Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Check Your Rhetoric: What Common Good?
Check Your Rhetoric: What Common Good?
Oct 3, 2024 9:24 AM

According to Daly, Soviet government sought to dictate every aspect of life in the name of mon good, including the indexing of Soviet publications by libraries. He writes, “[I]f Soviet publications failed to end up in libraries, then, as Lenin railed, ‘we have to know precisely whom to imprison.'”In the Winter-Fall 2012 issue of Modern Age (54, nos. 1-4), Jonathan Daly contributes a helpful exploration of what happens when desire for mon good goes bad. His article, “Bolshevik Power and Ideas of the Common Good,” focuses on the disastrously ill-conceived effort by the Russian revolutionaries to promote mon good through their self-proclaimed “revolutionary dictatorship of the proletariat.”

Daly contends, “The horrors of Bolshevik governance stemmed directly from their repudiation of the precious fruits of Western political thought.” It is a classic example of the tendency of some to promote cheap moralisms while ignoring the empirical realities of any given context, what then Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger termed in 1985, “the antithesis of morality.” In addition to fostering mass suspicion, starvation, and ultimately a despotic police state in Russia, the Bolsheviks also have the blood of literally millions on their hands, Orthodox Christians as well many Roman Catholics, Protestants, Jews, and others—the rotten fruit of their noble quest for mon good.

Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk of the Russian Orthodox Church mented on the legacy of the Bolsheviks on the Day of the Assembly of Russia’s New Martyrs and Confessors, saying,

The Bolsheviks created an antihuman and criminal ideology to guide the rulers of our country for decades. This ideology led to millions of victims, the people of different beliefs and social status. They began with the class struggle against nobility and merchants followed by the dispossession of well-to-do peasants, then resettlement and destruction of whole munities. One destruction campaign followed the other and these criminal actions continued for several decades.

But what was the basis of such an ideology? Daly isolates the convergence of two principle ideas in the works of Karl Marx: utopianism and gnosticism. By utopianism, he means “aspiring to create a social order requiring behaviors that we humans, in our frailty, are incapable of sustaining.” He uses the term “gnosticism” in a general sense, noting that “[g]nostics typically lay claim to knowledge of the inner workings of society unavailable to most people.” He concludes, “Neither of these means constitutes a ready or apt tool for bringing about mon good. They can instead only justify hijacking the very idea thereof.” And that is exactly what the Bolsheviks did.

This, indeed, is precisely the methodology of the sort of person Wilhelm Röpke termed a “centrist”:

a moralist of the cheap rhetorical kind, who misuses big words, such as freedom, justice, rights of man, or others, to the point of empty phraseology, who poses as a paragon of virtues and stoops to use his moralism as a political weapon and to represent his more reserved adversary as morally inferior.

The lesson here (among others, to be sure) is not to be too easily enchanted by every appeal to mon good or other equivalent phrases. What a person means by such terms are far more important than how often they use it, how much they praise it, and with what colors they paint their opponents.

One would think that, with the monumental failure of Soviet Russia—indeed, more than a failure, it was true tragedy—such centrist, moralistic conceptions of mon good would have been abandoned by anyone who witnessed the demolition of the Berlin Wall, but such is not, unfortunately the case. The value of limited government for mon good meets strong opposition even still.

The words of James Buchanan, from his 1979 essay, “Politics Without Romance,” are just as timely in this regard today:

The socialist mystique to the effect that the state, that politics, somehow works its way toward some transcendent “public good” is with us yet, in many guises, as we must surely acknowledge. And, even among those who reject such mystique, there are many who unceasingly search for the ideal that will resolve the dilemma of politics.

According to Buchanan, it is not simply socialists who fall into such an error, but sometimes even those who actively seek to reject it. Any conflation of society with government, any policy that forgets the necessary role of civil society, operates under a misconception of mon good, whether progressive or conservative.

Daly concludes his article with four conclusions that we can learn from the Bolshevik legacy that ought to temper any facile equation between mon good and idealistic turns to centralization. I will highlight here, however, only the last as it seems to me perhaps the most pressing today:

[T]he regime that provides the most goods and services imposes the greatest demands on its people. By giving individuals everything, it can legitimately demand total loyalty.

Accordingly, when es to looking solely to government and centralization as the primary means to promote mon good, I would offer the following modification of the famous dictum from John F. Kennedy’s inauguration speech: ask not what your country can do for you, lest it ask what you can do for your country.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The biggest beneficiaries of the success sequence
Good choices benefit everyone but, as in all of life, not all groups gain equally. The success sequence is no different. The sequence says that the vast majority of people can avoid living in poverty if they make a few deliberate life choices: finish high school, work full time, wait until age 21 to get married, and do not have children outside wedlock. Religion can provide unparalleled motivation for at least two of these goals.A new study has found that99.1...
Martyrs remind us to fight the ‘isms’
There is a longstanding liturgical and spiritual discipline practiced in Rome during Lent. It involves celebrating mass at the crack of dawn each day at a different church in various corners of the ancient quarter of Rome. A “station church”, as they are called, is usually the site of a great Christian martyr’s death, grave or an important relic preserved over the course of several centuries. Yesterday’s station church was the Basilica of St. Bartholomew the Apostle, who was skinned...
No, Mr. President, we don’t need more socialist policies
One hundred years ago, automaker Henry Ford announced in a meeting that in the future pany was going to build only one model of car, that the model was going to “Model T,” and that, “Any customer can have a car painted any color that he wants so long as it is black.” Increasingly, Americans are finding they have the same choice in government: You can have any economic policy you want so long as it’s socialism. On one side...
Is the Boeing 737 MAX safe? Who should decide?
Yesterday, Boeing announced a software update for the 737 MAX-8, the airliner that was grounded after two crashes and rising concerns about a possible flaw in the plane’s maneuvering characteristics augmentation system (MCAS). Boeing presented the MCAS updates as improvements to the system and has always maintained that the plane is safe. Now pany is asking the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to certify the updates so the aircraft can be returned to service. This has given lawmakers in Washington, D.C.,...
The reason statists always think things are getting worse
With unemployment and poverty levels at historic lows, why do so many people persist in believing people’s economic prospects are always getting worse? Why are discussions of current living conditions always marked by catastrophic thinking? Take, for instance, Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s recentassessmentthat “the America that we’re living in today is so dystopian.” The fact that her assertion is misguided does not mean it is not widely shared. One answer to America’s dyspeptic discourse is found in the Fraser Institute’s new...
‘The Road to Serfdom’ at 75: Reflecting on Hayek’s enduring work
This is the first in a series celebrating and exploring the enduring legacy and significance of Friedrich A. Hayek’s The Road to Serfdom. Friedrich A. Hayek’s The Road to Serfdom was first published 75 years ago this month. Initially written as a brief memo in 1933, it eventually grew into a book and is probably theNobel Laureate economist’s most well-known work. How does TRS hold up this many years later? What does it have to say about where we find...
Explainer: Republican lawmakers unveil paid family leave plan
What just happened? Senator Marco Rubio (R-Florida) and Rep. Ann Wagner (R-Missouri) re-introduced a bill yesterday (slightly modified from one from last year) that would allow parents to use their Social Security benefits to provide paid parental leave benefits following the birth or adoption of a child. “Our proposal would enact paid family leave in America without increasing taxes, without placing new mandates on small businesses,” Rubio said in a news conference. Earlier this month, Sens. Joni Ernst (R-Iowa) and...
The state of entrepreneurship in America
Alexis de Tocqueville’s Democracy in America is primarily and rightly regarded as a work of political science. But the book is also replete with economic observations. One of the most significant was Tocqueville’s astonishment at “the spirit of enterprise” that characterized much of the country. Americans, Tocqueville quickly realized, were mercial people.” The nation hummed with the pursuit of wealth. Economic change was positively ed. “Almost all of them,” Tocqueville scribbled in one of his notebooks, “are real industrial entrepreneurs.”...
The portable Trinity: Embracing the divine life of daily work
When re-imagining our economic activity through a Christian perspective, it can be easy to get stuck in simply observing and analyzing things from the outside—stroking our chins at the theological or moral implications of various jobs, enterprises, or economic decisions. These are important considerations, but we should be attentive to also inhabit our work with such a perspective—participating with the divine as an act of fellowship and love. We were not just created to know and understand our work’s purpose,...
Ben Shapiro and the alt-right smear
Misunderstanding the alt-right seems to be the favorite activity of the established media. In the latest case, the favorite magazine of globalists – the English magazine The Economist – has characterized Ben Shapiro as the sage of the alt-right. Under any conceivable point of view, such an idea would be surreal given that Shapiro is one of the favorite targets of that Internet trolling movement. A simple Google search would have told Economist’s reporters that Shapiro – who is Jew...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved