America. It doesn’t matter at all that the Gordon Gekkos in New York makes millions more than the gas station attendants in Portland. But it does matter when there is a significant disparity in e within families and neighborhoods.

It’s difficult to accumulate wealth when you’re helping to pay your sister’s rent and your father’s utility bill. It’s also difficult to implement a policy solution to alleviate the problem since the money is likely going to shore up people who are already supported by the government’s safety net. Aside from applauding the generosity, what can be done?

Perhaps one solution would be to offer tax deductions for verifiable support giving to poor family members. If a millionaire philanthropist can get a tax break for donating to her alma mater, why shouldn’t middle-class workers be able to deduct what they give to their real mothers?

As Proverbs says, “Whoever is generous to the poor lends to the Lord, and he will repay him for his deed.” The Lord will certainly reward the generosity of black Americans who help their friends, family, and neighbors. But since all Americans benefit from their sacrifice, we should find a way to repay them too.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A Culinary Introduction to the Devout Life
Want to be more disciplined in your spiritual life? Chow down with the saints. Taste and see that it is good. Read More… es a time when you yearn to live out your faith more deeply. This can mean different things for different believers, but it usually entails taking up a variety of personal disciplines, returning to tradition, mitting oneself to prayer and introspection. For harried souls making our way in a hectic, secularized world, an idealized spiritual life is...
Is Christianity Special?
A new book seeks to counter the trend in academia and pop literature to depict American history as a relentless trampling of human rights by an intolerant Christianity. But does the counteroffensive prove America’s essentially Christian—and liberal in the best sense—character? Read More… Mark David Hall’s Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land: How Christianity Has Advanced Freedom and Equality for All Americans defends the role of Christianity in American history against critics who either deny its influence or assert that...
This Fathers’ Day, Remember that Property Is Holy
What can a Christian socialist teach us about being a father and faithful steward of God the Father’s gifts? Plenty. Read More… The French Revolution of 1848, which began on February 22 in Paris, led to the fall of the July Monarchy in France, the founding of the Second Republic, a wave of democratic revolutions across Europe, a revival of European liberalism, and the spread of various forms of socialism. Once again, just as in 1789, the old order of...
European Union Demands Immediate Release of Jimmy Lai
Growing concerns over deteriorating human rights situation in Hong Kong, and the persecution of political dissidents, prompt EU’s call for immediate action. Read More… The European Parliament condemned the persecution of jailed newspaper publisher and pro-democracy activist Jimmy Lai, calling for his immediate and unconditional release from prison and the repeal of Hong Kong’s national security law (NSL), in a resolution passed on June 15, according to Voice of America. The resolution passed with 483 votes in favor, 9 against,...
Can Fraternities Save America?
There’s a movement afoot to abolish Greek life nationwide. But what if frats are actually great places to form virtue and character in young men and not just reboots of Animal House? Read More… Dr. Anthony Bradley is on a quest to make fraternities virtuous again. “This is the craziest thing I’ve ever done,” he tells me. “I’m essentially bailing out water on the sinking Titanic.” The problem he’s confronting is well engrained in American culture and media: a quick...
Jimmy Lai Appeals National Security Committee Decision—Again
Lai’s legal team is arguing that mittee’s decision, which directly affects his personal freedoms and the rights of Hong Kong citizens, should be subject to judicial review. Read More… Jimmy Lai, the imprisoned Hong Kong media mogul and pro-democracy activist, has lodged an appeal after his previous attempt to challenge a decision made by the National Security Committee was rejected, according to the Hong Kong Free Press. The high-profile entrepreneur and former Apple Daily publisher is seeking to overturn mittee’s...
Bridging the Church-State Divide
This sixth installment of a short history passionate conservatism explores what it meant to finally get into the White House and see policies implemented. Skepticism was not in short supply. Read More… In 2000, I didn’t realize until it was too late that my astronomically exaggerated proximity to presidential candidate George W. Bush would make me a target. For example, I had said in 1998 that women volunteers had run charitable enterprises in the 19th century, so women’s entrance into...
There Are No Alternatives to Free Market Capitalism
Exploring Catholic social teaching in relation to economics is fine, but if we’re too open-minded about seeking a new mon good” capitalism, our brains might fall out. Read More… Alexander William Salter’s new book, The Political Economy of Distributism: Property, Liberty, and the Common Good, is an odd fish. It begs questions, contains numerous chapters that consist mostly of lengthy quotations, and at times seems to contradict itself, yet in the end it affirms an essential truth that we may...
Freedom of Religion Is Inherently Good
In many parts of the world, and even among some thinkers in the United States, freedom of conscience is seen as a threat to order and decency. But free choice, especially in religion, aligns perfectly with our free wills and is necessary for true human flourishing. Read More… Growing up in Yemen, a conservative branch of Islam was ‎very popular in my household, school, and mosque. Freedom of ‎religion was a myth frowned upon. It was thought that Islam ‎is...
Spreading the Flame: The Pioneering Ministry of William Grimshaw
The 18th-century evangelical revival is believed to have saved England from a revolution akin to France’s. Among the lesser-known names who brought gospel hope to classes alienated from the church was a man whose tenacity at saving souls made almost as many enemies as friends. Read More… We have discussed so far the nature of the 18th-century evangelical revival in Britain through the eyes of the most well-known names, John and Charles Wesley and George Whitefield. From the 1740s munities...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved