Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Daniel Hannan addresses Greta Thunberg’s ‘Manichaean’ views
Daniel Hannan addresses Greta Thunberg’s ‘Manichaean’ views
Oct 6, 2024 4:20 AM

The sight of teenage Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg setting sail today for the United States has dominated global headlines. The 16-year-old, who is taking a year off school to demand a radical reorganization of the global economy, plans to attend the UN’s climate action summit in New York on September 23.

As she prepared for the two-week cruise, she warned ominously, “There are climate delayers who want to do everything to shift the focus from the climate crisis to something else, or want to make people question the science.”

But Daniel Hannan, who will be the final Member of European Parliament for South East England, says this view polarizes dialogue and blinds people to the harm caused by their fellow partisans.

“Isn’t it a fairly odd thing to assume that your opponents, however nasty they are, don’t at least want their own children to be able to inherit the planet?” Hannan asks in an online video about Thunberg’s school-strike movement.

“I suppose in fairness a lot of us have this rather Manichaean view of [heroes and villains] when we’re teenagers,” Hannan says. “Most of us grow out of that stage.”

(You can learn more about Manichaeanism, the heresy that captivated the young St. Augustine of Hippo, here.)

Bifurcating the world into two, hermetically sealed movements of light and darkness instills a herd mentality that ignores the root of much environmental damage: economic collectivism.

Hannan notes that many of the economic interventionists championing Thunberg had opposed removing subsidies to UK coal mines and railed against the U.S. fracking industry, which has reduced CO2 emissions by 30 percent in Pennsylvania alone.

European leaders, bowing to overzealous calls to save the planet through government policy, decided to financially punish drivers who used gasoline and incentivize the adoption of diesel fuel. Now that diesel has been shown to cause environmental damage that is worse in some ways, the technocratic elite blithely move on, counseling the government to economically suppress diesel and subsidize other technologies.

This whiplash-inducing about-face (by those who can afford to buy new expensive new cars every few years) provoked popular opposition in the form of France’s yellow vest (gilet jaunes) movement which this weekend, though reduced in numbers, entered its 39th week.

Rather than address environmental extremists’ record of failed alarmist predictions and counterproductive policies, today’s methane Manichaeanism simply orders people to find their tribe and obey their leaders.

Watch the videobelow, and see why Hannan says “a core of people on the self-righteous Left have retained their Harry Potter view of politics into adulthood.”

Parliament. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A world of economic miracles: The power of human cooperation
Surrounded by economic abundance, it can be easy to be distracted by what we see—products, tools, technology, resources—and assume our newfound prosperity stems from material causes. In turn, given the stability of many institutions and the increasing pace of innovation, continuous economic progress now seems somewhat inevitable. Economists like Deirdre McCloskey have challenged such notions, pointing instead to the power of rhetoric, virtues, and ideas to shape all else. It takes a special something to cultivate a society wherein basic...
How San Fransisco’s housing policy makes it harder for the homeless
I recently highlighted California’s counterproductive restrictionson private efforts to feed the homeless. But the state’s policies aren’t just inhibiting the bottom-up activities of non-profits and charities. They’re also restricting potential solutions via entrepreneurial investment. Alas, many municipalities have severely restricted new residential development, causing the housing supply to diminish and the cost of living to soar. In a city like San Francisco, such an approach has led to the highest rents in the world and a housing market wherein 81%...
The libertine road to serfdom
The Sexual State: How Elite Ideologies Are Destroying Lives and Why The Church Was Right All Along. Jennifer Roback Morse, Ph.D. TAN Books, 2018. 406 pages. Reviewed by Rev. Ben Johnson Keen-eyed analysts have probed every ideological trend threatening liberty – from socialism and fascism to the Alt-Right – with one glaring exception: the revolt against personal responsibility. Jennifer Roback Morse, the founder of the Ruth Institute,capably fills this void in The Sexual State. Building on her previous book Love...
Venezuelan Cardinal stands down Maduro’s Vatican mediation request
The Venezuelan bishop of Merida and current apostolic administrator of Caracas, Cardinal Baltazar Porras Cardozo, stood tall and firm while rejecting the validity of President Nicolas Maduro’s recent appeal for Vatican diplomacy. Maduro had written to the pope this week seeking his help amid an escalating violent opposition to his socialist government which has all but destroyed the country’s economy and thrust millions of people into abject poverty. Cardinal Porras publicly denounced Maduro’s letter to Pope Francis – of which...
Cronyism and conservatives
A major problem with America’s economy is what’s often called “crony capitalism” or simply “cronyism.” In other places, I’ve defined cronyism as the situation in which free markets are hollowed out and replaced by political markets. Businesses e less interested in meeting consumer demand and much more focused on extracting privileges, favor, grants, etc., from the state. When people speak about “the Swamp,” cronyism is often what they have in mind. Economic entrepreneurship gets displaced by political entrepreneurship. With good...
The ideological appropriation of Winston Churchill
If you’ve never watched Christopher Nolan’s Dunkirk, please do so. This is one of the best films about World War II ever made. Nolan, known for such works as The Dark Knight and Interstellar, was able to seize all the intensity, despair, courage, and hope present in one of the most dramatic moments of that war and in all of modern British history. The result is a claustrophobic film. For one and a half hour, it is practically impossible to...
Explainer: What you should know about Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s Green New Deal
What exactly is the Green New Deal? Yesterday Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) released a proposed resolution titled, “Recognizing the duty of the Federal Government to create a Green New Deal.” The document is a simple resolution, a proposal that addresses matters entirely within the prerogative of the House of Representatives. It requires neither the approval of the Senate nor the signature of the President, and it does not have the force of law. Simple resolutions concern the rules of one...
A rule of thumb for the Green New Deal
I have a couple rules of thumb that I hope help me cut through some of the noise around various policy proposals and political debates. One has to do with budgetary reform (a topic I covered at some length last week): If the plan doesn’t engage with entitlements, then it isn’t really a serious proposal. The same goes for policies that have to do with environmental stewardship, and particularly those focused on lowering carbon emissions. If nuclear power isn’t a...
EU President: ‘A special place in Hell’ awaits Brexiteers
In an age of receding religious faith, politics always borders on idolatry. The latest politician to elevate polemical differences to eschatological significance came on Wednesday, as European Council President Donald Tusk condemned the souls of his enemies to eternal damnation. At a press event at 10:42 a.m. local time, Tusk said, “I’ve been wondering what that special place in Hell looks like for those who promoted Brexit, without even a sketch of a plan how to carry it out safely.”...
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s Green New Deal is the same old socialist hooey
Official Washington is all atwitter today over the release of the “Green New Deal” by New York freshman Democrat Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Massachusetts Senator Ed Markey, also a Democrat. The proposal bundles many long-desired goals of the environmentalist movement into a neat legislative package, described by left-leaning Vox in this way: The resolution consists of a preamble, five goals, 14 projects, and 15 requirements. The preamble establishes that there are two crises, a climate crisis and an economic crisis...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved