Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
China’s BBC ban is a warning for those who could crack down on ‘fake news’
China’s BBC ban is a warning for those who could crack down on ‘fake news’
Apr 2, 2025 2:03 AM

Shortly after the Capitol riot, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez stated, “We’re going to have to figure out how we rein in our media environment so that you can’t just spew disinformation and misinformation.” This week, China put her words into action. It banished the BBC from Chinese airwaves, allegedly because of the global news service’s coverage of the COVID-19 pandemic and Uighur Muslims’ persecution amounted to “disinformation.”

The BBC reported on its own silencing:

China’s State Film, TV and Radio Administration said that BBC World News reports about China were found to “seriously violate” broadcast guidelines, including “the requirement that news should be truthful and fair” and not “harm China’s national interests”.

The BBC’s reports on Chinese activities “seriously violated the relevant provisions of the ‘Regulations on the Administration of Radio and Television’and the ‘Administrative Measures for the Landing of Overseas Satellite TV Channels,’ violated the requirements that news should be truthful and fair, harmed China’s national interests and undermined China’s national unity,” according to the government body.

The Chinese Embassy also chided the BBC to “stop fabricating and spreading disinformation.”

The ban – which took effect at 11 p.m. Friday, local time (10 a.m. Friday, Eastern time) – follows years of Beijing artificially limiting its audience. Although the BBC still aired in China, the government had long restricted its reach:

mercially funded BBC World News TV channel broadcasts globally in English. In China it is largely restricted and appears only in international hotels and some pounds, meaning most Chinese people cannot view it.

The global news giant responded with characteristic British reserve, saying it was “disappointed” by its ouster from the world’s most populous country. It added that its journalists “have reported stories in mainland China and Hong Kong truthfully and fairly, as they do everywhere in the world.”

The timing – one week after the UK’s Office of Communications ) revoked the broadcast license ofChina Global Television Network (CGTN) – provoked allegations that the ban represents a tit-for-tat in an international dispute. But for media consumers in the United States, it raises serious concerns about the law of unintended consequences.

The rationale – and some of the steps – taken by China against the BBC are identical to those American pundits have advocated for Fox News and other right-of-center media outlets. CNN media critic Oliver Darcy wrote that a handful of networks including FNC had “helped prime President Trump’s supporters into not believing the truth,” triggering the vandalism of the nation’s Capitol on January 6.

Others have been more pointed. “We are going to have to figure out the OANN and Newsmax problem,” Alex Stamos toldCNN host Brian panies have freedom of speech, but I’m not sure we need Verizon, AT&T, Comcast, and such bringing them into tens of millions of homes.”

Still others, like AOC, have flirted with government actions that would stress the limits of the First Amendment (hardly the only way that socialism violates the Constitution).

The BBC ban is not the first time a foreign power has invoked Western arguments to censor domestic journalists. In April 2019, Vladimir Putin signed a law fining citizens up to 500,000 rubles (approximately $6,800 U.S.) for posting “fake news – unreliable socially significant information that is disseminated as credible messages and poses a security risk.” Putin cited the EU’s adoption of the Code of Practice against Disinformation at the time – a code initially “voluntarily” adopted by various media. But last May, the European Council released a report that the “self-regulatory” nature of the agreement created drawbacks that could only be remedied by “co-regulation” from that global governance body.

Of course, there is more at work in the U.S. media’s calls to defenestrate Fox News, Newsmax, and One America News Network than civic-minded concern about journalistic integrity. Such a move would also sideline CNN’s most petitor. Moreover, the cable providers have a financial stake in this decision: AT&T owns CNN, while Comcast owns MSNBC. Such market interference could trigger an plaint that panies favored their own product, according to Bloomberg News.

In essence, CNN, Nicholas Kristoff, and others are demanding the cartelization of the news media. A cartel exists to restrict supply, erect barriers to entry, and increase the receipts of its members. By pressuring carriers to drop those expressinig an alternate viewpoint, the “fake news” ban would artificially deprive viewers of petition, and additional perspectives not heard on CNN or MSNBC.

The best means of assuring media integrity petition. “The media should be viewed in the same way as any other economic activity,” writes Julian Jessop at the London-based Institute of Economic Affairs. “This means that, in general, consumers should be free to decide what to watch, hear and read, without having their choices limited by politicians, regulators or a handful of dominant producers.” It is precisely the mainstream media’s dubious coverage, viewpoint bias, and resultant poor reputation that led to the rise of Fox and other outlets in the first place.

petitors out of business cannot restore the luster of the media’s integrity. It can only deprive individuals of news mentary that aligns with their own values and beliefs.

And, as leaders in China and Russia show, it can give cover to autocratic tyrants half a world away to bully, cajole, or regulate their critics into silence.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Why is customer service better at Starbucks than at the DMV?
Note: This is post #22 in a weekly video series on basic microeconomics. Prices are signals that indicate to suppliers how much is being demanded. So what happens when the government puts a cap on the price that can be charged for a product or service? Two effects are shortages and lower quality. In this video by Marginal Revolution University, economist Alex Tabarrok explains why this happens. (If you find the pace of the videos too slow, I’d mend watching...
To avoid a demographic winter, Europe must understand human dignity
Like all of Europe, Poland is suffering from a steep demographic crisis. Despite a relatively large (European) population andan expansive land mass that serves as a bridge between Europe and Asia, Poland has a fertility rate lower than that of China – a nation that only recently relaxed its One-Child Policy. (Beijing now enforces its two-child policy no less ruthlessly.) Several European (and non-European) nations have tried to incentivize their citizens to have more children through various means: taxpayer subsidies...
How Michael Novak changed your life
Michael Novak died last Thursday at the age of 83. In a remembrance for The Hill, Acton Institute President Rev. Robert A. Sirico reflects on the passing of his friend and mentor, and how he changed all of our lives: Some of my most memorable conversations took place over what would e effectively known as the Salon Novak: dinner parties that Karen and I would orchestrate where we witnessed Clare Boothe Luce contending with Jack Kemp and Bill Bennett on...
5 Facts about Washington’s Birthday
Today is the U.S. federal holiday known as Washington’s Birthday (not “Presidents Day—see item #1). In honor of George Washington’s birthday, here are 5 things you should know about the day set aside for our America’s premier founding father. 1. Although some state and local governments and private businesses refer to today as President’s Day, the legal public holiday is designated as “Washington’s Birthday” in section 6103(a) of title 5 of the United States Code. The observance of Washington’s birthday...
Toward a Christian view of economics
Embed from Getty Images Many Christians assume that the Bible has nothing at all to say about economics, says theologian Albert Mohler, but a biblical worldview actually has a great deal to teach us on economic matters. Mohler outlines twelve theses for what a Christian understanding of economics must do. Here are three of them: 1. It must have God’s glory as its greatestaim. For Christians, all economic theory begins with an aim to glorify God (1 Cor. 10:31). We...
5 Facts about Michael Novak
The theologian, scholar, and writer Michael Novak died yesterday at the age of 83. Novak was one of the most influential Catholic thinkers of his generation, and an indefatigable champion of free enterprise, democracy, and liberty. Here are five facts you should know about Novak: Michael Novak / Acton Institute 1. At age fourteen Novak entered Holy Cross Seminary of the Congregation of Holy Cross at Notre Dame with the intention of ing a Catholic priest. From there, he went...
Samuel Gregg on the legacy of the late Michael Novak
In a recent article for Public Discourse, Samuel Gregg articulates the great impact that the late Michael Novak had both on him personally, but also in promoting free market economics and moral living for a greater, more virtuous world. He says: When news came of the death of the theologian and philosopher Michael Novak, the loss was felt in a particularly sharp way by those of us who knew him personally. Like many people of all ages, I was fortunate...
Religion & Liberty: Fighting for totalitarianism’s victims
The unofficial theme for Religion & Liberty’s first issue in 2017 is despotism. In this issue, you’ll find stories from the Soviet Union, a close look into the North Korea regime and a reexamination of Hitler’s rise to power. The cover story is an interview with human rights expert Suzanne Scholte, who discusses her passion for fighting the sadistic rule of Kim Jong Un and working with North Korean defectors. After 20 years fighting for those who don’t enjoy freedom...
Explainer: What is the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA)?
On Wednesday, February 15, the European Parliament approved theComprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), a free trade agreement abolishing most trade restrictions between the European Union and Canada. Negotiators hammered out the 1,600-page agreement over the course of seven years before Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and European Council President Donald Tusk signed CETA last October 30. Then, the pact swept through the Strasbourg-based European Parliament by a vote of408-254 with 33 abstentions last week. What does it do? CETA...
When morality evaporates
When Tzvetan Todorov died on Feb. 7, the Bulgarian/French philosopher and literary critic was lamented only in certain intellectual ghettoes. To the men and women eulogizing Todorov in these circles, he was feted properly if not stingily, which is most unfortunate. Finite word counts are a harsh mistress when a fellow writer endeavors to create a fully realized portrait of his or her subject. Todorov leaves behind a body of historical and moral philosophy that connects the dots between the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved