Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Does the Generosity of Black Americans Explain the Racial Wealth Gap?
Does the Generosity of Black Americans Explain the Racial Wealth Gap?
Jan 16, 2025 12:34 PM

One of the most astounding economic statistics is the wealth gap between black and white Americans. According to a Pew Research Center analysis of government data from 2009, the total wealth (assets minus debts) of the typical black household was $5,677 while the typical white household had $113,149. Why is the median wealth of white households 20 times that of black households?

Plummeting house values were the principal cause, says Pew Research. Among white homeowners, the decline was from $115,364 in 2005 to $95,000 in 2009 and among black homeowners, it was from $76,910 in 2005 to $59,000 in 2009. The fact that only 46% of black Americans own a pared to a homeownership rate of 76% for whites likely affect the gap too.

But in a paper published last month, Princeton graduate student Rourke O’Brien suggests another reason: the generosity of black families.

O’Brien argues that middle and e black families don’t accumulate wealth as quickly because rather than investing their money, they give more of it to poor friends and relatives. Another study, cited in O’Brien’s paper, suggests that as much as 27 percent of the black-white wealth gap can be explained by the greater financial claims made on e blacks.

According to the Boston Globe, e blacks are more than twice as likely as e whites to have a poor sibling and more than four times as likely to have parents below the poverty line. O’Brien’s research finds that black families earning more than $100,000 a year are about twice as likely to have given money to friends and pared to white families.

While I certainly have no idea how to close the racial wealth gap, I think it does highlight how most economic debates miss the financial reality in America. Since the Occupy Wall Street crowd started focusing on the fact that investment bankers earn more e than bongo-playing hippies who spend their days protesting investment bankers, the economic buzz has been about e inequality.” But that misses the true e inequality gap in America. It doesn’t matter at all that the Gordon Gekkos in New York makes millions more than the gas station attendants in Portland. But it does matter when there is a significant disparity in e within families and neighborhoods.

It’s difficult to accumulate wealth when you’re helping to pay your sister’s rent and your father’s utility bill. It’s also difficult to implement a policy solution to alleviate the problem since the money is likely going to shore up people who are already supported by the government’s safety net. Aside from applauding the generosity, what can be done?

Perhaps one solution would be to offer tax deductions for verifiable support giving to poor family members. If a millionaire philanthropist can get a tax break for donating to her alma mater, why shouldn’t middle-class workers be able to deduct what they give to their real mothers?

As Proverbs says, “Whoever is generous to the poor lends to the Lord, and he will repay him for his deed.” The Lord will certainly reward the generosity of black Americans who help their friends, family, and neighbors. But since all Americans benefit from their sacrifice, we should find a way to repay them too.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Rev. Sirico on Research on Religion podcast
Acton Institute president and co-founder Rev. Robert Sirico’s Research on Religion podcast went live today. In it, Rev. Sirico sits down with host Tony Gill to discuss his new book, Defending the Free Market: The Moral Case for Capitalism, and a range of other topics, including the morality of capitalism, faith-based initiatives, and Austrian economics. The podcast is available to listen to or download online and regularly offers fresh perspective on relevant topics. Today’s is no exception. Check it out....
Rev. Sirico to speak at Freedom of Religion Rally in Grand Rapids, Mich.
A ‘Stand Up For Religious Freedom’ Rally, organized by a coalition of religious, non-profit, pro-life and pro-family organizations and individuals is scheduled for Friday, June 8, at Rosa Parks Circle in Grand Rapids, Mich. The Rev. Robert Sirico is a featured speaker. This public event, scheduled for 10:30 a.m. – 2:30 p.m. EST, is described as “…a peaceful protest to stand up for our religious beliefs and our 1st Amendment Freedoms guaranteed by the US Constitution.” Other speakers include former...
Being a Christian CEO Means Never Having to Fire Someone
Does being a Christian in business mean you’ll never have to fire someone? Of course not. But that’s one of the many subtexts that is detectable in the recent attention being given to this story: “CEO of Christian Publishing Firm Fires 25 Employees after Anonymous Email.” Now I don’t know any more details than what is contained in the Romenesko report, and it may well be that CEO Ryan Tate acted in an imprudent and incorrect fashion following his receipt...
Are There Rights We Can’t Give Away?
If inalienable rights are, as many people seem to believe, rights which the government cannot take away, does it follow that government can then take away rights that are alienable? As James Rogers explains, it is no less wrong for the government to take away an “alienable” right than it is for the government to take away an “inalienable” right. The difference between the two isn’t that one can be taken away while the other cannot but that an inalienable...
Sirico: The Great Lie of Socialism
Socialism, despite its deficiencies, still has its fans. “Visit the philosophy and English departments on most college campuses, and you will still find intellectuals waxing eloquent on the glories of socialist theory. Students are still encouraged to imagine that it could work,” says Fr. Robert Sirico, in Crisis Magazine. However, Pope Benedict XVI is not one taken in by the great lie of socialism: History is strewn with intellectuals who imagined that they could save the world–and created hell on...
Acton Commentary: Calvin Coolidge and the foundational truths of government
In this mentary, I take a look at Calvin Coolidge and his views on government. Coolidge is important today for many reasons. Chiefly, he’s a striking contrast to our current culture of government and the bloated state. Coolidge was sandwiched in between the progressive era and the rise of the New Dealers. And in his era of leadership, tyrannical leaders who preached the supremacy of the state rose to power abroad. Joseph Stalin and Benito Mussolini in Italy are two...
Politics and Pulpits Don’t Mix
Over at Commentary Magazine, Jonathan S. Tobin remarks on the double standards liberals have about allowing politicians to promote political positions from the pulpits of churches and synagogues: [A]llowing a religious event to e the venue for partisan politics is always asking for trouble. No one is saying, or ought to say, that synagogue buildings can’t be used for debates or forums in which politics is discussed. But there is a big difference between a Sunday morning bagel breakfast to...
Rev. Sirico talks to Human Events about ‘Defending the Free Market’
David Harsanyi of Human Events has shared a couple of videos of Rev. Robert Sirico discussing “Paul Ryan, Ayn Rand, Jane Fonda, Obamacare and the — sometimes unseen — morality of free markets.” He also touches on the core principles of his new book, Defending the Free Market: The Moral Case for a Free Economy. Part 1 Part 2 ...
On Call Check In Team
The team is growing as I write this. People from the On Call in Culture Community have taken the challenge to begin checking in with how they are being On Call in Culture on an everyday basis. You too can be a part of the encouraging and motivating exercise of checking in. By letting others know what God is doing through you and your work, you can encourage others, stay focused and be more aware of how God is working...
Crony Capitalism and Congressional Connections
“It’s helpful to look at the track record of this bipartisan idea that government is smarter and better at picking winners and losers in the marketplace,” said House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan at a recent hearing on efforts bat cronyism and promote upward mobility. “What we have learned from this bipartisan approach is that corruption does occur, cronyism does occur, and what ends up happening is those who are connected, those who have established connections, those who know the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved