Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
College student sets himself on fire for socialism
College student sets himself on fire for socialism
Apr 4, 2025 4:48 PM

On Friday, November 8, a 22-year-old French college student set himself on fire outside the government agency that administers university housing and living allowances. The reason? The government had revoked his monthly benefits after he failed his courses for the second year in a row.

His suicide attempt touched off violent national protests that the government is perpetrating “violence” against the students of France’s tuition-free universities, because it reduced students’ monthly living stipend by $10 a month.

The 22 year old, who is known as “Anas K.,” sustained burns over 90 percent of his body and, as of this writing, remains in critical condition.

A suicidal epitaph: “Long live socialism”

The fourth-year sophomore at Lyon 2 University – who also served as the federal secretary of a Trotskyite socialist organization known as Solidaires – explained the “political” reasons behind his decision on social media. France24 reports:

“I accuseMacron, Hollande, Sarkozy and the European Union of killing me by creating uncertainty over everyone’s futures,” the political science student added, noting that his monthly stipend of €450 had been withdrawn after he failed the second year of his degree for a second time.

The final sentence of the message, in which he announced that he would end his life, declared, “Long live socialism.”

Solidaires explained that Anas’ attempted self-immolation was a “deeply political, desperate act” to highlight the mon violence” that “inhuman institutions” including “the State and the University exert against the students.”

The group called for activists to gather last Tuesday, November 12, outside college, universities, and education ministry buildings to protest for higher living benefits.

Their slogan: “La précarité tue” – “Financial uncertainty kills.”

Hundreds stormed the Higher Education Ministry building in Paris and wrote the phrase on a wall nearby. Those unable to attend in person protested online, using the hashtag #LaPrecariteTue.

“Members of Communist youth organisation MJCF and Communist students organisation UEC, along with members of the student union Solidaires, of which Anas is a member, also took part in the protests,” according to the Peoples Dispatch.

Violent protesters prevented former Socialist President François Hollande from giving a speech in Lille.

One of the 800 protesters outside the Crous building in Lyon, named Lætitia, called Anas’ suicide “a strong, altruistic gesture.”

And rades in Solidaire threatened officials: “We want answers to our demands. Now. For this to not happen again.”

What cold-blooded violence had the government perpetrated to drag desperate French students to death’s door?

Life or death, for $10 a month

France long ago adopted “free” college education, allowing French students to attend university tuition-free. Roughly 800,000 students from a lower- or e background also receive a monthly government allowance of €234 to cover their living expenses. Anas received $500 a month. In fact, the French government spends €5.7 billion ($6 billion U.S.) on means-tested assistance to college students, more than it spends on foreign affairs.

But in 2017, President Emmanuel Macron reduced benefits to students by approximately €5 a month directly and another €4.20 a month by calculating benefits differently.

Most students still have money left over each month – but not enough to live on. That lit the fuse that ended in the West’s most recent public immolation.

Anas wrote in his farewell message:

This year I am doing the second year of my bachelor’s degree for the third time. I have no grant. Even when I had one, I received €450 a month. How can one live on that? And after our studies how long will we have to work to pay our social charges to have a decent pension?

Anas and his cohort are rebelling against France’s robust welfare state because, in addition to free tuition, it does not pay their full living costs for years at a time.

France24 reports that protesters are incensed that “students pelled to work to meet their needs.” In 2016, 46 percent of French university students held a job in addition to going to school. parison, 43 percent of all U.S. full-time students, and 81 percent of all part-time undergrads, also had a job, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.

“Free” university attendance has e a presidential campaign issue in the United States. Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, Pete Buttigieg, Julian Castro and Tulsi Gabbard would make four-year college “free” for all low- and e students; Warren, Sanders, and Castro would extend that to all students, without any means-testing.

However, too much of the analysis of “College for All” proposals has been purely economic, and too little has focused on how they affect the human person.

Lessons to learn

The tragic attempted suicide of Anas K. proves that this issue holds lessons for people of goodwill on both sides of the Atlantic.

1. Government benefits create an insatiable desire for more entitlements. France already has tuition-free college for all students. However, students are protesting – to the point of self-immolation – to demand the government pay all the costs associated with their schooling, regardless of their performance. Anas K. appears to have spent at least as much of his time and mental energy on socialist activism as on his studies. Yet he demands the government pay him to e in effect a professional student. Once the government begins to assume everyday functions that people can perform for themselves, the people demand prehensive benefits.

2. Receiving government benefits saps the energy of even the most vibrant citizens. As government grows, the individual’s initiative and agency shrinks. University students may have more enthusiasm and energy than at any other point in their lives. Yet college-aged socialist protesters would rather die a fiery death than work an average of nine hours a week. (Interestingly, less than half of French students who work a “very time-consuming” job say it has negatively impacted their studies.) “By intervening directly and depriving society of its responsibility, the Social Assistance State leads to a loss of human energies,” Pope John Paul II presciently observed in Centesimus Annus.

3. Socialism reduces the value of human life. The Judeo-Christian heritage of the West upholds the dignity and inviolability of every human person. Socialism, which believes the individual is less important than society as a whole, gladly sacrifices lives to fulfill its messianic aims. Christians may allow others to kill their bodies rather than deny God, but they do not kill themselves in service of a larger, all-consuming economic and social ideology. Instead of using the hashtag #LaPrecariteTue, students should have used #SocialismKills.

4. Government entitlements increase loneliness and alienation. The greatest pity is that no one who read Anas K.’s online suicide note stopped his “altruistic” gesture. For all its discussion of “solidarity,” creeping government encroachments displace real human interaction with a bureaucratic maze of impersonal laws and programs. “Collectivism does not do away with alienation but rather increases it, adding to it a lack of basic necessities and economic inefficiency,” Pope John Paul II observed. He realized that people’s “needs are best understood and satisfied by people who are closest to them and who act as neighbours to those in need.”

It is tragic that an outgoing, gregarious student like Anas K. found no one who would treat him like a neighbor in his hour of need.

Further reading: The spring issue of Religion & Liberty dealt with education, including “free” college and student loan forgiveness. The issue, which includes insights from Anne Rathbone Bradley and Trey Dimsdale, can be downloaded here.

This photo has been cropped. CC BY-SA 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Culture and Poverty
Here is an interesting article by Patricia Cohen in the New York Times about the role of culture in poverty: ‘Culture of Poverty’ Makes a Comeback While it is obvious to most observers that culture plays an important role in shaping norms and habits, and thus would have impact on poverty–discussions of culture have not been within the domain of polite conversation for the last several decades within many academic circles. As Patricia Cohen writes: The reticence was a legacy...
Rev. Robert Sirico: The Tea Party Movement and Catholic Social Teaching
Rev. Robert Sirico talked about the Tea Party movement and Catholic Social Teaching yesterday with Al Kresta on Ave Maria Radio. Click on the link below to listen: [audio: From Kresta in the Afternoon: The Tea Party Movement: How Does it Gel With Catholic Social Teaching? Since their not-so-quiet arrival on the U.S. political scene, the tea party has garnered a great deal of attention and found growing support among disgruntled Americans, many of whom are Catholics. A missioned earlier...
Meaningful Work and the Economics Nobel
This week’s Acton Commentary. Sign up for our free, weekly email newsletter here. While you’re at it, pick up a copy of Victor Claar’s new monograph, Fair Trade: It’s Prospects as a Poverty Solution, in the Acton Bookshoppe. +++++++++ Searching for Meaningful Work: Reflections on the 2010 Economics Nobel By Victor V. Claar This year’s Nobel economics prize was awarded to two Americans and a British-Cypriot for developing a theory that helps to explain why unemployment can persist even when...
Removing Faith from Public Life, Again
Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirill, at a meeting with German President Christian Wulff in Moscow today: “I am deeply convinced that modern civilization is making the same mistake as the Soviet Union. It doesn’t matter very much why you are removing faith from pubic life. The final result, as engineers say, is the same: you get dismantling of religious consciousness,” the Patriarch said. The Russian Church has lived for decades in a country where the official ideology was the ideology of...
Community, Culture, and Confession
Inspired by Art Prize, I wrote a blog about culture, technology, and the universal desire munity. This appeared on Ethika Politika‘s blog today and an excerpt can be found below: Last week as I was wandering through Grand Rapids’ Art Prize (the world’s largest petition), I came across the very simple interactive piece that is pictured below. Confess is a large board where people can anonymously write their confessions. Everything from the dark, to deeply personal, to lighthearted, to witty...
Were Alexander Solzhenitsyn and Jesse Helms Kindred Spirits?
Estelle Snyder makes an excellent case that Alexander Solzhenitsyn and Jesse Helms had similar humble backgrounds and beliefs that helped form a deep bond between the two men, despite being separated by language, culture, geography, and an Iron Curtain. In a paper published by the North Carolina History Project titled “Champions of Freedom: Alexander Solzhenitsyn and Jesse Helms,” Snyder argues that their relationship was an important one in terms of confronting the evils of Communism with a more aggressive posture,...
Interview: Ismael Hernandez
HernandezOn , Ismael Hernandez talks about his journey from anti-American activist to his disillusionment with socialism and eventually the founding of the Freedom & Virtue Institute. Hernandez, a frequent lecturer at Acton conferences, was asked by interviewer Jamie Glazov to recall the estrangement from family and friends that resulted when his “passion for socialism” faded away. For the first time in my life, I began to weakly contemplate the possibility that things were not as I had been told. There...
Acton and Cape Town 2010
This year’s Lausanne Congress, Cape Town 2010, is underway and all reports are of a massive event, with substantial buildup and coordination of efforts of and implications of various kinds across the globe. (Dr. Anthony Bradley, a research fellow at the Acton Institute, participated in one of the conversation gatherings last month leading up to the Cape Town event.) In my book published earlier this summer, Ecumenical Babel, I mentioned Cape Town 2010 as one of the major ecumenical events...
How Do You Say ‘Crony Capitalism’ in Hebrew?
It turns out there’s a phrase for the reality of ‘crony capitalism’ in Hebrew: hon v’shilton, which is “literally translated as capital and government, an expression Israelis use to describe the rich’s influence on government.” Check out Bloomberg Businessweek for an overview of current controversy on Israel’s “business elite.” Of course business need not corrupt government. But the temptation for those with a concentration of economic power to turn that into political advantage in order to retain economic dominance is...
Rev. Robert Sirico: Tea Party Must Define Ideas
A new Detroit News column by Acton Institute President and co-founder Rev. Robert A. Sirico: Tea party must define ideas By Father Robert Sirico If the recent analysis by the New York Times on the success of the tea party movement is correct, the influence of this movement favoring limited government and low levels of taxation may have a decided impact in the ing elections, particularly in holding the Republican leadership’s feet to the fire on a variety of related...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved