Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Does pork get your goat?
Does pork get your goat?
Oct 3, 2024 5:07 AM

John Stossel, the icon of indignation, has a piece today decrying the spending habits and attitudes of our Republican-led Congress. I will let you read his article for the details, but for what it’s worth, here are some reasons why I think the disgust Stossel projects is an entirely proper and fitting response to pork barrel spending.

When a servant of the people makes his servitude a catch-all reason for indiscriminate exertions of spending power, we call this pork. And it is essentially pride that is at work here. Stossel relates a story where Sen. Byrd grows indignant at Stossel’s indignation; the story is an example of a representative of the people who thinks that the will of the people is the driving force behind every decision he makes. Pork betrays a pride in humility.

This is outrageous. For example, just as there are limitations on the infalibility of the Pope (infallibility restricted to ex cathedra pronouncements on faith and morals; not, let’s say, the best variety of cheese), there are limitations on the will of the representative. What a representative wills is not, for that reason, necessarily willed by the represented–this is precisely backwards. To think and, what’s more, to act otherwise is an insult not only to the represented, but to the integrity of the representative system.

Another reason why Stossel is correct in his anger is that the actions of porkers are often, as he notes, blatant and unapologetic. To be wronged is one thing; but when the person who wronged you makes clear his indifference to the wrong–this is something else entirely. For not only is there the injury of the wrong, there is a new injury, an injury against the very standard of right and wrong.

Perhaps an analogy will explain this idea better. While swinging a golf club, a neighbor accidentally (or not) clips a few roses off your prized rosebush. Fine. But when plain, the neighbor rips the rosebush from the ground. How, he asks, could he be wrong for nicking a few roses off a bush that isn’t there?

This is precisely, I think, what gets Stossel’s goat. It is one thing that the Congress has wasted an enormous amount of tax dollars. But it is something else entirely that it resoundingly reaffirms that decision amidst a hail of criticism and a natural disaster. It is as if they are denouncing from the very beginning the idea that they ought to be fiscally responsible.

So where does that leave Stossel and the rest of the taxpayers? How can they cry foul when the other team has sacked the referee?

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
What You Need to Know About Wilhelm Röpke
Wilhelm Röpke is one of the most important 20th century economists that almost no Americans know anything about. To really learn about the man whose influence was considered largely responsible for enabling Germany’s post-World War II economic “miracle,” you should read Samuel Gregg’s Wilhelm Ropke’s Political Economy. But if you don’t have the time (or $109.25) to spend, you can read Ralph Ancil’s introductory article at Front Porch Republic: Throughout his professional life Röpke was concerned about a socially and...
Religious Shareholder Activists: Soros Gets a Free Pass
Reading the 2013 results of proxy shareholder resolutions orchestrated by various leftist organizations affiliated with “religiously” oriented investment groups, a colorfully descriptive phrase came to mind to describe both: Whatever its derivation, useful idiots is employed as “a pejorative term for people perceived as propagandists for a cause whose goals they are not fully aware of, and who are used cynically by the leaders of the cause.” For the purposes of this post, we’ll grant groups with purported religious and...
Australian PM Tony Abbott: Private Virtue vs. Public Duty
On Saturday, Tony Abbott, a member of the Liberal-National Coalition, was elected prime minister of Australia despite being considered “too religious, too conservative and too blunt” to win a national election. Turns out, he’s an admirer of the work of Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg (Australian born). In 2001, Abbott addressed the role of government in alleviating poverty and reducing unemployment in an issue of Policy Magazine, in a special feature titled, “Against the Prodigal State.” He begins: The story...
Callings and the childfree life
I share Fr. Robert Barron’s concern about many of the attitudes on display in this Time magazine cover story on “the childfree life.” As Barron writes, much of the problem stems from the basic American attitude toward a life of “having it all.” Thus, Barron observes, “Whereas in one phase of the feminist movement, ‘having it all’ meant that a woman should be able to both pursue a career and raise a family, now it apparently means a relationship and...
Peter Greer on the ‘Spiritual Danger’ of Service and Charity
Peter Greer has spent his life doing good, from serving refugees in the Congo to leading HOPE International, a Christian-based network of microfinance institutions operating in 16 countries around the world. Yet as Greer argues in his latest book, The Spiritual Danger of Doing Good, “service and charity have a dark side.” Pointing to a study by Fuller Seminary’s Dr. J. Robert Clinton, Greer notes that “only one out of three biblical leaders maintained a dynamic faith that enabled them...
The End of Anthony Weiner’s Sad and Pathetic Lust for Political Power?
Anthony Weiner did not win the Democratic Party primary for New York City last night. Leading in the polls at one time, he ended up with 5 percent of the vote. His defiant and circus like campaign appropriately ended with more bizarre theatrics. In a scolding interview, Weiner was called out for his political power addiction recently by Lawrence O’Donnell of MSNBC. Though O’Donnell sees no need to call him out for his moral behavior and personally he doesn’t feel...
The Camel’s Hump: Rudyard Kipling on Idleness and Hard Work
The other night, I sat down with my kids to read one of my favorite Rudyard Kipling poems, “The Camel’s Hump,”a remarkable 19th-century takedown of 21st-century couch-potato culture. With typical color and wit, Kipling takes aim at idleness, decrying “the hump we get from having too little to do” — “the hump that is black and blue.”Kipling proceeds to elevate labor, noting that hard work refreshes the soul and reinvigorates the spirit: “The cure for this ill is not to...
Quebec Ponders Banning Public Employees From Wearing Overt Religious Symbols
Parti Québécois and Bernard Drainville, minister of the newly proposed charter, announced yesterday that a new plan would ban overt religious symbols to be worn by “judges, police, prosecutors, public daycare workers, teachers, school employees, hospital workers and municipal personnel.” These symbols would include large crosses or crucifixes, turbans, hijab, and kippas. Smaller jewelry (such as Star of David earrings) would be allowed. This proposal has caused uproar, both in the Quebec government and in the public. Here are a...
Commentary: Federal Student Loans as a Problem of Subsidiarity
“When loans are guaranteed by the state and detached from market forces and personal responsibility,” says Dylan Pahman in this week’s Acton Commentary, “those institutions being paid with that loan money experience inflated demand as everyone and anyone now can go and wants to go college. As a result, tuition prices have been inflated. The full text of his essay follows. Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publications here. Federal Student Loans: A Problem of...
The Federal Government Attacks Louisiana School Choice
Last week, as the country was remember MLK’s dream of children being judged on the content of their character rather than the color of their skin, Attorney General Eric Holder was suing the state of Louisiana because he’s more worried, as the Wall Street Journal says, about plexion of the schools’ student body than their manifest failure to educate. Late last week, Justice asked a federal court to stop 34 school districts in the Pelican State from handing out private-school...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved