Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Do economists agree?
Do economists agree?
Apr 24, 2026 8:33 PM

Listen to politicians or cable news, and you will get the impression that economics is merely a thin veil for partisanship, the greatest mercenary discipline for justifying any policy. You can seemingly find at least one economist to agree with you; liberal economists favor liberal policies, while conservative economists favor conservative policies. While there are certainly some economists who make their discipline mercenary to politics, there is a surprising amount of agreement within the discipline. Jay Richards makes the case in the latest installment of the Journal of Markets and Morality that economists from a broad political spectrum and economic schools of thought agree on core economic facts. He outlines 30 facts on which he found a broad consensus between economists from varying schools of thought. Here is a selection.

Economists agree that scarcity is real. Scarcity means that resources in an economy are limited, i.e., there are less resources than there are ways that people would use those resources. Additionally, individuals face opportunity costs. The concept of opportunity cost follows directly from the idea of scarcity. For a given action, the opportunity cost is whatever you cannot do because you took that action. Individuals face opportunity costs in many, many situations. For instance, what is the opportunity cost of earning a four-year college degree? First, there is the cost of tuition and room and board. Add on transportation costs of moving to a new area, and we have the total cost. But if we stop there, we are missing the opportunity cost of the action. When you attend school, you are also giving up, among other things, four years of earnings from whatever job you would have had. The opportunity cost is the all the things that you must give up to attend college. Through this insight, economists can reveal hidden costs that could go unnoticed.

Economists also agree that “a society of well-defined and enforced property rights will be better off than a society with ill-defined and poorly enforced property rights.” Well-defined property rights result in a system where individuals can plan and invest for the future. For example, if you have no idea whether you will own your house tomorrow, what incentive do you have to make improvements? Furthermore, in a society defined by violence and theft, you will have to waste considerable time and money to protect your property. Savings and investment in new ideas increases general prosperity in the future.

Economists agree that “the percentage of the world’s population living in absolute poverty is at an all-time low and is much lower today than in any decade in the past.” This may seem surprising given mentators who dub 2020 the worst year in history. In reality, economic growth has driven a global increase in prosperity. Around the globe, fewer people live in absolute poverty than ever, an achievement that should be celebrated.

While many of these facts seem basic or even intuitive, they are extremely useful, even necessary to our understanding of the world. Richards points out that the majority of Americans do not understand even the simplest economic ideas, such as scarcity. Indeed, the most fundamental contribution of economics is the ability to systematize fundamentals of human behavior and reveal an unseen phenomenon beneath the seen. The consensus of economists should be an encouragement, showing that the discipline is not merely mercenary. Instead, economics can reveal truth about the world and help us solve real problems.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Day of Discovery interviews Acton Expert about dirt
Dirt… we sweep our floors, wipe our shoes, and wash our clothes to get rid of it. But how often do we stop and reflect upon the very fact that without soil life would not be possible? This November, the popular RBC television program Day of Discovery will launch a three-part series titled “The Wonder of Creation: Soil.” Acton Institute research fellow Jay W. Richards will be featured as a guest expert in the series. It will air on Ion...
John Jay Institute, Acton Partner in Film Premiere
From Christian Newswire: COLORADO SPRINGS, Colo., Oct. 2 /Christian Newswire/ — The John Jay Institute, a para-academic leadership development center based in downtown Colorado Springs, is pleased to announce a partnership with the Acton Institute, Grand Rapids, Michigan, to premiere the historical documentary film, “The Birth of Freedom” in Colorado. The screening will take place on Wednesday, November 5th at 7pm in the SaGaJi Theatre at the Colorado Springs Fine Arts Center, 30 West Dale Street in Colorado Springs. John...
The Reductio ad Hitlerum
It looks to me like Obama has this election about wrapped up. Why? Some of his opponents are resorting to the tired and fallacious reductio ad Hitlerum (aka argumentum ad Hitlerum). Exhibit A is this video: (The original context is this video.) This stuff is just beyond the pale in so many ways. You can find all manner of other similarly odious political rhetoric at YouTube (just check out the “related videos” category). Also, in 2004 Joe Carter discussed what...
Cardinal Bertone and Metropolitan Kirill on Social Doctrine
Paola Fantini has expanded her blog post on Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone’s new work on Catholic social doctrine into a book review for the ing Religion & Liberty quarterly published by the Acton Institute. She has also translated the prologue to the book by Russian Orthodox Metropolitan Kirill. These articles are, to my knowledge, the first to translate anything from Cardinal Bertone’s “The Ethics of the Common Good in Catholic Social Doctrine” (Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2008) into English. The Italian title...
The Credit Crisis: Who Brewed the Stupid Juice?
What is the root cause of the sub-prime crisis shaking the global economy? We need to know so we don’t allow it to screw up our economy even worse. Many point to dishonesty and poor judgment on Wall Street. There was plenty of that leading up to the near-trillion dollar bailout, and even now the stock market is busily disciplining stupid, panies. Others point to the many people who falsified loan applications to get mortgages beyond their means. That too...
A ‘Nazi Think Tank’
Speaking of the Nazis, I highly mend Heiko A. Oberman’s essay, “From Luther to Hitler,” contained in the posthumously published The Two Reformations (Yale University Press, 2003). The piece is short and pointed, well worth the read, and just one of a number of excellent essays in that collection. Here’s how Oberman concludes (p. 85): I do not intend this analysis to serve the cause of exculpating the Germans who were fated to be born too early. Rather I hope...
Birth of Freedom Shorts Series: Christianity and Human Equality
In the sixth Birth of Freedom video short, William B. Allen addresses the question, “What was Christianity’s Role in the rise of the idea of human equality?” In his discussion, which traces the Judeo-Christian origins of a “universal perspective,” he concludes that “what informs the spirit of Republicanism in the modern era, is this long development, this slow working-out of a specific revelation from God that leads human beings into the discovery of the fullness of their personality in the...
Jennifer Roback Morse to speak in Grand Rapids
Mark your calendars! Jennifer Roback Morse ing to Grand Rapids to speak at Aquinas College on Wednesday, November 19 at 7:00pm. Dr. Morse will speak on the topic of her provocative new book, Smart Sex: Finding Life-Long Love in a Hook-Up World. An excerpt from the prologue: The sexual revolution has been a disappointment, but people continue to acquiesce in its assumptions because no appealing alternative seems to be on the horizon. Many Americans think the only alternatives are bination...
Richards’ debate featured in The Grand Rapids Press
Jay W. Richards, Research Fellow and Director of Acton Media, was interviewed for a story in the Grand Rapids Press on the topic of religious and nonreligious views. The article, written in light of outspoken atheist Bill Maher’s new movie, looks at differing views of people such as Christopher Hitchens and John Ortberg. Jay Richards debated Christopher Hitchens at Stanford University last January on the topic of atheism vs. theism. Throughout the debate Hitchens grew increasingly angry and by the...
Feeding the World
There’s an interesting clip on YouTube of a discussion about the world food situation between, primarily, author Michal Pollan and Monsanto CEO Hugh Grant. Pollan is a champion of the “slow food” movement, which is, to simplify, associated more generally with trends such as whole foods, farmers markets (“localvores”), organic food production, etc. (The participation of otherwise fiscal and cultural conservatives in what is often presented as a left-leaning movement is a phenomenon that gave rise to the term “crunchy...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved