Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Died: Patricia Gundry, Evangelical Feminist Who Wanted Women to Be Free
Died: Patricia Gundry, Evangelical Feminist Who Wanted Women to Be Free
Oct 1, 2024 10:33 PM

  Patricia Gundry, an evangelical author who taught that God was the first feminist, died on July 31 at age 90.

  She was part of a movement of womenincluding Virginia Ramey Mollenkott, Letha Scanzoni, and Nancy Hardestywho reevaluated Christian teachings on gender and hierarchy in light of Scripture.

  With an evangelical commitment to rejecting tradition unless it could be backed up by the ultimate authority of the Bible, they came to believe the church had been wrong about women. The limitations and strictures placed on women were cultural, they said, and the hierarchy supposedly found in creation order was not part of Gods good plan but a result of sin entering the world.

  The evangelical feminists argued that people who loved Jesus should follow him in his proclamation to the woman crippled by a spirit in Luke 13, declaring, Woman, you are set free.

  Gundry adapted Jesus phrase for the title of her first book, Woman Be Free! It was published by Zondervan in 1977 and sold about 9,000 copies in two yearsa moderate success, but with a significant impact.

  Complementarian theologians John Piper and Wayne Grudem identified Gundrys book as one of the new interpretations of the Bible that had provoked a great uncertainty among evangelicals, leaving many men and women not sure what their roles should be. They coined the new term complementarianism and developed a theology of gender roles in response.

  Many regular readers of Woman Be Free! said they werent thrown into uncertainty, though. To them, the book was validating.

  I felt seen, one woman in Ohio wrote on Goodreads after finishing Woman Be Free! in a single day. Knowing youre not alone, youre not crazy, and youre not defective is a great feeling.

  In 1996, Christianity Today called Woman Be Free! one of the books with the greatest influence on American evangelicals since World War II.

  In it, Gundry urged women to read the Bible for themselves. She said they should start at the beginning, remember to interpret each passage in light of the whole, and always keep an eye on the larger story of sin and redemption.

  There is no indication of a subordination of woman in the beginning. No indication of mans position of authority appears until after the Fall, Gundry wrote. Instead of looking to the Fall for our example, lets look to Christ and His dealings with men and women. He dealt with them as equals whom He cared about intensely and impartially.

  Gundrys trust in Christ and reliance on Scripture started in childhood. She was born Patricia Lee Smith in Boone County, Arkansas. Her parents, Leonard and Frances Smith, bounced back and forth between farming in the Ozarks and working in the aircraft industry in Southern California. The Smiths were Southern Baptist and raised Patricia and her brother Daniel in church and Sunday school wherever they lived.

  Gundry later recalled two born-again experiences. At age six, at some sort of after school thing for children in a womans home in the Los Angeles area, she heard about Jesus standing at the door of her heart and knocking. She invited him in. Then, at 13, at a rural church in central California, she went forward at the end of a hell fire and brimstone sermon. She was pretty sure she was already converted, she said, but wanted to make sure it was clear.

  She was baptizedand that also happened twice.

  Just as I was catching my breath, the pastor dipped me under again, Gundry said. He explained that hed not immersed some part of me completely, and he knew there would be objections if he didnt do it again. I dont know what kind of Baptist that makes me, maybe a DuoBaptist.

  As a girl, Gundry bought her own Bible at a dime store and read it continuously. She became a whiz at trivia, memorizing the names of Jobs three daughters and the lineage of Esthers persecutor. At the same time, she developed a deep trust of Scripture, calling the Bible the most important book I own.

  She enrolled at Los Angeles Baptist College (now The Masters University) in 1957. She was 23. She met Stan Gundry, a young man four years her junior who was preparing for ministry and thinking about going to grad school to study the Bible, and they got married two years later.

  Stan Gundry told CT the wedding happened as soon as he turned 21 and didnt need his fathers permission for a marriage license.

  He didnt approve, Stan Gundry said. He thought she was pursuing me when, truth was, I was pursuing her. She was the most amazing woman I ever met.

  Stan Gundry admired the way his wife was fearless and so committed to getting answers from Scripture, she wouldnt let church leaders dismiss her questions. As he became a pastor and took a ministry job at a church in Everson, Washington, about 100 miles north of Seattle, she began to have a lot of questions.

  She asked her husband:

  If women are not to be the leaders and teachers of men, how does one account for Deborah, Huldah, Philips daughters, and Priscillas role in the instruction of Apollos? Why is it that Paul instructs women to be silent in one place and acknowledges with apparent approval that women publicly pray and prophesy in another? Doesnt the prominence of women among the followers of Jesus and in Pauls Epistles suggest something significantly more than women leading and teaching children and other women? How is it that in the church the benefits of Galatians 3:2628 apply equally and in very tangible ways to men, Jews, Gentiles, slaves, and those who are free, but not to women? If a woman is to obey her husband, is she not responsible directly to God for her actions? Is he in effect a priest, an intermediary between her and God? Stan Gundry didnt know.

  In 1964, Gundry tried to ask a visiting preacher. They had him to lunch at their house after church and she brought up 1 Timothy 2:12, where Paul says that women cannot teach men, and Acts 18:26, where a woman named Priscilla is described teaching a man the way of God more adequately. What did he make of that?

  The preacher snapped at her: Why do you want to know?

  He was sitting at my table, eating my spaghetti, and being obviously rude to me about a simple conversational question, Gundry later said. Thats when the light bulb moment came to me. I thought, He doesnt know. None of them know.But they are willing to limit all womens lives and participation on the basis of Bible passages they know are problematic and they dont know how to interpret.

  Gundry started researching the questions herself.

  She went back to the Bible, reading the Scripture passages again. And when her husband went to graduate school at Union College in Vancouver, British Columbia, and then the Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago, she made use of his access to academic libraries to discover forgotten generations of evangelical feminists. She read Gods Word to Women by Katharine Bushnell and The Bible Status of Woman by Lee Anna Starr.

  Gundry went back and forth with Stan Gundry about what she was learning and occasionally asked him to research a biblical text for her in the original Greek or Hebrew. She started writing Woman Be Free! in 1974. The first person persuaded by her arguments for evangelical feminism was her husband.

  The Fall turned everything topsy-turvy, Stan Gundry later wrote. After the Fall, the relationship between man and woman is quite different than it was before the Fall. It morphed from one of equality and complementarity to one of male domination and patriarchy, and that is the backdrop to all that follows in the Bible. In Christ right relationships are restored and in him there is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female (Gal. 3:28).

  When Stan Gundry graduated from seminary, he took a job teaching theology at Moody Bible Institute. Before Woman Be Free! came out, he spoke to the dean about the arguments of the book and said he agreed with them. He was assured, he later said, that this wouldnt be a problem.

  At first, it wasnt. Woman Be Free! received no significant backlash when it was published in 1977.

  The people who liked it told me so, Patricia Gundry said. The people who didnt like it just plain ignored it, pretended it wasnt there, the way they pretended feminists arent there.

  Then in 79, Gundry spoke at a meeting organized by Housewives for the Equal Rights Amendment in Glen Ellyn, Illinois. She wasnt asked to address the constitutional amendment itself but spoke on her research about what the Bible said about womens equality.

  The reason we have the situation we have now in the church is historical and theological. It is not because of what the Bible says, Gundry said. God was the first feminist because he created women as fully equal. Theres nothing wrong with us. Its only our interpretation of the Bible thats lopsided.

  A group of conservatives opposed to the amendment started a letter-writing campaign. Moody received around 80 letters, according to reporting at the time, and the issue of whether people who believe in womens equality could teach at Moody went to the trustees. The school decided the answer was no. Stan Gundry was told that if he resigned, he could receive a severance.

  Stan Gundry couldnt find a job teaching at a Christian college after that and had to change careers, going to work as an editor for Zondervan. He told CT he didnt regret it, though.

  I wore it as a badge of honor, Stan Gundry said. It was the right thing to do and I stood by her.

  Also, it wasnt all bad. Free from Moodys strict lifestyle rules, he told the Chicago Tribune at the time, Stan Gundry was finally able to go and see Star Wars.

  Patricia Gundry went on to write three more books about the biblical view of women: Heirs Together, published in 1980; The Complete Woman, in 1981; and Neither Slave nor Free, in 1987. She also wrote and edited The Zondervan Family Cookbook, which came out in 1988.

  When she wasnt researching and writing, Gundry raised four children, played music, taught art, and grew a garden that earned her the nickname the flower lady among local school children.

  Later in life, Gundry developed an interest in self-publishing, started a number of blogs, and maintained several active email Listservs, including one for evangelical feminists called PHOEBE-L, named for the woman Paul entrusted to deliver the letter to the Romans.

  To those who say women cannot fill positions of leadership, the Bible says women did, Gundry wrote. Remember who you are. You are a child of God. He is your director. You need no pope, bishop, synod, or council to tell you what you may believe or how you may serve Him.

  Gundry is survived by her husband Stan and their children, Ann Gundry Teliczan, Daniel, David, and Jonathan.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Up from the Liberal Founding
During the 20th century, scholars of the American founding generally believed that it was liberal. Specifically, they saw the founding as rooted in the political thought of 17th-century English philosopher John Locke. In addition, they saw Locke as a primarily secular thinker, one who sought to isolate the role of religion from political considerations except when necessary to prop up the various assumptions he made for natural rights. These included a divine creator responsible for a rational world for...
Adam Smith and the Poor
Adam Smith did not seem to think that riches were requisite to happiness: “the beggar, who suns himself by the side of the highway, possesses that security which kings are fighting for” (The Theory of Moral Sentiments). But he did not mend beggary. The beggar here is not any beggar, but Diogenes the Cynic, who asked of Alexander the Great only to step back so as not to cast a shadow upon Diogenes as he reclined alongside the highway....
How Dispensationalism Got Left Behind
Whether we like it or not, Americans, in one way or another, have all been indelibly shaped by dispensationalism. Such is the subtext of Daniel Hummel’s provocative telling of the rise and fall of dispensationalism in America. In a little less than 350 pages, Hummel traces how a relatively insignificant Irishman from the Plymouth Brethren, John Nelson Darby, prompted the proliferation of dispensational theology, especially its eschatology, or theology of the end times, among our ecclesiastical, cultural, and political...
C.S. Lewis and the Apocalypse of Gender
From very nearly the beginning, Christianity has wrestled with the question of the body. Heretics from gnostics to docetists devalued physical reality and the body, while orthodox Christianity insisted that the physical world offers us true signs pointing to God. This quarrel persists today, and one form it takes is the general confusion among Christians and non-Christians alike about gender. Is gender an abstracted idea? Is it reducible to biological characteristics? Is it a set of behaviors determined by...
Conversation Starters with … Anne Bradley
Anne Bradley is an Acton affiliate scholar, the vice president of academic affairs at The Fund for American Studies, and professor of economics at The Institute of World Politics. There’s much talk about mon good capitalism” these days, especially from the New Right. Is this long overdue, that a hyper-individualism be beaten back, or is it merely cover for increasing state control of the economy? Let me begin by saying that I hate “capitalism with adjectives” in general. This...
Spurgeon and the Poverty-Fighting Church
Religion & Liberty: Volume 33, Number 4 Spurgeon and the Poverty-Fighting Church by Christopher Parr • October 30, 2023 Portrait of Charles Spurgeon by Alexander Melville (1885) Charles Spurgeon was a young, zealous 15-year-old boy when he came to faith in Christ. A letter to his mother at the time captures the enthusiasm of his newfound Christian faith: “Oh, how I wish that I could do something for Christ.” God granted that wish, as Spurgeon would e “the prince of...
Creating an Economy of Inclusion
The poor have been the main subject of concern in the whole tradition of Catholic Social Teaching. The Catholic Church talks often about a “preferential option for the poor.” In recent years, many of the Church’s social teaching documents have been particularly focused on the needs of the poorest people in the world’s poorest countries. The first major analysis of this topic could be said to have been in the papal encyclical Populorum Progressio, published in 1967 by Pope...
Mistaken About Poverty
Perhaps it is because America is the land of liberty and opportunity that debates about poverty are especially intense in the United States. Americans and would-be Americans have long been told that if they work hard enough and persevere they can achieve their dreams. For many people, the mere existence of poverty—absolute or relative—raises doubts about that promise and the American experiment more generally. Is it true that America suffers more poverty than any other advanced democracy in the...
Lord Jonathan Sacks: The West’s Rabbi
In October 1798, the president of the United States wrote to officers of the Massachusetts militia, acknowledging a limitation of federal rule. “We have no government,” John Adams wrote, “armed with power capable of contending with human passions unbridled by morality and religion. Avarice, ambition, and revenge or gallantry, would break the strongest cords of our Constitution as a whale goes through a net.” The nation that Adams had helped to found would require the parts of the body...
Jesus and Class Warfare
Plenty of Marxists have turned to the New Testament and the origins of Christianity. Memorable examples include the works of F.D. Maurice and Zhu Weizhi’s Jesus the Proletarian. After criticizing how so many translations of the New Testament soften Jesus’ teachings regarding material possessions, greed, and wealth, Orthodox theologian David Bentley Hart has gone so far to ask, “Are Christians supposed to be Communists?” In the Huffington Post, Dan Arel has even claimed that “Jesus was clearly a Marxist,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved